46 réponses à ce sujet

[General TSAR]

Obviously Human. 

[Jason1990]

From a RP view:

 

DA:O - Aedan Cousland, male human noble, warrior. I felt like all the wardens were warriors for some reason, dont know why I felt that way though. Maybe because all of them were in heavy armor in the start of the game.

DA:2 - Marian Hawke, male human warrior. Still for the same reason as above.

DA:I  - Evelyn Trevelyan, female human warrior. Seeing the mark at the start of the game and seeing some spirit/god and being in the fade made me feel that we needed a templar in order to do this. Also a human because I thought this had something to do with the maker.

 

So yeah I think humans are the obvious choice for RP

 

What i realy did:

DA:O - Kaithlyn Amell, female human circle mage. I was a arcane warrior/spirit healer.

DA:2  - Tori Hawke, female mage. I was a force mage/spirit healer.

DA:I   - Edric Cadash, male dwarf warrior. I went for a templar tank build.

[nightscrawl]

^ Just FYI, despite the armor he's wearing in the game, Duncan is actually a rogue if we go by The Calling.

[Jedi Comedian]

^ Just FYI, despite the armor he's wearing in the game, Duncan is actually a rogue if we go by The Calling.

I haven't read The Calling yet, I kinda thought Duncan was a warrior (even though I absolutely love the rogue class) 'cause in the Fade he used sword and shield skills. But if he is indeed a rogue, then I like him even more!

[GoldenGail3]

DAO: Female Warrior Cousland - Templar/Warrior/Spirt Warrior, Female Amell - Acrane Warrior/Spirt Healer/ Battlemage, Male Warrior Cousland - Templar/Reaver/Spirt Warrior

DA2: Male Mage Hawke - Blood Mage/Spirt Healer, Female Warrior Hawke - Templar/Beserker, Male Warrior Hawke - Reaver/Templar

DAI: Female Mage Trevelyan - Knight Enchantress, Male Mage Lavellan - Knight Enchantor, Female Mage Lavellan - Storm Mage (no class choicen)

[Nefla]

Whichever one you like playing as. Personally I favor elves and mages and would much rather have played DA2 as an elf than a human.

[Evamitchelle]

DAO - Rogue City Elf. (About on par with Cousland acutally , but that's already been covered by multiple people.) Duncan was specifically looking to recruit Tabris, as he'd done for their mother before ; Tabris has very personal reasons to want to take Howe and Loghain down, as they're the people responsible for purging the alienage and selling their friends and family into slavery, respectively ; they can return to the alienage and interact with the people they left behind as part of the main quest (both during Unrest in the Alienage and the final battle). They can't rule Ferelden, but ending up the first elven noble in Fereldan history feels like enough of a progression that I can look past it. And rogue because it makes more sense given the City Elf background. 

 

DA2 - Warrior/Rogue makes more sense to me in Act 2 and 3. Hawke being a mage is never really brought up, and it can lead to some awkward lines (ie. Cullen telling mage Hawke that "mages aren't people like you or me"). Bethany's still there to give you a link to the mage storyline, so ultimately I think a non-mage works better. I usually play a rogue, but class doesn't make much difference here so both are equally good. 

 

DAI - Early game favors a non-mage Trevelyan, but the late-game and DLCs are pretty heavy on the elfy stuff: finding out what happened in Red Crossing, deciding who drinks from the Well of Sorrows, meeting Mythal, the first Inquisitor turning out to be an elven mage who was rewritten as a human warrior by the Chantry, learning more about Arlathan and the Evanuris, having one of their gods as a companion (and possible friend/romance) etc. So ultimately I'd say Lavellan is the most connected, and a mage one most of all. 

[Dieb]

I'm going to be honest with you.

 

DA2 - Human Male Rogue

DAI - Human Male Rogue

TES - Human Male Rogue

BG - Human Male Rogue

Every Installment Of Any Other Franchise With Applicable CC - Human Male Rogue

Kinda-Like-"Tetris"-Clone On My Casio Digital Watch - Human Male Rogue

Pong - Human Male Rogue

 

yet

 

DAO - City Elf Female Warrior

 

Origins was the only RPG I loved as much and still did not employ the above illustrated, very diverse pattern. The Human Noble Origin is incredibly boring compared to the others, and frankly, I still find DAO's (Archer) Rogue gameplay and equipment unbearably awful to an insulting degree.

