Aller au contenu

Photo

Mike laidlaw and David Gaider have contradictions:kill darkspawn is a job for HoF or warden orlesian


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
117 réponses à ce sujet

#26
Navoletti

Navoletti
  • Members
  • 373 messages

lady0635 i understood but i think they close the fate of hawke why they offer options for the hero of ferelden fate in DAO and they never close the story of warden alive?what is the point of offer options of states?

 

i think the warden need a closure with a cameo scene they not need talk or a scene with the control carácter of the Hof/warden orlesian same of joker scene control in ME2



#27
Pokemario

Pokemario
  • Members
  • 1 064 messages

i understood but i think they close the fate of hawke

 

They most definitely didn't.



#28
Guest_lady0635_*

Guest_lady0635_*
  • Guests

lady0635 i understood but i think they close the fate of hawke why they offer options for the hero of ferelden fate in DAO and they never close the story of warden alive?what is the point of offer options of states?

 

i think the warden need a closure with a cameo scene they not need talk or a scene with the control carácter of the Hof/warden orlesian same of joker scene control in ME2

 

The Warden if still alive is seeking a cure to the Calling. You can contact the HOF later in DAI. They write to you personally and apologize for being unable to help and send you a gift. They are alive and well and their story ended in DAO. Hawke's story can end in DAI, but I'm questioning it now since recent talks of future DLC implies it might not be the end for them.



#29
Navoletti

Navoletti
  • Members
  • 373 messages

shininan if i never see more my warden i quit the franchise for this i need a response of David Gaider and Laidlaw....really they play with the fans...why witch hunt never close the story of warden?why they offer a cliffhanger with the suspect dissapearences of warden and hawke....

 

they open,open and re open the story of warden i only need see a cameo scene or a time for use my warden in future dlc or games....much players sense this...Hof or warden orlesian is ignored since DA2...



#30
Jeremiah12LGeek

Jeremiah12LGeek
  • Members
  • 23 924 messages

I have no idea what's going on.


  • AllThatJazz, They call me a SpaceCowboy, Heimdall et 7 autres aiment ceci

#31
They call me a SpaceCowboy

They call me a SpaceCowboy
  • Members
  • 2 825 messages

shininan if i never see more my warden i quit the franchise for this i need a response of David Gaider and Laidlaw....really they play with the fans...why witch hunt never close the story of warden?why they offer a cliffhanger with the suspect dissapearences of warden and hawke....

 

they open,open and re open the story of warden i only need see a cameo scene or a time for use my warden in future dlc or games....much players sense this...Hof or warden orlesian is ignored since DA2...

 

 

Didn't someone already say above that Laidlaw said the HOF will never appear?

 

In any case, as Lady0635 says above, the HOF's story may be done in letters and codex entries. DAI did not ignore the Warden. It's unlikely they will ever appear though.


  • Heimdall et Pokemario aiment ceci

#32
Guest_lady0635_*

Guest_lady0635_*
  • Guests

Ah I just watched the trailer again in a quiet room and listened to the dialogue closely. The Inquisition is investigating dangerous tremors/earthquakes that could destroy Thedas and in doing so, run into the cause of it. The Darkspawn and Wraith. This is not Warden related at all.



#33
Navoletti

Navoletti
  • Members
  • 373 messages

lady0635 whatt they include more content of hawke in future dlc and not of warden?

 

 

really?if this happen i quit seriously the franchise.

 

 

hawke is not important for the franchise but the warden is much important and they decide ignore the fate of him...hee need hide the face or créate a option same of hawke for créate the face of him...not voice same of skyrim..or use a options of enable and disable voices and problema solved for much users...

 

 

warden need a chance for close the story of they with a quality scene or the control of they.



#34
Rabastan

Rabastan
  • Members
  • 74 messages
Spoiler

 

But don't tell anyone or BioWare and EA will sue the heck out of me !

 

Edit: seriously though, if s/he's that important to you then maybe you should quit the franchise.


  • They call me a SpaceCowboy, BadgerladDK, Demonique et 2 autres aiment ceci

#35
Guest_lady0635_*

Guest_lady0635_*
  • Guests

I'm very sorry Navoletti but it's been confirmed by the writers that the HOF is done. A minor cameo in a Codex is all we got in DAI. We might hear of them in the future, but unlike Hawke, they won't be there. Hawke was also the first talking player so it's easier to bring them back.

 

I guess it's how I played DAO and DAA, but I found my Warden got plenty of closure and returned to her lover in Antiva until she searched for the cure.


  • Avejajed aime ceci

#36
Navoletti

Navoletti
  • Members
  • 373 messages

i have rumours that they delete the presence of the Hof in the full game...for this is my dissapointing more with this franchise..they delete the content of the Hof scenes of the full game...i read in a magazine.



