141 réponses à ce sujet

[KalenNighteyes]

1. Garrus

2. Mordin

3. Thane

4. Kelly

5. Tali

6. Miranda

7. Jack

8. Grunt

9. Zaeed

10. Legion

11. Jacob

12. Samara



Think I got them all.

[kalerab]

Rate them based on their character, not on combat skills

Garrus
Tali
Grunt
Mordin
Zaeed
Legion
Thane
Miranda
Jacob
Samara
Jack

Modifié par kalerab, 17 février 2010 - 11:45 .

[Finnroth]

First Tier: Zaeed, Tali, Garrus, Legion, Mordin

Second Tier: Grunt, Miranda, Samara, Jacob

Third Tier: Jack

Fourth Tier: Morinth, Thane



Grunt, Miranda and Jacob lacked the little something for me, they were well done and by no means badly written or something - they just lacked small details here and there imo.

Samara I just didn't take too kindly to, don't ask me why. There character itself ist nicely done.



Jack i never romanced, so i never got to her more interesting parts. If i ever could muster the effort she would probably jump quite a bit up, but i just couldn't get myself around her yet.



Morinth just lacked depth though the character itself is very interesting imo. Give her more dialogue please



Thane...i just didn't like. The spark just didn't connect to me. I seriously expected to like him more there's just too little details given of the culture and background in any meaningful way out of dialogue to get a more serious impression.

Maybe if there was the Hanar homeworld or colonies with more Drell and more cultural depth i could get more into him.

[Zhijn]

1. Mordin.
2. Grunt.
3. Legion.
4. SubZ / Jack.
5. Tali.
6. Miranda.
7. Thane.
8. Samara / Morith.
9. Garrus.
10. Zaeed.
11. Jacob.

[Onyx Jaguar]

Gameplay



1. Miranda

2. Jack

3. Zaeed

4. Garrus

5. Legion

6. Tali

7. Grunt

8. Samara

9. Thane

10. Jacob

11. Mordin



Teamates in character



1. Mordin

2. Legion

3. Tali

4. Zaeed

5. Garrus

6. Thane

7. Jacob

8. Miranda

9. Grunt

10. Samara

11. Jack

[dreman9999]

1.Garrus, Tali, Mordin, Grunt, Legion,(I like them all so much I can't pick.)
2.Samara.(How can you hate a character who trying so hard to be unemotional and fails?)
3.Jack.(Too much issues.But still attracted.)
4. Thane(He was what I expected him to be except dieing.)
5.Mirand( Best #2 ever but is way too cold and controling.)
6.Jacob(He had my intrest until he stopped talking.)
7. Zaeed(Was I the only one how left him to burn on his loyalty mission?)

[shaneho78]

1.Legion

2.Mordin

3.Jack

4.Grunt

5.Thane

6.Jacob

7.Tali

8.Samara

9.Miranda

10.Garrus

11.Zaeed

[rabbitchannel]

1. Thane

2. Legion

3. Garrus

4. Miranda

5. Mordin

6. Grunt

7. Tali

8. Jacob

9. Jack

10. Samara

11. Zaeed



Actually, after the first few I don't feel especially strong about any. If I could group them they'd be:



Thane, Legion, Garrus



Miranda, Mordin, Grunt



Tali



Jacob



Jack, Samara, Zaeed

[XTVengeance]

1. Tali
2. Legion
3. Garrus
4. Grunt
5. Mordin
6. Zaeed
7. Samara
8. Thane
9. Jack
10. Jacob
11. Miranda
12. Morinth; because the whole concept of an Ardat-Yakshi scares the sh!t out of me.

Modifié par XTVengeance, 18 février 2010 - 01:22 .

[Prophet of Rage]

This is hard.

1. Samara
2. Grunt
3. Garrus
4. Tali
5. Thane
6. Zaeed
7. Mordin
8. Jack
9. Jacob
10. Miranda
11. Legion

I liked all the characters, though. Even Legion, Miranda and Jacob.

Modifié par Prophet of Rage, 18 février 2010 - 01:14 .

[Bergybud]

1. Ash

2. Wrex

3. Mordin

4. Miranda

5. Legion

6. Samara

7. Liara

8. Jack

9. Tali

10. Garrus

11. Zaeed

12. Thane

13. Grunt

14 Jacob



I am biased because of my numerous ME1 playthroughs.

[Juls1616]

1.Tali
2.Samara
3.Miranda
4.Garrus
5.Mordin
6.Grunt
7.Legion
8.Jack
9.Thane
10.Jacob
11..Zaeed

[Bibdy]

I think I'll just go with the first one who really stood out for me: Mordin. He talks in bullet-point form, he's brilliant, a little bit crazy and has a good sense of humour. Some of his lines really cracked me up. "Target is flammable! Or inflammable! I forget which...". Even though I was playing a Paragon, I absolutely agreed with his reasoning for the genophage. He's just one cool guy.

[Captain_Goodguy]

1. Miranda

2. Garrus

3. Mordin

4. Grunt

5. Jacob

6. Grunt

7. Legion - came too late to make much of an impact

8. Samara

9. Jack

10. Zaeed

11. Tali

[Nizzemancer]

Liked them in these orders, established by first impressions, somewhat different on the ME1 list right now:

ME1:

1. Liara

2. Tali

3. Ashley

4. Garrus

5. Wrex

6. Kaidan



ME2:

1. Tali

2. Garrus

3. Mordin

4. Thane

5. Legion

6. Samara

7. Grunt

8. Miranda

9. Jacob

10. Jack



Haven't picked up Morinth because I don't feel comfortable having an asari biotic vampire that wants to sex me up just to kill me running around on my ship.



Compilation-list (most updated opinion):

1.Liara

2. Tali

3. Garrus

4. Mordin

5. Thane

6. Ashley

7. Wrex

8. Legion

9. Samara

10. Grunt

11. Miranda

12. Kaidan

13. Jacob

14. Jack

[Dragoons19]

ME1

1: Liara

2: Wrex

3: Garrus

4: Ashley

5: Kaidan

6: Tali



ME2

1: Grunt

2: Garrus

3: Mordin

4: Miranda

5: Legion

6: Samara

7: Thane

8: Tali

9: Jacob

10: Jack