16751 réponses à ce sujet

[BlackEssence]

And ur right, it would be an angery relationship between them and you know what? I find that to be very, very intriguing. Can you imagine the chemistry? WOW!

[abnocte]

I can see the angry thing, but then I see Jack who is a uberpowerful ( story-wise ) biotic and combat-able versus Kolyat that has no training and hasn't killed anyone... and it appears cleary in my mind Jack totally owning Kolyat to the point that he ends being nothing but her toy...

Looks like I have no faith in the poor guy... XD

BlackEssence wrote...

I think if written right, a jack and Kolyat could work. Especially, since we barely know Kolyat and who he is. We dont have a clue as to what Kolyat has been through when Thane went off to search for the killers of his wife. That leaves plenty of room for someone to play with. I actually plan to do a oneshot fic of the two. I am very intrigued in s jack and Kolyat pairing right. I think it was a brilliant suggestion from Lem lemuri!

That's true, we don't really know what Kolyat has been up to. But the way he appeared in ME I assumed various things:
- He has no real training 
- He never killed anyone before
- He tried to follow Thane's footsteps as a way to get back at him.

The last point leads me to believe that he had quite a sheltered life with his uncles and aunts, and that he wasn't round when his mother was killed ( or he would be dead, bad guys dont spare kids ).

Otherwise I see no real reason why someone that lost people dear to him will want to become an "assassin" and inflict on other the same suffering he felt. Specially since he wasn't working for a goverment, or following a code that allowed him to "filter" who he was going to kill. Actually he was just becoming a thug, killing whoever he was ordered to if the money was right ( ... same scum that killer her mother...  ).

All of the above screams "inmature" to me, but well that's just my opinion.
It will be interesting to read your fic though 

Modifié par abnocte, 13 avril 2011 - 10:50 .

[TheSweetGirl]

I only see Thane with Femshep because of how strong she is and Thane is attracted to the strong-willed woman. ;D

Jack is just too crazy for him XD For Kolyat? O.O *imagines Renegrade scene between Maleshep and Jack in cargobay except replace Maleshep with Kolyat*


Edit: Oh Found this! XD Poor Thane!

Modifié par TheSweetGirl, 14 avril 2011 - 03:52 .

[JECWSU]

More Thane

[Tasha vas Nar Rayya]

I saw that comic on the Garrus thread. Made me laugh. There is alwasys someone with an epic monologue anyway. And in ME2. It was Thane at his RM.

I love that shot of when Thane is in the car too. He looks very cool and stylish there (Garrus' LM? Am I right?)
I think I deserve a high-five if I got that right

[BlackEssence]

@abnocte I think you nailed on what you assumed of Kolyat. I assumed the same thing in the since that he may have been on his FIRST assassination mission even though he is ruthless is you happen to fail that mission of saving him for Thane. He is ruthless like his father, but I think that is what could appeal to Jack. She could pick on him about that and call him a ruthless perpetrator. Kolyat would be pushed to try to prove that he does have the nerve to bust caps if he wanted to. Of course, his father would intervene in that...and....and.....goodness! The creative juices are just flowing! I need to write this stuff down! lol!

[JECWSU]

Yes it's from the loyalty mission.

Kolyat didn't really seem ruthless to me. He just seemed like a very angry kid.The way he reacts during Thane's loyalty mission told me he could never really handle being with someone like Jack. At least not for too long. He seems shocked if Shepard hits him. He can't even take a bullet if Shepard shoots him, and I think Shepard scared him if she kills Talid. He and Jack might be fun for a while, but in the end I think she would get bored and move on.

Modifié par JECWSU, 14 avril 2011 - 11:06 .

[TheSweetGirl]

*still has the image of Koylat and Jack in the cargo bay*

Get it outta my head!

XDD

Anyway, oooooooooooo I love that Thane pic XD and I think you are correct, Tasha.

[Tasha vas Nar Rayya]

I was. JECSWU confirmed it. And she knows EVERYTHING about Thane

And I don't see either Kolyat or Thane as ruthless. I think they were both victims of circumstance.

Thane was raised to be an assassin. He had no choice in this, and he was forced to be ruthless in order to cope with guilt.

Kolyat had an assassin for his father, and a mother who was murdered because of Thane's proffession. Neither of them seem inheritantly ruthless. They just had to become tough to cope with the events in their lives.

[JECWSU]

Thank you Tasha.

I don't really see Thane or Kolyat one of them being inherently ruthless either. I do think Thane can be ruthless.He was probably the most ruthless when he killed the Batarians that killed his wife. I agree that it probably does have a lot to do with the way he was raised. I don't know if Kolyat has it in him to be ruthless at all.

[XX55XX]

I think that Thane is probably going to die by the beginning of ME3 from his illness. His son could have a cameo or be the full squadmate.

It would make for an interesting dynamic between Kolyat and Shepard.

Thoughts? Is Thane going to die?

[xsprayx]

So, this is my first time posting in this forum...And where else is better for my fifrst post? I did read every page of this thead. Over the course of a few weeks, mind you. I have a life. So now that I'm depressed because I lack reading material...I thought I'd register my game and post.

