Aller au contenu

Photo

Marriages


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
59 réponses à ce sujet

#51
DreamSever

DreamSever
  • Members
  • 385 messages

There was nothing wrong in having marriages for two characters and not the others, since you wouldn't even know that without playing those romances and to be honest, I wasn't expecting marriage.   What annoyed me was Varric's stupid joke because it made me think it was going to be a possibility and then it was a big disappointment when nothing came of it.    

 

First time it was with Dorian.  Cassandra asking me about it, took me completely by surprise but I thought "why not" if I'm being given the option.   Cassandra encourages me to follow my heart.   I rush round to Dorian, only to find Varric holding a leaving party for him.   I was not amused.

 

Next run, I was actually romancing Cassandra.    The conversation was excruciatingly awkward and I really wanted to thump Varric.  

 

Finally, I braved my Solas run and it was even worse.   The joke was in the worst possible taste, made Cassandra look an insensitive idiot and Varric even worse, particularly when both Vivienne and Sera had been sympathising with my girl because they knew that after 2 long years she still wasn't over him.

 

So to my mind they should either have had the marriage as an option for everyone or leave out the stupid joke prank about it.

 

Oh and for people who want to be inclusive, how come only female characters get the option of marriage?

Just frustrated a male inq doesnt have one, i understand reasons but josie makes sense 


  • Hanako Ikezawa aime ceci

#52
AnimalBoy

AnimalBoy
  • Members
  • 583 messages

I really wanted to marry Cassandra. Unlike others in this thread, i don't really care that Marriage is just "a piece of paper". I love the idea of marriage and see it as the ultimate peak of romance. Considering everything the characters have been through together and what it took to get them together i really wanted the chance to cement the romance with a ring, etc. 

 

I don't see what everyone else sees when they say marriage is hinted at in the epilogue. The Inquisitor and Cassandra spend lots of time together. I don't see how that hints that they finally got married.


  • Hanako Ikezawa et Barnzi88 aiment ceci

#53
Scuttlebutt101

Scuttlebutt101
  • Members
  • 303 messages
 

I don't see what everyone else sees when they say marriage is hinted at in the epilogue. The Inquisitor and Cassandra spend lots of time together. I don't see how that hints that they finally got married.

Nothing says they didn't. I don't think they would ever include any slides that explicitly said "And then they wed" (King Alistair is an obvious exception) because not everyone's quizzy even wants to get married. That doesn't mean that the player who wants a wedding but doesn't get the option can't headcanon that their quizzies simply got married later. I used to be disappointed that Blackwall didn't get a wedding scene like Cullen and Sera, but now I'm kind of glad he didn't. I don't see my quizzy as someone who cares for eloping anyway, so I can just headcanon that they threw an actual wedding party with their friends and family present after Trespasser (and that Vivienne finally introduced me to her seamstress for the occasion). What's stopping people from doing the same with their LIs? It's not like it contradicts the epilogue or anything.



#54
AnimalBoy

AnimalBoy
  • Members
  • 583 messages

 

 

Nothing says they didn't. I don't think they would ever include any slides that explicitly said "And then they wed" (King Alistair is an obvious exception) because not everyone's quizzy even wants to get married. That doesn't mean that the player who wants a wedding but doesn't get the option can't headcanon that their quizzies simply got married later. I used to be disappointed that Blackwall didn't get a wedding scene like Cullen and Sera, but now I'm kind of glad he didn't. I don't see my quizzy as someone who cares for eloping anyway, so I can just headcanon that they threw an actual wedding party with their friends and family present after Trespasser (and that Vivienne finally introduced me to her seamstress for the occasion). What's stopping people from doing the same with their LIs? It's not like it contradicts the epilogue or anything.

 

 

I can't do that.  I'm the type where i don't like to count anything as official unless the game/book/movie/people officially involved says it is. If i make up my own endings there'll be 500 other people making up their own that differs from mine. My brain is too OCD to consider anything official unless it actually is.



#55
nightscrawl

nightscrawl
  • Members
  • 7 465 messages

Nothing says they didn't. I don't think they would ever include any slides that explicitly said "And then they wed" (King Alistair is an obvious exception) because not everyone's quizzy even wants to get married. That doesn't mean that the player who wants a wedding but doesn't get the option can't headcanon that their quizzies simply got married later. I used to be disappointed that Blackwall didn't get a wedding scene like Cullen and Sera, but now I'm kind of glad he didn't. I don't see my quizzy as someone who cares for eloping anyway, so I can just headcanon that they threw an actual wedding party with their friends and family present after Trespasser (and that Vivienne finally introduced me to her seamstress for the occasion). What's stopping people from doing the same with their LIs? It's not like it contradicts the epilogue or anything.

 
Yeah, this is the thing. I saw some posts from Cullen fans who were disappointed that they hadn't already gotten married during the two years preceding Trespasser, and one person went as far as to say they should have a kid by that time. I mean... really? If you want that then that's fine for you, but don't take away everyone else's RP agency by forcing such a personal character decision on a player.
 
