Aller au contenu

Photo

Eating Disorders Group photoshops female video games characters to make them more "realistic"


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
161 réponses à ce sujet

#76
Fishy

Fishy
  • Members
  • 5 819 messages

Honestly disgusting.

 

I will never accept the glorification of overweight people and the demonization of those who are healthy and fit.

 

 

There's a difference between being morbidly obese and a bit overweight. Being skinny does not guarantee  that you're  fit and healthy. I love my woman with a bit of meat on their bone. Although I have no problem with skinny woman either. If they're healthy and feel good in their skin. Go for it girl. I'm not the one to decide how you want to be.

 

One of my friend used to be quite fat, but he was fit. He was just  eating way too ****** much lol. While one of my other friend was super skinny. I mean at some point I though his skin color turned green. He was weaker than my grandma.

 

I'm not talking about morbidly obese people who have trouble just walking around. That just sad. I mean at which point you're like - **** I need to stop or i'm going to burst. But after watching vlogger like Boogie I'm starting to understand why some people may become that fat. It's often depression. But boogie get a free pass from everyone because he's an internet celebrity. Ordinary people still get bullied, harassed  and rejected.

 

it would be so much easier if everyone was the same has you and had the same personality has you and the same willpower. But it not. The world is not that simple and people aren't a list of trait that you can write down on a page and say - YES THAT IT IT'S HIM.



#77
Jester

Jester
  • Members
  • 1 118 messages

it would be so much easier if everyone was the same has you and had the same personality has you and the same willpower. But it not. The world is not that simple and people aren't a list of trait that you can write down on a page and say - YES THAT IT IT'S HIM.

True. But video game characters (as well as movie protagonists, TV series lead stars etc) many times are meant to show some idealistic traits (especially if it's fantasy) - be it psychological or physical - such as courage, honor, intelligence, physical strenght, endurance, beauty etc.

 

Asking for those characters to be slightly overweight (because an average person is) is like trying to force the view, that M.D. House should have an IQ of 100 instead of 160+ like in the series, because that's what an average person would score.

The problem is, that then the entire show/movie/game makes no sense.

 

Fat Commander Shepard would be riddiculous. Overweight Geralt would be a comic relief and not a serious monster hunter. Average intelligence Sherlock would make for a terrible TV or book series. Unfit Lara Croft would not survive the first day on the island in Tomb Raider. Frodo with a courage of an average person woud result in Sauron ruling over Middle-Earth. 

And returning to Mass Effect: fat and ugly Asari would not make very good "seductress" species of the galaxy now, would they?

 

We enjoy fantasy precisely because it shows us the ideals worth striving for - it let's us play as characters and people who have traits that we would want to see in ourselves and in other people that we interact with. 

This action is trying to persuade people, that being slightly overweight (as an average person in US - and many other countries - is) is somehow an ideal we should all try to achieve (or at least that it's just as desirable as being perfectly fit). It's not. Anything that's average does not require effort to achieve, by it's very definition. 


  • Heimdall et Sigma Tauri aiment ceci

#78
Fidite Nemini

Fidite Nemini
  • Members
  • 5 734 messages

There's a difference between being morbidly obese and a bit overweight. Being skinny does not guarantee  that you're  fit and healthy. I love my woman with a bit of meat on their bone. Although I have no problem with skinny woman either. If they're healthy and feel good in their skin. Go for it girl. I'm not the one to decide how you want to be.

 

One of my friend used to be quite fat, but he was fit. He was just  eating way too ****** much lol. While one of my other friend was super skinny. I mean at some point I though his skin color turned green. He was weaker than my grandma.

 

I'm not talking about morbidly obese people who have trouble just walking around. That just sad. I mean at which point you're like - **** I need to stop or i'm going to burst. But after watching vlogger like Boogie I'm starting to understand why some people may become that fat. It's often depression. But boogie get a free pass from everyone because he's an internet celebrity. Ordinary people still get bullied, harassed  and rejected.

 

it would be so much easier if everyone was the same has you and had the same personality has you and the same willpower. But it not. The world is not that simple and people aren't a list of trait that you can write down on a page and say - YES THAT IT IT'S HIM.

 

That's a nice point of view and all, but not exactly relevant to the point, nor is it the point the organization who did the photoshopping made.

