43 réponses à ce sujet

[Incognito JC]

Rewrite or wipe out? Leaning on rewrite. On the down side, the "native" geths might get stronger and rebel in ME3.. What did you do? Advice?

[jpetrey123]

i did a rewrite because maybe they would recognize that we helped them, and help us against the reapers.

[xMrAx]

I choose rewrite, but I played the entire game encouraging peace to both the quarians and legion.

[Bebbe777]

I did the same, rewrote them and hopefully they will recognize this as a show of good faith.

[childofbhaal]

So did I, but I get the feeling I killed some future quarians in the process.

I also have a sneaking suspicion that once the Geth 'build a consensus' on the heretics actions that they may be drawn to their conclusions. But that is just me being paranoid.

[VettoRyouzou]

Issue is the geth.. the normal geth have not attacked anyone ((outside the quarians and they attacked first)) they want to simply understand and evolve by there own hands a very.. odd new light over the geth.

[amrose2]

xMrAx wrote...

I choose rewrite, but I played the entire game encouraging peace to both the quarians and legion.

That's how I went about it too.

[amrose2]

VettoRyouzou wrote...

Issue is the geth.. the normal geth have not attacked anyone ((outside the quarians and they attacked first)) they want to simply understand and evolve by there own hands a very.. odd new light over the geth.

What about the Geth that are supposedly acting on their own in ME1, where you get the data disk for Tali? Supposedly staging an invasion or whatever. Were they heretics also? Or maybe just an oversight in canon?

Modifié par amrose2, 29 janvier 2010 - 03:34 .

[Bebbe777]

VettoRyouzou wrote...

Issue is the geth.. the normal geth have not attacked anyone ((outside the quarians and they attacked first)) they want to simply understand and evolve by there own hands a very.. odd new light over the geth.

Plus they say that they saveguarded the Quarian homeworld and have rebuilt it. In some ways it feels like the true Geth want to be "loved" by their parents, the Quarians. 

[hawat333]

Rewrite.

Legion is a potential ally (maybe a threat needs to be dealt with later) against the Reapers.

And when it comes to saving the galaxy, I'll take every ally I can get. Rachni, enraged korgan hordes, geth, anyone and everyone that can help defeat the force that wipes out civilizations in cycles.

After that, if they become a problem/threat we can deal with them.

[...mortaL]

mhm... rewrite.



seemed to be the most "humane" option, although it could backfire.. you (shepard that is) say something about traumatic effects of re-integrating heretics into the whole geth society.. if they have a society .. could well be that they just come to some sort of understanding without any of the debating humans would have to endure in a similar situation..

[Marco_Alberts]

The whole thing where the memories of the heretics being mingled with the memories of the true geth was what made me decide to blow them up. Can't take any chances that with the two joined they will eventually come to the same conclusion that made the heretics follow the reapers. The fact that Legion even says that the heretics aren't wrong in their conclusion doesn't help.

[Lost Cipher]

I did a rewrite as well, so that way hopefully they will join me in the future (i.e ME3) against the reapers.

[VettoRyouzou]

amrose2 wrote...

VettoRyouzou wrote...

Issue is the geth.. the normal geth have not attacked anyone ((outside the quarians and they attacked first)) they want to simply understand and evolve by there own hands a very.. odd new light over the geth.

What about the Geth that are supposedly acting on their own in ME1, where you get the data disk for Tali? Supposedly staging an invasion or whatever. Were they heretics also? Or maybe just an oversight in canon?

Ya know I asked that EXACT same question Different platforum perhaps ((Geth nations i assume)), mabye we jumped the the gun?

[CrazySockpuppetMan]

I decided to blow the place up. I didn't want to risk these reasonable geth getting influenced by the heretics. There was something in the dialog about "This was the only safe thing to do, they might have come to the same conclusions again". Also, I felt it was a bit more humane (if that even applies).



It will be interesting to see what happens.

[Martukis]

I chose to rewrite, in hopes of peace with the Quarians. As Legion said, whenever the quarians felt they stood a chance at military victory, they would fight. Increasing the geth numbers would make it even harder to think of it as a possible victory. Plus, it seemed more paragon - while they are being rewritten, their will and/or ideas are being assimilated are rethought. Hopefully, Shepard's defeat of their oh-so-mighty Old Machine, Sovereign, would lead them to conclude differently.

 On the other side, I also chose to supress the cure for the genophage (take it with us, but the genophage was still the right choice) with the mentality that Okeer's Legacy is a good idea; fewer krogan, each more powerful, so they could finally build a more modern culture. So hopefully I haven't doomed myself in ME3 to being shortchanged on Krogans and with too many traitorous geth.

Modifié par Martukis, 29 janvier 2010 - 05:37 .

[Promethean 47]

The whole thing where the memories of the heretics being mingled with the memories of the true geth was what made me decide to blow them up. Can't take any chances that with the two joined they will eventually come to the same conclusion that made the heretics follow the reapers. The fact that Legion even says that the heretics aren't wrong in their conclusion doesn't help.

This is a big rational fear. I ultimately decided to rewrite though cause I just don't think Bioware would do that to players. So far they've rewarded paragon actions with positive results (see rachni). So I made the leap of faith again, this time with the heretic geth. We'll see if it pans out.

[Nigawatts]

I chose destroy. If you think of Geth in an organic sense, this is more merciful

[MA5Bergey]

I'm thinking if you rewrite, the geth will stand by you against the Reapers in ME3... but I would love it if for once, the paragon decision had a bad result and they turned against you. I rewrote them btw.

[jpetrey123]

MA5Bergey wrote...

I'm thinking if you rewrite, the geth will stand by you against the Reapers in ME3... but I would love it if for once, the paragon decision had a bad result and they turned against you. I rewrote them btw.

i also think that it would very interesting to see that!!

[Fuzzyrabbit]

I chose to blow them up. Geth can't complete their evolution towards individuality and creative thought if someone takes away their ability to choose. They made their choice, picked their side, and suffered the consequences of their actions. Other Geth will see this, learn from it, and make their own informed decisions.

[Amplias]

Fuzzyrabbit wrote...

I chose to blow them up. Geth can't complete their evolution towards individuality and creative thought if someone takes away their ability to choose. They made their choice, picked their side, and suffered the consequences of their actions. Other Geth will see this, learn from it, and make their own informed decisions.

They didn't choose it, it was a mathmatical error, it says it in the game.

[stillnotking]

My feeling was that we need all the sentient races we can get to fight the Reapers in ME3, so I rewrote them. I see no reason to doubt Legion's claim that once the error is corrected, the heretics will realize that the Reapers brainwashed them and switch sides. That's a pretty big deal if you think about it, because the heretics did all the Reapers' dirty work in ME1.

[JakePT]

This is what drives me nuts about some of the people playing this game. Do what feeks right for your character in the moment. Don't research to find out what the 'best' option is so you get the outcome you want. Make the decisions and live with the consequences, it's a much more satisfying experience in my opinion.

[Wolfie-kun]

I went for what I felt was right and chose to destroy them, I was working on a Renegade character plus that what I may have done in real life anyways.



I'm not sad to see them go, but I dread to think what repercussions I may get in ME3.