Well, great. Now I have to go read it if you got into all that.
[edit]
Well, that whole thing was disturbing. But that is one of the reasons I never comment on Dorian anymore in relation to these issues; that is, trying to convince people of a certain point. I've done it over and over again since the game was released and I don't have the patience to do so anymore.
But I applaud everyone in the thread who tried.
I will say one thing though, in relation to vbibbi's recent remark (no, I don't consider this to be 'calling the person out' or anything, simply referential),
On the Dorian personal quest, it's not even necessarily that I see it as homophobic in a setting where it's unnecessary, it's that it feels like it wasn't designed for gay players to have a romance suited for them, but as a gay proxy for straight players. I'm sure the writers didn't mean it that way and Gaider would fight tooth and nail against this characterization, but the message feels worn out and repetitive to someone who is gay and has lived similar experiences or seen lots of gay films with the same content.
His message seems to resonate better with people who haven't lived that experience or are familiar with the story in their own lives. And I'm slightly resentful that such a big deal was made over the first official gay male companion when he's a tired trope rather than a person who happens to be gay.
While I do understand it, I think it is an unfortunate view, one that seems largely due to the fact that the gay players who liked the character's representation, his story, and felt that it spoke to them on a personal level, don't actually post on the boards anymore. I know of at least two gay men in the Dorian thread who just faded away from posting. David Gaider also remarked about the various positive messages he got from gay players.
So while I get the point vbibbi is trying to make, it should also be stated that queer people don't have some sort of hive mind and all like the same thing, even down to the representation of queer people in entertainment.
As a straight person, I suppose my opinion doesn't matter in this case, but that is how I feel nonetheless.
Of course, I do agree 100% with, "And I'm slightly resentful that such a big deal was made over the first official gay male companion when he's a tired trope rather than a person who happens to be gay." Even though I adore the character, his story is not something I expected from Dragon Age (as in, its inclusion was surprising), and do generally think that the best types of representation are people who happen to be whatever thing. "Othering" is bad and can ultimately defeat the purpose of representation in the first place.
But in the end, I do hope that Bioware continues with their trend of representation, for both followers in general and with the romances, and I think the games will ultimately be better for them.
Modifié par nightscrawl, 10 mars 2016 - 11:18 .