 

With the exception of the pre-reboot Lara Croft who simply didn't have an anatomically correct body structure (not talking about the 150% bustsize, mind you), none of the shown characters were abnormal. They aren't unrealistic body models that would drive women into unhealthy eating disorders to achieve some sort of beauty ideal like Barby dolls or some such. Those are perfectly healthy female bodies. And they're women who in their respective contexts SHOULD be fit, let alone rigurously trained in some cases. And using Cortana as an example is downright idiotic, because as an entity without a physical body (aside from a hardware chip or however the AI physically exists), her appearance is purely based on what she (or without meta-thinking, the artists) wants to appear like. As such if she wanted to appear sexy (as no one should kid him-/herself, Cortana as a character is subject to sexualization over the Halo franchise's history), it would be based on an ideal (which may or may not actually have to conform with human physiology on that matter!), not any physical approximation of an ideal. And as such, looking like she does is 100% natural given the situation. So whoever did pick the characters didn't go along with his/her work by picking ones who may promote an exaggerated/unrealistic ideal which may lead to people developing eating disorders to achieve some such, they purely just picked characters known throughout gaming that were sexy and photoshopped them into overweight version, then stated those are normal. Or in reverse, saying the original versions aren't normal.

 

 

 

Likewise, being a bit chubby, whilst not unhealthy unless you're positively obese, is not a physiological ideal. And I dare say a good chunk of those photoshops aren't just a little on the well-fed side, but rather look like someone's been eating too much AND not getting enough workout, which undeniably IS unhealthy when it develops into a living habit in the long run.

 

 

But the worst point of it is the apparent normalization. The ideal of a fit body isn't there because some pervert people think it's the most sexy thing, a fit body is the physiological ideal because it's healthy. And with increasing deviation, be that whichever direction, health issues will likewise increase. Sure enough, there's some wriggleroom before things actually get unhealthy from a purely physiological standpoint (albeit as I had already said, if the lifestyle that lead to said developement persists, things will inevitably become unhealthy!).

 

Being slightly overweight may be normal from a strictly statistical point of view (then again, statistical bias are in effect because the national average in the US shows that nearly 70% of adults are overwight or approaching obese and around 30% adults being obese), but it SHOULDN'T be normal.


  • Heimdall, TheRealJayDee, Il Divo et 1 autre aiment ceci

#79
Sigma Tauri

Sigma Tauri
  • Members
  • 2 675 messages

Darunia and Darmani.

 

Darunia is what one would refer to as a "musclegut." Not exactly fat.



#80
Sigma Tauri

Sigma Tauri
  • Members
  • 2 675 messages

Likewise, being a bit chubby, whilst not unhealthy unless you're positively obese, is not a physiological ideal.

 

Pft. You're so shallow. I don't care.

 

If Mrs. Santori has no comorbidities, has absolutely beautiful vital signs, but still has a bit of meat in her bones, that's physiologically ideal.



#81
Fidite Nemini

Fidite Nemini
  • Members
  • 5 734 messages

Pft. You're so shallow. I don't care.

 

If Mrs. Santori has no comorbidities, has absolutely beautiful vital signs, but still has a bit of meat in her bones, that's physiologically ideal.

 

Way to go and ignore the entire rest of my post to call me shallow.


  • Reezus Christ aime ceci

#82
General TSAR

General TSAR
  • Members
  • 4 384 messages

This is actually the very good point here!

These characters are supposed to be highly trained athletes. Watch females practicing any sport (except Sumo wrestling), then tell me again how 'realistic' these images are.

Exactly.

 

And one of them is an AI!



#83
Sigma Tauri

Sigma Tauri
  • Members
  • 2 675 messages

Way to go and ignore the entire rest of my post just to call my shallow.

 

Yeah, calling you shallow was too much. Sorry about that lol. But, aside from a reductive argument, I have issues with that statement alone.



#84
Fast Jimmy

Fast Jimmy
  • Members
  • 17 939 messages

9335275112767a70cf18d58a0d239029.jpg


Dat name change TBH
  • Sigma Tauri, leighzard et malloc aiment ceci

#85
leighzard

leighzard
  • Members
  • 3 187 messages

Oh it's THIS thread.

Mean-Girls-Eye-Roll.gif

Voxr was right!


  • Sigma Tauri et malloc aiment ceci

#86
TheRealJayDee

TheRealJayDee
  • Members
  • 2 950 messages

I guess they have good intentions with this, but as others pointed out the way they went about it is a whole new kind of problematic, and their choice of characters to use as examples is plain nonsensical in many cases.

 

They did one with superheroes as well, and here we also got a few adjusted male characters:

 

PoisonIvy.pngCaptainAmerica.png



#87
Beerfish

Beerfish
  • Members
  • 23 867 messages

quarian_melon_by_violanarrayya-d7wnk0w.j


  • Eternal Phoenix aime ceci

#88
Sigma Tauri

Sigma Tauri
  • Members
  • 2 675 messages

That's Jersey Batman after a manicotti binge with a cannoli chaser.


