221 réponses à ce sujet

[artmonster1967]

wlcina wrote...

artmonster1967, please dont flame here, make your comment constructive, or just tell me why I am wrong. Like Chamuck Deluxe did.

2 Chamucks Deluxe: Each RPG has dragons so its no + :-)
You probably dont understand me, I am writing this because I think the Bioware SHOULD KNOW opinions of the users, even the BADs, do you think they will create great games if everyone is saying this is superb, it has some bugs, but I can live with that. That is not a progressive way !

Think about DA as rpg - the game is pushing you directly to the end. No chance for your own options / opinions and so on, that is not RPGish.

not flaming as much as you are shoving "your-opinion-broccoli" down our throats with no cheese.

and yes...I'm still laughing at you....you arent going to convince anyone here that the game is bad....lol.

[LaztRezort]

wlcina wrote...
I think all negative review is constructive...

1.  A constructive discussion of negatives can be constructive.

2.  Most people here are (surprise!) fans of the game, enjoy it, and have heard many of the same critisms before (even before release).  So don't be suprised to catch some flame, even if you think you are providing a "service to the developers."

[Sylixe]

I'm sorry i must have missed all the mindless hack and slash that they OP is eluding to.  I actually have seen more combat in NwN1 and 2 than in this game.

[Vellen]

I think this game is awesome, and I think its funny how thi sguy is moaning because he wants co op.



I don't want to play this game with other people, this game is exactly what most of the users wanted.



That is the spiritual successor of BG and KOTOR and this is what we have and its great.



I really feel like the average "gamer", and i hate that term has been dumbed down and stupefied, playing too many sub par games without any substance. They find the simplest things to hard to do. These guys need to go and find copies real PC games like BG1/2, Fallout 1/2, XCOM, Jagged Alliance 1/2.



This game is one of the only games to come out in the 2000 that lives up to games above, thank you bioware for making it and I hope Mass effect 2 is just as good as this or better.



Just look at what is happening to games these days.



OFP:dragonrising should have been great, it was nothing more than a **** console port.



Look at what happened to the call of duty games.



This game is about single player role play you need to read up about the game before you buy it.



Once again for the record, thank you so much for not making this a dumbed down console port!

[bestial2009]

wlcina wrote...

I think all negative review is constructive, because they will show the bads of the game to creators, creators usually see their game as their child : without mistakes :-)

I am just saying, this game HAS a potential, a GREAT potential, but 40% of that potential is wasted, or not used.

Scientific proof right here fellas!

End of discussion.

[Talian Kross]

Well, I'm enjoying the game. My only two gripes are that the game environment is way too static (you can't really interact with anything other than doors) and the UI is extremely limited for a game of this type, especially when compared to previous BioWare releases.

[elemental150]

nope....I like it and you do have some choices......just from what I am seeing not as many of them have true consequences, like all of the development videos would have you believe.....Some of the bigger ones do obviously.



I think it is a good RPG and yes I use that term.....I have played tons of RPGs and don't see much difference between this game and baldur's gate as all of the naysayers seem too (although I am aware there are many)

[syclonix86]

demicraftgod wrote...

one thing about being a PC game...is that WE have the ability to make the game into a perfect 10...because after all, from developer's perspectives--thus the game itself--might not be as attractive to you as they would have hoped...though...when toolset comes around, you can make your dragon age worth that rating of 9.5 or even 10 if you so desire...

Agreed. Oblivion is definitely a solid case for this. You could spend a lifetime customizing the game to your hearts content with a little elbow grease and time (okay, I lied a lot of time, but it sure is fun playing game developer).

[Aapheus]

wlcina wrote...

I am writing again, why I consider this game as "average":

1) COOP play, Bioware is stupid if they didnt add multiplayer to DA. Why ? It will make game playable 10 times longer ! Just have look at the Neverwinter Nights (1) - people are still playing over internet, modding comunity is working on their new mods. This is just fact. Each good multiplayer game lasts much longer. Single player ? - you will win 2 - 3 times and you will never return to game again.

I happen to agree with you there to a point.  I wish there were multiplayer, and I think it could have been done without ruining what Bioware was trying to do.  However, maybe they'll add such a thing in a future patch, and in any event, it really doesn't diminish what this game is.  It's tremendous fun to play, and the characters you meet are every bit as interesting as some of the jackholes you'd end up playing with online anyway.

2) Tactics - there is ONE!! command action. I do not understand such this thing. Why just one ? This is called tactics ? horrible, just imagine they were at least 3, what a nice combos you can create.

The operative words there are "[you] do not understand such this thing [sic]."  Learn the combat tactics.  You add ranks to your ability and you get more options.  Savvy?

3) User interface why on each side of my monitor, not ergonomic. You will have to run with you mouse here, then there, then there again.

Not following you there.  The principal part of the UI that you routinely use is on the left half of the screen along the bottom.  The party members are lined up along the left edge (where in NWN and NWN2 they were lined up along the right side).  You have the local map on the top right corner, that you don't need to interact with anyway, and then you have the icons across the top middle for those who can't remember I = Inventory, J = Journal, etc.  Don't see what your problem is.  At all.

