Aller au contenu

Photo

MEA to be yet another "human story" confirms Bioware


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
287 réponses à ce sujet

#126
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 815 messages

More than likely the leadership will be a mix of the main races like the Council, with the humans in equal standing. After the trilogy, there's no reason why the leadership would only be one or more of just the aliens. 

 

What I'm really really hoping for though is that they're not an obnoxious gaggle of talking heads designed to test our patience. 


  • Grieving Natashina et Addictress aiment ceci

#127
Medhia_Nox

Medhia_Nox
  • Members
  • 3 530 messages

Yes to human protagonist.

 

No to humanity as the central focus.  

 

My true hope is that ME:A will be about the refugees (I'm calling them refugees until proven otherwise) battle for the scraps at the ass end of civilized Andromeda space.  The next installment will be them trying to gain favor with the powers that be in the Andromeda Galaxy.  With the last installment (assuming a trilogy) probably focusing on humanity at least gaining some measure of relevance or prominence in Andromeda - but still remaining a tiny faction in a great big new galaxy. 



#128
LordJeyl

LordJeyl
  • Members
  • 336 messages

More than likely the leadership will be a mix of the main races like the Council, with the humans in equal standing. After the trilogy, there's no reason why the leadership would only be one or more of just the aliens. 

 

Except for that tiny little detail that Earth now possesses the Citadel station. So if Earth were to say... do their own thing apart from the other races in the galaxy, they'll have the Citadel. It's funny how the evil human organization Cerberus was focused on ensuring Mankind would be the dominate species of the galaxy, yet they end up being that way by default in the end.



#129
Reever

Reever
  • Members
  • 1 435 messages

So human only player confirmed, huh? Haven't been keeping up with any news for a long time now.



#130
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 815 messages

Except for that tiny little detail that Earth now possesses the Citadel station. So if Earth were to say... do their own thing apart from the other races in the galaxy, they'll have the Citadel. It's funny how the evil human organization Cerberus was focused on ensuring Mankind would be the dominate species of the galaxy, yet they end up being that way by default in the end.

 

Somewhere out there, TIM smiles down on all of us.



#131
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

Yes to human protagonist.

 

No to humanity as the central focus.  

 

My true hope is that ME:A will be about the refugees (I'm calling them refugees until proven otherwise) battle for the scraps at the ass end of civilized Andromeda space.  The next installment will be them trying to gain favor with the powers that be in the Andromeda Galaxy.  With the last installment (assuming a trilogy) probably focusing on humanity at least gaining some measure of relevance or prominence in Andromeda - but still remaining a tiny faction in a great big new galaxy. 

 

If that one leak is any indication, this will be the same plot over all again. Humanity uncovers another crisis involving an "Ancient" evil/artifact/one ring. This time the Remnants.. or something.

 

I doubt the Refugee bit would play out for long in that way. That's too down to earth. And apparently, their core fans need to feel special, messianic, and needed by the universe or everyone dies. Won't work well as a refugee just trying to get crops working and being diplomatic and ****.



#132
Vilio1

Vilio1
  • Members
  • 299 messages

Except for that tiny little detail that Earth now possesses the Citadel station. So if Earth were to say... do their own thing apart from the other races in the galaxy, they'll have the Citadel. It's funny how the evil human organization Cerberus was focused on ensuring Mankind would be the dominate species of the galaxy, yet they end up being that way by default in the end.


The Citadel remaining in orbit around Earth after ME3 doesn't mean humanity will suddenly be the dominant species, especially because Earth was hit much harder than Thessia or Sur'kesh. We don't even know if there is still a council after ME3, or if they still meet on the new citadel.

#133
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 815 messages

The Citadel remaining in orbit around Earth after ME3 doesn't mean humanity will suddenly be the dominant species, especially because Earth was hit much harder than Thessia or Sur'kesh. We don't even know if there is still a council after ME3, or if they still meet on the new citadel.

 

I imagine there would have to be something akin to a Council, since matters that span multiple worlds and multiple species couldn't just be overseen by any one race. Some or all would have to have representation of some sort. It could be sort of like a Galactic Senate. As for the Citadel, there's no better place to do this, since it's already a structure that exists and can be used as a major hub for all races and takes away the necessity to build something else. 



#134
DrBlingzle

DrBlingzle
  • Members
  • 2 073 messages

I'm a bit disappointed really. We've already had the whole "humans are special" thing with the original trilogy, ME:A was supposed to be a new game with new themes. Personally I'd prefer a game focused on interspecies co operation with all of them working together to make a new home, with no single race being superior.

 

But oh well, I'll be fine with the story being told from a human perspective, I just hope it doesn't go down the "Humans are the best! All other races should look up to us! homosapiens FTW!" route.


