Aller au contenu

Photo

An Open Letter to Bioware Regarding Explicit Content


3411 réponses à ce sujet

#2776
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 752 messages

Reading this thread again, I feel like one of the LI's should have a gratuitously long sex scene, like Dan and Laurie in Watchmen with a flamethrower coitus. Unskillable of course.


Shep and Jack really should've just stripped down and shagged at the arena during the Citadel DLC.

#2777
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 846 messages

Shep and Jack really should've just stripped down and shagged at the arena during the Citadel DLC.

It's even better when you realize that the top of the arena has viewing windows for an audience.

"Hey did you catch Commander Shepard's last match?"

"Yeah. Hot."

#2778
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 752 messages

It's even better when you realize that the top of the arena has viewing windows for an audience.


Let alone possibly being broadcast to improve morale!
  • N7M aime ceci

#2779
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 846 messages
"That extranet vid hit 12 billion views in just 3 hours."
  • N7M aime ceci

#2780
AlanC9

AlanC9
  • Members
  • 35 706 messages

The ME1 scene is skippable.  Which is what I have asked for if fade to black is not in the cards.


Right. And I'm saying that I want them to do better than ME1. As usual, I don't share your tastes.
 

And as I said, "M" covers a lot of things.  They have been "using it" Just not this particular aspect.  "Because I can" is probably the worst excuse for adding any content.


My point was that I don't think they should feel restricted, since they are not restricted. Yeah, I'm assuming that they felt restricted when doing ME. You didn't?
  • FKA_Servo aime ceci

#2781
EmperorSahlertz

EmperorSahlertz
  • Members
  • 8 809 messages

So, what would the purpose of these filters be exactly? To blur out the sex scenes? To fade to black and skip them? To bleep out swear words? But most importantly, for what purpose?



#2782
Cyonan

Cyonan
  • Members
  • 19 366 messages

So, what would the purpose of these filters be exactly? To blur out the sex scenes? To fade to black and skip them? To bleep out swear words? But most importantly, for what purpose?

 

My suspicion is that the purpose would be for people who don't want those things in the game.


  • N7M et Arius aiment ceci

#2783
caradoc2000

caradoc2000
  • Members
  • 7 550 messages

My suspicion is that the purpose would be for people who don't want those things in the game.

There are plenty of other games for people who don't want such things.



#2784
Cyonan

Cyonan
  • Members
  • 19 366 messages

There are plenty of other games for people who don't want such things.

 

There are also other games for people who do want such things.

 

Plus the part where it's been discussed to death about not being financially viable aside, it's not like this thread was asking for that content to be removed from the game entirely for everybody.


  • N7M, Pasquale1234 et Arius aiment ceci

#2785
EmperorSahlertz

EmperorSahlertz
  • Members
  • 8 809 messages

My suspicion is that the purpose would be for people who don't want those things in the game.

But why buy a game that contains such things in the first place, if you are so against it?


  • caradoc2000 aime ceci

#2786
Cyonan

Cyonan
  • Members
  • 19 366 messages

But why buy a game that contains such things in the first place, if you are so against it?

 

My guess is because they got into the franchise before and BioWare has gotten more explicit in their content as time goes on with the exception of a short time where they seemed terrified of nudity after the controversy of Mass Effect 1.

 

I'm not actually against such content, though. I just believe that more choice in how we consume our media is typically a good thing, provided it is financially viable for the developer to do it.


  • Arius aime ceci

#2787
AlanC9

AlanC9
  • Members
  • 35 706 messages
Hey, I just thought of something.... what if the silly ME3 scenes happened because the ME3 team thought they were going to get the same freedom that the DAI team got, but they didn't. Not enough time to re-do them, but enough time to reskin to underwear.

Probably not, but I'd like to think that nobody ever deliberately intended that shower scene.
  • Il Divo aime ceci

#2788
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 752 messages

Hey, I just thought of something.... what if the silly ME3 scenes happened because the ME3 team thought they were going to get the same freedom that the DAI team got, but they didn't. Not enough time to re-do them, but enough time to reskin to underwear.

Probably not, but I'd like to think that nobody ever deliberately intended that shower scene.


It's a shame, because it was a few strips of fabric away from being one of BioWare's better romance sequences.

#2789
goishen

goishen
  • Members
  • 2 427 messages

"****, you sound like a *****."  Jack

 

That right there would be enough to merit an M rating.

