Aller au contenu

Photo

Illusive man was the good guy


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
109 réponses à ce sujet

#26
N7Jamaican

N7Jamaican
  • Members
  • 1 778 messages

The Illusive man was a good guy.  He did the dirty work, the unethical tests, the super secret missions, putting people in positions of power, developing technology to advance humanity...

 

Let's be honest, some of the greatest inventions came from some people willing to make sacrifices.


  • Kalas Magnus et IMNOTCRAZYiminsane aiment ceci

#27
spinachdiaper

spinachdiaper
  • Members
  • 2 042 messages

All he wanted to do was enslave the human race. 

 

If the new game is andromeda, it will be discovered the colony slaver ships sent there were directly funded by cerberus!

Fixed it for you.



#28
Salarian Master Race

Salarian Master Race
  • Members
  • 2 773 messages

Not really, he was after the collector base for the technology.  If you destroy the base he chews Shepard out stating that he/she "choked" when it counted, clearly showing he feels the mission was a failure. If he cared about humanity he would have at least shown some relief that humans would no longer be targeted by the Collectors but his actions showed that he could really care less if he doesn't get what he wants, which was the collector base and the technology it had.

 

Good thing then that in ME3 he gets it anyway



#29
Mdizzletr0n

Mdizzletr0n
  • Members
  • 630 messages

And my point is comparing actual aliens to foreigners is stupid. 

Nope. The turians pretty much just open fired on humanity because they activated the wrong relay. 
 
 


The what now? Everyone wants their species to gain more prestige and standing. That's why we aren't extinct right now.   


On the turians, that's essentially what I was saying. I just said it terribly.
And we aren't extinct because we're gaining prestige and standing over whom, exactly? Lions, tigers and bears?

#30
Battlebloodmage

Battlebloodmage
  • Members
  • 8 698 messages

He really is a good guy, he tried his best the entire game to prevent Shepard from seeing the terrible ending, screw Marauder. 


  • Dubozz, DeathScepter, Flaine1996 et 1 autre aiment ceci

#31
kajtarp

kajtarp
  • Members
  • 423 messages

I hated him from the moment he ordered Dr. Eva to execute Ashley.



#32
Navasha

Navasha
  • Members
  • 3 724 messages

I never understood where the love people have for Cerberus comes from.   They were clearly a terrorist organization bent on truly horrifying research in the first game.   

 

In the second, TIM treats everyone simply as tools to carry out their tasks and then be discarded.   95% of ME2 is simply team building for the final mission.   A mission where if you don't capture the station like TIM wants, he effectively says you failed.   His intention was the station the whole time.   

 

Some keep saying they changed into the 'bad' guys in ME 3.  They were always the 'bad guys'.   Everything in the first two games was just building to this apex.   They were consistently looking for ways to create and control super-soldiers.    Everything they ever did was to grab more power for themselves, right up to the end when they wanted to control the reapers themselves for the power it could give them. 


  • Pressedcat, Hanako Ikezawa, Trikormadenadon et 14 autres aiment ceci

#33
Flaine1996

Flaine1996
  • Members
  • 213 messages
Actually I see Tim as this renegade Shepard with no boundaries. He is the type of person who would do absolutely anything or sacrifice anything to get what he wants... I would never trust him but I respect his abilities in acquiring resources from anything really... So I don't necessarily see him as a good guy just a morally grry character... Afterall he did try to save humanity in the crudest ways possible...

#34
Dantriges

Dantriges
  • Members
  • 1 288 messages

Cerberus wasn´t the Alliance´s intel branch but did its own thing and most of that exploded in their face. There was one man in charge with no oversight and lo and behold, the whole organisation turned against humanity with one indoctrinated guy. And well Ceberus is humanity, when Cerberus is strong every human is strong, yeah sure. Considering that TIM is Cerberus or more the lynchpin that holds the whole thing together, you get the idea who should be the pinnacle of the galaxy according to his visions. It´s pretty obvious that TIM was suffering from delusions of grandeur even in ME 2.



#35
Chardonney

Chardonney
  • Members
  • 2 199 messages

I never understood where the love people have for Cerberus comes from.   They were clearly a terrorist organization bent on truly horrifying research in the first game.   

 

In the second, TIM treats everyone simply as tools to carry out their tasks and then be discarded.   95% of ME2 is simply team building for the final mission.   A mission where if you don't capture the station like TIM wants, he effectively says you failed.   His intention was the station the whole time.   