  • Barquiel, Tayah, Will-o'-wisp et 6 autres aiment ceci

#135
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

I'm a bit disappointed really. We've already had the whole "humans are special" thing with the original trilogy, ME:A was supposed to be a new game with new themes. Personally I'd prefer a game focused on interspecies co operation with all of them working together to make a new home, with no single race superior.

 

But oh well, I'll be fine with the story being told from a human perspective, I just hope it doesn't go down the "Humans are the best! All other races should look up to us! homosapiens FTW!" route.

 

It'll probably be OK.

 

It'll just be your human character that gets the praise. Possibly with multiple LIs involved, who are in awe of your superior qualities or chosen one nature, etc..



#136
In Exile

In Exile
  • Members
  • 28 738 messages

I'm a bit disappointed really. We've already had the whole "humans are special" thing with the original trilogy, ME:A was supposed to be a new game with new themes. Personally I'd prefer a game focused on interspecies co operation with all of them working together to make a new home, with no single race superior.

But oh well, I'll be fine with the story being told from a human perspective, I just hope it doesn't go down the "Humans are the best! All other races should look up to us! homosapiens FTW!" route.


But humans weren't really special. Or rather it was only ME1 were we were special in that way. ME2 dropped it like a hot potato (especially the sheer insanity of an all human council) and replaced it with human genetic slurpee is special which is a very different kind of trope. And ME3 was very much in the humans are not special box despite the plot focusing on humanity in nonsensical ways (Earth and the Alliance got curb stomped immediately unlike the Turians and Asari).

#137
straykat

straykat
  • Members
  • 9 196 messages

But humans weren't really special. Or rather it was only ME1 were we were special in that way. ME2 dropped it like a hot potato (especially the sheer insanity of an all human council) and replaced it with human genetic slurpee is special which is a very different kind of trope. And ME3 was very much in the humans are not special box despite the plot focusing on humanity in nonsensical ways (Earth and the Alliance got curb stomped immediately unlike the Turians and Asari).

 

I could have used more human stuff in ME3 actually. Grissom is just a sidenote, not a Priority quest. But I'm urged to care about Krogans and Quarians over the best and brightest of the human race.

 

Yes, ME2 was the weirdest culprit of the bunch...

 

But like I said, I think their problem in general is the protagonists themselves. Not necessarily where they come from. At least to me. Most people seem to love this.


  • In Exile aime ceci

#138
Jagaro

Jagaro
  • Members
  • 133 messages
I didn't get a 'humans are special' vibe from that trailer.

To me it seems more of a 'humans have a thirst for exploration and discovery.' More of a Star Trek vibe so I think alot of people are jumping to conclusions and making alot of assumptions based on very little info.
  • Chardonney et blahblahblah aiment ceci

#139
KrazyKiko

KrazyKiko
  • Members
  • 321 messages

One of the factors that made me enjoy the first ME was the element that, "humans" weren't the alpha species.  In lore, we were the sibling learning their place in the new galaxy...  The asari, turians, salarians were all well established, and we were only getting to understand our role. It added a semblance of realism.  Yet, the wheels came off in ME2 and ME3 where this ideology was lost and Broward succumbed to the cliché to have the humans the 'alpha' species, exhibit their plotline of having the Reapers' focus on humans and the Citadel's new home at the end of ME3.  While I'm fine with a human protagonist, I hope ME:A doesn't continue the "humans are holier than 'other galactic races'" ME2 and ME3 embodied.  My .02.


  • Majestic Jazz aime ceci

#140
Keitaro57

Keitaro57
  • Members
  • 585 messages

I didn't get a 'humans are special' vibe from that trailer.

To me it seems more of a 'humans have a thirst for exploration and discovery.' More of a Star Trek vibe so I think alot of people are jumping to conclusions and making alot of assumptions based on very little info.

Would be a good trailer for a Star Wars movie or game, yeah. But it is a ME game with a lore contenaing several alien species who worked together thousand years before humanity known the Earth was not flat. Humanity is the rookie here. So why suddenly must they be the boss and have all the other species under their tumb? Geths are the best zero-g complex builder, Quarian have a long experience of long-life space travel, Asaris have launched the Concil history by discovering the Citadel... And we must forget everything to use the tired rope of "Humanity n°1" because, after all, space opera is not about alien species?

 

Already getting tired of ME:A before I even see it...



#141
Majestic Jazz

Majestic Jazz
  • Members
  • 1 966 messages

Well, they made them more plot relevant with the fact that they were chosen to be the next Reaper, but I don't see how they're perfect or idea. Also, they were already special in  ME. Their rise in the galactic community was something no species previously did. They gained a embassy (and Spectre) and at least a seat in no time, they co-created a really advanced ship, and they saved the Citadel. They were already the galaxy superstars.

