Aller au contenu

Photo

Will Cerberus Make It To ME:A?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
338 réponses à ce sujet

#176
Fixers0

Fixers0
  • Members
  • 4 434 messages

Narrative overuse and constant demonization, yes.

 

Actual lore utility, no.

 

 

Yeah, because it's totally not lore breaking that one deranged indvidual could be leading a galaxy wide conspiracy organisation just a few years or so years after Humanity got introduced to the galactic community. Thanks to Foundation we know that Cerberus was doing it super secret stuff some twenty years before the start of ME1.

 

Oh yeah and they commissed an entire military fleet in a whopping three years, And they got a dozen front corpations somehow, who set they up exactly? and why didn't the Alliance notice that private shipyards were building military warships? I just doesn't make any sense given the small time frame.

 

For such an insignificant presence humanity had on the galactic scene, Cerberus got a disproportionately large influence on that same galaxy. There's no way a Human splinter organisation can match the technological, military and logistical capabilities of the established powers that have been in charge for many centuries when even humanity's main vehicle, the Systems Alliance can't even come close to them.

 

Of course this reflected in many  more aspects as well, for example: Why are there so many humans in the Terminus systems? Why are two of the three major merc bands dominated by human members? Why are most of the important galactic corporations human founded/owned? 


  • Vortex13 et WildOrchid aiment ceci

#177
WildOrchid

WildOrchid
  • Members
  • 7 256 messages

Of course this reflected in many  more aspects as well, for example: Why are there so many humans in the Terminus systems? Why are two of the three major merc bands dominated by human members? Why are most of the important galactic corporations human founded/owned? 

 

Because the game was ridiculously favoring "teh humanz".



#178
Dantriges

Dantriges
  • Members
  • 1 288 messages

They commissioned the fleet three years ago? I thought it was even shorter.



#179
Jock Cranley

Jock Cranley
  • Members
  • 1 646 messages

Let's hope not. Everything interesting about them was gutted in ME3.



#180
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

"We spent $$10,000,000,000,000 to bring a single person back from the dead. Also, we, a secretive organization operating in the shadows, slap our logo on everything. And we have limitless resources and personnel. And we want humans to dominate the entire galaxy! But we don't hate aliens or anything..."

 

After ME1 Cerberus is entirely stupid and the fact that BioWare shoved them down our throats is, to me, proof that they had no idea what they were doing with the franchise.

 

Said person is well worth the cost, probably worth more than entire civilizations. 

 

Slapping your logo on everything is something secret organizations do: it tends to help that 1) nobody notices what it means (except people who are in the know), and, 2) an even better solution, their logo is representative of somebody else (like a front corporation perhaps...) in the minds of the galaxy.

 

Human dominance and not hating aliens isn't mutually exclusive. I fully support a system where humans are the 'dominant' species in the galaxy, the leader in progress and advancement, and the big power, so to speak. That does not at all mean that I support marginalizing, enslaving, or outright eradicating other alien groups. And Cerberus is the same. Hell, it doesn't even preclude a sort of intergalactic super/supranationalist entity for all the species.

 

It just means I want to see humanity at the cutting edge, ahead of the curve, and the technological, economic, cultural, and military leader of the galaxy.



#181
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

Yeah, because it's totally not lore breaking that one deranged indvidual could be leading a galaxy wide conspiracy organisation just a few years or so years after Humanity got introduced to the galactic community. Thanks to Foundation we know that Cerberus was doing it super secret stuff some twenty years before the start of ME1.

 

Oh yeah and they commissed an entire military fleet in a whopping three years, And they got a dozen front corpations somehow, who set they up exactly? and why didn't the Alliance notice that private shipyards were building military warships? I just doesn't make any sense given the small time frame.

 

For such an insignificant presence humanity had on the galactic scene, Cerberus got a disproportionately large influence on that same galaxy. There's no way a Human splinter organisation can match the technological, military and logistical capabilities of the established powers that have been in charge for many centuries when even humanity's main vehicle, the Systems Alliance can't even come close to them.

 

Of course this reflected in many  more aspects as well, for example: Why are there so many humans in the Terminus systems? Why are two of the three major merc bands dominated by human members? Why are most of the important galactic corporations human founded/owned? 

 

Sans the bit on the 'deranged' leader, I chalk a lot of this up to narrative overuse. I'm not going to deny that Cerberus became whatever the writers wanted them to become at any given time, much like Liara. 