4) Predefined paths , exploration killed. In RPG ? great ways to destroy one of great RPG elements.

Hmmm, there are some predefined paths, yes, and the world is certainly not nearly as wide open as Oblivion and its predecessor, Morrowind, but I'd contend the thousands-times-better gameplay and interesting story more than makes up for that.  RPGs are about a lot more than wandering around in the woods hoping to find a Ring of Fire Resistance nestled in one pixel out of millions way off the beaten path.

... more are coming...

We all wait with breathless anticipation.

[wlcina]

Reeditet thoughts - after your comments:



1) COOP play, Bioware is stupid if they didnt add multiplayer to DA. Why ? It will make game playable 10 times longer ! Just have look at the Neverwinter Nights (1) - people are still playing over internet, modding comunity is working on their new mods. This is just fact. Each good multiplayer game lasts much longer. Single player ? - you will win 2 - 3 times and you will never return to game again.

your comments: MMORPG / WoW, answer: No I dont want to play MMORPG, I want to play this game with friends, like I did with all previous Bioware RPG games I mentioned, I want to make balanced party with my 2-3 friends and want to have fun with game, - in current state as SP game, it loosing this great potential



2) Tactics - there is ONE!! command action. I do not understand such this thing. Why just one ? This is called tactics ? horrible, just imagine they were at least 3, what a nice combos you can create.

- no one answered for that, do you think it is ok ? :-)



3) User interface why on each side of my monitor, not ergonomic. You will have to run with you mouse here, then there, then there again.

- for some ppl it is ok, I agree, what about consensus - make it drag and drop where you want it, that would be best for all.



4) Predefined paths , exploration killed. In RPG ? great ways to destroy one of great RPG elements.

your comments: play Morrowing (boring ? :-O) , I am not saying about extremly HUGE world.But about how the game is pulling your hand, and taking you where you have to be. I need some free space for me, I want to see here and there, there could be barricades, but not so close the predefined paths, you practically cannot move out of the way for a bit.



Dont flame please.

[Rubbish Hero]

Very good game, worth the wait.

[artmonster1967]

Aapheus wrote...

We all wait with breathless anticipation.

or flatulent exclamation

whichever comes first 

*poot

[Chamucks Deluxe]

They see me trollin'.. they hatin... patrollin... they tryin' a catch m- DELETED

[dharani]

stop trolling, game is great not average.

[wlcina]

2 aapheus: you wrote: "The operative words there are "[you] do not understand such this thing [sic]." Learn the combat tactics. You add ranks to your ability and you get more options. Savvy?"



You do not understand me (its because my english is horrible, sorry) I mean the queue of actions, for example, you will pause the game, then select your mage, and do queue : go here, (1st command), cast fireball to here (2nd command), heal "xxx" (3rd command), unpause, and the char will do queue

[wlcina]

dharani wrote...

stop trolling, game is great not average.

I do not agree with you so I am trolling ? dont flame. Add critics to my negative review, do not just write "game is great not average". OMG.

[artmonster1967]

for someone starting a thread about censorship....





you sure are trying to tell everyone how to post.



...

[lunasea3]

wlcina...trolling because you have to argue with everyone who states an opposite opinion. You stated yours...they state theirs..end of story but you have to go on and on in broken english that's tough to understand anyway. We get it, you aren't bowled over. Yippeeee

[Kortok]

What predetermined path? You can go wherever you want about 4 hours into the game.



NWN...are you kidding me? NWN doesn't hold a candle to DA.

Multiplayer? Doesn't make sense with a party based game like DA. NWN isn't party based.

Tactics? I don't use them I input every move for every character.

UI? UI is great imo.



Just admit the game is too hard for you and move on. I mean you love NWN, but that game is so insultingly easy DA is probably a bit too much for you.

[lunasea3]

wlcina...trolling because you are arguing with anybody who doesn't agree with you as if you were right. You have your opinion, they have their opinion..state it and move on for petes sake. You aren't that impressed...we get it.

[AngryFrozenWater]

I have read just a couple reviews and then I gave up. I decided to make up my own mind. And so far I am enjoying the game. That's what counts.

[lunasea3]

sorry, posted twice...first one didn't show for awhile so I though I mussed it up somehow...my bad

[Dorkington]

DA isnt bad ,  Legend hand of God , now that was bad .. Im still not lovin DA, but when I get a handle on im sure it will grow on me.. i can feel it.

[Purssy1980]

Catsith wrote...

Umm, every video game studio I know only advertises their best reviews. Bioware aren't censoring anything. I see plenty of negative threads here that aren't locked.

If you don't like the game, too bad. Go get a refund. Trolling the forums and telling people their opinion is wrong is a waste of time.

I agree but aren't you also telling telling people the op is wrong??

[orpheus333]

What would you do to make it better?