Also the fact that the focus is on humanity doesn't mean the'd be perfect or ideal in Andromeda.

 

Oh come on don't be so naive. The Reapers did not write Mass Effect 2, Bioware did. Bioware did not HAVE to make ME2 be all about Human's being the saviors of the galaxy which essentially what happened in ME2 and especially ME3.

 

Bioware did not HAVE to make Earth or "take back Earth" the main theme of ME3. Why not take back the galaxy? Why the focus on Earth? I thought the Reapers where a threat to ALL life in the galaxy? This was the vibe I got in ME1 but fast forward to ME3, it was mainly about taking back Earth with all the other homeworlds just be remote problems.

 

One good thing I can say about the Dragon Age series is that despite Humans being the political, social, economical, and even military power in Thedas, the game stories never make it out to have Human's as the main saviors. But with ME2 and ME3, it is ALL about humanity and how powerful they are and how much of a threat they are to the Reapers and how it will be up to them to save the galaxy.

 

I just hope that MEA is a story about ALL species endeavor to find new hope beyond the milky way....but just told through a human lens rather than a story about HUMANS endeavor to find new hope beyond the milky way. 


  • Heimdall, Will-o'-wisp et Drone223 aiment ceci

#142
Majestic Jazz

Majestic Jazz
  • Members
  • 1 966 messages

One of the factors that made me enjoy the first ME was the element that, "humans" weren't the alpha species.  In lore, we were the sibling learning their place in the new galaxy...  The asari, turians, salarians were all well established, and we were only getting to understand our role. It added a semblance of realism.  Yet, the wheels came off in ME2 and ME3 where this ideology was lost and Broward succumbed to the cliché to have the humans the 'alpha' species, exhibit their plotline of having the Reapers' focus on humans and the Citadel's new home at the end of ME3.  While I'm fine with a human protagonist, I hope ME:A doesn't continue the "humans are holier than 'other galactic races'" ME2 and ME3 embodied.  My .02.

 

Well said.

 

In ME: Revelation (ME1 prequel novel) as well as ME1, humans were just a small fish in a big ocean. In ME2 and ME3, they were the big fish in a small pond. 



#143
BatarianBob

BatarianBob
  • Members
  • 585 messages
The hardcore fans (what few are left) might like a turian or asari story, but normal people will take one look and say "nope".

Of course it'll be a human story, and it should be.

#144
Keitaro57

Keitaro57
  • Members
  • 585 messages

The hardcore fans (what few are left) might like a turian or asari story, but normal people will take one look and say "nope".

Of course it'll be a human story, and it should be.

There is a big big gap between human-centred story and multi-species centred story. A shooter with mostly humans and have only aliens in the background exist already and is named Halo. Don't want to play an Halo spinoff but a game in the ME world, a world filled with various species. Being able to play Asari, Turian or other bring diversity and after three whole game centred on the main and unique and totally badass and absolutely perfect human species I'm getting bored....



#145
The Elder King

The Elder King
  • Members
  • 19 630 messages

Oh come on don't be so naive. The Reapers did not write Mass Effect 2, Bioware did. Bioware did not HAVE to make ME2 be all about Human's being the saviors of the galaxy which essentially what happened in ME2 and especially ME3.

 

Bioware did not HAVE to make Earth or "take back Earth" the main theme of ME3. Why not take back the galaxy? Why the focus on Earth? I thought the Reapers where a threat to ALL life in the galaxy? This was the vibe I got in ME1 but fast forward to ME3, it was mainly about taking back Earth with all the other homeworlds just be remote problems.

 

One good thing I can say about the Dragon Age series is that despite Humans being the political, social, economical, and even military power in Thedas, the game stories never make it out to have Human's as the main saviors. But with ME2 and ME3, it is ALL about humanity and how powerful they are and how much of a threat they are to the Reapers and how it will be up to them to save the galaxy.

 

I just hope that MEA is a story about ALL species endeavor to fiSorry,nd new hope beyond the milky way....but just told through a human lens rather than a story about HUMANS endeavor to find new hope beyond the milky way. 

Sorry, why am I being naive? I never implied in my post that it wasn't Bioware that picked humans to be the net Reaper or to put the focus on humanity.

 

This doesn't change the fact that humanity was ALREADY special in ME, due to their unique way of achieving space-faring status, due to the speed in achieving an embassy and council member status, their military strenght and their own contribution to the Normandy. Also, the role of the Alliance in saving the Citadel from the Sovereign (not to mention Shepard's own status). If you don't recognize how special and different humans were already in ME you're denying the truth.