#37
They call me a SpaceCowboy

They call me a SpaceCowboy
  • Members
  • 2 825 messages

i have rumours that they delete the presence of the Hof in the full game...for this is my dissapointing more with this franchise..they delete the content of the Hof scenes of the full game...i read in a magazine.

 

 

They deleted a lot of stuff from the game, simply because of time, or because the content didn't work. This is normal game development. It's unfortunate, and I'm sure the devs are disappointed too, that something they worked on got cut. That's the way it goes, Gotta accept it and move on



#38
dewayne31

dewayne31
  • Members
  • 1 452 messages

i try not to get in hof should return threads. but i think hawke had a greater impact on the series then the warden. yes laidaw himself the warden would never appear again.



#39
Nixou

Nixou
  • Members
  • 614 messages
The Warden didn't have a voice back in DA:O. If BioWare brings them back, they'd be forced to give him/her a voice, and believe me when I say that a lot of people WON'T like that. And if they bring them back, many people would complain about how he/she is not the character they played in Origins

 

 

Revan was a non-voiced cypher for the players to inhabit in KOTOR.

 

As for the very likely differences that will appear between the portrayal of the HoF and the players' headcanon, well, nine years stand between Witch Hunt an Inquisition's beginning: people change in a decade.

 

***

 

The Warden if still alive is seeking a cure to the Calling. [...] They are alive and well and their story ended in DAO

 

 

Indeed, but by allowing the possibility of the Warden surviving the fifth Blight and rising through the ranks to become Warden-Commender in Ferelden, the writers dug a hole they can't get out of:

The Warden's tale was complete at the end of Origin, that's absolutely true. Even Awakening isn't really the tale of "The" Warden: it's the Tale of the Commander of the Grey in Ferelden, who may be the HoF but whose origin is virtually inconsequential in this story.

The problem is that the writers keep bringing back the story into the Warden's home turf. A surviving HoF being invisible in DA2 wasn't a problem at all: s/he was busy ruling over an Arling located on the other side of the sea. But Inquisition put nearly half of the action in Ferelden, a large part of the plot involve the Wardens being enthralled by Corypheus because the Orlesian commander of the Grey panicked while her Fereldan counterpart was absent, and now they bring in more Darkspawn and potentially the Architect as well.

The Warden's story is over, yet Bioware's writers, despite being openly unenthusiastic about bringing back Origins' protagonist into the spotlight, keep making new stories involving his/her legacy, and predictably, people seeing keep asking for the Warden to reappear onscreen.

 

Which is why I maintain that the best thing to do is to bring back the Warden... in order to give him/her a definitive unambiguous plotline death and be done for good with this character.



#40
Sunnie

Sunnie
  • Members
  • 4 068 messages

I have no idea what's going on.

Shenanigans, Darkspawn shenanigans.

 

Didn't someone already say above that Laidlaw said the HOF will never appear?

 

In any case, as Lady0635 says above, the HOF's story may be done in letters and codex entries. DAI did not ignore the Warden. It's unlikely they will ever appear though.

This is correct, Gaider, Laidlaw and then Weekes all said about the same thing, the HoF is not going to be back in DA:I.

 

i have rumours that they delete the presence of the Hof in the full game...for this is my dissapointing more with this franchise..they delete the content of the Hof scenes of the full game...i read in a magazine.

There was never going to be the HoF in DA:I, there were no scenes to cut because they never existed. Not sure what magazine you saw that in, I would cancel that subscription if you have one because that is a big load of BS.



#41
Guest_lady0635_*

Guest_lady0635_*
  • Guests

 

Which is why I maintain that the best thing to do is to bring back the Warden... in order to give him/her a definitive unambiguous plotline death and be done for good with this character.

 

 

The tricky part is the Warden commonly dies doing the US so their story is officially complete in DAO if you refuse Morrigan's ritual and don't bring Alistair/Loghain with you.



#42
pdusen

pdusen
  • Members
  • 1 788 messages

Oh, look. He's back.

 

...and people are humoring him for some reason.


  • BadgerladDK et randomcheeses aiment ceci

#43
correctamundo

correctamundo
  • Members
  • 1 673 messages

Like the wind that's always blowing, life is flowing - move on.



#44
dsl08002

dsl08002
  • Members
  • 1 779 messages

Ok,look. The Warden didn't have a voice back in DA:O. If BioWare brings them back, they'd be forced to give him/her a voice, and believe me when I say that a lot of people WON'T like that. And if they bring them back, many people would complain about how he/she is not the character they played in Origins (because they'd be forced to give ALL OF THEM the same personality)
 
They brought Hawke back since it was easier for them as
1. He/She has a voice. The Warden does not.
2. He/She has a set personality. The Warden does not.


I dont think that is true anymore. Because the more bioware progress you would be forced to accept that many things are changing and you simply have to keep up. But the most truobling and annoying is that the warden has no role in DAI whatsoever. Besides Hawke wasnt brought back because of the mage/templar conflict only because of the run in with corypheuS, so it gives the signal they never intended to have hawke in DAI anyway. And i agree with the author of the thread there are a lot of contradictions and poor excuses from Bioware regarding the HoF return if alive, especially in this situation.

