Aller au contenu

Photo

Which romance of the saga do you think loves more the Protagonist?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
125 réponses à ce sujet

#26
GoldenGail3

GoldenGail3
  • Members
  • 3 778 messages

My love for Cassandra is so great that I support her in what she does. The things she tries to do to make the world a better place is admirable and its okay if we have to break up for her to achieve that... 

 

Plus if she becomes Divine, my inquisitor and her can always have a little free time on the side in her room ;)

My Quizzie had a divine Leliana, so he's a happy fellow right now!  -_- In this way....  :wub:  -_-



#27
Fuyin

Fuyin
  • Members
  • 22 messages

You love your mother the same way you love your cat?


I said LI. You clearly didn't read what I wrote and you just want to troll so I'm going to stop reading here and I'll go have a life. You should try it someday.

#28
Knight of Dane

Knight of Dane
  • Members
  • 7 451 messages

It can be compared and measured, we have Alistair romance in DA:O, that if you want to sacrifice yourself he simply let you do it, and there is Yennefer romance from Witcher 3, she sacrificed herself to resurrect Geralt.

 

No it can't. Willingness to sacrifice yourself for someone else is not dependent on love for the person and it would be a unfair element to use in comparison since other companions don't actually get a chance to offer their sacrifice.

 

Love is as varied as clouds in the sky, there is no correct way to describe how it feels.



#29
PhroXenGold

PhroXenGold
  • Members
  • 1 854 messages

Same with Sera, she breaks up with you if you don't stop being dalish.

 

This is love to you compared to the love of Josephine?

 

If the Inquisitor truly loved Sera, she would be prepared to give up on her "elfiness".



#30
Qun00

Qun00
  • Members
  • 4 371 messages

If the Inquisitor truly loved Sera, she would be prepared to give up on her "elfiness".


That sounds like an unhealthy relationship.
  • Patchwork, Bayonet Hipshot, KumoriYami et 2 autres aiment ceci

#31
Catilina

Catilina
  • Members
  • 2 019 messages

I don't know all romances in DA, but I think for example Anders and Fenris really loves Hawke, and stays with Hawke until the end, if Hawke care for them.



#32
XEternalXDreamsX

XEternalXDreamsX
  • Members
  • 497 messages
It depends on the romance route. Some routes lead to a break up so it's null and void. If you take the best conditions of each, they are fairly even but it would depend on your protagonist's view on romance.

I like Leliana as Divine with HoF with an intact romance, Isabella with Hawke since they may have passed each other since she worked together with the Inquisition. Also, with Hawke surviving Here Lies the Abyss, I am sure they will reunite once he returns to Kirkwall with Varric. The Inquisitor stays in a romance with Cassandra but they keep their duties. Overall, I'm satisfied.

#33
Arshei

Arshei
  • Members
  • 921 messages

I don't know all romances in DA, but I think for example Anders and Fenris really loves Hawke, and stays with Hawke until the end, if Hawke care for them.

 

Sure, Anders loves you that much that he uses you to blow up a chantry, and if you refuse to help him blindly he breaks up with you.

 

And he has no problem in killing you for his "mage freedom" cause, you can't be in love with an Abomination.


  • Dutchess aime ceci

#34
KaiserShep

KaiserShep
  • Members
  • 23 806 messages

If the Inquisitor truly loved Sera, she would be prepared to give up on her "elfiness".


Personally, I think the best route for players seriously rp'ing Dalish that have strong feelings toward retaining these beliefs to come to terms with the idea that it just wouldn't work out.
  • Reznore57, ljos1690 et Beregond5 aiment ceci

#35
vertigomez

vertigomez
  • Members
  • 5 309 messages
Obviously the most loyal relationship in this series is Varric/Hawke.

*cries a single tear*
  • Reznore57, Patchwork, Bayonet Hipshot et 5 autres aiment ceci

#36
Arshei

Arshei
  • Members
  • 921 messages

If the Inquisitor truly loved Sera, she would be prepared to give up on her "elfiness".

 

If Sera truly loved the Inqusitor, she wouldn't break up with her because of religion.

 



#37
TheAtomicSurvivor

TheAtomicSurvivor
  • Members
  • 116 messages

If the Inquisitor truly loved Sera, she would be prepared to give up on her "elfiness".

 

Cassandra ends up loving the Inquisitor, even if he does not believe in Andraste, even if he is an elf, even though he's a mage. Three things she normally would have looked at and judged someone for. So, no. 

 

Sera is being immature.

