[quote]Asurablade wrote...
Well to rebut what you've just said i could point out the many sidequests of Dragon Age which lack any real story[/QUOTE]
It ain't much as a rebuttal. I never said that there aren't some quests in DA:O that aren't up to par with the majority story-wise. The difference is that in Oblivion ALL the sidequests are boring and dull.
[quote]at all and that includes the incessantly measly reward of gold and experience[/quote]
Who exactly judges what is the right reward for a side quest?
Is there a sidequester union somewhere?
[QUOTE]The areas of Oblivion and likewise Dragon Age are both remarkable in some respects, although not exactly awe-inspiring they both add a touch of realism as i repeat the aesthetic beauty of time affected environments, to the well rendered environments of Dragon Age.[/QUOTE]
I find nothing remarkable in massive recycling. Realism? I wouldn't know what's realistic in basically making a statement that the Ayleid had absolutely no architectural variation, same with the ones that build the keeps and so forth, given that Bethesda was too lazy to actually add some variation in the tiles they used.
[quote]Sidequests 100% Linear? Is that not true for Dragon Age ? [/quote]
My bad, I meant the main quest.
[QUOTE]
Consequently, i believe both games are entitled to whatever people consider them to be, in my opinion, both
great games, but i feel it is unfair to merely exaggerate and speculate on game weaknesses.[/QUOTE]
Good for you. I don't think people are exaggerating, and I feel that DA:O is a great game, while Oblivion is a very mediocre and overrated game out of the box, that becomes quite good when modded.
[QUOTE]I might also add that we all know Bestheda aren't that great at storytelling thus the story may have been generic and/or weak, however the game wasn't merely played juse for the main story.
[/quote]
I'm sorry but I disagree here. Story and character depth are THE most important element in an rpg. If you fail at those, you fail at RPGs. Hence, bethesda fails at RPGs, IMHO of course.
[quote]Tankkiller1337 wrote...
Holy Crap can't you stop bashing Oblivion like a 12-year old?[/QUOTE]
Why should I? for fear of offending some oblivion fanboy that gets all bent out of shape if his
game is criticized? People come here to talk about Oblivion. I happen to have an opinion on the topic, and I express it. Last time I heard, this was a discussion board. Also, I might want to point out that not having Oblivion in high regard has nothing to do with age.
[QUOTE]
I know this is a Dragon Age Origins board and I thought that people here could be somehow reasonable.
But now seeing how you are handling your responses I see that this is leading to nothing. This thread was about the weaknesses and strenghts of both games. The thing you do is: [/QUOTE]
Actually, looking at the OP, this thread is about how Oblivion sucks compared to DA:O, and I happen to agree wholeheartedly with it.
[QUOTE]"QQ DAO is so much better than ****oblivion although I put hundreds of hours into modding a mediocre
graphical improvement instead of just being able to enjoy the game".[/QUOTE]
I'm sure you will understand that the only one "QQing" here because someone criticized his beloved game is you.
[QUOTE]
Good, just stay out of this thread, I am sick of your trolling and bashing Oblivion.
[/quote]
And pray tell, who are you to decide who should participate to a thread or what ideas should be expressed in it?
It's unfortunate that the truth behind what I say puts a flame under the toes of the bethesda fanboys. But I would like to point out is that a "troll" is someone that goes to a forum about another game in order to bash it, most of the time praising rival games. In this, I'm definitely not the troll here.
[quote]Alendor1989 wrote...
Oblivion is a great game, not too many get the title "game of the year" and Oblivion did. [/quote]
Actually there's no "supreme" entity that gives the right to create a "game of the year" edition of a game. The software house decide that by themselves regardless of titles. Title like Gears of War 2 had a "game of the year" edition despite being lackluster and having been pretty much ignored by most "game of the year" awards out there. I would not be surprised at all if DA:O would come out with a Game of the Year edition sooner or later.
Modifié par Abriael_CG, 28 janvier 2010 - 04:45 .