Given that Velanna can be persuaded to change her mind about humans (she can defend a human village, alone, against a horde of darkspawn), I don't think she would necessarily buy into Solas' genocidal plans.
I doubt Solas would present his plans as such. He would likely promise her only that the ancient world of the elves would return, and omit the part about how even her own fellow modern elves will die in the raw chaos.
I also don't think Lanaya would ever serve Solas; wanting an independent, autonomous kingdom isn't the same as wanting to destroy all of humanity, after all. The fact that Solas is Fen'Harel seems like a strong deterrent for many Dalish to ever agree to side with, even the ones who follow the Forgotten Ones (the ones with crimson vallaslin).
Maybe. Depends on their current conditions, I would say. Some might want a change so badly that they throw caution to the wind. Sometimes... change is what sets them free. Some might also forsake the Dalish legends as false if Solas can demonstrate special powers or provide evidence condemning the evanuris.
I wholeheartedly agree. Merrill's research into Eluvian lore was pretty much dropped, and that's unfortunate.
Thanks. I think BioWare should also consider the fact that some players romanced Merrill. So having her show up again should be pretty important. Fenris too, I suppose, with Tevinter and all.
Okay, I'll give you the bit about Solas. But Mythal could very well have plans for whoever she controls through the Well, assuming she still exists as a force independent from Solas. The thing where there haven't been whispers from the Well could be because the time hasn't come for the Inquisitor/Morrigan to act yet. (According to Mythal, anyway.)
I'm sure Mythal does exist. The spirit that floated out of the Well and into the eluvian was probably her spirit. As for the knowledge of the Well, I'm wondering why the Inquisitor can't even ask questions or at least have it stated that the Well won't answer questions about Solas. If Mythal wants Solas to continue, then yeah, she won't let the Inquisitor know how to stop him. But I think this is because Solas' plans and Mythal's are consistent for now. My main issue with the Well is that you can't use it to ask about the titans, not even the veilfire rune on the titan mural, nor can you consult with it during the conversation with Solas or the spirits in the Vir Dirthara to verify any of it.
I'm not sure they plan to add anything to the Keep, and I really doubt they'll add Velanna. Planning Solas's part in Inquisition (which they were doing around when they wrote the Keep) means planning the basic outline for DA4. So if they didn't add it then I don't think they're going to for DA4, and DA4 is the logical time for Velanna to re-emerge.
But yeah, theoretically they can add anything to the Keep. So maybe it's too early to write off any plot line as abandoned unless the logical time for it to come back has past.
Agreed.
I'm not sure about the Anvil of the Void being relevant enough that it's surprising it didn't come up. Unless Branka's working overtime to produce golems you wouldn't expect them to be so common that they come up in Descent, and there's no other time when they logically would.
Well I was thinking more along the lines of Valta referencing the Anvil or Shale at least. Both seem relevant to the theory on titans.
How do we know that having a Warden body and being in Southern Thedas is enough? As far as I know we don't know how the spell is targeted. It could be that anyone who's taken the Joining and is in Southern Thedas is targeted, or it could be that Nightmare has to target every Warden individually, or it could be that Nightmare targets Warden compounds and that any Warden not in those compounds isn't effected. Warden!Alistair would hear it in all of those cases, and King!Alistair would only hear it in one of them.
From what I remember, the Warden contact states that all Wardens in the south began hearing the Calling. So it seemed to me like Cory taught the Nightmare how to mimic the Calling, and then showed it how to send that telepathic message out to those who would hear it. I think the Hero was simply out of range, but Alistair wouldn't be.
Cole mentions that the two Wardens who helped that elf girl in Crestwood, the ones looking for the Warden contact, were still themselves. So maybe that means those two didn't hear the false Calling for some reason. Maybe they were new recruits. In that case it likely worked based on how far along the taint was in the Warden's body. Just like how the Hero couldn't hear the voices or sense darkspawn soon after the Joining.
I don't remember having the option to send the letter to the HoF before handling Adamant Fortress, which would mean that the Inquisitor would think to specifically ask the HoF if they're hearing a Calling.
Well, if the Hero romanced Alistair then you get the Contact Hero of Ferelden chore table quest from him at Skyhold before Adamant. But that's neither here nor there. My only point was that the Hero had the good sense to include that bit of information in the reply letter. Corypheus and his influence doesn't reach the Hero, wherever the Hero is. So that at least lets the Inquisitor know there is or was a range to it. Doesn't really matter after Adamant when you already know the truth, but the point is that the Hero shares important information with the Inquisitor, so a king Alistair should have as well. As it stands, it just seems like BioWare forgot that even a king Alistair is still tainted.
Though it could be the continuation of the plot that Alistair is an unthinking moron.
Meanwhile all interactions with King Alistair can be over with before that happens. And I'm not sure why you think King Alistair's first priority would be to volunteer this information to the Inquisition. Even if he is hearing it (which as I've stated is questionable) it seems like you'd pick and choose who you'd let in on something like this very carefully, weighing whether or not they can be trusted to know as well as whether or not they need to. It seems to me that the Inquisition only really proves itself to point where Alistair should consider trusting them this far by solving the problem, which renders the question moot.
Over with before what happens? Adamant? We can possibly meet Alistair at the end of IHW. We can also have written communication with him regarding Venatori agents in Denerim's court. So if he trusts the Inquisition with that, then why not info regarding the Grey Wardens, especially when the Inquisition's enemy is a darkspawn magister, and the Inquisition is in the process of tracking down the Wardens and why they were disappearing. Seems like Alistair would be one to ask, and if Alistair cares about the Order or just defeating Cory in general, then he would share the fact that he is hearing a Calling before his time.
Again, the Hero had no problem trusting the Inquisitor with this information, and the Hero didn't even meet or benefit from the Inquisitor.
Technically the lack of an heir could get resolved depending on if the Warden finds a cure for being a warden for world states that have Alistair and/or the Warden as ruler. Anora might be able to have children with someone else (since Rowan got her sickness before having Cailan, it could have been him who couldn't have children), Also, it felt like everyone is just planning to have another Landsmeet in the future anyway. I'd feel sorry if Kieran was found out in some world states.
Nope. Anora doesn't have children with the male Cousland either, and we know for a fact that he is capable of getting Morrigan pregnant before the Battle of Denerim. No doubt his effectiveness has diminished in the follow years, but the fact that Anora didn't become pregnant at any point after the wedding proves that she is in fact barren.