 

A real relationship, one that's adult, and mature. Is about two people coming together and they don't necessarily have to agree with everything to love each other. That's how relationships work.

 

Fintan doesn't believe in the Maker, but respects Cassandra for his beliefs. And even with a bit more freedom, he supports her. He may not agree with her on every time, but he finds her passion, her aspiration something to admire to. He'd never ask her to change. Just as much Cassandra has never asked him to change. She becomes acceptant that there will be things they disagree on.

 

And if we expand this in real life.

 

That's how real relationships work. I have dated Christian woman before, I am not Christian, nor religious, I'm Aethist. But I never once had someone tell me, that now that we have been dating for IDK 2 months I must give myself to Jesus Christ or else the relationship is over.

 

A healthy mature relationship is one of disagreements, and communication. 

 

As stated earlier, we need to stop trying to achieve the ideal fairy tale romance. Because it doesn't exist. A relationship is hardwork, but is also love. You will hate each other, disagree, from time to time. But you also love each other, and agree. You need communication and responsibility, but there's no magical perfection in a relationship.

 

If you love someone you work towards loving them. But that doesn't mean shedding your values or worth for someone. 


  • ljos1690, roselavellan et Arshei aiment ceci

#38
Catilina

Catilina
  • Members
  • 2 019 messages

Sure, Anders loves you that much that he uses you to blow up a chantry, and if you refuse to help him blindly he breaks up with you.

 

And he has no problem in killing you for his "mage freedom" cause, you can't be in love with an Abomination.

But Hawke betrayed him... not only refused.



#39
Arshei

Arshei
  • Members
  • 921 messages

But Hawke betrayed him...

 

How exactly you betray someone because you don't help him with his terrorist things?



#40
Catilina

Catilina
  • Members
  • 2 019 messages

How exactly you betray someone because you don't help him with his terrorist things?

He does not know what plans Anders. And do not forget: If Hawke in the friendship with Anders, he support mages against templars, against Chatry. Maybe do not want to blow up anything, but I dont think, he betray to Grand Cleric. I have one Hawke (with Fenris, not Anders), who refused him in his last personal quest, but never occurred to me that a pro-mage Hawke able to betray him. Just not helped him in the chantry.
 
Okay, now I loaded my Hawke, who in love with Anders, and tryed this version, but Anders after the that fckn betrayal still in Hawke's mansion, then he don't left Hawke, just was sad and disappointed. 
 
Ergo Hawke, who can betray Anders (and kill him), not Anders, who betray Hawke and left (or kill) him.
 
And Anders can follow Hawke against Mages...


#41
roselavellan

roselavellan
  • Members
  • 475 messages

Of the romances I've experienced (most of the straight male ones, I think - except Blackwall and IB), I would say Fenris. The way he says, "Nothing could be worse than the thought of living without you", I fully believe it.

 

I mean, I wish I could say Solas... but I guess we'll see what DA4 brings.


  • Catilina aime ceci

#42
PhroXenGold

PhroXenGold
  • Members
  • 1 854 messages

Cassandra ends up loving the Inquisitor, even if he does not believe in Andraste, even if he is an elf, even though he's a mage. Three things she normally would have looked at and judged someone for. So, no. 

 

Sera is being immature.

 

A real relationship, one that's adult, and mature. Is about two people coming together and they don't necessarily have to agree with everything to love each other. That's how relationships work.

 

Fintan doesn't believe in the Maker, but respects Cassandra for his beliefs. And even with a bit more freedom, he supports her. He may not agree with her on every time, but he finds her passion, her aspiration something to admire to. He'd never ask her to change. Just as much Cassandra has never asked him to change. She becomes acceptant that there will be things they disagree on.

 

And if we expand this in real life.

 

That's how real relationships work. I have dated Christian woman before, I am not Christian, nor religious, I'm Aethist. But I never once had someone tell me, that now that we have been dating for IDK 2 months I must give myself to Jesus Christ or else the relationship is over.

 

A healthy mature relationship is one of disagreements, and communication. 

 

As stated earlier, we need to stop trying to achieve the ideal fairy tale romance. Because it doesn't exist. A relationship is hardwork, but is also love. You will hate each other, disagree, from time to time. But you also love each other, and agree. You need communication and responsibility, but there's no magical perfection in a relationship.

 

If you love someone you work towards loving them. But that doesn't mean shedding your values or worth for someone. 