  • Eternal Phoenix aime ceci

#89
TheClonesLegacy

TheClonesLegacy
  • Members
  • 19 014 messages

I guess they have good intentions with this, but as others pointed out the way they went about it is a whole new kind of problematic, and their choice of characters to use as examples is plain nonsensical in many cases.

They did one with superheroes as well, and here we also got a few adjusted male characters:

PoisonIvy.pngCaptainAmerica.png

Guess that Super Soldier Serum was a dud eh?
  • LPPrince et Eternal Phoenix aiment ceci

#90
TheClonesLegacy

TheClonesLegacy
  • Members
  • 19 014 messages

That's Jersey Batman after a manicotti binge with a cannoli chaser.

It looks like a shaved Kevin Smith cosplaying.
  • Sigma Tauri et Eternal Phoenix aiment ceci

#91
SlottsMachine

SlottsMachine
  • Members
  • 5 529 messages

Here's one. 

 

344sidv.jpg

 

bob-300x257.jpg


  • Eternal Phoenix et Reezus Christ aiment ceci

#92
leighzard

leighzard
  • Members
  • 3 187 messages

I demand all video game characters be as ugly as myself from this day forward.

 

You are not even ugly.

 

Wait, you've seen a photo? 

I need to know what's going to happen to my video game characters if Recon's demands are met, but someone won't post a picture in the picture thread.

C'mon Recon.... all the cool kids are doing it.  /peerpressure


  • mousestalker aime ceci

#93
Queen Skadi

Queen Skadi
  • Members
  • 1 036 messages

I guess they have good intentions with this, but as others pointed out the way they went about it is a whole new kind of problematic, and their choice of characters to use as examples is plain nonsensical in many cases.

 

They did one with superheroes as well, and here we also got a few adjusted male characters:

 

PoisonIvy.pngCaptainAmerica.png

 

I suppose Poison Ivy uses her plants to do everything for her, but in the case of Batman you gotta be in tip top physical condition to be able to keep up with those pesky supervillains, not sure slightly chubby batman is going to cut it, best leave it to the national guard or superman.



#94
Dobbysaurus

Dobbysaurus
  • Members
  • 1 305 messages

I thought this thread got deleted or was there another one just like this one?



#95
TheClonesLegacy

TheClonesLegacy
  • Members
  • 19 014 messages

I suppose Poison Ivy uses her plants to do everything for her.

She's a plant person though. I don't even think she eats anything.

She probably uses Photosynthesis.

Like a plant.

There's no fat to be had.



#96
Guest_Puddi III_*

Guest_Puddi III_*
  • Guests
I'm sure she can still make vegetable oil.

#97
Fidite Nemini

Fidite Nemini
  • Members
  • 5 734 messages

I suppose Poison Ivy uses her plants to do everything for her, but in the case of Batman you gotta be in tip top physical condition to be able to keep up with those pesky supervillains, not sure slightly chubby batman is going to cut it, best leave it to the national guard or superman.

 

Tbh, If I were to be offended by anything in that photoshop, it's Batman's chin.

 

Because apparently wide people are normal, but wide jaws have to be eradicated! Great, now I feel insecure within my own body. I will immidately commence to smash my face against a lamp post until it has multiple fractures, upon whence I shall scrape out some of my bones in a desperate attempt to remodel my jawline so I won't have to PTSD everytime I look into a mirror now.


  • Eternal Phoenix aime ceci

#98
TheClonesLegacy

TheClonesLegacy
  • Members
  • 19 014 messages

Oh yeah, there's one of Iron Man that had me laugh my ass off.

bulimia-iron-man.png

Because Tony would purposely design a suit of armor to have a beer gut (I know he's an alcoholic but come on)

Lol.


  • Sigma Tauri, ObserverStatus, Eternal Phoenix et 2 autres aiment ceci

#99
malloc

malloc
  • Members
  • 782 messages

Oh yeah, there's one of Iron Man that had me laugh my ass off.
bulimia-iron-man.png
Because Tony would purposely design a suit of armor to have a beer gut (I know he's an alcoholic but come on)
Lol.


He is an alcoholic? Is he my super hero spirit animal?

#100
Torgette

Torgette
  • Members
  • 1 422 messages

I'm guessing the people who photoshopped these have never lifted, hiked, biked, exercised, dieted, etc..  :lol:


  • Eternal Phoenix aime ceci