I'd like to take Artificier, as I'd like to be that "jack of all trades" I spoke of some posts ago. Even "lore-wise" I mean... But not being able to use a Concentration ability just sucks.... I don't play friendly fire, so Iron Bull won't be an issue...but...1 - Is he strong? 2-Does he have an interesting story?
1)Honestly, statwise they are all the same except for their Specialization, he has a lot of take damage to do damage abilities since he is basically a Reaver. I personally am less fond but many people adore it. 2) An Amazing interesting story. He has an interesting view of things and is way more balanced than he seems. I really like him and he became one of my favorite companions because of his complexity. Did you never talk to him the first time?
And basically the other rogue is because you increase and benefit from crits within the party. Usually rogues crit more because it is their thing. So a duelweilding rogue works well on top of your tank and healer, but you are talking about statwise, most interesting is way more subjective.
Take who you want. Really any disparity is usually easy to overcome by getting more gear/ exploring more.And it is cool to take who you like. If you want MY order of who I find has an interesting story here it is, but its pretty darn subjective.
1) Iron Bull, (especially since your decision has a more lasting impact on him. He has a story, and its tied into the Inquisition)
2) Blackwall (One of my least favorite, but he has a story that you can take some involvement in)
3) Cole (Coles story was told somewhere else, but deciding a lasting impact on a character and having a story puts him up there)
4) Dorian (He has a story but its short, he has complex feelings about Tevinter, intimacy, and his dad, but a funny character, has a story)
5)Solas (Um he is very important to the game but only after the game is over. Solas friends to spirits has a Theme if not a story by the end of the game)
6) Sera (My romance, she doesn't make much sense including her backstory. I don't think you are supposed to understand, but she has one.)
7) Vivienne (Another character I loved and we are told practically nothing about, she doesn't really have a story, but tiny backstory)
8) Cassandra (I love her, took her everywhere, but she is constantly down playing her past, and her story with the Seekers is meh)
9) Varric (Really he doesn't have a story, it was told. He is friends with Hawke, and doesn't know how to be with you, thats his story)