Cassandra is a little controversial around these parts. I'd advise anybody who has concerns to express then openly but have an open mind and give uBSN a chance because we have assembled a promissing team of mods and this project is bigger than any one person.
I'm really hesitant to write this post as I don't have a personal vendetta against Cassandra Saturn. After reading her blog, I'm sympathetic and support many of her life struggles. I've spoken about my concerns publicly twice on these forums and once in PM. When I wrote those concerns, I had not seen her blog or read about any of her history with other forums. My concerns don't originate from any of that history but from what I personally witnessed since the forum closure announcement.
What struck me as odd was seeing the poster RealKorra follow Cassandra Saturn around praising her. The posting style was identical and the praise was....oddly personal. I suspected a sock and several other long-term posters made the accusation that RealKorra was an alt for Cassandra. After reading her blog, it's all but confirmed. She states in her blog:
"Cassandra prefers to be called Korra"
http://cassandrasatu...-cassandra.html
That statement coupled with the similarity in posting style (lower case letters, etc) and the odd adulation of Cassandra Saturn all but confirm in my mind that this is Cassandra's alt account used to promote Cassandra. So, here are some of the odd posts made by RealKorra praising Cassandra Saturn that first caught my attention:
"yeah, she's very busy and multi-tasking everything. she'll get the boards up soon she's really great person. made over 90 forums (including her own forums), 30 forum theme samples, doing lot of things for transgender community, communities. all while in college."
https://forum.biowar.../#entry20414760
"yeah, but Cassandra is the best in the world. she knows her stuff. she has done lot for Transgender Community this year
Proboards forum can host over 900 million posts. the policy changes very rarely. "
https://forum.biowar.../#entry20414721
"that's Cassandra's thing here. she is actually doing that with every forum she makes. did you know that she has a game studio called Crossphase Studios, which will go to these "old days" era of making video games, interacting with the community, players etc etc on the forums someday. she hopes to make it happen after she graduates from her college. she has very big plans for future and great good things for us as well. right now, that company doesn't exist.. yet."
https://forum.biowar...2#entry20413034
So, why does it matter that Cassandra Saturn has a sock account that promotes herself? Well, for one, it's manipulative. She's using her alt to give the appearance of false support from 'fans' that she doesn't have. It also calls into question the stability of this person. None of this would even matter if she wasn't setting herself up as the lifeboat for BSN refugees. I think it's great that she's kind enough to provide an alternative and the site looks beautiful. But, I question the long-term viability of the site when the creator is not above manipulating people with socks and appears unstable. From my perspective, the entire point of setting up a new BSN is to keep the community together as much as possible.
What happens if drama sinks that ship and the community further fractures?
Who else is in charge of uBSN?
How much control do the other people in charge actually have over the site?
There are several other sites being built. Before we reach a tipping point of 'joiners' to uBSN that makes it all but inevitable that most will follow, I'd like to see these other sites given a chance. See these threads for alternatives to uBSN:
https://forum.biowar...boration/page-1
https://forum.biowar...ommunityforums/