 

Some keep saying they changed into the 'bad' guys in ME 3.  They were always the 'bad guys'.   Everything in the first two games was just building to this apex.   They were consistently looking for ways to create and control super-soldiers.    Everything they ever did was to grab more power for themselves, right up to the end when they wanted to control the reapers themselves for the power it could give them. 

 

Basically all this, 100%.


  • Dabrikishaw et Degrees1991 aiment ceci

#36
Killdren88

Killdren88
  • Members
  • 4 640 messages

Credit where it's due, but the Thorian business was ExoGeni.

Didn't Cerberus steal a sample of Thorian though? It's been awhile but I seem to recall a Cerberus research facility that got a hold of Thorian.



#37
Linkenski

Linkenski
  • Members
  • 3 452 messages

All he wanted to do was save the human race. 

 

If the new game is andromeda, it will be discovered the colony ships sent there were directly funded by cerberus!

By shooting everything in sight with his clone army, yes.


  • Dirthamen et Mdizzletr0n aiment ceci

#38
Salarian Master Race

Salarian Master Race
  • Members
  • 2 773 messages

TIM had been in the early stages of Indoctrination all along, and he knew it, but being such a strong-willed individual he was able to fight it up until ME3, when it overtook him entirely.  The rank and file of Cerberus had more frequent and direct contact with Reaper Tech, as they were studying it, and were also not as mentally resiliant as TIM, which explains why some of the cells were doing horrific things.  TIM didn't necessarily know the extent of these, or even approve of them, but the Indoctrinated part of him let them continue.

 

What we see of TIM in ME2 is his last ditch effort to give the galaxy the hero he knows it needs, in direct conflict with the Indoctrinated part of him wanting to use that hero to secure the ultimate treasure trove of Reaper Technology, the Collector Base.  He really is a tragic, yet heroic character in his own right.


  • Kallas_br123, DeathScepter, DoomsdayDevice et 2 autres aiment ceci

#39
Dabrikishaw

Dabrikishaw
  • Members
  • 3 243 messages

Cerberus got a lot of people here to drink their Kool-aid.


  • Dirthamen, Rampy, ComedicSociopathy et 1 autre aiment ceci

#40
Karma_Joy

Karma_Joy
  • Members
  • 12 messages

I honestly hoped in ME3 there would be a twist and you would discover Admiral Hackett was indoctrinated the entire time. It would explain why the reapers bypassed earth's defenses so quickly, and no warning was ever sent to earth before the attack. They knew the reapers were coming but were shocked to learn they even lost the moon when they did. I hoped cerberus would turn out to be the good guys the entire time but were painted as the bad guys because of the commander of the alliance being indoctrinated. The illusive man had to attack mars and go rogue because he knew the Alliance was corrupted. 

 

I was so depressed when none of that happened and they were just the stereotypical bad guys we all expected them to be.


  • Laughing_Man et Salarian Master Race aiment ceci

#41
Laughing_Man

Laughing_Man
  • Members
  • 3 663 messages

I never understood where the love people have for Cerberus comes from.   They were clearly a terrorist organization bent on truly horrifying research in the first game.   

 

In the second, TIM treats everyone simply as tools to carry out their tasks and then be discarded.   95% of ME2 is simply team building for the final mission.   A mission where if you don't capture the station like TIM wants, he effectively says you failed.   His intention was the station the whole time.   

 

Some keep saying they changed into the 'bad' guys in ME 3.  They were always the 'bad guys'.   Everything in the first two games was just building to this apex.   They were consistently looking for ways to create and control super-soldiers.    Everything they ever did was to grab more power for themselves, right up to the end when they wanted to control the reapers themselves for the power it could give them. 

 

Don't know about the others, but with me it's not the "love for Cerberus", but rather my dislike for Bioware's naive stance on morality in politics and shadowy affairs.

 

It's like Bioware is trying to push the idea that if you are a "good guy", you can just power through everything with your Awesome Paragon Powers.

 

There is zero acknowledgment to the fact that politics and spy games between nations - and most certainly between different species alien to each other,

are a dirty affair, occasionally dotted by conspiracies, murder, blackmail, frame jobs, cyber warefare, psy-ops, etc.

