29 réponses à ce sujet

[Aren]

Fiona was cured from the taint by some mysterious circumstances.

Some say that it was accidentally the Architect to do that,others that it was the dragon blood of the Theirin family.

The only thing that's certain is that he went from Ferelden to Weisshaupt to make report about what happened with the Architect then returned to Maric when she was no longer tainted.

Fiona said that she do not know what happened to her obviously she could have been  lying about it,maybe she do know but she do not want to disclose.

 

My theory is that some high ranking Grey wardens of Weisshaupt gave to her the cure.

A cure for the Calling may  exist and may be  in the hands of those who are in Weisshaupt but they don't wont to gave it for their own interests such as:

 

 

-Force the others members of the order to remain in the order because one way or the other they will still be all tainted

 

-The senior warden are always forced to go in Orzammar for their calling thus help the dwarves and in doing so maintain the validity of the GW treaties for the help of the Dwarves.

 

-have always around GW for the blights.

 

 

 

[Abyss108]

But why would they give it to Fiona?

[MidnightWolf]

But why would they give it to Fiona?

This. Plus, Fiona was shunned by the Wardens and forced to leave. I doibt they'd cure her just to shun her. Personally, I think it was just that Tavinter Amulet, with magic gone wrong which cured her.

[nightscrawl]

It could just have had to do with the whole pregnancy thing. Perhaps her body purged the taint in an effort to safeguard the fetus. Of course, since she was a Warden she would have had a difficult come conceiving anyway, so perhaps the Theirin blood helped with that.

[thats1evildude]

I'm not sure why people have a hard time accepting that the Architect cured her by accident.

[Aren]

I'm not sure why people have a hard time accepting that the Architect cured her by accident.

Because i don't think that the Architect did something to her, even by accident.
The blood of the Theirin is too much of a far fetched theory...
I think that the wardens of the Anderfel did something to her.

[Aren]

But why would they give it to Fiona?

Because she was in love with the king of a nation and they probably wanted to gain some advantage from this situation and from their child.

[Mykel54]

I agree with the theory that  conceiving a fusgorah kid cleansed her.

[Abyss108]

Because she was in love with the king of a nation and they probably wanted to gain some advantage from this situation.

 

...how does curing her and kicking her out give them an advantage?

[Knight of Dane]

Because she was in love with the king of a nation and they probably wanted to gain some advantage from this situation and from their child.

Did they know that she was in love with Maric?

 

Regardless, she is a mage and an elf. Any advantage a match with a foreign king could get them would be lost then.

[Aren]

...how does curing her and kicking her out give them an advantage?

It doesn't seem to be a bad idea to seduce the king of the same nation that exiled them with a Gw lover in order to try to rebuild the order in Ferelden.
If the cure they gave to her allowed her to give birth more easly?

[Hanako Ikezawa]

It doesn't seem to be a bad idea to seduce the king of the same nation that exiled them with a Gw lover in order to try to rebuild the order in Ferelden.
If the cure they gave to her allowed her to give birth more easly?

Except she wasn't a Grey Warden. After she was cured of the taint, she was kicked out of the order.

 

The Grey Wardens gain nothing by curing Fiona of the taint.

[Abyss108]

It doesn't seem to be a bad idea to seduce the king of the same nation that exiled them with a Gw lover in order to try to rebuild the order in Ferelden.
If the cure they gave to her allowed her to give birth more easly?

 

Except they didn't need to kick her out for that. They were already lovers. Kicking out the kings lover probably isn't going to make either of them happy. This only hurts their cause.

 

There's nothing to suggest it would help with the birth. Gray Wardens aren't even supposed to be able to become pregnant, so it suggests that whatever happened, happened before this point.

[Aren]

Except she wasn't a Grey Warden. After she was cured of the taint, she was kicked out of the order.

The Grey Wardens gain nothing by curing Fiona of the taint.

It they knew about her pregnacy and gave her the cure to allow her to gave birth to the child more easly even if they had personally nothing to gain in the matter.
There could be plenty of reasons, but i don't think she was cured by accident or luck.
I seriously doubt that after all this time the GW are around they don't have already the cure in their hands.

[Beerfish]

Could a warden fake it?  Can one warden tell that others are not real wardens?  Perhaps she never was a warden but just hung out with the wardens enough that they assumed she was one?

 

(I of course am not thinking clearly and am just rambling becasue I can't remember all that much about Fionas story life in it's entirety .)

[Aren]

Except they didn't need to kick her out for that. They were already lovers.

Fiona said why the wardens kick her out, it was because many members of the order didn't like the fact that she was the only one free of the burden of the taint.
I'm not saying that all the GW of Anderfel have the cure, but i believe that some of them (Chamberlain, First warden ) has it and they have no interest in sharing it with everyone, but maybe for one reason or the other they decided to give it to Fiona.

[Abyss108]

It they knew about her pregnacy and gave her the cure to allow her to gave birth to the child more easly even if they had personally nothing to gain in the matter.
There could be plenty of reasons, but i don't think she was cured by accident or luck.
I seriously doubt that after all this time the GW are around they don't have already the cure in their hands.

 

Wardens slaughter entire towns of people, including children and babies, to protect people from the blight. I doubt they will get all sentimental about one baby now.

[Aren]

Wardens slaughter entire towns of people, including children and babies, to protect people from the blight. I doubt they will get all sentimental about one baby now.

But that baby was a royal bastard one....and even if it wasn't for any political interest not every GW have to think like that.

[Gold Dragon]

Fiona was cured of the blight to total immunity.  After her pregnancy, she was forced thru the Joining again, but it failed.  Hence, she was kicked from the order.

 

Baby Alistair had nothing to do with her being kicked out (She tells you this in Skyhold).

[Mykel54]

^ this, according to her she cannot be tainted now. Still curious how in the dark future she was being eaten alive by red lyrium.

[Knight of Dane]

^ this, according to her she cannot be tainted now. Still curious how in the dark future she was being eaten alive by red lyrium.

Because Corypheus commands the blight in the same way the Arcitect does?

 

If the Arcitect can accidentally undo someone's taint and make them immune then it wouldn't be much of a stretch to suggest that Cory could intentionally reverse it.

[Aren]

Fiona was cured of the blight to total immunity.  After her pregnancy, she was forced thru the Joining again, but it failed.  Hence, she was kicked from the order.

 

Baby Alistair had nothing to do with her being kicked out (She tells you this in Skyhold).

This is way i believe that she was not cured by accident,because she not only was cured from the taint but now is even immune to the joining.

I don't trust the GW and i beleive that some of their members already have a means to remove the effect of the joining..

[Knight of Dane]

It wouldn't make sense for them to have those means and not use them. They could literally recruit half of Thedas during blights and then cure them again after. It wouldn't make sense for them to have that option and not use it.

[Aren]

It wouldn't make sense for them to have those means and not use them. They could literally recruit half of Thedas during blights and then cure them again after. It wouldn't make sense for them to have that option and not use it.

The joining is potentially lethal so there is always the risk but that's not even the point,after one get cured the same way Fiona did is apparently unable to do the joining againg.

The GW don't just want ot save world from the blights they want the monopoly over it,and what better way to have your army forever at disposal until death?

[Knight of Dane]

 

The joining is potentially lethal so there is always the risk but that's not even the point,after one get cured the same way Fiona did is apparently unable to do the joining againg.

The GW don't just want ot save world from the blights they want the monopoly over it,and what better way to have your army forever at disposal until death?

 

A case study of one single subject is barely anything to hold a theory up for. If the Grey Wardens just wanted a big effective army then they would simply use blood magic. I think you just have to face that your "theory" presently is very bad.