Anyway, Thane is one of my favourite characters, and my favourite LI, so...

I also want to discuss ME3 possibilities and things. I have no one to do thiswith IRL because my boyfriend won't hurry up and finish the game.

So, hi everyone.

[ebidebby]

Hi! I am the same way - I have no one to talk about this stuff in real life, either. My husband plays, but any time I talk about Thane or Kaidan, he kinda rolls his eyes. Heh.

[xsprayx]

ebidebby wrote...

Hi! I am the same way - I have no one to talk about this stuff in real life, either. My husband plays, but any time I talk about Thane or Kaidan, he kinda rolls his eyes. Heh.

I once had a lenghtly discussion with my boyfriend about which LI I was going to pick in ME2. It was fun.

He just won't finish the game. He claims he hasn't been in the mood, but really, I think he's trying to get back at me for taking so long to finish Kingdom Hearts...

[JECWSU]

How many months later is ME3 suppose to start?

No I don't believe Thane will die at the beginning of ME3. I believe he has about 8 to 12 months before the disease starts to effect him.

Kolyat as a replacement for Thane would never work. He doesn't have the training or the skills that his father has. All you have to do is watch him during Thane's loyalty mission to see he could never handle being apart of Shepards squad.

Modifié par JECWSU, 15 avril 2011 - 07:06 .

[Kim Shepard]

I think Game Informer said that ME3 will start a few months after ME2.

JECWSU wrote...

Kolyat didn't really seem ruthless to me. He just seemed like a very angry kid.The way he reacts during Thane's loyalty mission told me he could never really handle being with someone like Jack. At least not for too long. He seems shocked if Shepard hits him. He can't even take a bullet if Shepard shoots him, and I think Shepard scared him if she kills Talid. He and Jack might be fun for a while, but in the end I think she would get bored and move on.

This is about how I see it. They might be compatible enough to start something, but not enough to finish it. Maybe it could work for older Kolyat if Shepard doesn't stop him from becoming an assassin. He could get some character development, become more used to killing, and after living that crazy life long enough that he could stand a chance with Jack.

If that really happened... Kolyat and Jack could double date with one of my FemSheps and Zaeed. xD

[BlackEssence]

Zaeed was my other boy in the game! LOL. He's too old, though. Way too old. >____<*

[kaimanaMM]

XX55XX wrote...

I think that Thane is probably going to die by the beginning of ME3 from his illness. His son could have a cameo or be the full squadmate.

It would make for an interesting dynamic between Kolyat and Shepard.

Thoughts? Is Thane going to die?

Thane is not going to die at the beginning of ME3.  His son having a cameo would be pretty neat, but being a full squadmate would be like replacing the Widow with a BB gun.  (Nothing personal, Kolyat!)

No.  It would not make for an interesting dynamic between Kolyat and Shepard.  It would make for an interesting dynamic between Thane and Kolyat, though if we came across Kolyat again.

A better question would have been : Will Thane be shirtless in ME3, will we finally see full on drellchest? Thoughts?

[JECWSU]

Maybe we will. If he does get sick he will need to be checked out. You can't do an examination fully clothed. Maybe we will get a nice love scene like the ones we had in ME1.

I don't mind seeing Kolyat in ME3. Hopefully he and Thane will have worked out some of their problems.

Modifié par JECWSU, 15 avril 2011 - 11:58 .

[Apathy1989]

Yeah I hope he makes an appearance in ME3, either as a member briefly or entire way through.

He needs to die though, I don't want a cheesy happy ending. A good tragic love arc would be good, perhaps shepherd can try to find a cure but fails.

Also no real interest in seeing kolyat again besides knowing that he is consoling and growing to love his father.

[JECWSU]

Not one person on this thread wants something cheesy or some kind of miracle cure. We would like a chance to cure him, but maybe at a cost. Nothing to easy. If not at least some way to prolong his life. I don't understand why some people seem to think he needs to die.

[TheSweetGirl]

^ Agreed

We don't want a miracle cure (how many times have we said that? XDDD) Koylat being in shepard's squad is a contradiction towards everything Thane's loyalty mission showed us. And why does he need to die?

My question is why do people want such a tragic, brooding ending? XDD That is so depressing. No chessy ending but not a totally depressing ending either. Well, that's just me. I love dark endings when they are necessary, not when their purpose is very, very angsty to the point I can't even watch it.

And here everyone, look! A vid about Male Shepard and Thane's friendship!

[kaimanaMM]

Why does Thane need to die?  Because he said he's going to?  Because of the story set up?  With that logic, does Shepard need to die?  The story certainly strongly hints that that is possibly one of the many endings.  But necessary?  Not totally, no.

If Thane has to die for your story to make more sense / feel better / provide you with what you're looking for, then more power to you.  But I don't think anyone should be locked into one batch of choices with only one outcome.  Nor, do I think, anyone wants the story between Thane and Shepard to suddenly lose all depth and meaning (i.e. magical tube of mystery cure).  

What's wrong with the hero saving the day and riding off into the sunset with his / her guy / gal in the passenger seat?