 

I can't do that.  I'm the type where i don't like to count anything as official unless the game/book/movie/people officially involved says it is. If i make up my own endings there'll be 500 other people making up their own that differs from mine. My brain is too OCD to consider anything official unless it actually is.

 
I hear ya. Even though I write fanfic revolving around my Inquisitor, I don't deviate from the events presented in the game and primarily use it as filler. If I just made things up it wouldn't seem real to me. But, I do also have off-camera stuff that isn't (and can't be) reflected in the games, and I'm OK with that.
 
 
This is not addressed to anyone in particular, just a general statement of my own view.
 
Unfortunately, I'm rather torn as a result of not being able to address it with the LI at all. As I said previously, I can understand why they did it if the writer felt that it isn't what their character would want to do for whatever reason. I happen to feel that Dorian would have multiple reservations about getting married, if that's something that he even wants at all or considers important to the relationship. But I don't know, do I? Because I couldn't discuss it with him. Was this just because David Gaider felt it would be out of character for him? Was it only because of gamey reasons, perhaps involving the next game? Was it a bit of both? I'll never know.
 
I don't mind using head-canon to supplement the game in this way. BUT, because character decisions like this come down to characterization of the individual as well as practical gamey reasons, I think it's hard to guess what would be the "right" head-canon choice in that case. Because in this case, I DO think there is a right and wrong choice, and it's not ONLY about the LI complying with your wishes, but you as their partner accepting what they want (or don't want) as well. I think some players fail to consider that when they ask for a marriage option for all LIs.
 
When talking about companions, players often claim that they want them to be independent of the PC, to have their own thoughts and feelings about whatever issue, and not just blindly follow. This then has to be taken to the next level and applied to the relationships as well.

#56
Cyberstrike nTo

Cyberstrike nTo
  • Members
  • 1 713 messages

Those are the only two unfortunately.

 

Blackwall, Cassandra, Dorian, Josephine, Solas, and The Iron Bull don't have an option for them and the Inquisitor to get married. 

 

Iron Bull actually agrees to get married even though he doesn't get what the big deal is. 

 

It is heavily implied that the Inquisitor marries Josephine in the coda.

 

Because Cassandra can be the Divine it's make sense that she can't get married without a scandal.

 

Blackwall can become a Grey Warden not much of a future there.

 

Dorian has to return to Tevinter and take his father's seat in the Magisterium and given how homophobic that country is and even if he was straight there is a good chance that they wouldn't recognize due to it being sanctioned by the Southern Chantry.

 

I don't think a marriage to Solas will ever work due his plans to destroy the world. 



#57
Battlebloodmage

Battlebloodmage
  • Members
  • 8 698 messages

I'm kinda annoyed that none of the male protagonists can get married. They're really ignored the male players with the entirety of this game. Josephine and Cassandra would both be perfect candidate to get married. Cassandra who is head over heel over romance should be able to get married if not a divine, Josephine is also about to be engage to someone and should be open up as well. You can propose marriage with Iron Bull but can't see actual marriage. If they bother to show marriage for certain characters, then show it for all the other characters that make sense as well, in this case, none of the male inquisitior's options can even get married. Seriously, playing as a guy you get all kinds of screws in this game. 


  • AnimalBoy aime ceci

#58
Sah291

Sah291
  • Members
  • 1 238 messages

Finally, I braved my Solas run and it was even worse.   The joke was in the worst possible taste, made Cassandra look an insensitive idiot and Varric even worse, particularly when both Vivienne and Sera had been sympathising with my girl because they knew that after 2 long years she still wasn't over him.
 
So to my mind they should either have had the marriage as an option for everyone or leave out the stupid joke prank about it.


Haha, I didn't mind the Varric joke so much on my Lavellan/Solas playthrough, actually. I just headcannoned it was Varric's not so subtle way of nudging her to move on (plus getting to fluster Cassandra at the same time). And I figured yeah, she is finally ready to move on, why not, so I picked the "maybe someday/I've thought about it" option. Then later she's confronted with Solas again. Damn, so much for that.

I can see how it is really awkward with a Dorian romance though, when he is just right there, and then he announces he's leaving and nothing happens.

It seemed to me like it was kinda written with a Cassandra romance in mind? Because she seems sorta embarrassed and almost... Jealous? Like maybe the Inquisitor has had random suitors expressing interest or something. At least I could see it interpreted that way with a male Quizzy.

#59
Iakus

Iakus
  • Members
  • 30 263 messages

I can't do that.  I'm the type where i don't like to count anything as official unless the game/book/movie/people officially involved says it is. If i make up my own endings there'll be 500 other people making up their own that differs from mine. My brain is too OCD to consider anything official unless it actually is.

The Inquisitor can suggest that they get married.  But Cassandra wants a "proper proposal" after this is all over.  Much like she wanted a ""proper courtship" before with the poetry and candles as such.

 

I can totally see the Inquisitor purchasing a diamond, taking her to an expensive Orlesian restaurant, getting down on one knee, etc, once the Exalted Council was over.


  • MidnightWolf aime ceci

#60
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

English is weird.


It's called common law as a shorthand for the type of law that governs property distribution on separation.