193 réponses à ce sujet

[challenger18]

Tali had me at "I wish Shepard were here" when you do her recruit mission.



Though I have to ask this, and I asked it in another thread and no one replied to it.



While I thought it was awesome when she says she wants me to see whats under the face mask, the thought immediately popped into my head, "why not have a face mask that isn't tinted?" Someone brought up that maybe they wanted to keep out the radiation from the sun, to which I reply, but ME2 has shown that you can tint and un-tint your face mask (dude who fixes up gunship during Archangel mission does this). So wouldn't Tali just have to tint when she's in the sun and let the tint drop to clear when she's out of the sun or indoors?



Is this a too simple solution that I think is staring me in the face?

[InvaderErl]

I imagine Garrus would be the one adding "Playa" followed by some kind of high five.

[epoch_]

LemuresXL wrote...

InvaderErl wrote...

antilles333 wrote...

I personally tried shoving Tali in Liara's face after it was done. And I will continue to shove only Tali.

Though my friend picked Garrus and he is just once again, the most unintentionally hilarious character in the game.

But seriously. Tali. Should've been in ME1.

The wait made the relationship better.

There should be a joke about this in ME3... if confronted by Ash or Liara... we can just say "Hey... You were just there till I could get with Tali.  Playa!"

I fully expect ash/kaiden to throw a ****storm of EPIC proportions when they found out you cheated on them with an alien.

If this doesn't make it into ME3, I will be disappointed.

[Samurro]

I got Miranda in the first playthrough, and was a bit disappointed. Liara from ME1 felt more romantic and deep. Also the conversation were really dumb... "you want it too, right?" *blink* .....*facepalm*

[binaryemperor]

the best romance subplots would have been Grunt, but they did not make one. Jerks.

[InvaderErl]

epoch_ wrote...


I fully expect ash/kaiden to throw a ****storm of EPIC proportions when they found out you cheated on them with an alien.

If this doesn't make it into ME3, I will be disappointed.

I don't think Kaiden would mind the alien part. Ashley would have a freaking fit though, she's territorial.

[wulf3n]

Was it just me, or did Miranda go from practically hating shep, to being really friendly practically flirty. All the other female li's may have been a bit defensive at the start but still receptive, though Miranda really cold/harsh and practically says at the space station before you get the mission, i dont like you, lets just do this and go home, then the next time you talk to her she's all flirty and nice...wierd

[MerchantGOL]

Is it just me or did Miranda's and Jacob's Come off kinda ....Trashy?





Like bad porno

[NeoGuardian86]

for male Shepherd (one that i play the most with and is my 'canon' version)



It's Tali,

I do hope to continue the romance in ME3, and have the option to see her face (i say option for those who don't wanna see it don't have to).





For female Shepherd, i really like how Bioware guys handled Garrus and Thane's romantic scenes.



very good imo.

[IccaRa]

THANE.

Absolutely Thane. His romance is the most bittersweet one of the lot and that's what makes it beautiful. His VA and animations during the final scene are fantastic and the delivery socked me in the gut. And what I appreciate most about his romance is that there is no question over how he feels about Shepard -- he is in love with her. He openly admits it more than once, and she to him. Some of the other romances felt shallow by comparison. And I guess that's okay -- not everyone is into the deep spiritual stuff. I am, which is why his romance is my favorite.

(Not that I don't like Garrus', I do. It's very cute. But Jacob's I flat-out don't care for.)

The MaleSheps options? I'd have to say... hm. Jack's is very moving, but Tali's has this heartwarming familiarity to it and the added element of her life within the suit.

Modifié par IccaRa, 03 février 2010 - 12:56 .

[wulf3n]

MerchantGOL wrote...

Is it just me or did Miranda's and Jacob's Come off kinda ....Trashy?

Like bad porno

lol, i reckon shepards lines are more trashy, i half expected to walk into mirands office and say "Ive come to clean zee pool".

Modifié par wulf3n, 03 février 2010 - 12:54 .

[this isnt my name]

LemuresXL wrote...

InvaderErl wrote...

antilles333 wrote...

I personally tried shoving Tali in Liara's face after it was done. And I will continue to shove only Tali.

