Aller au contenu

Photo

An Open Letter to Bioware Regarding Explicit Content


3411 réponses à ce sujet

#1
dinobot100

dinobot100
  • Members
  • 6 messages

I recently posted this on my blog, and I wanted to share it here as well.

 

 

An Open Letter to Bioware,

 

Your games (specifically the Mass Effect and Dragon Age Trilogies) are among the finest action-RPGs on the market. In anticipation of Mass Effect: Andromeda, I feel compelled to write openly on behalf of a minority demographic your team may not be aware of: players who love the story and action elements of the game but don’t care for the explicit content. I’m asking on behalf of myself and others for you to add a feature in the settings of your future titles allowing players to set which explicit content they want displayed in the games—namely language, gore, and sexual content.

 

Please understand that I am not advocating censorship, but merely choice. I am a writer myself, and I know I don’t want anyone telling me what is or isn’t appropriate for my own work. Instead of trying to control the content you put in your games, I’m simply asking for the choice to customize my experience for maximum enjoyment. Videogames have the unique providence of being a medium built around individuals. I can already control gaming aspects like difficulty, subtitles, and graphic and auditory settings, so why not what explicit content I see and hear? Choice is a key aspect of Bioware games, it is one of the attributes that truly make your titles stand out, so why not extend that choice further into the real world, embracing players who want to play the games without the explicit aspects? Of course those of us who want to limit our own exposure to explicit content already have a choice: to not play. But I hope you’ll give us a third option: to play without the content we hope to avoid in media.

 

I have seen countless forum threads where gamers have asked if X game has an option to turn off explicit content, and the answer is almost always the same: no such option exists. The replies on these threads then usually go on to mock the gamer in question, attempting to emasculate the player (regardless of whether they are male or female), telling them they need to “grow a pair” etc. I don’t see any need for this kind of mentality in the gaming world. Bioware games champion the fact that different kinds of people, leaders, and problem-solvers all have a place, e.g. you can be a renegade, you can be a paragon, etc. I don’t think Bioware needs to limit its fan base to those who enjoy explicit content. My reasons for wanting to limit my own exposure to explicit content are personal. Strangers don’t have to understand my reasons for them to be valid.

 

I know I’m not the only one with concerns about what kind of content will be in ME:A. The first Mass Effect game had no strong language, very little gore, and very brief partial nudity, while the most recent Mass Effect game had strong language at times, gore in the form of heads exploding when sniped, and the most recent Dragon Age game had much more explicit nudity. It leads some of us to wonder what the future holds if in such a short period of time this much new explicit content is introduced.

 

Let me reiterate my stance that this is a personal choice. I’m not saying it’s right or wrong for any other person to view or enjoy this content, but that as for myself I know I want to avoid it, and that I can enjoy your future action-RPGs much more without it. I hope I am not opening myself and others up to derision by asking for this concession, but I hope you will seriously consider implementing three separate toggles in the settings of your future games to control language, gore, and sexuality. Some games have given these options in the past, but I challenge you to set an industry standard by doing this with your A-list, flagship titles. Show that you care about all of your fans, not just the majority, and other companies will follow.

 

Regardless of what you choose to do, please accept my gratitude for making some of the best games I’ve ever played.

 

 

EDIT: Some commentors here don't seem to have read the letter carefully, which might be my fault because it's kind of long. But just to be clear, I'm not in any way asking for them to reduce the language, sexual content, or gore from future games. I am not making any attempt at cencorship. I'm simply asking for the option to turn off explicit content when I play, and I know I'm not alone in wanting such an option.

 

EDIT: "Gore" and "violence" are not the same thing, please be aware of the distinction.


  • N7M, Elhanan, Althix et 30 autres aiment ceci

#2
JamesFaith

JamesFaith
  • Members
  • 2 301 messages

The first Mass Effect game had no strong language, very little gore, and no real nudity,

 

What?

 

ME1 was nearly accused from being pornography in TV for showing nudity, it was quite big affair.

 

Nudity in ME1 is reason why in next installments love interest were always in underwear.  


