That is one interesting statement. I wonder what are your motivations to write it, but I am glad you did, I welcome criticisms.
The only reason I got to that position was the fact that I have played nonstop from the beginning, mostly in good teams. I did get carried at times, Jailson helped me a lot. I would not have got there had I not had his help. So probably you are right about the carried part.
Also, just to reiterate, I am all in for people getting more Prestige. I believe the Leaderboards needs to be 'refreshed'. I just do not think faster promotions are the way to go since it has lead to abuse and misuse in the past.
But that's the thing, if you want your player base to actually move on to higher levels to consolidate it, you need to get them there faster. Bioware should totally keep the 2x XP as a weekend buff, if only to push the newer players faster to at least Perilous.
Let's be real here. What does Routine or Threatening are all about? The answer's simple: grinding to get the gear necessary to go Perilous. You can take any simpleton (no offense to any simpleton), give him good gear and launch him in Perilous. That simpleton will learn just as fast on Perilous as he would have on Routine or Threatening. The only difference is he won't have to play 400 hours to get up to speed.
The Leaderboard shouldn't exist if the only reason for it is to justify its existence. I said it before, the promotions shouldn't be there. The leaderboard is flawed, it's supposed to be all about challenges but most of the points are from promotions. Remove the promotions from the system and you get something that is a lot more representative of what it should be.
The leaderboard doesn't need any refresh, it's flawed at its very core which makes its significance void of any meaning. Please, stop using the "leaderboard" as an excuse to justify the boring grinding for promotions. We got the bad end of the stick with it, doesn't mean other people should also suffer the same fate. Or we could follow your line of thoughts and remove all and any changes from all and every patches since new people would benefit from something we didn't have at the time... The leaderboard is flawed, stop trying to justify it in any way, it will never work. Take it for what it is, an approximation of what happened in the past. That's all it really is.
I've played a lot with you and I know you're a really good guy, I'm just saying you're taking this a bit too seriously even if you're not realizing it. Loosen up a little, Bioware can take all the blame, they designed that piece of **** challenge system. But for the sake of having more players available to play with us veteran players, we definitely need to do something. And faster promotions is the only way to get new players on the higher difficulties (Perilous+) within any reasonable timeframe. Using the leaderboard, a broken system to begin with, as justification to limit the arrival of new players to higher difficulties will only make the player base crumble faster.
[ TL;DR ]
So the real questions is: Does the leaderboard is more important to you than having new players ready to play with us now?
Personally, my answer is screw the leaderboard!!!
Edit: I would also like to add that if XP was generated in a balanced way from characters to characters, we would all promote at least 3x as fast... So they flawed system for awarding XP is already a big mess that goes against the players...