 

In lore though, yes, I support Cerberus doing all of this. Because I want to see Cerberus at the top of humanity, with humanity at the top of the galaxy. There are explanations I can make (purely speculative of course, with no emphasis on canon necessary) that justify each of these.



#182
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

Because the game was ridiculously favoring "teh humanz".

 

Better than "teh aleinz"


  • themikefest et YHWH aiment ceci

#183
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 830 messages

Said person is well worth the cost, probably worth more than entire civilizations. 

 

That depends. In ME2, Shepard was brought back simply for some sort of symbolic value. Realistically, there would have to be something more than Shepard's mad skillz or being the hood ornament of cosmic awesome. The cipher would be as good a reason as any, since it's unique information that can never be recreated, since Shepard was the only being in the galaxy that really possessed all of the pieces between the two beacons and what Shiala provided. It's fairly miraculous that somehow, this was restored as well. F***in' Project Lazarus. How does it work? 


  • Nomen Mendax et Natureguy85 aiment ceci

#184
Dantriges

Dantriges
  • Members
  • 1 288 messages

True Resurrection. :wizard:  Cleric 9th spell level. :whistle:


  • Natureguy85 aime ceci

#185
N7Jamaican

N7Jamaican
  • Members
  • 1 778 messages

Shepard is Cerberus. When he left, Cerberus lost the best agent they've ever had.



#186
Nomen Mendax

Nomen Mendax
  • Members
  • 572 messages

That depends. In ME2, Shepard was brought back simply for some sort of symbolic value. Realistically, there would have to be something more than Shepard's mad skillz or being the hood ornament of cosmic awesome. The cipher would be as good a reason as any, since it's unique information that can never be recreated, since Shepard was the only being in the galaxy that really possessed all of the pieces between the two beacons and what Shiala provided. It's fairly miraculous that somehow, this was restored as well. F***in' Project Lazarus. How does it work? 

So much this! In my fantasy version of ME this is why they bring Shepard back. Its the one thing that genuinly makes Shepard unique. If you also make it so Cerberus for some reason suspect that the Collectors were once the Protheans then there is even more reason to resurrect him/her since he can read/speak/understand Prothean.


  • Natureguy85 aime ceci

#187
breakdown71289

breakdown71289
  • Members
  • 4 195 messages

I think Cerberus has had plenty time in the limelight thus far. Time for a new enemy to engage in firefights with.



#188
Dantriges

Dantriges
  • Members
  • 1 288 messages

I think the human representative in this multispecies endeavour can look after humanity´s interests this time without Cerberus lurking behind the corner which would make turning him into some who sympathizes with the organisation way too easy.



#189
shodiswe

shodiswe
  • Members
  • 4 999 messages

Wouldn't be surprised if we find Cerberus on Andromeda first,annoying the alien races there lol,considering the resources Cerberus have.
Our crew members could be undercover Cerberus,or some Cerberus Phantom will infiltrate the ship.


Kind of doubt it since they were indoctrinated slaves of the Reapers and their focus was the harvest and end of all Life in the milkyway. By the middle of ME3 there was none except for indoctrinated slavesleft, everyone was either indoctrianted or purged. They were never about survival or escaping from the Reapers.

Some of them might have tried to become reapers.

#190
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

Kind of doubt it since they were indoctrinated slaves of the Reapers and their focus was the harvest and end of all Life in the milkyway. By the middle of ME3 there was none except for indoctrinated slavesleft, everyone was either indoctrianted or purged. They were never about survival or escaping from the Reapers.

Some of them might have tried to become reapers.

Well, there were a few agents that weren't indoctrinated slaves or purged. General Oleg Petrovsky comes to mind. 



#191
SNascimento

SNascimento
  • Members
  • 6 002 messages

I hope their armor designer do. My, didn't Cerberus know how to make armors or what?



#192
Vortex13

Vortex13
  • Members
  • 4 186 messages

Better than "teh aleinz"

 

 

Outside of Avatar I can't think of any mainstream science fiction setting that had a major focus on aliens. Sure we had invasion movies, and the like, but all of that is just the camera looking at the humans reacting to what the off screen aliens are doing. 

 

A stronger (not complete) focus on the alien side of the galaxy might not be the next 2001: A Space Odyssey, but it would at least be different from 99.999% of all the other settings out there.



