114 réponses à ce sujet

[NoForgiveness]

Still Hawke. Wardens need someone to lead them, preferably someone not involved in the "let's throw ourselves on a pyre!" thing. Plus sacrifice fits my Hawke soooooo much better than "ah **** Corypheus. I'm out! Cya!"

[rpgfan321]

Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo! Don't make me choose *ahem* I would leave Hawke in the Fade because HoF is a Warden-Commander and the Wardens need leadership more than ever after Adamant. It's just after Legacy, Hawke's story seem to tie with Corypheus and stopping the Nightmare demon is stopping his plan. I thought it comes full circle. Maybe. :/

[Dabrikishaw]

Hawke never leaves the Fade in any of my playthroughs anyway. 

[Ryzaki]

Ugh I guess I'd leave my warden.

 

But that'd mega suck I love all my PCs.

[TheExtreamH]

I'd leave the Warden, Hawke is a civilian so i'd expect any well respecting Soldier (The Warden) to take the fall.

[Pokemario]

I would have sacrificed the Warden.

[Ariella]

The Warden. She already cheated death once, and the Wardens were responsible. New leaders will rise, the Hero of Ferelden is proof of that. So she stays in the Fade. Dying??? Don't know.

[Nixou]

I'm firmly convinced that this was the setup at some time during game development, and that they only didn't implement it because they'd have to give the Warden a voice, and because of the reception of ME3's ending.

 

 

It's rather probable that the writers at least toyed with the idea, the problem is that Inquisition's story would make no sense if the HoF was directly involved.

 

First, there's the whole Grey Wardens arc: they all disappear because Clarel pulled rank on all the southern Wardens: if the HoF is still present, there's two commanders in the South and at the very least the Fereldan Grey Wardens wouldn't have disappeared: meeting the HoF alone in a cave instead than in Vigil's Keep with the Fereldan Wardens and Amaranthine's military at his/her beck and call would make no sense.

 

And then, there's the whole explosion at the Conclave: it happens because Corypheus used Wardens enthralled to him to sneak in and capture the Divine. Except the HoF was Justinia's first choice to helm the Inquisition, which means that had the HoF remained in Ferelden, s/he would already have been proclaimed Inquisitor and would have been present, with troops loyal to him/her with the Divine. Corypheus could have tried to get to the Divine anyway, but instead of taking everyone by surprise, he would have been intercepted by highly trained Darkspawn killers who would have sensed his presence from miles away: at the very least the Conclave would have been evacuated while the HoF and co kept Corypheus busy.

 

We come back to the HoF's main problem: you bring him/her back, you break the story.

[trevelyan_shep]

I always leave Hawke. Never liked the character, anyway. Not as much as the Warden.

[Mummy22kids]

Leave them both. 

[Phoe77]

I'd probably always leave the Warden.  I like all of my Hawkes way more than any of my Wardens.

[Nefla]

I dunno, a lot of my wardens did the US already. When I wanted to have Alistair and Loghain instead of Stroud (aka sacrificial goat) I just made fake Hawkes that were horrible, looked and acted like monsters, and I left them in the fade. For the Hawkes I actually played, there was Stroud.

[DuskWanderer]

It would be easier, the HoF is a mute, blank slate. Easier to kill them. 

[myahele]

I'd decide to Keep my Warden. Unlike Hawke, the Warden have more relevancy, power and allies ... Hawke what will s/he have? Templars/Mages blame Hawke and got kicked out of Kirkwall even if a Viscount

 

Seeing that Hawke is pretty much useless in DAI (Varric becomes Viscount and that thing with Wardens in Weishaupt is swept under the rug) then I'd say Hawke is better to be left in the Fade. Had I known I would have left Hawke in the Fade. I dislike how they treat Hawke since he was a main protag i one of their own games, oh well.

 

In either case, the person left in the Fade will "likely" die, so that pretty much means they're alive in one way or another. If Leliana can be some sort of "lyrium ghost" then surely whoever left in the Fade will get the same treatment.

[Vegeta 77]

The sarcastic champion or a empty shell easy the warden i do not care for him.

[ReadingRambo220]

I would sacrifice them both to save Stroud! Because mustache

[MrMrPendragon]

All of us will fight the demon together. Can't be any harder than fighting a dragon, and both Hawke and the Warden have already killed a few.

 

I mean for one, the demon has a very short attention span. 5 people managed to somehow walk past it even though it basically blocked the entire path to the exit. So I'm pretty sure all 7 people - Inquisitor, Warden, Hawke, party members - can take out the demon.

[DWareFan]

My canon warden is the queen of Ferelden.  Bye bye Hawke.

[Niniel]

I'd leave the Warden, because I care more for Hawke. I had many different Wardens, but my Hawke was always the same.

[leaguer of one]

My Warden would get left behind. She on borrowed time and she knows it. it would be worse for the blight to take her and a better way for her to say good bye to Leliana then having her watch her die. She not going to let someone else die for her now.

[leaguer of one]

 

It's rather probable that the writers at least toyed with the idea, the problem is that Inquisition's story would make no sense if the HoF was directly involved.

 

 

 

Wait, why would it make no sense? Ofcourse the warden can be involve. With the false calling going on and disappearing wardens of course the warden would investagate it...just on their own with Hawke. The plot make them impossible to be the hero this time.

[KaiserShep]

The Warden without hesitation. Partly to make Leliana sad, partly because I like Hawke more, and for just a smidgen of spite for all those folks that keep going on about the Warden. 

[Ash Wind]

Hawke, if only to put him out of his misery.

[Former_Fiend]

I mainly would have questioned why the three of them together wouldn't have been able to kick the Nightmare's ass. I'm slightly more forgiving in accepting Loghain/Stroud/Alistair as being the weak link in the trio. But with at least three dead high dragons, an archdemon, at least one ancient magister, two harvesters, two varterrals, I've lost count of how many pride demons...is the Nightmare really so far above all of that that these three individuals, the biggest badasses in Thedas, couldn't hope to defeat it directly? That's pretty amazing, if true. 

 

But if I had to choose...Well, I've said that choosing between Loghain and Hawke was the most difficult decision I've ever had to make in a game. This probably would have been more so. 

 

I think I'd ultimately go with the Warden for my canon playthrough due to the grey warden mentality and just figuring he'd have the best chance of actually making it out alive. 

[Tamyn]

I'd leave the Warden because she's already under a gruesome death sentence via monstrous deformity, she has nightmares all the time, she can never have children, her first love died in her arms, she was separated from her whole family who she'll never see again, and she was forced to become a Warden in the first place.