Aller au contenu

Photo

Black Ark Theory


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
193 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Gamedam Meister

Gamedam Meister
  • Members
  • 174 messages

 

I had this idea on a possible means of getting to Andromeda, so made this video to explain it and spark discussion.

 

My hypothesis is that rather than the Council or whoever is behind the ARKCON Pathfinder Initiative building an intergalactic ark, they instead capture a vessel that has already solved all the issues involved for them: the Black Ark aka Collector Cruiser. With the incident with James Vega on Fehl Prime, the Alliance and by extension the Council have extensive data on how the ships function so if one was able to be captured it could be utilized.

 

The four issues solved are:

Drive discharge: Being Reaper tech, the ship has solved the drive discharge issue. 

Crew/passenger support: It has advanced stasis pods which can either be used or swapped out with other stasis pods like Prothean ones.

Size: It is the size of a Reaper Dreadnought yet hollow so has plenty of space to build and store everything needed within. 

Time: Since the superstructure already exists, our cycle would only need a few months to retrofit it. 

 

I would appreciate any input.


  • Beerfish, Samahl na Revas, Absafraginlootly et 33 autres aiment ceci

#2
Cheviot

Cheviot
  • Members
  • 1 479 messages

Input? A text summary of the video would be nice.


  • Ahriman aime ceci

#3
Gamedam Meister

Gamedam Meister
  • Members
  • 174 messages

Input? A text summary of the video would be nice.

I added a summary. 


  • SpaceLobster aime ceci

#4
ArabianIGoggles

ArabianIGoggles
  • Members
  • 475 messages

That actually sounds like a pretty good idea.  


  • Portalbendarwinden aime ceci

#5
Glockwheeler

Glockwheeler
  • Members
  • 46 messages

What if you chose to destroy the Collector base and ship in ME2?



#6
Ahriman

Ahriman
  • Members
  • 2 007 messages

Aside from cool name it actually makes sense. Though knowing a bit the way Bioware thinks, I suppose chances for this one are close to zero.


  • Beerfish, pace675, Bayonet Hipshot et 2 autres aiment ceci

#7
Gamedam Meister

Gamedam Meister
  • Members
  • 174 messages

That actually sounds like a pretty good idea.  

Thank you. I'm glad you like it. 

 

What if you chose to destroy the Collector base and ship in ME2?

The Collector Ship in Mass Effect 2 isn't the only Black Ark is existence. There was also the one that harvested Fehl Prime that was destroyed and during the Reaper War Harbinger brings in more Black Arks from Dark Space as reinforcements to harass our cycle's forces. 



#8
SpaceLobster

SpaceLobster
  • Members
  • 262 messages

Sounds good, but are they truly as large as a Sovereign-class Reaper?


  • marcelo caldas aime ceci

#9
Gamedam Meister

Gamedam Meister
  • Members
  • 174 messages

Aside from cool name it actually makes sense. Though knowing a bit the way Bioware, I suppose chances for this one are close to zero.

Thanks. When I heard about Ark Theory and was reading how it would work but also the limitations and problems faced with it I thought "What about using a Black Ark?" Since I hadn't seen anyone make a case for Black Arks as being the Ark, I threw this video together. 



#10
Gamedam Meister

Gamedam Meister
  • Members
  • 174 messages

Sounds good, but are they truly as large as a Sovereign-class Reaper?

Yep. Someone made a size comparison chart and it shows it as large as a Reaper Dreadnought. 

Spoiler


#11
SpaceLobster

SpaceLobster
  • Members
  • 262 messages

Yep. Someone made a size comparison chart and it shows it as large as a Reaper Dreadnought. 

Spoiler

Makes sense, as the one we entered in ME2 was said to be capable of abducting every human in the Terminus Systems, and even more than that...



#12
Vespervin

Vespervin
  • Members
  • 2 027 messages

I really like this idea, and I would be perfectly fine if this was actually in the story. Very nice work, OP.



#13
Chardonney

Chardonney
  • Members
  • 2 198 messages

I really like this idea. Nicely thought-out.



#14
Capsr

Capsr
  • Members
  • 44 messages
Lets just hope the devs realised they had these ships in their universe too :P

#15
Swan Killer

Swan Killer
  • Members
  • 3 184 messages

Yep. Someone made a size comparison chart and it shows it as large as a Reaper Dreadnought. 

Spoiler

 

There's no way that this is accurate. The SR2 isn't 1/4 of the size of a Reaper capital ship, that would make the SR2 over 500 meters long. It's actually less than 200 meters long.


  • kathic, adi21, Enigmatick et 3 autres aiment ceci

#16
Monica21

Monica21
  • Members
  • 5 603 messages

This is a very well thought out idea, and good video!



#17
Sleeper_Tyrant

Sleeper_Tyrant
  • Members
  • 64 messages
I actually liked this idea, and it would make a great begging for the game, as you board one of the Collector's Ships in the middle of the reaper war.

But probably this won't happen, because it would require prior knowledge of the other games, or a infodump right at the beginning.