[Catilina]

I'm going to be honest with you.

 

DA2 - Human Male Rogue

DAI - Human Male Rogue

TES - Human Male Rogue

BG - Human Male Rogue

Every Installment Of Any Other Franchise With Applicable CC - Human Male Rogue

Kinda-Like-"Tetris"-Clone On My Casio Digital Watch - Human Male Rogue

Pong - Human Male Rogue

 

yet

 

DAO - City Elf Female Warrior

 

Origins was the only RPG I loved as much and still did not employ the above illustrated, very diverse pattern. The Human Noble Origin is incredibly boring compared to the others, and frankly, I still find DAO's (Archer) Rogue gameplay and equipment unbearably awful to an insulting degree.

My main characters in some games:

 

WoW: Night elf male – Druid (Balance ofc, from the beginning – was a hard way in the eary times)

TESO: High elf male – Sorcerer

TES, Morrowind: High elf male – Sorcerer, Oblivion: High elf male – Sorcerer, Skyrim: High elf male – Sorcerer

NWN: Half elf male – Druid

Mass Effect, 1, 2, 3: Human male (ofc...) – Biotic (Adept)

DAO: Elf male – Mage (specced as "druid"): spirit healer, shapeshifter, keeper), DA2: Human male – mage, DAI: Human male mage (and yes, i have 2 Elves too ...)

 

AND: if the game allowed, my all chars have high persuasive skills! I miss it in the DA2/DAI. So much!

[Jason1990]

 

 

AND: if the game allowed, my all chars have high persuasive skills! I miss it in the DA2/DAI. So much!

You could take the know knowledge inquistion perks wich gives you more speech options in alot of conversations. the ones with the more xp from codex ones.

[Mykel54]

These are mine

 

Brosca. male casteless dwarf, dual wield rogue (duelist/assassin)
Hawke. female noble human, two hander warrior (champion)
Adaar. female tal-vashoth, combat mage (knight enchanter)

[GoldenGail3]

Fine if we're getting into Skryim and etc....

Skyrim; Male Dark Elf Rogue.

KOTOR: Female Human Jedi Consular (is playing for free. Doesn't feel like wasting money on video games)

[ElementalFury106]

DAO: Human Male Warrior. Romances Leliana. Dark Ritual performed. Alistair and Anora marry; Warden Cousland is named Chancellor, Arl of Amaranthine, and Warden Commander of Fereldan.

 

DA2: Male Mage Hawke. Romances Isabela. Carver becomes Grey Warden. Sides with the Mages.

 

Now with Inquisition, I'm torn between two scenarios that just would be perfect for canon, I'll just list both

 

DAI: Human Male Mage. Romances Cassandra. Sides with Mages. Celene rules Orlais (three way truce). Wardens allied. Morrigan drinks the Well of Sorrows. Inquisition remains as peace-keeping organization.

 

alternatively...

 

DAI: Elf Female Mage. Romances Solas. Sides with Mages. Briala rules Orlais through Gaspard. Wardens allied. Inquisitor drinks from the Well of Sorrows. Inquisition disbanded.

[DreamSever]

Human noble rogue, at least there is no bias and i feel it blends in when cassandra said she wanted hof first then hawke second, my rogue was determined and won them over, while the mage made sense, he, she was powerful already, the rogue grows into it, love it

[Valerius]

DA:O - Human Male Cousland who romances Morrigan and performs the ritual, eventually walking in the portal with her.

 

DA2 - Male rogue Hawke who sides with the mages due to his sister and the actions taken by knight commander Meredith.

 

DAI: Now here is where I'm a bit torn. I'm stuck between choosing my canon to be a M Trevelyan Mage, or a M Trevelyan Sword and Shield Warrior. The mage makes a lot of sense considering the problem with the breach and all of the magic related issues (like entering the fade and dealing with Corypheus.) However a non-mage makes more sense in terms of leading an organization that is affiliated with the chantry. Not to mention its difficult to see how the people of thedas would support a mage as the herald of andraste no matter how desperate things were. What do you guys think?

[Tidus]

Actually Cassandra wanted the HoF or Hawke for Inquisitor but,ends up with a Dalish Elf in my game..