Though my friend picked Garrus and he is just once again, the most unintentionally hilarious character in the game.

But seriously. Tali. Should've been in ME1.

The wait made the relationship better.

There should be a joke about this in ME3... if confronted by Ash or Liara... we can just say "Hey... You were just there till I could get with Tali.  Playa!"

I tried to romance Tali in ME1 and was dissapointed, then I was just  like "well I guess you have to do then" with the other LIs.

[Raoune]

Thane's is so epically romantic. He's really my type of guy.



Seeing the development of Garrus with my FemShep was beautiful though. I was going to set her up with Jacob, but I'm glad I didn't. After seeing it on the web, it's just a booty call. Not good, at all.





As for the females, Jack is the best, no question.

[kell-vallon]

I went w/ Tali for the romance scene on my 1st play through. But........................was Massively ticked off that i didn't even get to see her face. It was one of those moments like at the end of Halo 2. You just wanted to throw things lol.

[MisterShine]

challenger18 wrote...

While I thought it was awesome when she says she wants me to see whats under the face mask, ... *snip

Is this a too simple solution that I think is staring me in the face?

When she said that, I'm fairly certain she meant it more in a metaphorical way. She wanted someone to be close to, and she wanted it to be Shepard.

That's how I looked at it anyway

Or maybe the materials in the quarian face masks CAN'T be tinted? Who knows..

edit:

Tali had me at "I wish Shepard were here" when you do her recruit mission.

Also, I want to second this. I liked Tali in the first game, but I was planning on going for jack on my first playthrough. Tali's amazing voice acting had me sold on that line though

Modifié par MisterShine, 03 février 2010 - 01:07 .

[NoUserNameHere]

epoch_ wrote...

LemuresXL wrote...

InvaderErl wrote...

antilles333 wrote...

I personally tried shoving Tali in Liara's face after it was done. And I will continue to shove only Tali.

Though my friend picked Garrus and he is just once again, the most unintentionally hilarious character in the game.

But seriously. Tali. Should've been in ME1.

The wait made the relationship better.

There should be a joke about this in ME3... if confronted by Ash or Liara... we can just say "Hey... You were just there till I could get with Tali.  Playa!"

I fully expect ash/kaiden to throw a ****storm of EPIC proportions when they found out you cheated on them with an alien.

If this doesn't make it into ME3, I will be disappointed.

Yes! Seconded!

[siltsonata]

Garrus is my favorite, because it felt real. A situation like that, two completely different species (completely different DNA for crapssake)? HELL YAH IT'S GONNA BE AWKWARD. But between all that, it was sweet and touching, and it felt very complete. Plus, come on, Garrus deserves a break.



I would also say that Thane's final scene is well worth watching. The whole romance didn't do it for me; he fell oddly flat, until the final scene, then HOLY CRAP. It was great. Very bittersweet.



For the guy LIs, I've only seen the final scenes but Tali's seemed the cutest.

[KFeril]

Thane hands down (by the old drell gods I hope he can be cured for ME3)!!!

In the first game there weren't really any viable options, what with the cardboard cut-out that was Kaidan or the rascist/humans first shrew that was Ashley. I thought Liara was nice, but a little too naive at the time.

In ME2 Jacob just seemed like Kaidan 2.0. Miranda is too much in Cerberus's pocket (and way too ****y if you side with Jack when they're having their fight). And as much as I feel bad for Jack and all the horrible stuff that happened to her, that doesn't really translate into desire for me.
I don't hate Tali, but I don't entirely like her either. I think the Quarians got what they deserved over the whole Geth mishap, and I didn't like her treatment of Legion who I really liked (though I can sort of see where she's coming from).
As for Garrus, he was one of my favorite characters from the first game, along with Wrex, but he's my brother-in-arms - it was a little weird going down that road with him.

So like I said: Thane all the way baby!

[Xevious550]

I really don't get all the Tali gushing. She's a great character, I loved her story, missions, and the background she has with Shepard. But in my mind, she's much more a younger sister type person in Shepard's life. While she obviously has matured in the two years that have passed and cares for Shepard a great deal, she was just coming into adulthood in the first game while Shepard was already a seasoned vet. It just doesn't seem right. And that's not even considering the difference in species.

