36 réponses à ce sujet

[FemShem]

People always whine so much...why not do it as an option?

Instead of playing the Inquisitor have the HoF or Hawke have the improbability drive going to have been at the conclave, get the Mark (because that is their luck) and do the play through with slightly altered dialogue.  

Acknowledge or not the Leliana romance (or if you killed her) as HoF with some backhanded humor and away we go, plus wouldn't the Winter Palace be fun with the Morrigan reunion (if she had you baby as HoF). or as aggressive Hawke (who is only slightly less destructive that renegade Shepard).  Dress them up, but you can't take them out.

Though you to be Qunari you'd have to role an Inquisitor.

They'd just have to call in the VO actors for Hawke and HoF can be printed out old school to annoy us all and live in the past.

It would be a job for the writers.  Actually, it could be done fairly cosmetically on BioWare's part or as deeply as they wanted.

Sell it for a 14.99 DLC, give it away for free, probably some fan will program a HoF option now that I have mentioned it, or attempt it.

Actually the writers could do as little or as much as they wanted with this farce of an idea, take it seriously or not.  Do default Hawke appearance male or female and use it based on the Trevelyan story (Free Marcher).

*This is why I shouldn't go get a flu shot, and spend 3 days on the boards.

Tell me why this idea would be fun absolutely horrible.

[AresKeith]

*sigh*

[Ghost Gal]

No.

[ComedicSociopathy]

Do I seriously need go grab Elsa and explain that people need to let this go. 

 

Again. 

[Heimdall]

...Do I actually need to explain how much work and rewriting this would have to be to make the swap more than a palate swap?

[MyKingdomCold]

I'm confused. Is the OP making fun of people who come with these ideas or something?

 

I mean the last sentence "Tell me why this idea would be fun absolutely horrible." is a bit confusing

[Toasted Llama]

I'm confused. Is the OP making fun of people who come with these ideas or something?

 

I mean the last sentence "Tell me why this idea would be fun absolutely horrible." is a bit confusing

 

Considering its FemShem there's a strong possibility

[FemShem]

C'mon.

Don't you want to suspend you disbelief and play with me while on cough syrup?

Technically, it's kind of a fun a idea.

If you did as a lark.  Not part of cannon.  Stick it in a file next to bi-Cassandra.

What the hell is in the cough syrup?

[ComedicSociopathy]

C'mon.

Don't you want to suspend you disbelief and play with me while on cough syrup?

Technically, it's kind of a fun a idea.

If you did as a lark.  Not part of cannon.  Stick it in a file next to bi-Cassandra.

What the hell is in the cough syrup?

 

Alright...

 

I mean, having Hawke as Inquisitor would probably force the story to focus more on the Mage-Templar War and give the hunt for Corypheus a more personal connection. But I'd still prefer not to have all the baggage of DA 2 affect Inquisition. 

[straykat]

Alright...

 

I mean, having Hawke as Inquisitor would probably force the story to focus more on the Mage-Templar War and give the hunt for Corypheus a more personal connection. But I'd still prefer not to have all the baggage of DA 2 affect Inquisition. 

 

That's the only one I'd like.

 

That way DA2 would be the origin story of a character that mattered.

 

Now I have an origin story of a random character in DA2. And a random character in DAI who somehow matters. *scratches head*

[FemShem]

Te

 

Alright...

 

I mean, having Hawke as Inquisitor would probably force the story to focus more on the Mage-Templar War and give the hunt for Corypheus a more personal connection. But I'd still prefer not to have all the baggage of DA 2 affect Inquisition. 

Cassandra technically brushes that DA2 conflict under the table when she talks about the fact the war was inevitable because The Seekers of Truth let it slip that the right of Tranquility was created by them and could be reversed, and that was what ignited the flame.

It sort of made what Anders did inflammatory, but inconsequential.  I wish they had tried to reverse the right of tranquility on a mage in game.

But having Hawke lead the Inquisition would have changed things.  Even if you took it as a plot option, and the Inquisitor had the mark, stayed the Herald but didn't become Inquisitor.

Why would all have Thedas respected Hawke though as leader of the Inquisition?  HoF makes sense.  Kirkwall is just one city.  Hawke's story...well...Hawke could have sided or done a bunch of different things end game.

Though, YES, then the Corypheous story would be personal!