 

As long as they've got the M rating, why not go whole hog?



#2790
SlottsMachine

SlottsMachine
  • Members
  • 5 541 messages

 

There seem to be all too many people who do want mammaries bouncing around.  And more.  

 

 

I am not familiar with these people but it sounds like they have some good ideas. 


  • Dermain aime ceci

#2791
AlanC9

AlanC9
  • Members
  • 35 706 messages

It's a shame, because it was a few strips of fabric away from being one of BioWare's better romance sequences.


It's good to be a member of the PC Master Race. I'd link, but I don't remember what the TOS says about this sort of thing.

#2792
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 752 messages

It's good to be a member of the PC Master Race. I'd link, but I don't remember what the TOS says about this sort of thing.


Being a Traynor fan, I know what you're referring to.

I think Shepard's arms and hands covering the naughty bits during a backwards embrace would've worked. Camerawork can do wonders, if they felt inclined to shield easily-offended eyes from such things.

#2793
N7M

N7M
  • Members
  • 11 477 messages

Inconsistencies in game rating categorization is part of the problem.
Here is a recent Reuters article addressing smoking and flaws in ESRB ratings system.
 



#2794
Arius

Arius
  • Members
  • 29 messages

But why buy a game that contains such things in the first place, if you are so against it?

 

This is quite a silly question. I bought Skyrim, even though I hate cliche main stories in video games. I bought it for lore, for gameplay, for modding potential to craft it into something I could really enjoy...

 

I still hate the bloody main story and wish it were different.

 

We buy games for the things we like in them, that doesn't mean we can't say we'd prefer something in them were different. We buy games if we find them to be overall fun/good. I dislike many things in Mass Effect 2 and it's my favorite game of all time. You're saying I shouldn't buy Mass Effect 2 because it has very linear game missions? I'm very against that!



#2795
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

Right. And I'm saying that I want them to do better than ME1. As usual, I don't share your tastes.

So you want unskippable sex scenes?



#2796
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 349 messages

Clearly they aren't, as per the complaints made towards previous BioWare games.

Inquisition shows that they're listening to those folks, resulting in some really solid intimate scenes.
 

Wait, they were uncomfortable with...literally every game they've ever made before?

 

 

 

Uh ...

http://forum.bioware...ent/?p=19487202

That's not drama.  THat's a sex scene.

 

SHeesh no wonder romance fans get laughed at on other forums if that's what passes for "relationship drama"

 

 

 

Okay, but being a retriever automatically makes it a dog. Why shouldn't the game embrace being a retriever, especially if it's a well-behaved one?
What makes ME1 a M-rated game to you, instead of a T-rated game?
 

THis is me saying I prefer spaniels.

 

ANd offhand, I'd say ME1 is M instead of T because of the blood, language, partial nudity, sexual themes, and violence

 

 

 

I agree, but by properly using the M-rating, those scenes would also appear exactly as they were shot and intended with *gasp* the human(oid) body visible. You know, the way people actually do things. Nudity can also be done tastefully.
 

Please, please please don't tell me you think Traynor's shower scene would have been more tasteful if she wasn't in her underwear!

 

 

 

Are you offended by the Inquisitor also being topless?
 

 

Less so. THe Inquisitor's boobs weren't crowding the dialogue wheel

 

 

 

I think all those scenes should be skippable in some way, but not at the expense of them becoming trivial. That's precisely what'll happen if they're relegated to "the scenes that have to exist with or without a toggle". Inquisition took some strides forward in that arena, strides that this proposal would undo.
 

THey're romance scenes.  Optional content of optional content.  MAybe they should be "trivial"

 

You know what I think Inquisition made "great strides" in?  Blackwall and Dorian's sex scenes were entirely optional.  Not skippable.  Optional.  You could decline sex and not break the romance.

 

 

 

 No, you're asking for the writers to keep conservative tastes in mind.

You keep using that word.  I do not think it means what you think it means

 

 

 

How about the parents who would prefer for "the alien sex game" to be rated T so they can safely buy it for their children? Shall they keep their tastes in mind? If this content is going to become so inconsequential that it's able to be switched off with a toggle, why bother with the M rating?
 

Dang, I guess ME2 should be rated T!

 

 

 

Do you really consider what most pro-nudity people have discussed in this topic to be "clamoring"?
 

