12 replies to this topic

[Gilli]

I made these lists because I like to upgrade my Potions/Grenades/Tonics all at once.
 
Complete List for Potions/Tonic/Grenade Herbs:

Spoiler

• Amrita Vein: 30
• Arbor Blessing: 108
• Black Lotus: 3
• Blood Lotus: 258
• Crystal Grace: 5
• Dawn Lotus: 6
• Deathroot: 119
• Deep Mushroom: 146
• Dragonthorn: 7
• Elfroot: 137
• Embrium: 205
• Felandaris: 16
• Ghoul’s Beard: 10
• Prophet’s Laurel: 11
• Rashvine: 149
• Rashvine Nettle: 18
• Royal Elfroot: 3
• Spindleweed: 60
• Vandal Aria: 107
• Whiterstalk: 9

 

Breakdown

 

Potions: 

Spoiler

• Amrita Vein: 6
• Arbor Blessing: 54
• Black Lotus: 1
• Dawn Lotus: 1
• Deathroot: 22
• Deep Mushroom: 22
• Elfroot: 83
• Embrium: 83
• Prophet's Laurel: 9
• Rashvine: 22
• Rashvine Nettle: 4
• Royal Elfroot: 2

 

Tonics:

Spoiler

• Amrita Vein: 24
• Arbor Blessing: 40
• Blood Lotus: 46
• Crystal Grace: 3
• Dawn Lotus: 2
• Deathroot: 39
• Deep Mushroom: 70
• Dragonthorn: 3
• Elfroot: 54
• Embrium: 55
• Felandaris: 4
• Rashvine: 70
• Rashvine Nettle: 14
• Spindleweed: 40
• Vandal Aria: 20
• Witherstalk: 5

 

Grenades:

Spoiler

• Arbor Blessing: 14
• Black Lotus: 1
• Blood Lotus: 212
• Crystal Grace: 2
• Dawn Lotus: 3
• Deathroot: 42
• Deep Mushroom: 54
• Dragonthorn: 4
• Embrium: 67
• Felandaris: 12
• Ghoul's Beard: 10
• Prophet's Laurel: 2
• Rashvine: 67
• Royal Elfroot: 1
• Spindleweed: 20
• Vandal Aria: 97
• Witherstalk: 4

 

Complete List for Fetch Quest Items:

Spoiler

• Blood Lotus: 1
• Canine Leather: 10
• Crystal Grace: 12
• Elfroot: 20
• Felandaris: 1
• Greater Bear Pelt: 3
• Iron: 5
• Ram Meat: 10
• Royal Elfroot: 1
• Spindleweed: 12

 

Quest Breakdown:

Spoiler

A Well-Stocked Camp: (Sub-quest of By the Grace of the Dalish (Exalted Plains))

• Canine Leather: 10
• Elfroot: 10
• Greater Bear Pelt: 3
• Iron: 5
• Spindleweed: 5

The Tiniest Cave: (Emerald Graves)

• Crystal Grace: 10

Note: May not start if you have more than 10 Crystal Graces in your inventory. Best approach the cave with 9, let the man say "Not enough, not enough" and then grab the Crystal Grace near the cliff where you finish the Motherly Encouragement quest.
 
A Spirit in the Lake: (Hinterlands)

• Blood Lotus: 1

Elven Healer: (Sub-quests of A Healing Hand (Hinterlands))
 
A Common Treatment: 

• Elfroot: 4
• Spindleweed: 2

An Advanced Treatment:

• Elfroot: 6
• Royal Elfroot: 1

A Rare Treatment:

• Crystal Grace: 2
• Spindleweed: 5

Hunger Pangs: (Hinterlands)

• Ram Meat: 10

Note: Only start dropping once the quest has been started. Haven Rams also drop Ram Meat.
 
Letter from a Lover: (Hinterlands)

• Felandaris: 1

 

Haven & Skyhold Requisition Items:

Spoiler

• Blood Lotus: 35
• Elfroot: 60
• Iron: 5
• Logging Stands: 7
• Quarries: 5
• Spindleweed: 30
• Spirit Essence: 3

Note: I did not include Items for repeatable Requisitions.

 

Special cases: (these are "Fetch Quests" but the needed items need to be crafted at the Requisition Table)

Spoiler

 

Mercy Crest Amulet: (Cleaning House (Storm Coast))

• Deepstalker Hide: 1
• Serpentstone: 2

An Offering for the Arena: (Hakkon’s Trials (Jaws of Hakkon))

• Everite: 2
• Silverite: 2

Book-Binding: (They Came From Somewhere Else (Jaws of Hakkon))

• Mysteries of the Frostback Basin: 4
• Nugskin: 1

How to get Mark's Mangled Mace:

• Sad Weapon Schematic - found in a random pile of dung in the Exalted Plains near Ville Montevelan. The pile of dung will have a [Loot] sign over it.
• Sad Splinter: 3 - You get Sad Splinters by destroying the doors of Caer Bronach, Griffon Wing Keep and Suledin Keep. 
  Important: You only get the Splinters by destroying the doors yourself, so be careful and don't enter Griffon Wing Keep through the Old Well. (only applies for capturing the Keep, after you claimed it you can enter Griffon Wing Keep through the Well as often as you want)

Like the other Special Cases, this Weapon needs to be crafted at the Requisitions Table. Mark's Mangled Mace can be used by any S&S warrior who has reached Lvl 12. 

