The point is not that the MC can perform feats of magic but rather that magic itself finds it's way to work with the MC.
Case in point, the Inquisitor, regardless of being a mage or not, got mastery over Fade Rifts due to Solas true magic being transplanted into his/her hand and to match Solas the next MC will inevitably need an overwhelming amount of magic power at his/her disposal.
This can happen through two ways:
1- The next MC is a hedge mage whose unique untamed magic can interact with ancient Elven artifacts and screw up with Solas plans.
2- The next MC is Inquisitor 2.0 who gets his mojo from interrupting Solas magic ritual entirely by chance.
The first option gives way for an MC which is unique to all of Thedas in his/her own right like a true choosen one for all subsequent games, the second basically makes retiring the Inquisitor and severing his hand a blatant cop-out for having made the previous protagonist too powerful to remain on the front.
So to beat Solas we need a protagonist who randomly has the power to take him on at the expense of lore and story? No. I think the writers can come up with something better than Inquisitor 2.0. Even if they did go down that road mutilating the lore surrounding Hedge Magic is not the way. That said I do think the DA4 protagonist will have unique abilities. Not random but something that has been brewing for a while. Even still they shouldn't be able to take Solas on one on one and even in a group. He is an ancient God after all. Even IF he is defeated by force it should be done in a smart tactical way, not through blunt force.
Again, I admit that I'm not incredibly well versed in this issue. However, what I have read and heard stated about the subject seems to indicate that arcanist derangement is about more than a lack of discipline. If it were as simple as that then there would not logically be any reason that a hedge mage would not be able to develop normal spellcasting practices.
I also didn't get the impression that all hedge mages belong to specific traditions. I suppose that traditions such as Avvar shamanism would fall under the distinction of hedge magic (though I wouldn't be inclined to believe that if it weren't stated), but what I've read seems to indicate that hedge mages can manifest their abilities without any specific training. They may develop their own methodologies for employing their gifts, but I'd be more likely to believe that most of them would be more akin to solitary practitioners who don't belong to a formal tradition than someone who actively participates in Wicca or, like, the Golden Dawn.
The way that hedge magic is discussed in the Apostate codex entry makes it seem like the term "hedge mage" can be applied to any mage who practices magic in a way different than the one taught at a Circle. I doubt that's all it takes to be labeled a hedge mage, since groups like Dalish mages would then fall under that description. It leaves out any mention of arcanist derangement, which seems to be a key element of what separates a true hedge mage from a mage who just hasn't been trained.
On a side note, I wonder if all this means that Avvar mages and Chasind witches would then be unable to employ traditional spellcasting as practiced by Circle Mages, or if they're referred to as hedge mages more as a colloquialism than a strict academic term. I'm inclined to believe the latter, but not for any specific reason.
As I stated in an earlier post, there Hedge Mage as an insult and then Hedge Mage as a condition. Avvar and Rivaini Mages are derided as Hedge Mages, the insult, because they do not follow "traditional" Circle teachings. This is all part of the Chantry's dogma and their crusade to control Magic. Avvar, Chasind and Rivaini Mages do not suffer from Arcanist Derangement and are trained.
In fact, their methods and teachings predate the Chanty and Circle and as we see in The Jaws of Hakkon their unrestricted exploration of Magical Forces over their history has made them and their societies safer from threats like Demons as opposed to Circle Mages who are forbidden from such research. And we know that they are capable of learning Circle taught Spells and vice versa as Morrigan, a "hedge mage" can teach the Circle taught Mage Warden Shapeshifting and a Mage Inquisitor can learn Fade Magic as Solas does.
You are right that in the case of the Avvar and Rivaini Mages that the term is colloquial but in the case of Mages such as the Sarrebas who lack training it is academic.





Retour en haut