#193
Sylvius the Mad

Sylvius the Mad
  • Members
  • 24 111 messages

ME2 is the best game of the trilogy.

It's the one I enjoy the least. It had the worst combat, the least roleplaying freedom, and planet scanning. ME2 is dreadful.

#194
Jay P

Jay P
  • Members
  • 442 messages

FTFY.


So it's not called Mass Effect: Andromeda because we are leaving the Milky Way Galaxy and going to the Andromeda Galaxy?

#195
N7Jamaican

N7Jamaican
  • Members
  • 1 778 messages

Cerberus had resources and access to TONS of credits.  I wouldn't be surprised if TIM commissioned their own "ARK" in case the Cerberus operations in the Milky Way failed.  But what I think is, why wouldn't TIM go on this said ARK to Andromeda?  Why would he stay in the Milky Way, with the possibility knowing "controlling" the Reapers won't work?

 

And considering TIM was indoctrinated, it would make sense if the Reapers knew of an ARK to go to the Andromeda and perhaps wanted to arrive there first.



#196
Natureguy85

Natureguy85
  • Members
  • 3 254 messages

But I don't know. I mean, they really are everywhere. And TIM even made the whole "idea not organisation" thing opening up the way for a new breed of Cerberus to try to plant their flag in Andromeda. If that's going to happen though, please for god's sake can we not have them being main antagonists?

 

That "Cerberus was an idea" is just a common line they slapped in there. Particularly villains say it a lot.

 

Am I the only one that feels that provided some small changes you can play ME1 and then safely jump directly to ME3 without even noticing too much. Not debating the game itself (ME2 was fun and had my favorite DLC LoSB) but I just feel the entire working with Cerberus in that game is absolutely worthless. I feel better just skipping the game and move to the third chapter as you are not achieving anything in that game other than making your next enemy stronger.

 

That's because the main plot had nothing to do with the Reapers. You are not any closer to beating them than you were at the start of the game and now they are just two years closer. Arrival at least had something to do with the Reapers but was ultimately pointless.

 

Hell, can we have the option to actually sympathize, ally with, and even join said group?

 

I was tired of constantly getting shat on in ME3 for supporting and promoting Cerberus. It's just not good writing over how anvilicious BW was in ME3.

 

Most of ME2 and ME3 main plots are not good writing.

 

Like Thane, or Jacob, or just about everyone. Seems like unless you romance Liara/VS, the whole thing just sort of fizzles out.

 

I don't think ME2 is the best game of the trilogy, but it was alright until ME3 came out and somehow made it worse.

 

ME1 is still solid, in spite of everything (including its unfortunate gameplay).

 

Well Tali and Garrus carry over as well. Anyway, ME has the best plot but ME2 develops the characters really well.

 

Thanks a lot for coaxing me out of the shell, but I'm one of the people who does defend ME2's place in the series and the role given to the player.

 

I know ME2 is rather weak narratively, but it did leave a basis of structure for ME3 to follow... which ME3 never followed up on.

 

As well, you'll have to define for me how Cerberus was stupid 5 minutes into ME2. Seemed like they were the only ones who had a plan for anything going on at all.

 

What did ME2 leave for ME3? It did nothing for the Reaper plot. I'll tell you how Cerberus was stupid; spending all that money and time resurrecting Shepard when he did nothing special that some other competent military person, like perhaps Zaeed, couldn't do. All of that blather between TIM and Miranda at the start? None of that happens. Nobody rallies behind Shepard. He has to do favors to recruit people and then do more favors to keep them from screwing up their jobs in the Suicide Mission. The Cypher and strong Will that made Shepard special in Mass Effect are totally dropped from the narrative. Then there's the crew on the derelict Reaper, but we didn't know about that yet.

 

Oh yeah and they commissed an entire military fleet in a whopping three years,

 

For such an insignificant presence humanity had on the galactic scene, Cerberus got a disproportionately large influence on that same galaxy. There's no way a Human splinter organisation can match the technological, military and logistical capabilities of the established powers that have been in charge for many centuries when even humanity's main vehicle, the Systems Alliance can't even come close to them.

 

Of course this reflected in many  more aspects as well, for example: Why are there so many humans in the Terminus systems? Why are two of the three major merc bands dominated by human members? Why are most of the important galactic corporations human founded/owned? 