 

In my DA:O ending story lines she wouldn't want the HoF because after Leliana returned to the Chantry Tidus became a drunk,Camine marries and settles down. She's still friends with the Royal couple.  

 

Chasha returned to the Circle for a short time then departed to join Lanaya's  Clan as her second. 

 

Rikku( my brand) tires of the quiet life at Orzammar and joins a Dwarven surface  Carta as a enforcer and smuggler. I'm currently using her in my Dwarf test game.. She smuggled some Lyrium into the concave and was caught in the explosion before she could leave.. Josephine does bring up her criminal past.

[DreamSever]

DA:O - Human Male Cousland who romances Morrigan and performs the ritual, eventually walking in the portal with her.

 

DA2 - Male rogue Hawke who sides with the mages due to his sister and the actions taken by knight commander Meredith.

 

DAI: Now here is where I'm a bit torn. I'm stuck between choosing my canon to be a M Trevelyan Mage, or a M Trevelyan Sword and Shield Warrior. The mage makes a lot of sense considering the problem with the breach and all of the magic related issues (like entering the fade and dealing with Corypheus.) However a non-mage makes more sense in terms of leading an organization that is affiliated with the chantry. Not to mention its difficult to see how the people of thedas would support a mage as the herald of andraste no matter how desperate things were. What do you guys think?

Rogues best option , no ties to circle or chantry, rogue dalish could work but a first nope

[JadeDragon]

My Personal favorite

DA:O - Male Cousland Warrior: I enjoyed HN the most due to how your nemesis is so personally tied to the plot. And waiting till near the end to get revenge on him was a good moment. Romanced Morrigan with the Dark Ritual and going through the mirror.

 

DA2 - Male Hawke Mage: Besides the nobody reports you for being a mage thing I enjoyed my mage hawke the most. Especially having Carver as a Templar to add sibling rivalry to the story and siding with the mages to eventually your little brother deciding not to turn against you was just a nice touch for me storywise. Romanced Izzy which fit best for me since my hawke was sarcastic and humorous kinda keeping him in that roguish like area despite being a mage.

 

DA:I - Male Trevelyan Rogue: I knew coming in I wanted a rogue to round out my 3 heroes and I wasn't really disappointed. Making my Human Noble a rogue worked because he was more cutthroat as the game would allow and since his family had strong ties to the chantry and Templars that made enough sense for him to be at the conclave more so then my other Inquisitors(minus Human Mage). Went the Templar Route. Romanced Cassandra. Morrigan Drunk the juice and Kept the Inquisition as a peace-keeping force for Divine Cass.

[Frybread76]

What class/race combo do you think makes the most sense for every MC in the franchise from a roleplaying point of view?

 

DA:O - I like the male human noble, basically because I like the romance with Morrigan.  I had hoped the OGB would have been a major factor in the series but whatever.

 

DA2 - I didn't really like this game, but I really did like the Sarcastic Hawke male voice actor.

 

DA:I - I think an elven mage makes the most sense, whether male or female.  It  just seems to fit in better with what happens, especially taking into account Trespasser and JoH.

[draken-heart]

I switch them around so much, that I can not answer this, sorry.

[correctamundo]

M!Brosca

Rogue f!Hawke

F!Cadash

[Shizukai]

What class/race combo do you think makes the most sense for every MC in the franchise from a roleplaying point of view?

 

DAO: Human male warrior/rogue, Morrigan romance. A somehow classic hero with a not so classic love interest.
DA2: Difficult. For me, Hawke is a  cynical underdog fighting his/her way through the dort of Kirkwall. He/she could be anything.
DAI: I read that DAI was build around a human main character, but because of its contents (the revelations about the former Inquisitor in FoH for example) I really see and feel that an elven Inquisitor is fitting very well. A female one because of the outcome of the Solas romance maybe. But I do believe that my personal preference influences this answer. Also, I'm not sure with the class.


My personal favorites are:

DA:O: Female elven mage, Alistair-romance,
DA2: Female Hawke mage, Anders-romance

DAI: Female elven mage, Solas-romance

Elves are my favorite race in nearly every fantasy-universe I'm familiar with. And I love to be a mage - especially

in the DA-series for their position is always a very hard-fought one. The desire of freedom and the temptation of

even more power are powerful drives.