 

To be honest, I agree with this in general. Relationships are usually built on a degree of compromise, particularly when it comes to beliefs. My point in the previous post (which I had intended to be read in a somewhat tongue in cheek manner, forgetting of course that people on the internet read things seriously too often) was more that if you criticise Sera for being unwilling to compromise on her beliefs to be in a relationship, then you should likewise criticse an Inquisitor who does likewise. Maybe the relationship wouldn't have worked out, but the breaking up comes from both parties being unwilling to change. Too often is see people complaining about how characters won't change to be what they want, when they themselves are unwilling to change their character to be more like what said NPC wants.



#43
Qun00

Qun00
  • Members
  • 4 371 messages

To be honest, I agree with this in general. Relationships are usually built on a degree of compromise, particularly when it comes to beliefs. My point in the previous post (which I had intended to be read in a somewhat tongue in cheek manner, forgetting of course that people on the internet read things seriously too often) was more that if you criticise Sera for being unwilling to compromise on her beliefs to be in a relationship, then you should likewise criticse an Inquisitor who does likewise. Maybe the relationship wouldn't have worked out, but the breaking up comes from both parties being unwilling to change. Too often is see people complaining about how characters won't change to be what they want, when they themselves are unwilling to change their character to be more like what said NPC wants.


Nobody expects Sera to compromise on her beliefs.

#44
PhroXenGold

PhroXenGold
  • Members
  • 1 854 messages

Nobody expects Sera to compromise on her beliefs.

 

I've seen plenty of people on these forums complain that she doesn't.



#45
Catilina

Catilina
  • Members
  • 2 019 messages

Of the romances I've experienced (most of the straight male ones, I think - except Blackwall and IB), I would say Fenris. The way he says, "Nothing could be worse than the thought of living without you", I fully believe it.

 

I mean, I wish I could say Solas... but I guess we'll see what DA4 brings.

Yes, Fenris is very loyal, one of my favorite (but Fenris and Bull not straight).


  • roselavellan aime ceci

#46
roselavellan

roselavellan
  • Members
  • 475 messages

Yes, Fenris is very loyal, one of my favorite (but Fenris and Bull not straight).

 

Yes, sorry, wasn't referring to their sexuality. I meant, it was a straight relationship in my game (female protag romancing male).



#47
Catilina

Catilina
  • Members
  • 2 019 messages

Yes, sorry, wasn't referring to their sexuality. I meant, it was a straight relationship in my game (female protag romancing male).

Okay, no problem, I see.



#48
TheAtomicSurvivor

TheAtomicSurvivor
  • Members
  • 116 messages

To be honest, I agree with this in general. Relationships are usually built on a degree of compromise, particularly when it comes to beliefs. My point in the previous post (which I had intended to be read in a somewhat tongue in cheek manner, forgetting of course that people on the internet read things seriously too often) was more that if you criticise Sera for being unwilling to compromise on her beliefs to be in a relationship, then you should likewise criticse an Inquisitor who does likewise. Maybe the relationship wouldn't have worked out, but the breaking up comes from both parties being unwilling to change. Too often is see people complaining about how characters won't change to be what they want, when they themselves are unwilling to change their character to be more like what said NPC wants.

 

That's an unrealistic expectation to want your partner to have to change for your point of views. There needs to come a level between both parties to say, "Let's disagree to agree".

 

Because that comes with maturity.

 

It should not be the only expectation that I should be the only one to compromise my beliefs for someone, just as someone should not have to compromise my beliefs for someone. Now the Inquisitor could have compromised their beliefs for Sera, by having a third option

 

"How about I don't bring the topic up when you're around"

 

Which is reasonable, imo. When I was Aethist and dating my Christian girlfriend at the time, we just agreed we wouldn't bring up subjects about God. 



#49
Catilina

Catilina
  • Members
  • 2 019 messages

Strange thing about this love and beliefs. Love can not win everything. It depends on how important someone is, what he believes in, and how important the other the fact that it is against. Religion or other thing: it can kill the love. In game example: Anders and pro-templar Hawke. I cant imagine a long-term love relationship with this setup.



#50
TheAtomicSurvivor

TheAtomicSurvivor
  • Members
  • 116 messages

Strange thing about this love and beliefs. Love can not win everything. It depends on how important someone is, what he believes in, and how important the other the fact that it is against. Religion or other thing: it can kill the love. In game example: Anders and pro-templar Hawke. I cant imagine a long-term love relationship with this setup.

 

I didn't claim that love conquers all. Actually what I am talking about is Respect. In general, all relationships are built upon respect and trust. This is friendship, this is romantic relationships.

 

Love = Respect + Trust

 

Sera does not Respect nor Trust the Inquisitor enough, to not let something like beliefs get in the way of Love