 

If you think I might have forgotten some Fetch Quest Items tell me and I'll add them.

(this doesn't count for items that don't appear in your inventory, like the Flower for Senna, supplies/signs of Dragons for Frederic etc...)

 

Common Herbs:

Spoiler

 

Tier 1: 

• Blood Lotus
• Elfroot
• Spindleweed

Tier 2:

• Deathroot
• Deepmushroom
• Embrium
• Rashvine

Tier 3:

• Arbor Blessing
• Vandal Aria

Rare Herbs:

Spoiler

 

Tier 1:

• Black Lotus
• Crystal Grace
• Dawn Lotus
• Dragonthorn
• Royal Elfroot
• Witherstalk

Tier 2:

• Ghoul's Beard
• Prophet's Laurel
• Rashvine Nettle

Tier 3:

• Amrita Vein
• Felandaris

 

Edit: Now with Herb Tier List: (thought about adding T1-T3 to the Herbs above but that would look too confusing)

 

Edit 2: Added how to get Mark's Mangled Mace in the Special Cases section

Edited by Gilli, 21 July 2016 - 04:15 PM.

[PapaCharlie9]

Beautiful! Wish I had this every single playthrough. Thanks so much!

EDIT: Could you do me a huge favor and sort the lists alphetically? Will make it easier to look up herbs by name.

[Gilli]

Beautiful! Wish I had this every single playthrough. Thanks so much!

EDIT: Could you do me a huge favor and sort the lists alphetically? Will make it easier to look up herbs by name.

 

Thanks You're welcome

 

Oh, sure, till now it was sorted by Herb Tiers and which you need first in a potion etc.

[PapaCharlie9]

Thanks You're welcome
 
Oh, sure, till now it was sorted by Herb Tiers and which you need first in a potion etc.

Hmm, that's a good point. Both are useful. Maybe make some kind of notation for T2 and T3 herbs? Like ** for T2 and *** for T3? Or bolding? I dunno.

And I'm not demanding or high maintenance at all. No, not at all.

[Gilli]

Hmm, that's a good point. Both are useful. Maybe make some kind of notation for T2 and T3 herbs? Like ** for T2 and *** for T3? Or bolding? I dunno.

And I'm not demanding or high maintenance at all. No, not at all.

 

Hmmm, why not?

 

Hey, I like editing and having everything clearly arranged

[Gilli]

OP updated: Everything's now alphabetical and I added Herb Tier Lists

[Dabrikishaw]

Great organization.

[PapaCharlie9]

THANK YOU, Gilli-chan!   
 
Bookmarked it. It is now in good company with http://forum.bioware...echanics/page-1 and http://forum.bioware...pgrade-toggles/

I also gave it a plug on /r/dragonage.

[Gilli]

THANK YOU!   

 

Welcome

[PapaCharlie9]

Here's where I first find each herb. There are many places to get them, but I'm usually interested in the earliest possible access.

 

Common

 

Tier 1: 

• Blood Lotus - Hinterlands, can be bought at Crossroads Merchant
• Elfroot - Haven, can be bought at Crossroads Merchant
• Spindleweed - Hinterlands/Redcliffe Village, can be bought at Crossroads Merchant

Tier 2:

• Deathroot - Western Approach
• Deepmushroom - Western Approach/Forbidden Oasis
• Embrium - Hinterlands/Crestwood, Crestwood Village merchant
• Rashvine - EdL/Exalted Plains, Crestwood Village merchant

Tier 3:

• Arbor Blessing - EdL/Emerald Graves, note: not sold by main-game merchants
• Vandal Aria - Western Approach Coracavus/Hissing Wastes, note: not sold by main-game merchants

 

Rare

 

Tier 1:

• Black Lotus - Storm Coast
• Crystal Grace - Hinterlands
• Dawn Lotus - Fallow Mire
• Dragonthorn - Forbidden Oasis
• Royal Elfroot - Hinterlands (house near first camp, Valammar, Dusklight Camp dragonling area)
• Witherstalk - Forbidden Oasis

Tier 2:

• Ghoul's Beard - Western Approach
• Prophet's Laurel - Storm Coast (NW of Driftwood Margin Camp, Lyrium Falls)/Emerald Graves
• Rashvine Nettle - EdL/Emerald Graves near Chateau d'Onterre

Tier 3:

• Amrita Vein - Westeran Approach (one near Shimmerstone Mine, SE of Nazaire's Pass camp)
• Felandaris - EdL (N of Elfsblood Tower)

[Gilli]

I just had a thought: Should I add how you can get Mark's Mangled Mace?

 

It is an unusual fetch quest, so I'd probably add it to the Special Cases, IF I add it.

 

What do you think?

[PapaCharlie9]

I just had a thought: Should I add how you can get Mark's Mangled Mace?
 
It is an unusual fetch quest, so I'd probably add it to the Special Cases, IF I add it.
 
What do you think?

Sure! No need to even ask, just put whatever you think would be worth noting.

[Gilli]

OP Updated: Added how to get Mark's Mangled Mace