#18
Ahglock

Ahglock
  • Members
  • 3 660 messages

I like the idea. It is about the only one I have heard that fits the lore of the setting without saying poof wormhole.  I can see another take on this where this isn't a council plan but a collector abduction with some kind of prison break.  I think your core plan is better but they seem to be trying to copy open world things from elder scrolls and that is how like every elder scrolls happen,(released, or escaped) and similar to the beginning of dragon age Inquisition.



#19
AlanC9

AlanC9
  • Members
  • 35 540 messages
@ Sleeper Tyrant: That's no worse a problem than the one ME2 and ME3 faced.
  • UniformGreyColor aime ceci

#20
BabyPuncher

BabyPuncher
  • Members
  • 1 939 messages

I wish they hadn't introduced the whole 'drive discharge' thing into the lore.



#21
Gamedam Meister

Gamedam Meister
  • Members
  • 174 messages

I'm glad everyone likes the idea. Thank you. ^_^

 

Makes sense, as the one we entered in ME2 was said to be capable of abducting every human in the Terminus Systems, and even more than that...

Yeah, it had a capacity of carrying millions of people aboard it in stasis pods, with most of its space to spare.

 

There's no way that this is accurate. The SR2 isn't 1/4 of the size of a Reaper capital ship, that would make the SR2 over 500 meters long. It's actually less than 200 meters long.

That's true. It seems the size comparison made a goof with that. Still, the Collector Cruiser/Black Ark is as large as a Reaper Dreadnought, or at least very close. 

The Normandy SR2 I read is about 220 meters long and the Collector Cruiser is about 8.5 times longer, measuring to 1,875 meters long. For a size comparison from another franchise, it is slightly larger than an Imperial-class Star Destroyer from the Star Wars universe. 

 

I actually liked this idea, and it would make a great begging for the game, as you board one of the Collector's Ships in the middle of the reaper war.

But probably this won't happen, because it would require prior knowledge of the other games, or a infodump right at the beginning.

Chances are they'll have the game start when we get to Andromeda or have been there already a little bit, but I can see them including something about it in the opening crawl they have with every Mass Effect game. Something like: 

 

In the year 22nd century, the Milky Way was assaulted by a sentient machine race bent on galactic extinction known as the Reapers. During/After the war, a plan was conceived to ensure the survival of the various races. The Council/Alliance/etc managed to capture one of the Reaper ships, and turned it from a tool of destruction to a tool of salvation. The ARKCON Pathfinder Initiative was founded and its mission to find and establish a new home was launched. 

 

I like the idea. It is about the only one I have heard that fits the lore of the setting without saying poof wormhole.  I can see another take on this where this isn't a council plan but a collector abduction with some kind of prison break.  I think your core plan is better but they seem to be trying to copy open world things from elder scrolls and that is how like every elder scrolls happen,(released, or escaped) and similar to the beginning of dragon age Inquisition.

 

Well, Bioware has said our new protagonist won't be an established soldier like Shepard was. Maybe if they go the route you're referring to we start as a civilian that was captured than freed by a boarding party as they took the ship from the Collectors, and later we join the ARKCON Pathfinder Initiative. 



#22
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 678 messages

I have to admit, while I'm not a fan of Ark Theory this Black Ark Theory sounds very promising. As you pointed out, it is a way to get to Andromeda without going against the established lore or introducing a Deus Ex Machina by solving the issues our cycle has with intergalactic travel. 

 

Since you brought up Mass Effect: Paragon Lost, it should be noted that the first thing involving Mass Effect specifically that Bioware has done since the announcement of Mass Effect: Andromeda was have a screening of Mass Effect: Paradise Lost. It could be a coincidence, or maybe Bioware is trying to show the information given in that movie, particularly the Alliance having full data on the Collectors and their Black Arks. 

 

Overall, very well done OP. :)



#23
JoltDealer

JoltDealer
  • Members
  • 1 091 messages

This theory is the most brilliant thing that I've seen on BSN in quite some time.  I sincerely hope that Bioware does something along these lines.


  • BMcDill aime ceci

#24
Mercyva

Mercyva
  • Members
  • 132 messages

Yep. Someone made a size comparison chart and it shows it as large as a Reaper Dreadnought. 

Spoiler

 

 

i think that would solve all our problem. i'm still pretty pissed off that shepard was not informed on this. the council is a bxtch and would not expect less of them, but the alliance? i mean... unless shepard knows of this (which i doubt) i still think bioware just thought this through and not the otherway around. if this theory is true, then shepard whole crew could survive and maybe lead that vessel to a new galaxy, at least the useful ones, like Liara/Edi :/. while shepard is the one to save the milky way, his trusted crew should have survived this :/ idk, pretty sketchy to me. unless this is not at all the case



#25
Chealec

Chealec
  • Members
  • 6 502 messages

i_approve_of_this_post_by_iwoenai.jpg

 

indeed.


  • DeathScepter, countofhell, 9TailsFox et 4 autres aiment ceci