172 réponses à ce sujet

[endo689]

Was able to make it through on the first try. Had Tali, go through the tubes and Jacob the other team. Miranda led another and Jacob the return party. Also used Jack, for the biotic shield.  Everyone survived and completed all loyalty missions. Fight against Reaper, was with Miranda and Garrus. Paragon was maxed out.

[CandidCarnage]

In order...

Soldier, Paragon. Garrus romanced. Full team loyal *before* crew abducted. Neglected to check whether Boo was missing. Assumed he was for sake of rage.



Quick mining run for ship upgrades.

Omega 4 relay...

Shep /w Miranda + Grunt (drone invades cargo)

Legion goes in the pipe.

Shep /w Tali + Thane

Jacob leads team 2.

Garrus goes back /w crew.

Jacob leads team 2 (again)

Samara uses Barrier

Shep /w Tali + Thane



No losses. =) Wonder whether there's an element of chance? Hope so. New character going now.

[GodEmperor0956]

I did but lost mordin,Thane,kellly,and chawkas

[DK_DOOM]

I made it through on the first try which I found extremely surprising. Every single cutscene, I expected to see someone die. I was waiting for it, and then it didn't happen, and I felt an odd sense of satisfaction when that No One Left Behind achievement popped up.

[Lethys1]

They made it way too easy for everyone to survive based on how heavily they advertised, ooh he may not come back.

Garrus led the groups both times.
Samara did my barrier.
Legion was my tech expert.
Jacob went back with survivors
When Occulus is in the ship, beat it with Jack and Grunt.
Through the collector base, had Miranda and Thane, with one Miranda and Grunt.

Nobody died at all, everything went well. I am shocked at how people chose Grunt to lead the secondary squad when Garrus is in. Garrus leading the party is basically the most obvious decision in the whole game.

Did anyone choose Miranda to do the barrier? I wonder how that would go.

Modifié par Lethys1, 31 janvier 2010 - 03:00 .

[CandidCarnage]

Oh crap, forgot to say: People have been saying that if you preserve the collector station, then Legion will die unless it went back with the crew. This is *NOT* true. As stated in my post above, everybody including Legion survived my endgame, and I made the decision to keep the station. Garrus went back with the crew.

[ljd121879]

I agree, it is way too easy for everyone to survive...all you have to do is their loyalty missions...and of course not give them a final task they are not suited for....I can only imagine what would happen if Grunt would be chosen for the tech expert....scary...



I have Miranda lead the secondary teams, Samara do the barrier, Tali for Tech, Mordin took the survivors back.



From what I've heard, Miranda doing the barrier causes you to lose...which makes sense, since Samara is the most powerful biotic and can barely make it through. I would imagine Jack is the only other person who can handle the barrier

[Strephon Gentry]

Everyone on my team lived but, I lost Gabby, Kelly and half the crew. The good Doctor survived.



Vanguard, Paragon, Import



Legion = Tunnel Rat

Garrus = Fire Team lead both times

Jack = Shield

Mordin = Escort

Miranda (romanced because Ashley really gave me the old FU on Harmony) and Grunt = My team



Didn't know about the timer or would have left right after the attack...wanted 5/5 on all weapons first..(grumble)

[N30795]

That mission get me paranoid. I expected many of my squadmates to die. It turned out well. :]

[TechnoBeast]

I save everyone including my crew on my first play through, i had all my squadmate loyal except for Zaeed and some of my upgrade not even max.

[ChuckNorris18]

 I just finished my first playthrough and everyone survived.
Just watched the bloodbath video on youtube  and the way everything went down, it was just so sad!
Joker was the only one left on the normandy.

[Virginian]

WIth the exception of Chambers, Rupert, Gabby, Mordin, & half the crew everyone survived my first playthrough.

[camcon2100]

I will replay the game i lost some of the crew and thane.........but for ME3 i will play this one it was heart wrenching and i cried when i lost thane

[ThatDancingTurian]

I made it through with zero casualties on the first try. I had a ton of saves ready just in case, so I was surprised when I didn't need them. Even saved the entire crew.



Man, if my Shep wasn't being worshipped by her crew before, she will be after that.

[SunfighterG8]

Im sorta irritated that they didnt at least guarentee one would die like in ME1...Hell the mission in ME2 was tons more suicidal then ME1...yet you have a chance where nobody dies? WTF.... Why call it a suicidal mission the whole game only to have not even one person drop dead somewhere....crazy...