 

They commissioned the fleet three years ago? I thought it was even shorter.

 

Yes, it was in the few short months between ME2 and ME3. Cerberus is tiny according to EDI if you talk to her after she is unshackled in ME2. Fixer, I love your other questions.

 

Said person is well worth the cost, probably worth more than entire civilizations. 

 

How was Shepard worth the cost? Sure, he ends up winning but what did he do that any other good soldier couldn't have done? Maybe they'd have a harder time convincing Garrus and wouldn't get Tali, I guess.

 

That depends. In ME2, Shepard was brought back simply for some sort of symbolic value. Realistically, there would have to be something more than Shepard's mad skillz or being the hood ornament of cosmic awesome. The cipher would be as good a reason as any, since it's unique information that can never be recreated, since Shepard was the only being in the galaxy that really possessed all of the pieces between the two beacons and what Shiala provided. It's fairly miraculous that somehow, this was restored as well. F***in' Project Lazarus. How does it work? 

 

And that symbolic value is never realized in the plot. Shepard still has to do favors to get everyone to join. You can even lampshade this in one of the responses to Mordin when he tells you to distribute the plague cure first.  As Norman Mendax said, the Cipher is the prime reason Shepard was special in ME1.  They could have made the beacon visions develop more clearly over the course of the series, as Shiala told him it will take time to process the Cipher. That would have been a way better introduction to the Crucible that it being found on the Mars Archives. The only other way to go would be that Shepard has extraordinarily strong will, as several characters in ME1 mention. Emphasizing that would have made the story ripe for an Indoctrination plot with Shepard actually being able to resist.



#197
sjsharp2011

sjsharp2011
  • Members
  • 2 676 messages

Personally, I didn't like it too much, although a lot of folks said it was better written than Mass Effect 3 apparently back when it was released.

 

Truth be told I take anyones opinion on his work with a grain of salt, maybe watch a video of the game or something to get a feel for it.

I thought Halo 4 was a good solid story. In my case I'd say it's more the level designs I didn't like



#198
Vortex13

Vortex13
  • Members
  • 4 186 messages

I thought Halo 4 was a good solid story. In my case I'd say it's more the level designs I didn't like

 

 

I didn't like the focus being once again on humanity as the apparent Übermensch of the universe; then again my interest in the series had been waning since Halo 2. Humans being somehow able to manipulate Forerunner artifacts? Cool. Humans existing back when the Forerunners where around as well as kicking the ever-loving crap out of them; only being taken down by the double team of Forerunner and Flood attacks? Boring, self gratifying trite (IMO).

 

Can't we see a story from the Covenant's side of things, can't we play as an Elite, Brute, Drone, etc. after the events of Halo 3 and see how the aliens handle life after the war? I admit that I found a perverse pleasure in the teaser trailer for Halo Wars 2; hopefully it will have a Covenant campaign and I can grind the demons into dust  :devil: 



#199
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

I didn't like the focus being once again on humanity as the apparent Übermensch of the universe; then again my interest in the series had been waning since Halo 2. Humans being somehow able to manipulate Forerunner artifacts? Cool. Humans existing back when the Forerunners where around as well as kicking the ever-loving crap out of them; only being taken down by the double team of Forerunner and Flood attacks? Boring, self gratifying trite (IMO).

 

Can't we see a story from the Covenant's side of things, can't we play as an Elite, Brute, Drone, etc. after the events of Halo 3 and see how the aliens handle life after the war? I admit that I found a perverse pleasure in the teaser trailer for Halo Wars 2; hopefully it will have a Covenant campaign and I can grind the demons into dust  :devil: 

 

You can read the books. They give you plenty of perspective from the Elites, Grunts, and other perspectives.

 

Still, I guess I'm one of those few who doesn't think that 'humans are special' is a problem, though I don't believe anything intrinsic about it. 

 

I don't think we have more of a right to live than anyone else. That said, I don't think that anyone has more of a right than us, and, well, better us than them. 

 

If there's one lesson, just one lesson that anyone should ever learn about bullying, it's that it's better to be the bully than it is to be the bullied.



#200
Fixers0

Fixers0
  • Members
  • 4 434 messages

If there's one lesson, just one lesson that anyone should ever learn about bullying, it's that it's better to be the bully than it is to be the bullied.

 

O, how wrong you are on this one, mister.