While we're at it, ultimate party: HoF, Hawke, Inquisitor, and Leliana (if you specialized differently)...could be fun!  Since PC toons tend to be a bit OP, and Leland was always my fav OP rogue in Origins once she leveled up to using Major (her ex's) bow.

[FemShem]

...Do I actually need to explain how much work and rewriting this would have to be to make the swap more than a palate swap?

No, I know.

[GoldenGail3]

Te
 

Cassandra technically brushes that DA2 conflict under the table when she talks about the fact the war was inevitable because The Seekers of Truth let it slip that the right of Tranquility was created by them and could be reversed, and that was what ignited the flame.
It sort of made what Anders did inflammatory, but inconsequential.  I wish they had tried to reverse the right of tranquility on a mage in game.
But having Hawke lead the Inquisition would have changed things.  Even if you took it as a plot option, and the Inquisitor had the mark, stayed the Herald but didn't become Inquisitor.
Why would all have Thedas respected Hawke though as leader of the Inquisition?  HoF makes sense.  Kirkwall is just one city.  Hawke's story...well...Hawke could have sided or done a bunch of different things end game.
Though, YES, then the Corypheous story would be personal!
While we're at it, ultimate party: HoF, Hawke, Inquisitor, and Leliana (if you specialized differently)...could be fun!  Since PC toons tend to be a bit OP, and Leland was always my fav OP rogue in Origins once she leveled up to using Major (her ex's) bow.

Hawke as the Inquistor? NO. THATS THE WORST IDEA EVER. The Warden would've been possessed by Coryphues and then the game would've sucked as the Warden destroyed Thedas.

[Toasted Llama]

Hawke as the Inquistor? NO. THATS THE WORST IDEA EVER. The Warden would've been possessed by Coryphues and then the game would've sucked as the Warden destroyed Thedas.

Worst idea ever?

 

Wasn't it originally Bioware's idea to make Hawke into the Inquisitor?

[FemShem]

Worst idea ever?

 

Wasn't it originally Bioware's idea to make Hawke into the Inquisitor?

*Snort* Yes.  I do believe it was.

Whether that was rumor or proven I am uncertain of; however, supposedly it was due to DA2 sales and the loss of popularity (i.e. the game being rushed by EA) that led to Hawke being replaced by the IQ in DA:I.  Wasn't an alternate game for the name DA: Asunder at one point?  I cringe everytime Corypheus gives the Asunder line in his final Boss fight. 

Can't stand putting the title and the line of the game...wait for it...wait for it...here it is folks..."rips a asunder" and the ground shakes...I blush and go...that would have been the worst line ever...if they named the game that.

As it is...many brilliant lines, and that one goes unnoticed.  

So many writers in my lifetime love to do that crap...here's the line from the title...see, see how smart I am, SHM.

Eh-hem.

OH, yes, OP,

C'mob Hawke's whole bloodline thing with Cory would have been great...or so BioWare set up.

Great point of HoF being possessed...short game...unless of course they were cured from the blight (as they are trying to be if they survived and are in a relationship with Leliana, as was...going blank on leader of the mage rebellion name...used to be a grey warden...but she no longer has the blight...) they could have cured the HoF by the same means...

Great thing about writing cannon in sic-fi and fantasy...you just poof...and make it possible...

sci-fi add tecnobabble...fantasy throw a curveball plot line that almost males sense...much like me...

If I wrote for BioWare...hell I'd hit a forum...trouble shoot an idea...pull it bury it...and be done...btw I don't...but I totally would in today's world.

Eh-hem, not that I've ever done that in a fandom...but fans are smart and know their cannon better than your pile of research;)

[CoM Solaufein]

no

[Almostfaceman]

People always whine so much...why not do it as an option?

Instead of playing the Inquisitor have the HoF or Hawke have the improbability drive going to have been at the conclave, get the Mark (because that is their luck) and do the play through with slightly altered dialogue.  

Acknowledge or not the Leliana romance (or if you killed her) as HoF with some backhanded humor and away we go, plus wouldn't the Winter Palace be fun with the Morrigan reunion (if she had you baby as HoF). or as aggressive Hawke (who is only slightly less destructive that renegade Shepard).  Dress them up, but you can't take them out.

Though you to be Qunari you'd have to role an Inquisitor.

They'd just have to call in the VO actors for Hawke and HoF can be printed out old school to annoy us all and live in the past.

