I prefer physical copies to digital. It's just this odd thing I have. I feel like I'm buying air with digital and that if somehow I don't have the disk as back-up, something might happen that prevents me from getting the game back if I only own it digitally. Like they accidentally delete my account or something. I know, it's weird and paranoid. But that's just how I feel. So the only reason I pre-order, if I will do that, is so I can get the physical copy as fast as I can.
Although, there have been instances where it was in reverse. I pre-ordered DA2 but the company I ordered it from didn't send them out until launch day. So it came too late. Which was very unfortunate since I had the day off on launch day but not the two days after that. And I -didn't- pre-order ME3, however the store I bought it at were already selling them before EU-release.
I would personally rather have a game online if I knew I would play it often, so I don't need to worry about losing the disks or them breaking or taking up space (not that I buy a lot of games anyway). Though if it's a game I know I won't keep or replay, physical copy is better since I can sell it back to Gamestop.
But I have no interest in the trinkets included in collector's editions. Especially after hearing how poorly managed DAI's were, with missing or broken pieces and shoddy craftsmanship and materials. It seems like too much of a gamble rather than waiting for product reviews.
I think my biggest issue is that I don't want to purchase a product whose quality is unknown at time of purchase and hope for the best, if I'm paying at least $60. Why do that and deal with bugs when I can wait until patches come out and the price lowers? Or be really patient and wait for a GotY edition, since that's really the best value.