Then you really shouldn't be surprised when the journalists call people out for being a dick then? What goes around does come around by that logic, first off.
In my experience what you ask for is not even the truth of the matter; what the majority of people want is not just entertainment or facts in some form; they want to be vindicated for being right- hence the polarized news cycle to begin with in all forms of media; the pundits en-masse by the likes of Sterling, Kuchera, Kain, and youtube entertainers like Vargas and Bain.
Journalism is not a service in that way- my goal when I write or editorialize is to inform and educate, sometimes simultaneously, so you can make decisions on things you see and read- a public service for truth and ideals. If you don't like what you see and read, there is little I can do about that of course, but what people define as helpful or informative is too subjective in it's own right in the end to be of any use; facts are facts, stubborn and infallible like that- popular opinion is meaningless to good journalism in that way as it only gets in the way of the facts, especially if it's contrary to the truth.
Editorials and critic pieces like reviews are a different beast all together, and some of what you say is all true on that aspect of journalism. Bare news, however, I would argue you are off-base.
And I also wasn't talking about journalists being the only ones legitimizing it, I mean companies too like EA and Activision working their asses off to make the hobby fun. The rebellious "we don't need approval" attitude is all well and good, just don't be shocked when say congress blames you for the next mass shooting, along with ten other things perceived as the "problem" because of how outsiders look at it. All sides, consumers, developers, publishers, and journalists, should be on the same page for that, but they aren't because of distrust, cynicism or just plain rebelliousness.
Like it or not, their opinion is kind of important in the end to the mediums growth. Long-term acceptance and all of that, something the likes of comic books finally achieved in the past 20 years after 50 or so under the comic code authority and having psychiatrists saying batman turns people gay.
I think we can do better in the long run through that.
I fail to see how the fact that I find highly subjective, stuck up, opinionated and disconnected journalism unappealing makes me a dick.
Do I want to be right? Well, obviously, but not necessarily as a rule, I can agree to disagree, or even *le gasp* admit that I'm wrong. (sometimes...)
A journalist that thinks similarly to how I think, has an added value to me because at least to some degree, I know that I can trust his recommendations.
That is more important to me than petty vindication.
I am not your friend, and I don't come to read gaming media to be educated, I either find your opinion useful / entertaining, or I don't.
Example: I watch John Bain's (TotalBiscuit) youtube channel semi-regularly. Do I agree with everything he says? Not even close.
But I do like the fact that he tends to wear his biases on his sleeve without trying to be too underhanded about them,
I also find his personality and method somewhat entertaining, finally I found his channel to be informative on subjects that interest me.
Logic is something I can respect, even if my own brings me to a slightly different conclusion.
My point is, this is not a negotiation between me and you about what is the percentage of crap I am willing to swallow with the kind of entertainment / info I want.
But rather, this is me telling you that for me, you and your kind's work is for the most part unappealing, uninteresting, and mildly offensive.(and therefore irrelevant and ineffectual for the most part)
I understand that some gaming media websites has begun to lose some of their spunk and fighting spirit after seeing a sharp decline in interest and views (they certainly became more polite about their opinions).
That's good. I don't have to settle for a preachy journalist or a website that tries to "educate" me about their personal opinions, I merely have to wait for someone else. There is always someone else. The laws of supply and demand are on my side.
I am just one consumer that do not even live in the US. Worrying about the US congress and public opinions is pointless for me.
I prefer putting my trust in market forces (which will not allow a potentially lucrative market to dry up / be completely blocked by politicians) than in
a few try hard journalists, the idea that you guys are the last line of defense for video games is laughable, especially considering the dubious integrity
of gaming media in general.