Ok I'm enjoying this rather well. Firstly I love shooting toasters as much as anyone else, if not more. But come on, you gotta admit them suit rats ain't got much on the geth much less all the other council races. Let's look at it in general shall we. The quarians are generally considered to be the tramps of the ME universe, not having a home of their own, widely seen as thieves and scavengers and generally looked down on by the rest of the galaxy. They are also not even a part of the council races. They also didn't have the balls to recolonize another planet against the wishes of the council. Instead they pussied out and recalled the initial colonists they sent to the planet and were confined to their ships for 300 or so years. Another i factor is their ****** poor immunity, hell they can even "Let's Bang Ok" without first taking a heavy dose of antibiotics and possibly soup! Lets not forget they have to carry their wates in their suits and if thats not a shitty state of affairs, I dunno what is!
They are simple hive minded machine servants (not slaves, that implies that they actually deserve to be called a people or something), so congratulations on calling it like it is there.
That we underestimated our own creations initially just means that not even we truly know how brilliant we are and what wonders of technology we are capable of.

No just no...That's not brilliance, that's just sad! In your own words you people got your collective asses kicked by these simple minded toasters despite having the surprise factor and readiness advantage over them. That's just military incompetence! Also while the geth may have been used for small scale military applications, they were always under the guidance of their quarian masters and had never fough an actual war of such scale by themselves. That too without preparation. If the quarians were any good they'd have blitzkrieged through the geth when they were in their self discovery process but nope they botched it on a planetary level.
As noted before, taking a billion casualties to Pyrrically defeat a numerically, vastly smaller force isn't really an asskicking. That's why in the movie 300 we root for the Spartans instead of the Persians even though the latter eventually "wins" solely by virtue of having 10x as many guys and getting most of them killed. So the geth can build a lot of platforms? Such skill. Very amaze. USSR "won" the Winter War too, but everyone agrees that losing half a million guys and gals against a couple thousand Finns means that you are the one who got rekt.
According to the wiki, they quarians took casualties numbering in the billions as well, lost their homeworld and had to scram with whatever scrap they could get their hands on. Due you expect the geth to not follow the approach they took just because it is less "muh honoroabu". Please this is war we're talking about, it was a perfectly viable strategy for the geth since they are essentially a software hive collective and could afford to do it.
The way you're presenting it, the geth apparently had great difficulty in defeating the quarians when in reality, the quarians had difficulty in just staying alive and not getting wiped out much less winning the war! Besides I think the geth more than easily made up for their losses after the battle whereas the quarians were still affected by it 300 years after the war!
Also you can't really compare "300" or something like the winter war or tas another example the US Iraqi invasion because these are conventional military conflicts where as the geth are simply different in their strategy. It doesn't matter to the geth because that is the very goal the geth are aiming for which is victory irrespective of numbers since to them platforms are expendable due to large scale availability. This is different to conventional war since there I assume they are aiming for a victory with the least amount of casualties possible since soldiers are not an expendible commodity.
Also we are rooting for the 300 spartans because Zach Snyder took the side of the spartans and portrayed them in that light. Your sympathies would have been different had he focused on the persians which is evident in the sequel where I'm sure quite a lot of the viewers changed sides because of Eva Green alone! The movie could have quite as easily been about the noble persians being impeded by the barbaric spartans who show no honor by killing their messengers and are a cowardly bunch of primitives in leather underwear who fight huddled along the base of a narrow valley rather that facing the persian army on plane ground. It's just a matter of perspective m9.
So the geth are also mentally incompetent weaklings too afraid to finish a foe when they gain the advantage? Why would I want help from something like that? Anyway, their mistake. We'll be back for our planet toasters.
It's in no way an assumption. The geth admit this themselves. Direct quotes
Shepard: "Why did the geth choose to join the Reapers?"
Legion/VI: "The creators attacked, the geth wished to live. The old machines extended an offer"
That "offer" being to become the Reapers slaves in return for the Reapers stopping the beatdown the quarians were inflicting upon the pathetic toasters (seriously, you've got billions of platforms and 17 million space gypsies are kicking your ass?). Legion pretty much admits the decision was made out of fear if Shep asks. Admiral Xen developed a superweapon that makes the geth utterly powerless, and the quarians erase so many of them from existence that the geth's networked intellgence is reduced. They're quite literally beaten stupid.