  • Really Sad Panther, Tony Redgrave, Meesherbeans et 40 autres aiment ceci

#3
katerinafm

katerinafm
  • Members
  • 4 291 messages

I don't think you can get away from even a small amount of gore when a game is 85% combat. As for nudity it only happens in select romances if you choose to pursue the romance content, and as for language...why limit the writers in an adult game with an adult rating? The language is not that bad from what I recall in all games. I've only heard the 'heavier' swear words being used in both mass effect and dragon age combined less than 10 times.

 

Both the series were never meant to be for younger audiences, regardless if people choose to ignore it.


  • Kalas Magnus, monicasubzero, LunaFancy et 2 autres aiment ceci

#4
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 765 messages

*
MESSAGE POPULAIRE !

rawwr_by_badpie1-d2ysd68.jpg

maxresdefault.jpg

[Takei] OH MY. [/Takei]
  • Rappeldrache, Really Sad Panther, In Exile et 51 autres aiment ceci

#5
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 431 messages

What?

 

ME1 was nearly accused from being pornography in TV for showing nudity, it was quite big affair.

 

Nudity in ME1 is reason why in next installments love interest were always in underwear.  

Citation needed



#6
Killroy

Killroy
  • Members
  • 2 839 messages

OP, you're just going to have to play other games. Wasting time, money and resources on putting a babby filter in the game is not going to happen. Nor should it.


  • pace675, MrObnoxiousUK, Tony Redgrave et 37 autres aiment ceci

#7
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 431 messages

OP, you're just going to have to play other games. Wasting time, money and resources on putting a babby filter in the game is not going to happen. Nor should it.

 

 

 

I have seen countless forum threads where gamers have asked if X game has an option to turn off explicit content, and the answer is almost always the same: no such option exists. The replies on these threads then usually go on to mock the gamer in question, attempting to emasculate the player (regardless of whether they are male or female), telling them they need to “grow a pair” etc.

 

Thank you for proving OP's point.


  • dfjdejulio, HK-90210, chris2365 et 12 autres aiment ceci

#8
dinobot100

dinobot100
  • Members
  • 6 messages

As my faux-paux with saying there was no nudity in the first game seems to be what everyone is most concerned about, I fixed that section. Thanks for bringing that to my attention.



#9
Jeremiah12LGeek

Jeremiah12LGeek
  • Members
  • 23 955 messages

Your definition of "explicit" seems dubious.


  • pace675, stretchbl, sH0tgUn jUliA et 5 autres aiment ceci

#10
Il Divo

Il Divo
  • Members
  • 9 789 messages

If we're not going to do nudity, fine. But I'd prefer fade to black rather than the awkward underwear scenes. 


  • PhroXenGold, Heimdall, Shazzie et 22 autres aiment ceci

#11
Mcfly616

Mcfly616
  • Members
  • 9 002 messages

I'm all for them fully embracing the Mature rating for once. Come on, Bioware......show us some alien genitalia, finally. I wanna know what I'm really getting into  :rolleyes:


  • Really Sad Panther, pace675, vbibbi et 34 autres aiment ceci

#12
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 765 messages

Your definition of "explicit" seems dubious.


You seem dubious.
  • Asari Goddess, Kalas Magnus, AWTEW et 1 autre aiment ceci

#13
N7Jamaican

N7Jamaican
  • Members
  • 1 778 messages

Maybe Fox News should make a game called "Right Wing Effect: Conservatives"


  • pace675, Edelas, Weskerr et 13 autres aiment ceci

#14
agonis

agonis
  • Members
  • 896 messages

Gods, I loved those exploding heads in ME:3. It is strangly satisfactory.

 

But I´m not sure how I feel about seeing my 15 year old cousins playing that game and shooting the heads off the Cerberus soldiers. So... you are not wrong.


  • jstme, Shinobu, dragonflight288 et 6 autres aiment ceci

#15
Jeremiah12LGeek

Jeremiah12LGeek
  • Members
  • 23 955 messages

You seem dubious.

 

*shrug*

 

Maybe so, but the meaning certainly seems inconsistently applied in this case.