[DarthRic]

izmirtheastarach wrote...

I am very surprised that so many people actually lost anyone. I found it very easy to keep everyone alive. As long as you actually play through all the content, and make sensible choices about the mission assignments, it's not difficult at all.

Sensible? what was not sensible about having thane go through the vents to open the door? I did this and he dies

[ThatDancingTurian]

DarthRic wrote...
Sensible? what was not sensible about having thane go through the vents to open the door? I did this and he dies

Thane isn't a tech expert. The sensible choice is someone who -is- a tech expert. As in, Tali or Legion.

[DocSun]

Everyone made it through my first run.... except the "non-esental crew" I didnt realize that the game actually peanilized you for not going into the Omega 4 relay ASAP until it was too late. I plan on rectiflying that with my 2nd playthrough.

[MediumD]

I had Thane do the ducts, Samara led a squad, Garrus led a squad, SuZe popped the biotic shield, and Tali led the survivors. I had all of the ship upgrades available about about 3/4 of the squad upgrades. I didn't want to spend hours mining so I just pulled the pin on the Omega relay.



Jack wasn't loyal since she had a catfight with Miranda. Something killed her after she finishing shielding my group from the bugs. Thane took a round to the face when Shep closed a door. Grunt was dragged away and devoured by bugs. Samara died off camera.



I only really miss Grunt. Legion fills in nicely for him, though.

[ThatDancingTurian]

I noticed a lot of people putting Thane in the ducts for some reason. Is it because you guys thought the heat would clear up his watery lungs or something?

[DarthRic]

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

I noticed a lot of people putting Thane in the ducts for some reason. Is it because you guys thought the heat would clear up his watery lungs or something?

I choose him because I didn't think the game would take it into account who goes and I thought "well hes gonna die soon anyway so if the character here does have to die he would want to be the one so he goes out saving people" I felt bad but it was the logical choice to me

[Pauravi]

Yeah, I made it through with everyone on the first try, including the whole crew.
I picked Tali for the ducts. I was nervous because she was my LI, but the job called for a technician and she is a technical genius. I decided to trust in her despite my fears. She didn't let me down
I picked Garrus to lead the first fire team due to his experience leading that vigilante group back on Omega. Plus, Garrus is a badass.
Garrus also led the escort. He was going to be essentially alone, so I wanted a very proficient combatant who cared for the people he was escorting. Everyone made it back alive, including all crew members.
The second fire team was led by Miranda, because she is a smart girl who is a Cerberus Leader by trade. She did very well, although I held my breath a bit when she took a bullet. Sighed relief when she shook it off.
My biotic shield-bearer was Samara, because she is a wickedly powerful biotic with a millenia of experience. Everything went fine; she struggled a bit at the end, but she was impressive nonetheless. It was between her and Jack -- I may choose Jack next time just to see how she handles it.
The teams that came with me were Grunt/Samara, Thane/Tali, and Samara/Tali.
Oh, and Zaeed is an **** and if he had died I wouldn't have gone back and reloaded I almost kicked him off the team during his loyalty mission, even though I had the Paragon option. I wouldn't trust him to take care of my fish, much less my companions. I left him on for the hell of it (more firepower is better I guess), but I never put him in any sort of important role, nor would I ever.

Modifié par Pauravi, 01 février 2010 - 02:33 .

[RiotLaFontaine]

There seems to be many variables involved in the suicide mission, some of which may stem from earlier choices in the game (and not just loyalty). My friend and I made identical choices in one segment of the mission and one of his assigned squadmates died, while mine were perfectly fine.

[Javanaut]

brocodaily wrote...

 I am sort of tooting my own horn I guess but i am just super excited that without help, without any advance knowledge whatsoever I was able to make the right choices and the right personnel decisions to keep everyone (including my crew) alive on my first attempt without retry.

I was so damn scared when I was having to choose who did what though!

Who else made it through on the first try?

I am uber excited to see who all I can kill now though!

 

I'm not trying to burst your bubble or offend you in any way; but I honestly felt like my hand was being held when it came to making decisions about who did what during the final mission and during the journey there. They not only told you what was needed for each role but gave you descriptions of each character on the selection screen. I would have prefered if they didn't do either. Then you would have to truely be a leader and decide based on what you know about your team just through playing the game.

It was too easy to figure out which person(s) was best for what job, imho.

Modifié par Javanaut, 01 février 2010 - 02:59 .

[Arelyte]

Everyone survived except Grunt. Made me so sad when the swarms carried him away...