What happened 300 years in the past is irrelevant, the quarians are superior by the time of ME3. Britain invaded the US and beat them so silly they burned down the White House 200 years ago. They probably could have had the Colonies sipping tea and eating crumpets yet again had they decided they wanted to. I doubt it would go that way today.
If the toasters don't wanna fight, maybe they should GTFO and stop squatting on our planet? That's like Hitler invading and occupying Russia then crying about it when they come back and kick his аss.
No mate, the geth didn't finish off the quarians because they felt sympathy for them and were too soft to wipe them out. Rather its because they considered them to be harmless incompetent boshtets who couldn't even realize their own mistakes. You can imagine how pathetic the quarian situation was for the geth to consider them nonthreatening. It's like punching a boxer once he's down, there's no need to do it, they're already beat!
Also during the time of the reaper invasion, the geth were not just fighting the quarians but almost all the other organic races largely due to being sided by the reapers. And what's wrong with accepting the reaper code if it makes them stronger? Shepard himself does something similar to this at the end of the game in one path. I'm quite sure the quarians would've done the same were they in the same situation. Legion admits to fear of the geth wiping out but that's just the non heretic geth who are targeted same as the heretics. Legion aconsiders the heretics to be separate from the true geth who are a minority and so that is why he fears for their existance.
Also after the destruction of the reaper on rannoch and once the geth have control over themselves, allowing the quarians are only able to destroy the geth after space jesus disrupting the reaper code activation and so exponentially weakening the geth.
Also the hitler referance made me laugh! The difference here is that the geth were made by the quarians on Rannoch. They were not an alien invasion but a construct of the quarians themselves. In fact the quarians are more similar to hitler for the fact that they're the ones doing all the attacking and are prosecuting the geth merely because they exist. But unfortuantely or otherwise they don't have the bark behind their bite to actually wipe out the geth. Besides I think the quarians were mostly busy getting their ass kicked instead of doing much of the kicking!
Yes they do. Add the maximum numbers for the 3 seperate quarian fleets from the post I direct to Derperus above. Heavy Fleet has 280 and the other two 250 each, so you you get 780 maximum. It isn't "easily pulverized" by the geth. It can only lose if you betray the quarians by not telling them about the geth getting Reaper tech again (which is a stupid decision to allow), after they've destroyed the Reaper and already broken cover to attack. In this case the codex describes afterword that the geth "win" because the Reaper upgrade makes them "smart" enough to go after the civilian ships instead of An-heroing themselves against the military ones (babykilling cowards the lot of them, too afraid to go up against us in a straight fight). If you don't get on board with the Reaper upgrade, the quarians blast the toasters virtual аssses into actual dust because we're naturally superior and don't need Reaper garbage to beat some stupid robots.
I never denied that the quarian fleet had less than 780 war assets. If you read my earlier post, you can see that I'm saying that the Alliance fleet is better than the scrap museum of a fleet the quarians have. From the link the Systems Aliiance has a fleet strength of 758 not including the crucible. If you include the crucible which is a vital part of the Alliance arsenal against the reapers, its not even close. Also as I'd already mentioned the Alliance is more military grade and of higher grade than the recycled armada of the geth. As to quarian efficiency, remember Tali's mission in ME2 where a bunch of recycled geth take over the Alerai, which is one of their bigger and more important ships? And space jesus had to appear to save the quarians from that screw up. That's not saying much for the efficiency of the fleet either!
Also in your own words you could only compete against the geth, paltry as it was, because they were much simpler without the reaper code. Once the geth had the reaper code and attained a basic level of sentient intelligence akin to normal organics, you lost. Oh that's right, they targeted you civilian ships! Well too bad, and here you were complaining about the geth not having the balls to finish you off earlier. Well that's exactly what they did, no point calling them cowards when its your fault for not covering your asses and protecting your civvies instead of leaving them open like you did! Also needing antibiotics just coz you got a papercut is hardly a definition for natural superiority!
Look QMR, you're a great player but this is just where you and I disagree. I'm awaiting you fiery response. Come get some. 