SOme, yes .  Not all, but certainly the more"enthusiastic" ones

 

 

 

 
Can you run me through how the gameplay-based gore toggle is the same as a narrative-based content filter?

 

Gore toggle:  violence without gratuitous amounts of blood

Skippable sex scenes:  ROmance content without gratuitous amounts of T&A


  • dragonflight288 et Arius aiment ceci

#2797
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 846 messages

Gore toggle:  violence without gratuitous amounts of blood

 

Heh, as if. All the gore toggle does is keep your characters clean, but when the weapons come out the viscera still flies. On or off, my Warden decapitates the hell out of everyone and it's still a glorious crimson sprinkler. In DA2 a powerful critical blow makes mooks look like they stepped on a land mine. 

They should've done like that GoW comic and have rainbows and sprinkles come out of them.



#2798
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 349 messages

Heh, as if. All the gore toggle does is keep your characters clean, but when the weapons come out the viscera still flies. On or off, my Warden decapitates the hell out of everyone and it's still a glorious crimson sprinkler. In DA2 a powerful critical blow makes mooks look like they stepped on a land mine. 

They should've done like that GoW comic and have rainbows and sprinkles come out of them.

Okay, violence with less gratuitous amounts of blood ;)



#2799
dreamgazer

dreamgazer
  • Members
  • 15 752 messages

Wait, they were uncomfortable with...literally every game they've ever made before?


Yes, literally every one. Please, Iakus.
 

That's not drama.  THat's a sex scene.
 
SHeesh no wonder romance fans get laughed at on other forums if that's what passes for "relationship drama"


Yes, sex scenes are very frequently the culmination of relationship drama, and there's nothing wrong with that.

You're smarter than this.
 

This is me saying I prefer spaniels.
 
ANd offhand, I'd say ME1 is M instead of T because of the blood, language, partial nudity, sexual themes, and violence


Most of which can be found in T-rated games.

I repeat: what, specifically, makes ME1 M-rated instead of T-rated? The language isn't bad, the violence moderate, and not a female nipple in sight.
 

Please, please please don't tell me you think Traynor's shower scene would have been more tasteful if she wasn't in her underwear!

 
Sure, I'll say it: that scene would've exhibited a better taste level by showing Traynor's body while showering instead of showering with underwear on. Is that inaccurate?
 

Less so. THe Inquisitor's boobs weren't crowding the dialogue wheel

 

Wait, but you were still offended? By the shirtless male Inquisitor?
 

THey're romance scenes.  Optional content of optional content.  MAybe they should be "trivial"


Why, instead of being integrated into the storytelling? Why cheapen it?
 

You know what I think Inquisition made "great strides" in?  Blackwall and Dorian's sex scenes were entirely optional.  Not skippable.  Optional.  You could decline sex and not break the romance.

 

Inquisition did a lot right all-around.
 

You keep using that word.  I do not think it means what you think it means


Why not?

conservative: disposed to preserve existing conditions, institutions, etc., or to restore traditional ones, and to limit change. Cautiously moderate or purposefully low. And, traditional in style or manner; avoiding novelty or showiness.

This attitude toward words of the English language and toward the human body are incredibly conservative.
 

Dang, I guess ME2 should be rated T!

 

Censor the language with another conservative ( :)) content filter, and it just might've been!
 

Gore toggle:  violence without gratuitous amounts of blood
Skippable sex scenes:  ROmance content without gratuitous amounts of T&A


... gratuitous? Good grief.

Still didn't actually answer my question about the difference. One involves gameplay, the other narrative censorship and triviality.

PS: I'm just fine with a "Skip" button.
  • Sylvius the Mad et Dirthamen aiment ceci

#2800
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 846 messages

I would argue that Traynor's shower scene would have been more tasteful if she was actually nude, and that Shepard actually stripped as well. I don't think the bra and Shepard getting her uniform/hoodie wet because she's just so damn hot for not-yeomen is particularly good aesthetic judgment. It just looks dumb. Of course, a simple solution that satisfies this without causing any kind of stir would simply be to have the proper shots that just omit the "naughtiest" bits of the scene. If you're going to go full upper torso in an intimate scene that is typically done without clothing, it's silly to half-ass it. 


  • Il Divo, Han Shot First, dreamgazer et 2 autres aiment ceci