86 réponses à ce sujet

[TheLostGenius]

Ok, so during Garrus's loyalty quest you are given the option to warn Sedonis. What happens if you do? Do you lose the loyalty quest or is simply the Paragon way of completeing it? 

[InvaderErl]

I believe there is a Paragon way.

[masterp1975]

Paragon way.

[ComTrav]

There's always a Paragon way.

[Gnomebomb]

Its the Paragon way of doing it. I warned him, and then stayed between him and Garrus (you have to react quickly to a paragon action choice to do this) and then ultimately Garrus thought better of it, took the high road and you get a bunch of paragon points and his loyalty.

[Cypher0020]

Yup. I convinced Garrus not to blow his head off. Found it fun to sway him into not taking the shot.



Plus still got his loyalty anyways.

[defenestrated]

I think there might be a point where you need to have decent Persuasion to make Garrus okay with sparing him but yes, you can warn Sedonis and still keep Garrus's loyalty.

[MrVincent]

It's the Paragon way of gaining loyalty from Garrus...and there is a great conversation involved in it.

[InvaderErl]

Did the game ever give a reason NOT to kill Sedonis? I let Garrus shoot him but I haven't been able to find the Paragon choice on YouTube.

[raven2510]

Well there are 3 ways.

The paragon way, the renegade way, and the Homer way.

[Bio Addict]

Quick question for those who took that paragon way.



When I first went through the game, roleplaying as just myself, I was determined to help Garrus get revenge so I just stepped out of the way and let him shoot Sedonis. It wasn't until later that I realized that there was probably more to the story. So what I wonder is if you save him, and get his side of the story, does it turn out that he actually didn't betray Garrus?

[Ileanos07]

You can. You just need enough paragon points. If you dont have them, then you can save him, but you loose Garrus´s loyalty.

[MrVincent]

Bio Addict wrote...

Quick question for those who took that paragon way.

When I first went through the game, roleplaying as just myself, I was determined to help Garrus get revenge so I just stepped out of the way and let him shoot Sedonis. It wasn't until later that I realized that there was probably more to the story. So what I wonder is if you save him, and get his side of the story, does it turn out that he actually didn't betray Garrus?

*Spoiler*


He did, but he was threatend by the mercs.  He says how he is already a dead man, how he can't sleep at night...well here.

[Splinter Cell 108]

I warned Sidonis. There is a paragon way to do it and you do gain Garrus' loyalty plus you keep him from ruining his life if you ask me. He forgives Sidonis if you do this.

[talon4000]

my paragon shepard kills people for much less than what sidonis did, I don't see any reason to prevent him from killing sidonis

[Wintermist]

I didn't like the fact that there was always a Paragon or Renegade with every single character. They should have built it more like if you are a certain way, some people will follow you, and if you're not, they'll tell you to go shag a volus. Like how they did it in KOTOR.

[tmp7704]

InvaderErl wrote...

Did the game ever give a reason NOT to kill Sedonis? I let Garrus shoot him but I haven't been able to find the Paragon choice on YouTube.

There's no reason given really, beyond a "oh he's feeling so sorry about what he did, it's already punishment enough".

In fact you could probably argue granting Sidonis the swift death he wishes for is more of the Paragon choice here since it gives closure to both people affected and it doesn't force your own morality on Garrus. Preventing it felt very self-righteous to me and to a degree hypocritical*, too much to personally go with it.

*) doubtful many of the paragon types would be so quick to forgive if a betrayal by one crew member resulted in the whole staff of Normandy and all your team mates getting murdered by mercs e.g.

[ElBiggus]

talon4000 wrote...

my paragon shepard kills people for much less than what sidonis did, I don't see any reason to prevent him from killing sidonis

Which is precisely the problem with the Renegade/Paragon system...

[Deuterium_Dawn]

MrVincent wrote...

Bio Addict wrote...

Quick question for those who took that paragon way.

When I first went through the game, roleplaying as just myself, I was determined to help Garrus get revenge so I just stepped out of the way and let him shoot Sedonis. It wasn't until later that I realized that there was probably more to the story. So what I wonder is if you save him, and get his side of the story, does it turn out that he actually didn't betray Garrus?

*Spoiler*


He did, but he was threatend by the mercs.  He says how he is already a dead man, how he can't sleep at night...well here.

So he's a coward and a traitor. Glad I let Garrus take the shot.

[Pathogen69]

my first playthrough i let garrus take the shot. second time, i convinced him to stay his hand. but, i guess it works out. if you listen to the galactic news network on the citadel, sidonis turns himself in to citadel security for his actions.

[greengroove]

I warned Sedonis and left it until the last possible moment before letting Garrus take the shot. If Garrus didn't want to take the shot after hearing what the guy had to say - so be it, if he still wanted revenge - fine by me.

[InvaderErl]

Dude was responsible for the deaths of Garrus' entire team. I thought he had done for a legitimate reason (his family was in danger or something). I wonder how many people would have let him live had he sold out Liara, Kaiden or some of the ME2 crew.

Modifié par InvaderErl, 02 février 2010 - 11:23 .

[Vaenier]

I let Garrus take the shot. Some things cant be fixed by words alone. Saying sorry doesnt bring those 10 people back to their families, someone has to pay for their murder.

[Splinter Cell 108]

talon4000 wrote...

my paragon shepard kills people for much less than what sidonis did, I don't see any reason to prevent him from killing sidonis

I would have let him shoot the Turian if that's what he really wanted but somehow I think it is better to walk away. What if Garrus finds out the guy was threatened? He might think of it as another mistake, it could haunt his entire life if you ask me. He's already got enough problems as it is, his face, C-Sec, his father and his team. I let him reconsider if you ask me, if he really wanted to do that then he would have said so and I wouldn't have objected.

[ReubenLiew]

I talked to Garrus up until he's ready to take the shot, I only wanted to know if he really wanted to do it, but I'd shoot the muther himself if it were up to me...