#16
Kappa Neko

Kappa Neko
  • Members
  • 2 328 messages

DA2 had an option to disable the ridiculous kill animation that had body parts flying around like somebody nuked them. It toned down the gore in general. I used it.

 

I used a mod to tone down gore in Skyrim too. A bit...

 

Would have preferred not to have headshots cause a blood fountain in ME3. Still grosses me out.

 

I'm all for the option of less graphic violence. Don't have a problem with nudity, but why not?


  • mopotter, Suketchi et dinobot100 aiment ceci

#17
Jeremiah12LGeek

Jeremiah12LGeek
  • Members
  • 23 955 messages

Please understand that I am not advocating censorship

 

You technically are. You are advocating a level of censorship with which you are comfortable in order to censor content with which you are uncomfortable. You have the right to ask what you are asking for, but it doesn't make sense to be disingenuous in the process.


  • PhroXenGold, pace675, MrObnoxiousUK et 30 autres aiment ceci

#18
Il Divo

Il Divo
  • Members
  • 9 789 messages

You technically are. You are advocating a level of censorship with which you are comfortable in order to censor content with which you are uncomfortable. You have the right to ask what you are asking for, but it doesn't make sense to be disingenuous in the process.

 

Well, self-censorship maybe. He did ask for the option to do it, to be fair. 


  • mopotter aime ceci

#19
AlanC9

AlanC9
  • Members
  • 35 825 messages
How would the proposed toggle work in practice? Black bars or blurred screens for nudity? Bleeps for bad language?
  • sH0tgUn jUliA, Kalas Magnus, Grieving Natashina et 2 autres aiment ceci

#20
dinobot100

dinobot100
  • Members
  • 6 messages

You technically are. You are advocating a level of censorship with which you are comfortable in order to censor content with which you are uncomfortable. You have the right to ask what you are asking for, but it doesn't make sense to be disingenuous in the process.

 

I guess it's a matter of semantics, but to me "cencorship" implies I'd be trying to limit what content they put in the game, and I'm not.


  • PlasmaCheese aime ceci

#21
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 431 messages

If we're not going to do nudity, fine. But I'd prefer fade to black rather than the awkward underwear scenes. 

Agreed


  • Heimdall, laudable11, Il Divo et 6 autres aiment ceci

#22
Cyberstrike nTo

Cyberstrike nTo
  • Members
  • 1 732 messages

What?

 

ME1 was nearly accused from being pornography in TV for showing nudity, it was quite big affair.

 

Nudity in ME1 is reason why in next installments love interest were always in underwear.  

 

That was FNC and since the average age of their viewers has been stated to be around 72 years. I don't know how many 72 year olds are playing video games but I don't think it's enough to hurt sales. All that did was galvanize players against FNC and create plenty of "take down" videos on youtube and helped show how dishonest all of the mainstream corporate media is in America was to gaming culture at the time. 


  • jstme, stargatefan1990 et The_Prophet_of_Donk aiment ceci

#23
dinobot100

dinobot100
  • Members
  • 6 messages

How would the proposed toggle work in practice? Black bars or blurred screens for nudity? Bleeps for bad language?

 

Good question. There are other games that have had such options in the past, and with the exception of Brutal Ledgend, none of them have used black bars or bleeps, they have simply reworked the scenes to 'skip,' but seemlessly, the content. You can't tell at all that anything is missing.



#24
Battlebloodmage

Battlebloodmage
  • Members
  • 8 700 messages

Please no, it's a waste of resource to create 2 versions for that. It would never happen or should it. The game is rated mature, so those who are over 18 should be able to handle it. There are T rated games like Star Wars the Old republic, so Bioware does have games like that. Let ME be ME, don't change it. The game already has a bad reputation for being too mild for today's standard, there is no need to dilute it more.


  • Spectr61, Andres Hendrix, ArabianIGoggles et 5 autres aiment ceci

#25
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 431 messages

DA2 had an option to disable the ridiculous kill animation that had body parts flying around like somebody nuked them. It toned down the gore in general. I used it.

 

DAO had a "persistent gore" toggle as well.