109 réponses à ce sujet

[Sylmawen]

Confirming bug, with just 1 package before and both packages later.

[Kelmen Wong]

Bioware probably is busying with internal restructuring. They probably fired the QA team b4 the release, or they hiring QA (outsourcing) who don't understand English.

[tnt118]

Just wanted to add a little info in case a dev looks at this:



Same problem as OP, did Citadel datapad second, and when doing the paragon option the question completion bugged. I think the problem went back to when I actually picked up the second datapad though, as it never updated my journal to return the datapad to Ish. I think the problem comes from that not flagging correctly.

[Frostune]

I did not get this bug. Here's the order I did it: Got quest from Ish > Got the Citadel package > Back to Ish for delivery > Got the Illium package > Back to Ish for delivery. I picked all bottom (renegade) options in conversations. Played on PC.

[taelus.calimshan]

I've played with this one a few different ways, all of which use a charm option somewhere, because I'm a min-maxer and non-charm options are for sissies ;-)

Anyway, after speaking with Ish, finding either package and returning to Ish, the conversation option to discuss the information in the package concerning Anto (the Batarian guard in Afterlife) and Aria becomes available. This opens up the options with Ish to convince him to leave it be. Choosing the Charm option convinces him to leave, completes the quest in terms of reward, and results in the bug everyone's seen in their journals.

The alternative I've found that closes the case is to speak with Anto after discussing the information in the packages with Ish. Again, the charm/intimidate options pop up and you can get Anto to handle Ish, thus protecting his job and Aria's reputation. This closes the assignment in the journal with an "Ish was never seen again" finish. I'm not a fan of that as a paragon approach, but hey, it closes the assignment out correctly in the journal.

Now Bioware, in the words of Jon Stewart, meet me at camera three. In this assignment, you've just given us information about a leak in Aria's personal contingent of guards. When we found a datapad suggesting a bunch of now-dead mercenaries might have tried to overthrow her, you gave us the option to report it to her. Why in Jebus' name can't we show Aria the information about her guard sneaking things around her back? Why would we want to discuss the issue with a Solarian or a Batarian when we could use it to hit on Aria? My hormones, jarred by my wife and placed on top of our fridge as they might be, find your lack of foresight on this issue unacceptable. Thank you for your time.

Modifié par taelus.calimshan, 20 février 2010 - 11:33 .

[Dr Bob UK]

taelus.calimshan wrote...

Now Bioware, in the words of Jon Stewart, meet me at camera three. In this assignment, you've just given us information about a leak in Aria's personal contingent of guards. When we found a datapad suggesting a bunch of now-dead mercenaries might have tried to overthrow her, you gave us the option to report it to her. Why in Jebus' name can't we show Aria the information about her guard sneaking things around her back? Why would we want to discuss the issue with a Solarian or a Batarian when we could use it to hit on Aria? My hormones, jarred by my wife and placed on top of our fridge as they might be, find your lack of foresight on this issue unacceptable. Thank you for your time.

I agree.

I wanted to show Aria the data, as well.

Modifié par Dr Bob UK, 21 février 2010 - 12:34 .

[RomiBraman]

Yep same bug here and apparently it's not in Patch 1.01 fix list

[Aaediyen]

Nope, wasn't fixed. I guess I get to either play through it again or look at that unfinished quest I finished for an eternity.

[brfritos]

If you choose the Paragon the quest finishes, but still shows in the journal.
If Renegade path is chosen, you deliver the data to Ish and the quest completes correctly.

Odd thing...

Thalandor21 wrote...

AFAIK, it's the only bugged quest in the game... except maybe for Conrad Verner who always thinks you did the renegade thing in ME1... Please fix !!! I love perfection.

AFAIK if you ended "The Fan" quest in ME1 with the Renegade option, this quest shouldn't even exist!

Remember you on the elevator and the news service announcing that a certain Conrad Verner was killed?

So much for continuity, hun? 

[ ]'s

[theblob2]

Galford24 wrote...

metalcalf wrote...

hey, you guys after talking to ish got alk tot he guard...I forget his name. He is the one standing at the bottom of the stairs on the right set of stairs on the way up to talt o aria. He might have something to say about the packages for ish story.

I went to that guard several times after i convinced Ish to stop, but the guard still has nothing to say but "go to aria if you want to talk" (or something like that)
Even after i finished the suicide mission i went back to omega to talk to the guard - nothing! 