As for the other two options, Miranda didn't seem to have any emotion behind it. And Jack needs friendship and stability more than anything. Romancing her doesn't seem right if I'm to assume my character still has feelings for his game 1 squeeze (Ash).

So in the end I went for Miranda just for the acheivement and cutscene. But on my "canon" playthrough, I won't romance anybody in hopes that Ash shows up again in part 3.

Modifié par Xevious550, 03 février 2010 - 01:23 .

[BeetleBrewin]

My femShep stayed faithful to Liara. Would have liked more intimate interaction between them as in ME1. Hope chance to keep this romance in ME3.
Would also have liked the chance of femShep romance with Jack, Miranda or Samara.
Hope more choice in ME3

[AngryTigerP]

Xevious550 wrote...

I really don't get all the Tali gushing. She's a great character, I loved her story, missions, and the background she has with Shepard. But in my mind, she's much more a younger sister type person in Shepard's life. While she obviously has matured in the two years that have passed and cares for Shepard a great deal, she was just coming into adulthood in the first game while Shepard was already a seasoned vet. It just doesn't seem right. And that's not even considering the difference in species.

As for the other two options, Miranda didn't seem to have any emotion behind it. And Jack needs friendship and stability more than anything. Romancing her doesn't seem right if I'm to assume my character still has feelings for his game 1 squeeze (Ash).

So in the end I went for Miranda just for the acheivement and cutscene. But on my "canon" playthrough, I won't romance anybody in hopes that Ash shows up again in part 3.

I guess the character appeals to something different in everyone. I'm not gushing, but I'm telling you, I thought the whole bit about Tali having a crush on Shepard (but thinking that he wouldn't reciprocate) was heartwarming, especially when you find out (via Kelly) that she feels this way whether or not you romance her, and from hints like the log on her Recruitment Missions ("I wish Shepard were here...") Granted, the latter will make some people think there was a little sister aspect going on there, but I just interpreted it as a would-be private appeal to the powers that be that Shepard would, you know, BE THERE for her.

Again, might have to do with the fact that my current girlfriend was much the same as Tali in terms of not thinking she would be 'good enough', but I love that aspect of Tali's personality.

[tmp7704]

epoch_ wrote...

I fully expect ash/kaiden to throw a ****storm of EPIC proportions when they found out you cheated on them with an alien.

Kaiden struck me as very mature kind of guy. I think he'd be more of type who bites his tongue, acknowledges what happened as just part of "that's how life goes" and then acts it's all okay while he carries on brokenhearted. He's also very open minded about aliens, i wouldn't expect that to become a sore point for him. Come to think of it, gotta feel sorry for him.

On the other hand. If Bioware likes to screw with their playerbase (and all signs point to yes) they may as well reveal in ME3 that it's actually your old LI that had a relationship of their own with some 3rd party while they thought Shepard was dead...

Modifié par tmp7704, 03 février 2010 - 01:42 .

[Faldarian2]

tmp7704 wrote...

Kaiden struck me as very mature kind of guy. I think he'd be more of type who bites his tongue, acknowledges what happened as just part of "that's how life goes" and then acts it's all okay while he carries on brokenhearted. He's also very open minded about aliens, i wouldn't expect that to become a sore point for him. Come to think of it, gotta feel sorry for him.

On the other hand. If Bioware likes to screw with their playerbase (and all signs point to yes) they may as well reveal in ME3 that it's actually your old LI that had a relationship of their own with some 3rd party while they thought Shepard was dead...

That already happens in ME2, or it does with Kaiden at least. He tells you that he's tried to have a relationship with someone else, albeit mostly unsuccessfully.

I didn't do any of the romance options in ME2, since I didn't feel like it fit my character. I really wish there had been a bit more to the previous relationship than what was done... it was a painful, and short, connection with Kaiden when you finally run into him that feels like a kind of punch in the gut. The mail you get later on shows that it was the same on the other end, and that things aren't resolved at all.

For all the running around that was done to straighten out other people's lives before we headed on with the mission, Shepard is the one who never sought any resolution to anything and probably needed it most. I'm hoping it pays dividends in ME3.