16751 réponses à ce sujet

[xsprayx]

I wasn't sure about who had and hadn't been confirmed, honeslty.

Thanks for clearing that up.

[IndigoWolfe]

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

[BlackEssence]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

That's two options. First, I wouldn't let him sacrifice himself. Period. The second choice, if the option to keep his sexy booty on the ship, even if it caused me to be renegade with him, I would chose that. No matter what. Even if it risked him being mad at me or losing his loyalty, I would choose that. Because I love him. His life is more precious to me. If that choice was not there, I wouldn't let his body be probed and dissected for anything. There are plenty of other drells that have KS. Let them be a case study, but if Thane dies with honor, he will be buried with honor as well. I won't let anyone mutilate or defile his body for anything in the world. I want him to cross that ocean into the heavens just as he was planning to.

Modifié par BlackEssence, 16 mai 2011 - 02:09 .

[hanar05]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

First option. From a story perspective, that would be my preference. I think he would rather go that way too.
Also because I don't know how much use his body would be to find a cure if there's already numerous other drell who have died from Kepral's whose bodies they could study.

[Alknost]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

I would hope, given the choices, that Thane would express which of the two options he would prefer- and my Shep would default to his decision even if it would fill her with angst.

[wildannie]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

I'd pick the former, but I wouldn't be happy about it... that's not a choice I want forced on me in ME3.

[abnocte]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

Well, If I had to choose among those I would choose the first easily.
Why? Because when you meet him, after killing Nassana he tells your Shep that this was supposed to be his last mission.
I don't remember the exact words but I remember him impliying that after killing her he would let the guards kill him. Looks like he doesn't want to end in a hospital suffering during his last days, it's better to go while doing some greater good.

[PinkSugarCube]

yay thane, I knew there had to be one of them here heh.

[disjunctionreaper]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

First choice definitely, IMO Thane (like Garrus) would go down in a blaze of glory, caring for any and all members of the squad even if it gets him killed, and if the mision is vital he would go down for a good cause, sad but necessary for his son to live a longer life instead of dying at the hands of the Reapers.

[Homebound]

do u think post-suicide mission Thane can still take on Kai Leng? He mightve softened up, being introduced to his son, finding new meaning in his life and all.

[Tinve]

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

I do not like all the options. Your mail-order catalogue has light colours?

[abnocte]

Hellbound555 wrote...

do u think post-suicide mission Thane can still take on Kai Leng? He mightve softened up, being introduced to his son, finding new meaning in his life and all.

 

What do you mean by "softened up"?

If he didn't "softened up" when he was happily married I don't see why would he now. He is a professional first and foremost.

And let's not forget his own words :

"Guilt? no, I've never felt any particular guilt about my contracts. My employers killed them, my body was only the tool they used."

I have a hard time imagining someone able to say that "softening up".

[Tasha vas Nar Rayya]

I still have hope that Thane won't necessarily be left to die in a hospital.

But I would rather see him sacrificing himself for a good deed and 'go out with a bang.' Than spend his last moments dying helplessly in a hospital bed. I am sure it is what he would prefer too.

[JECWSU]

Alknost wrote...

IndigoWolfe wrote...

Question; if there's a choice between letting Thane sacrifice himself to achieve some worthy goal, but having him... y'know die right then and there but letting him do so in an honorable way that saves lives or helps complete a vital mission objective, or holding him back to keep him alive and stay with him in the knowledge that you would eventually have to watch him die in a hospital and let his body be used in studies that could produce a cure for KS, which would you pick?

I would hope, given the choices, that Thane would express which of the two options he would prefer- and my Shep would default to his decision even if it would fill her with angst.

I agree with this. I would rather the decision be left up to him, and even if I hated it I would probably do as he asked.

I really hope Bioware does not give us a decision like this to make.  I really don't want to see anything like this in ME3.

[JECWSU]

Hellbound555 wrote...

do u think post-suicide mission Thane can still take on Kai Leng? He mightve softened up, being introduced to his son, finding new meaning in his life and all.

Of course I think he can still take Kai Leng. I don't thin those things have softened him up. I think they have only made him stronger. Also Thane loves Shepard. Kai Leng is going to try and kill her. He already lost his wife, because he was unable to protect her. He isn't about to let that happen again.

[Fault Girl]

JECWSU wrote...

I agree with this. I would rather the decision be left up to him, and even if I hated it I would probably do as he asked.

I really hope Bioware does not give us a decision like this to make.  I really don't want to see anything like this in ME3.

It's like the Kasumi choice, I'm such a sap. Even if it might not be the best option I always go with what is less upsetting. I wish I was more of  a tough nut. I'm still unsure whether to use my Thane save first incase it is something I might not be able to do as an LI in the future.

But I will put faith in Bioware. Unless each LI would have a hard choice implemented...

[Tinve]

Welcome back! I'm glad you're back with us.

Gnas wrote...
In respon to IndigoWolfe, the only way I would allow Thane to sacrifice himself would be for my Shepard to go with him. After all, I am willing to hold the galaxy hostage to obtain a cure for Thane.

My Shepard agree with your.

Modifié par Tinve, 17 mai 2011 - 09:49 .

[JECWSU]

Gnas wrote...

I am here because of Thane. So... Let's talk about Thane and his lovely dark eyes, his oh so tight clothes and his wonderfully deep and reverberating voice. 

I am willing to hold the galaxy hostage to obtain a cure for Thane.

Welcome back

I agree with this.

[Fiery Phoenix]

One of them is this: Storm - Lifehouse

[Tentura]

This was brought to my attention by meekzu, and I think it needs to be shared here as well!  Everyone could use a little dose of drellchest.

JECWSU wrote...

Alknost wrote...
I would hope, given the choices, that Thane would express which of the two options he would prefer- and my Shep would default to his decision even if it would fill her with angst.

I agree with this. I would rather the decision be left up to him, and even if I hated it I would probably do as he asked. I really hope Bioware does not give us a decision like this to make.  I really don't want to see anything like this in ME3.

I agree.  I wouldn't want to be forced into this situation, but if it did happen I would want him to have a say in his own fate.

Modifié par Tentura, 18 mai 2011 - 03:02 .