I just found this bug, too. Seems to be a problem with the charm-/renegade-option.

You can talk to the guard after getting the packages (and before talking to Ish) and tell him that Ish reveals his secrets.

[taelus.calimshan]

theblob2 wrote...

Galford24 wrote...

I went to that guard several times after i convinced Ish to stop, but the guard still has nothing to say but "go to aria if you want to talk" (or something like that)
Even after i finished the suicide mission i went back to omega to talk to the guard - nothing! 

I just found this bug, too. Seems to be a problem with the charm-/renegade-option.

You can talk to the guard after getting the packages (and before talking to Ish) and tell him that Ish reveals his secrets.

Small correction: You can talk to Anto (the guard) during the time after acquiring one of the packages, but before completing the quest.  By "completing" I mean giving both packages to Ish or convincing him to give it up.

Anyway, what I mean to add is just that talking to Ish about the packages doesn't stop the interraction with Anto unless you go so far as to complete the quest with Ish himself.

[Thalandor21]

So, the patch didn't fix it...let's keep this up in the forum list.

[CatNoise]

Bump

[FlabOere]

i can't see the datapad outside marab's shop in citadel at all, tried to save and reload since that had fixed some other problems but no luck. now i'm just stuck with this quest

Modifié par FlabOere, 26 février 2010 - 09:51 .

[taelus.calimshan]

FlabOere wrote...

i can't see the datapad outside marab's shop in citadel at all, tried to save and reload since that had fixed some other problems but no luck. now i'm just stuck with this quest

I know this is going to sound a bit silly, but have you checked to make sure your journal says to find the packages?  Next, have you gone to Ilium to see if the package there is present?  And last up, if you've nabbed the one on Ilium and returned it to Ish, have you already convinced him to quit to ratted him out to Anto?

If your answers are yes, yes, and no, then either it's being tricky about letting you see it in the Citadel, or you're mission is bugged.  It'd be the first time I've heard anyone mention that kind of bug, but hey, it could be happening.  Still, stand at the door to the shop and look just slightly to your left on top of the first of the boxes in the pile in front of the shop window.  That's where it should be sitting.

[yahavbr]

Bioware don't care, plain and simple, I'm not bit surprised - I didn't expect any better from big and arrogant company.

For what it's worth, links to screen shots proving this bug.

First screen shot
Second screen shot

By the way, I delivered only one package, so it's "double bug".

Modifié par yahavbr, 27 février 2010 - 12:42 .

[Thalandor21]

Yep, buggy buggy. I would like to point out that when inspecting the patch notes, I noticed that it was dated from january... So most bugs listed were pretty old knowledge from bio. The "newer" bugs like Ish assignmentor Conrad Verner always renegade might be fixed in a future patch...

[Adielr]

I don't see the package in Eternity (Illium) after giving the package from Marab's shop(The Citadel) to Ish in Omega.

[Terminus Pi]

Bump this!

Picked up both packages first and then went to Ish. Used the paragon line on him. Quest completed but stayed active in journal.

On the second playthrough, I picked up only one package and then used the paragon line on Ish before picking up the second one. Same result.

Using the paragon line to convince Ish, will always result on the journal not updating.

[taelus.calimshan]

For the folks with the missing package issue, if you use the paragon option in the dialogue to convince Ish not to pursue the venture any further, the second package will be gone. This is because in theory, the assignment is complete. The same result will come if you deliver one package and then have Anto "deal with" Ish, though that approach completes the journal.



So, if your journal is still telling you to grab a package, there's a chance that you've landed in the middle of the bug and you don't need to do a thing...well...you'll have to wait for Bioware to get the journal fixed :-)

[taelus.calimshan]

Sir Bumply would like to thank BioWare for looking into this issue and/or letting us know they're aware of it.



Cheers.

[JustGez]

Same. Bump.

[PnXMarcin1PL]

the same glitch

anyway i usually inform anto about this (using paragon blue option)

[taelus.calimshan]

PnXMarcin1PL wrote...

the same glitch
anyway i usually inform anto about this (using paragon blue option)

I always thought that was a hilarious option for them to put in since the charm (paragon) option still results in having Ish killed.  Not very noble or kind really.  I'd have been fine with no charm option at all and the only options with Anto being to intimidate him into taking care of his business :-)