It would be a job for the writers.  Actually, it could be done fairly cosmetically on BioWare's part or as deeply as they wanted.

Sell it for a 14.99 DLC, give it away for free, probably some fan will program a HoF option now that I have mentioned it, or attempt it.

Actually the writers could do as little or as much as they wanted with this farce of an idea, take it seriously or not.  Do default Hawke appearance male or female and use it based on the Trevelyan story (Free Marcher).

*This is why I shouldn't go get a flu shot, and spend 3 days on the boards.

Tell me why this idea would be fun absolutely horrible.

 

 

No... and step back slowly from the cough syrup. 

[FemShem]

LOL.

You win.

I'll take my fever and go to bed.

Can you kill a High Dragon with a fever on Nightmare?

Maybe, I can just annoy myself.

Ty for you indulgence.

*bows out graciously.

Maybe my cough syrup is better served in DQ;)

OMG I'm laughing so hard I think I broke a rib...tyvm...ouch.

[MileyChicken]

My Hawke is too cool to be the Inquisitor.

 

As for the warden well.. I never got around to making a canon. But not one of them would wanna be an inquisitor.

[Aren]

Yes the elder one will be very happy to face an Inquisitor who happen to be also a  Warden,no need to fight,s/he will become directly a tool.

[SardaukarElite]

Because of the look the development team would give the lead designer if they floated the idea.

[GoldenGail3]

Worst idea ever?
 
Wasn't it originally Bioware's idea to make Hawke into the Inquisitor?

Worst idea ever?
 
Wasn't it originally Bioware's idea to make Hawke into the Inquisitor?

No. It was to make the Inquistor human only though.

[FemShem]

No. It was to make the Inquistor human only though.

 

Yes, as was the ME Shep problem.  I would miss the classism issues that come into play in Thedas, which merely sub in for social/societal issues here on terra nova.  Of course this varies country to country with religious influences, and culturally dependent on where you are w/i the US (we're an odd bunch).

It was interesting having Shep for ME trilogy and human only issues, when we role DA with different games only in DA2 were we forced to be human...only in ME2 were we forced to be straight (w/o an important from ME1).

Off to fake kill things in Thedas since I can't kill this cough.  Why do I find BioWare soothing when I feel like crap?  Awwww.  BioWare.

[GoldenGail3]

Yes, as was the ME Shep problem.  I would miss the classism issues that come into play in Thedas, which merely sub in for social/societal issues here on terra nova.  Of course this varies country to country with religious influences, and culturally dependent on where you are w/i the US (we're an odd bunch).
It was interesting having Shep for ME trilogy and human only issues, when we role DA with different games only in DA2 were we forced to be human...only in ME2 were we forced to be straight (w/o an important from ME1).
Off to fake kill things in Thedas since I can't kill this cough.  Why do I find BioWare soothing when I feel like crap?  Awwww.  BioWare.

I understand. I have jet lag that makes me feel real cracky. I mean, if you looked at my past posts, I sound super cracky because of a time change of 1 day and three hours. It's gonna take me two weeks to adjust to the time change....

[dsl08002]

People always whine so much...why not do it as an option?
Instead of playing the Inquisitor have the HoF or Hawke have the improbability drive going to have been at the conclave, get the Mark (because that is their luck) and do the play through with slightly altered dialogue.  
Acknowledge or not the Leliana romance (or if you killed her) as HoF with some backhanded humor and away we go, plus wouldn't the Winter Palace be fun with the Morrigan reunion (if she had you baby as HoF). or as aggressive Hawke (who is only slightly less destructive that renegade Shepard).  Dress them up, but you can't take them out.
Though you to be Qunari you'd have to role an Inquisitor.
They'd just have to call in the VO actors for Hawke and HoF can be printed out old school to annoy us all and live in the past.
It would be a job for the writers.  Actually, it could be done fairly cosmetically on BioWare's part or as deeply as they wanted.
Sell it for a 14.99 DLC, give it away for free, probably some fan will program a HoF option now that I have mentioned it, or attempt it.

Actually the writers could do as little or as much as they wanted with this farce of an idea, take it seriously or not.  Do default Hawke appearance male or female and use it based on the Trevelyan story (Free Marcher).
*This is why I shouldn't go get a flu shot, and spend 3 days on the boards.
Tell me why this idea would be fun absolutely horrible.

Its no use of mention either hawke or mostly the warden as that, these ******* people will chirp at you right away.