Although I am getting sick and tired of the hatedick on Mac Walters...I have never seen people so venomous over someone for something so minute...it's like he shot everyone's pet dog while we had to watch. I just don't get it sometimes with people, its like a blood feud.
To be absolutely fair, I gave him the benefit of the doubt after ME2's decline in writing quality. I thought, "Well, he's new to this whole lead writer thing. Hopefully he will have learned from his mistakes when making ME3."
Hoo boy was I wrong.
Even his comics, which he wrote completely on his own, were atrociously written, filled with clichés, plot holes and just badly paced and badly structured in general.
It got even worse after I read Geoff Keighley's Final Hours of Mass Effect 3. Mac's BioWare career is a classic case of cronyism. Casey and Mac knew each other from before Mac joined BioWare. His first game was Jade Empire. Mass Effect, his second. By his third game he was made lead writer after Drew left, even though there were a lot of other writers who'd stayed with BioWare longer, with more games under their belt. Three games aren't enough experience to be made lead writer of a AAA franchise.
He pushed Cerberus superhard since the first game and turned them from a minor villain into the Mass Effect equivalent of the goddamn Sith Empire. It's a problem when a minor villain from the first game ends up overshadowing the main villains of the franchise. They are now the textbook example of a plot tumor.
Bottom line, Mac's contributions to the Mass Effect franchise aren't good enough to justify him being in the position of power he has attained.
As for the scientific accuracy...Mass Effect was always a space opera...i'm not sure why people are surprised by this.
It wasn't like other space operas though. Right from the start they had the agenda to make Mass Effect more grounded than sci-fi's like Star Wars and Star Trek.
Former Mass Effect writer Chris L'Etoile fought really, really hard to keep Mass Effect as scientific as possible, but he was constantly hamstrung by devs on a higher payroll level than him. As an example, he wanted to avoid the pinocchio syndrome with Legion and EDI. He was particularly opposed to the idea of Legion having an obsession about Shepard, but was forced to write it in anyway and tried his best to write it so it made some sense. He also thought the notion of Reapers being literally made from organic goo was a bad idea, so he pushed another idea that they were purely machine but incorporated information stripped from organic DNA into their code structure, but the higher-up (never mentioned by name, maybe Casey, maybe Mac, maybe someone else we don't know of?) ruled in favor of the goo = Reaper scenario. There are way more examples of perfectly good, scientifically accurate writing being arbitrarily tossed in the bin for the sake of coolness factor or just someone's personal tastes.
What's obvious is that neither Casey nor Mac gave even the tiniest sliver of a f**k for scientific accuracy when they churned out the abomination some have taken to call the ending of Mass Effect 3.
Is eezo going to appear in Andromeda? I don't know much about it. What if it's only found in the Milky Way? Someone clarify?
IIRC eezo is a byproduct of stars dying, so it ought to exist in the Andromeda as well.