And lets be honest after the ME3 ending bioware doesnt care if the fans get upset or angry in response what they do.

#45
Guest_AedanStarfang_*

Guest_AedanStarfang_*
  • Guests

lady0635 this is a plot hole...really they use the excuse of the inquisition is a former group for solve the conflicto of mage and templars...well why now inquisitor steal the Jobs of the gray wardens?

 

 

 

They-took-our-gggfx8.jpg

 

I apologize, I couldn't resist!

 

Also as others have stated the dwarves, more specifically "The Legion of the Dead" have been fighting off the Darkspawn hordes for years with nary a warden among them. As also mentioned in DA2, Hawke and company venture into the Deep Roads and encounter darkspawn while obviously not on Warden Duty. So no the Deep Roads and exploration therefore of is NOT relegated or limited to strictly Grey Wardens, the grey wardens are called in to deal with blights and Archdemons -- the Deep Roads and Darkspawn stragglers are left for separate armies and entities to deal with until such a time arrives. In fact if anyone is "stealing jobs from anyone" it is the wardens stealing from the Dwarves as going down to the Deep Roads and killing Darkspawn has been a Dwarven honor and tradition for generations and they have had to share living quarters in proximity to Darkspawn and Archdemons longer than the actual wardens have had to fight them on the surface for blights.

 

i try not to get in hof should return threads. but i think hawke had a greater impact on the series then the warden. yes laidaw himself the warden would never appear again.

 
Personally "I" don't believe that Hawke had a greater impact on the series than the HOF, I just think that with all of the variables and time it would take it was simply easier for BW to write the HOF off as a non-entity researching the calling somewhere [if alive] and simply dead if dead. I mean as far as having an impact goes I hear/see more  people crying for a HOF/Warden return than a Hawke one, who even in the game world is regarded as a pariah and a precursor of bad luck, at least in Kirkwall and the regions thereof. 

  • Demonique aime ceci

#46
Nixou

Nixou
  • Members
  • 614 messages
The tricky part is the Warden commonly dies doing the US so their story is officially complete in DAO if you refuse Morrigan's ritual and don't bring Alistair/Loghain with you.

 

 

Which brings us back to Awakening: Awakening is the story of the Warden-Commander, with the two potential Commanders (HoF or Orlesian replacement) being interchangeable. The same can be done again: if the HoF is dead, introduce the Orlesian Commander upholding his/her illustrious predecessor's legacy; if the HoF made a deal with Morrigan or sent Alistair/Loghain to their death in the final battle, give your audience the fan service they crave so much by having a handful of bonus scenes, dialogs and banters triggered by the HoF presence in an otherwise identical tale... and then  crush them by killing the HoF at the end.  :devil:



#47
Nightshade715

Nightshade715
  • Members
  • 137 messages

 

Which brings us back to Awakening: Awakening is the story of the Warden-Commander, with the two potential Commanders (HoF or Orlesian replacement) being interchangeable. The same can be done again: if the HoF is dead, introduce the Orlesian Commander upholding his/her illustrious predecessor's legacy; if the HoF made a deal with Morrigan or sent Alistair/Loghain to their death in the final battle, give your audience the fan service they crave so much by having a handful of bonus scenes, dialogs and banters triggered by the HoF presence in an otherwise identical tale... and then  crush them by killing the HoF at the end.  :devil:

Your obsession with killing off the Hero of Ferelden is getting pretty weird.



#48
Jawzzus

Jawzzus
  • Members
  • 2 399 messages

Que?


  • jawsisinmywc aime ceci

#49
Avejajed

Avejajed
  • Members
  • 5 155 messages

The Hof?

 

thehoff.jpg?w=300&h=282


  • BadgerladDK, wildannie, Demonique et 3 autres aiment ceci

#50
Nixou

Nixou
  • Members
  • 614 messages
Your obsession with killing off the Hero of Ferelden is getting pretty weird.

 

 

There's nothing weird about it: on one hand I:

 

  1. Consider Origins the weakest episode in the series plot-wise
  2. Agree with the notion that the Warden's tale is complete
  3. Like the fact that each new episodes introduce a new protagonist

So i'm perfectly fine with the HoF being simply absent.

 

But on the other hand Bioware's writers keep bringing back characters, places and events directly linked to the HoF, and are introducing new plot-lines (Cure for the taint, exploring the uncharted West) just to keep the character away from a story that concern him/her rather directly. (If DA4 centers around, say, the Nevarran succession crisis or the Qunari reconquering Rivain instead of gravitating around the Taint, Darkspawns and other Warden-related matters, I'll be perfectly fine with the HoF gallivanting somewhere else)

 

Or the most definitive way to get rid of a character you don't want to write about anymore is to simply kill that character.