ME2 and ME3 certainly put more focus, but let's not forget that humans in ME can achieve a nonsensical human all council. Bioware developed the IP with humans as special compared to the other species from the start.


  • Will-o'-wisp, Il Divo, Grieving Natashina et 1 autre aiment ceci

#146
Selene Moonsong

Selene Moonsong
  • Members
  • 3 393 messages
Frankly, I'd rather not play as other races in Mass Effect: Andromeda

For certain, I have not been actively participating in the forums other than to post on an interesting topic I happen across and prefer to remain oblivious to What BioWare may or may reveal in here or in social media.

However, as I initially noted, I would rather play as human simply because they are the most unpredictable creatures in the universe. If a story is to be human centric then by all means the playable character should be human. The main reason I prefer humans in the Mass Effect universe is for the chance to interact with aliens.

Besides, to make a story line work with a choice of other species as the protagonist would require equal story lines from the alien's perspective meaning just as much history as would be created for humans. I don't bring this up as a matter of resources or time limitations, but the ability to create so many different possibilities of the other species version of the over-all plot of the game evenly, but within the limitations of the various species as well. By comparison, humans are less predictable than the other space-faring races in how they would likely react to things.

While a common objective works for some things (like DAO and DAI) I am not so certain it would work with Mass Effect.

Playing an Elf or Dwarf in DA II would not have worked in that game, because it was a human centric plot unlike DAO for DAI because the objective format is different. The Mass Effect Series has been human centric from the beginning. And, while we are used to them by the time we reach ME 3, not enough to not be upset by the limitations imposed on those species due to their limitations as has been discussed throughout the series of games so far.

I can see some of the attraction of playing another species due to their abilities and/or social structures that create their limitations and abilities/powers that would make them interesting in combat and doing their own thing in their own way according the available data on all the species of the Mass Effect universe, But if all the decisions the player has to make are based on the identical plot line for humans, then the only difference would the advantages or disadvantages of the other species. In other words one plot would not fit all and we would be playing them for the sake of a meaningless choice of races and may as well be a generic shooter rather than an RPG.
  • CrimsonN7 et Grieving Natashina aiment ceci

#147
Display Name Owner

Display Name Owner
  • Members
  • 1 190 messages

I'm a bit disappointed really. We've already had the whole "humans are special" thing with the original trilogy, ME:A was supposed to be a new game with new themes. Personally I'd prefer a game focused on interspecies co operation with all of them working together to make a new home, with no single race being superior.

 

But oh well, I'll be fine with the story being told from a human perspective, I just hope it doesn't go down the "Humans are the best! All other races should look up to us! homosapiens FTW!" route.

 

That's what I'm hoping for, and I have to admit that I might be being a touch optimistic on it. But then I was reminded by a post on some other thread that the whole Pathfinder Initiative is an Alliance thing, which would be the equivalent of the Alliance spearheading the Crucible plans for some reason. But then it's worth remembering that by this point in the MEverse the Alliance is on the same political level as the Hierarchy and whatever the Salarian and Asari ones are called (I forget...), so them being in charge of major things isn't quite as silly as it was in previous games.

 

Still... we're an Alliance guy, not working for the Council at large, so I guess there is the threat of this daft 'Humanity are good at everything while other species only have one talent' thing cropping up, which I am really not fond of.



#148
ComedicSociopathy

ComedicSociopathy
  • Members
  • 1 951 messages

I think the series ME was less of a "humans are the center of the galaxy" and more of a "Shepard is the center of the galaxy". 


  • straykat aime ceci

#149
CrimsonN7

CrimsonN7
  • Members
  • 17 277 messages

Another win for the Human Master Race

 

Suck it Beta Aliens. The+flag+means+it+s+ours_7cc82f_5294367.

 

Worth clicking on this thread alone, that gif. :lol:



#150
Il Divo

Il Divo
  • Members
  • 9 768 messages

Well said.

 

In ME: Revelation (ME1 prequel novel) as well as ME1, humans were just a small fish in a big ocean. In ME2 and ME3, they were the big fish in a small pond. 

 

Wait, wasn't this the same human race that in the span of a few decades managed to attain political status/power that other races had spent lifetimes trying to achieve, which everyone goes out of their way to comment on?

 

ME1 wasn't about humans as a small fish in a big ocean, it was humanity right on the cusp of becoming a galactic super power. Luckily ME2 retconned the renegade ending, but that aspect of ME1 also didn't do a great job of downplaying the idea that humans are special/awesome. If ME2 was about how amazing humans were, it was only because ME1 basically told us that this was where the writers were going.