 

Alliance Intelligence was nothing if not an example for incompetecy throughout the ME story, with virtually next to no useful intel coming from their direction. By all rights, Humanity should have had an organization to fill the void and counter its counterparts.

 

It could have been Cerberus if Bioware didn't make them into the over-the-top incompetent villains that they were.


  • Kallas_br123, DeathScepter, Wolven_Soul et 1 autre aiment ceci

#42
Catastrophy

Catastrophy
  • Members
  • 8 477 messages

I always fond it kinda unbelievable (illogic? bullshitty?) that Cerberus could field so many expensive assets.


  • DeathScepter aime ceci

#43
HusarX

HusarX
  • Members
  • 2 041 messages

Exaxctly. He was good strong leader, not like that weak Citadel Council. ME3 was really lame, cos' you were forced to play fight against him. While I just really wanted a full Cerberus crew, and a romance option with a Phantom.


  • DeathScepter et Salarian Master Race aiment ceci

#44
Dantriges

Dantriges
  • Members
  • 1 288 messages

There is zero acknowledgment to the fact that politics and spy games between nations - and most certainly between different species alien to each other,
are a dirty affair, occasionally dotted by conspiracies, murder, blackmail, frame jobs, cyber warefare, psy-ops, etc.


There is dirty affairs and moustache twirling villainy. Cerberus was more known for blowing up because of their illegal research.
 

Alliance Intelligence was nothing if not an example for incompetecy throughout the ME story, with virtually next to no useful intel coming from their direction. By all rights, Humanity should have had an organization to fill the void and counter its counterparts.

 

Hardly the only ones. Every political organisation was holding the idiot ball to empower Shepard, the (wo)man who gets things done.
 

It could have been Cerberus if Bioware didn't make them into the over-the-top incompetent villains that they were.

 
Cerberus was a rogue organisation since ME 1. And if it was, it wouldn´t have looked like it did with TIM as sole boss. No sane governments would organize his intel division like that with no oversight. Happens but then you have a problem.



#45
Mdizzletr0n

Mdizzletr0n
  • Members
  • 630 messages

Exaxctly. He was good strong leader, not like that weak Citadel Council. ME3 was really lame, cos' you were forced to play fight against him. While I just really wanted a full Cerberus crew, and a romance option with a Phantom.

But you were fine with being railroaded in to joining Cerberus?

I think that if BW hadn't killed Shep at the beginning of ME2 to move the plot in that direction, there could've been a stronger case for them. Even with the dialogue options, no matter what Shep said about it being his/her choice and whatnot, it sounded ridiculous. Nothing in the plot really reinforced that.

#46
Pasquale1234

Pasquale1234
  • Members
  • 3 059 messages

Didn't Cerberus steal a sample of Thorian though? It's been awhile but I seem to recall a Cerberus research facility that got a hold of Thorian.


Yes, I believe so.

ExoGeni did all of the initial research on Feros, and shipped some samples to another one of their facilities on Nodacrux. There were 3 Cerberus research facilities on Binthu - 2 had Rachni, the other had Thorian Creepers. How they got them isn't really clear.

#47
Ahglock

Ahglock
  • Members
  • 3 660 messages
I think the issue I had was in ME1 they were unknown villains. In ME2 you learn they are still evil in some definitions of the term but basically villains with your same end goal. In ME3 they became villains directly opposing your end goal. Which would have bothered me less if there was a story reason instead of the indoctrination hammer.

#48
Amirit

Amirit
  • Members
  • 1 168 messages

All he wanted to do was save the human race. 

 

If the new game is andromeda, it will be discovered the colony ships sent there were directly funded by cerberus!

 

The funniest thing will be if every race sent some "ark" there in hope to save their race. So, we will be fighting\compete for resources with familiar races :) I see a great potential for a strategy game!



#49
Beerfish

Beerfish
  • Members
  • 23 867 messages

Good or bad I was very upset that they did such a poor job with that character in his ME3 resolution in my opinion.  He deserved a better ending to his part of the story.


  • Kallas_br123, DeathScepter et Salarian Master Race aiment ceci

#50
Salarian Master Race

Salarian Master Race
  • Members
  • 2 773 messages

It wasn't just the ending that was disappointing.  The entirely of ME3 is a series of bad writing and missed opportunities, TIM being one of many.


  • Beerfish et IMNOTCRAZYiminsane aiment ceci