89 réponses à ce sujet

[sir_edwart]

 Hi @all,

i am new here in this forum. normally i am not posting feedback for a game anywhere, but it comes to my mind i have to do that for mass effect 2.

first of all, i loved mass effect 1. i played it more than one time and i loved really.
i loved the cool mix of action and rpg and the real cool story.

so i was happy to get the second one on the release date.

i am amazed from the intro and the story. the action part is good and it makes fun to fight against the enemys.

But: where is the RPG part of the game?

A RPG must have, good story, good dialogs, good main AND  side-quests, inventory, skills, shops, ... .
in mass effect 2 many of these things (side-quests, inventory, skills, shops) are only implemented as minimal as possible. there is no motivation to level up, the skills are very basic. There is no inventory. I want to compare items. in every rpg i can compare the items to select the best one. the differences between the weapons are minimal. the items to buy in the shops are really little.

where is the rpg-part? Mass effect is really a good action game, but the name "RPG-Shooter" doesnt match it really. it is only a action game. I want to walk through a big world to explore it but in mass effect 2 its a big world whre i have to fight. the omega base gives a first clue of it. in mass effect 2 it was great on the citadel. now the citadel is only a small base where i cant explore much. Why not more space-stations for exploring?

@Bioware: thats the wrong direction for the game - please go back and make a real RPG "Mass Effect 3".

Thanks
Bye
Edwart

[lurking fear]

Dude, this topic was beaten to death a countless times.

[DarthCaine]

Ah, and I see you registered today just to troll and don't have the game registered

And ME2 has all of the things you said except an inventory

[Tobebech1307]

Well the rpg part of the game is in the dialog, story, skills, side-quest, which are all there....

[ShadyKat]

Use the search function dude. This is getting really old, really fast.

[olp33]

Don't agree this isn't trolling he's sharing his opinion like everyone else does.

[Garvare]

RPG = Role Playing Game = Playing in a Role = Playing as Shepard (good or evil, male or female, whatever you like) = ME2



RPG != Looting or Inventory. Those things do have nothing to do with playing a role.



ME2 is awsome.

[Mehow_pwn]

ME2 Is awesome, but not epicly awesome as the first one was when it came out

[Jackal904]

Dude seriously stfu. It is more of an rpg than most rpg's out there. You actually play a distinct role and you level up and get skill points, sounds like an rpg to me. Just because you don't have 20 stats that you have to manage and every piece of clothing can't get upgraded, doesn't mean it's not an rpg. And you must be absolutely retarded to say ME2 does not have a good story and good dialogue. Clearly you are a PS3 fanboy. GTFO!

[ShadyKat]

Mehow_pwn wrote...

ME2 Is awesome, but not epicly awesome as the first one was when it came out

ME2 is much better than ME1, and I loved the first game.

[Mehow_pwn]

ShadyKat wrote...

Mehow_pwn wrote...

ME2 Is awesome, but not epicly awesome as the first one was when it came out

ME2 is much better than ME1, and I loved the first game.

Yes the ME2 Is better ,but not much better... seriously the rpg lvl system and items in ME2 are so dull and gay . Also the planet scaning thing is kinda boring

Modifié par Mehow_pwn, 02 février 2010 - 02:40 .

[DadeLeviathan]

I see everybody is having tremendous amounts of fun beating this dead horse. Or the giant puddle of goo that used to be the dead horse. How fun.

[T1l]

ANY game is a Role Playing Game. You could call Halo a Role Playing Game becasue you're playing the "role" of Master Chief - but that does not mean Halo is a god damn Role Playing Game. For ****s sake, a Role Playing Game is a genre based on core RPG elements which, lets be honest, have been trimmed in Mass Effect. It doesn't make it any less fun, it doesn't make it any less of a great game, but yeah, it does make it less of an RPG than say, Dragon Age.

If people were walking in to Mass Effect expecting Dragon Age they've only got themselves to blame.

[Mehow_pwn]

Jackal904 wrote...

Dude seriously stfu. It is more of an rpg than most rpg's out there. You actually play a distinct role and you level up and get skill points, sounds like an rpg to me. Just because you don't have 20 stats that you have to manage and every piece of clothing can't get upgraded, doesn't mean it's not an rpg. And you must be absolutely retarded to say ME2 does not have a good story and good dialogue. Clearly you are a PS3 fanboy. GTFO!

Are you seriously stupid? 

So your gone call Halo , Call of duty and gears of war a rpg? omg typical respond from a noob

and WTF does ps3 have anything to do with this? GTFO troll

[Caion]

Garvare wrote...

RPG = Role Playing Game = Playing in a Role = Playing as Shepard (good or evil, male or female, whatever you like) = ME2

RPG != Looting or Inventory. Those things do have nothing to do with playing a role..

I agree. I find it a bit insulting when games such as Borderlands
toss in a loot system and some fetch quests and style itself as an RPG.
I still shake my head when I see websites and retailers cetegorize
Bioshock as an RPG. Also, for the love of God, I swear if I see the
phrase "(insert genre here) with RPG elements" one more time I am going
to go on a rampage.

[Mister Mage]

DarthCaine wrote...

Ah, and I see you registered today just to troll and don't have the game registered
And ME2 has all of the things you said except an inventory

Wrong.  It has everything they said, and moves the inventory to the spaceship.  Automanages it so you don't need to go "Durr, that number is bigger than that number!  Me smart!"

[Mehow_pwn]

I rather call ME2 a RPS than a RPG even tho I really love ME2 and im still playing it after beating it twice

[Killian Kalthorne]

Garvare wrote...
ME2 is awsome.

No it is not.
ME1 is awesome.
ME2 is not ME1.

[_KTA_]

These threads are worse than Mass Effect 1's cluttered equipmentory, seriously it's like tons of **** just filling up the forum. "warning your **** threads are at 138 of your maximum 150, please clear some space before we omni-ban trolls"

[Jorlen]

lurking fear wrote...

Dude, this topic was beaten to death a countless times.

Shame it didn't drop any loot.

[Mehow_pwn]

_KTA_ wrote...

These threads are worse than Mass Effect 1's cluttered equipmentory, seriously it's like tons of **** just filling up the forum. "warning your **** threads are at 138 of your maximum 150, please clear some space before we omni-ban trolls"

and? You could always sell them no problem or simply delete **** no problemo..

FAIL

Modifié par Mehow_pwn, 02 février 2010 - 02:54 .

[Selvec_Darkon]

*Face palm*



It's a newbie, I find the reaction towards a newbie on this forum rather distasteful. Take your trolling comments elsewhere, bloody hell. This forum is to express opinions about ME2, not to **** and moan about user postings. Don't like the opinion, gtfo of the thread.

[Elanareon]

ME2 is a great gane but lets be honest. Its too fps type now than an rpg.. Skills what skills? You mean 3 - 4 skills? Too dumbed down from me1 i say... Exploration was minimzed or entirely removed. Items was remived! They did this good in me1 why remove it? The probelm with me1 was inventory but that's what they did not improve! The ship storage concept is good because i doubt any people. An carry many items at once, but its still in lame list for

! Me2 removed things that are good in me1 and retained the bad things.

[_KTA_]

Mehow_pwn wrote...

_KTA_ wrote...

These threads are worse than Mass Effect 1's cluttered equipmentory, seriously it's like tons of **** just filling up the forum. "warning your **** threads are at 138 of your maximum 150, please clear some space before we omni-ban trolls"

and? You could always sell them no problem or simply delete **** no problemo..

FAIL

Yes after 2 loading screens and an elevator ride you could sell them.  it sucked: http://gamedesignrev...rt-ii/#more-999