16751 réponses à ce sujet

[mnomaha]

Hey...does anyone remember Joker mentioning Thane after he's murdered?

[mnomaha]

I just wanted to see this again and I got top of page.

[Thrazesul]

mnomaha wrote...

Hey...does anyone remember Joker mentioning Thane after he's murdered?

None mentioned Thane. And afterwards Garrus was all "Do you miss Ashley?"

Not Garrus's fault but sheesh.

[mnomaha]

That's what I thought, but somebody mentioned it on that other thread. I've only played the game through once, so have probably missed quite a bit.

[Twilight_Princess]

mnomaha wrote...

@Sable and Dine...I loved my Garrus romance. Totally...well the fade to black pissed me off...but the rest was awesome. That date on the Citadel? The Gone with the Wind kiss? Yeah, incredible. You know what is sad? The fact that they locked out Garrus for new players. Why? To get them to buy the previous games.

Considering what they did to Thane and Jacob, they should have made him available in ME3. And like you guys have said already, garrus's romance was damn near perfect in ME3. Before I realized what they did to the other options I was just so happy they listened to us and that garrus wasn't constantly calibrating anymore (he actually had lines!) The conversations, the pacing, the little details, the date, THE KISS, the goodbye, the "I love you too". Holy crap! Apart from that annoying fade to black (really? give us SOMETHING bioware) it's up there as one of the best bioware romances. 

So I experience this brilliant romance and of course I think Thane was given the same amount of effort in his.  Before I imported my Thane shep, I hadn't read a single spoiler about his role in ME3 and I missed him during the first playthrough so I honestly went in blind..and optimistic. Disappointed doesn't even begin to describe how I felt when I finally realized what they did to him.

Modifié par Hyrule_Gal, 25 octobre 2012 - 09:18 .

[giftfish]

DineBoo wrote...

What gets me about Jacob is that even though he was a weak character, there was no need to turn him into a cheating douche. I mean, WTF? Who made that decision? It wasn't in his make up at all! Just because he dated Miri didn't mean he was going to cheat.

It looks like they just wanted to write off two of femShep's romances, thinking that Liara, Garrus, and Kaidan would satisfiy everyone, but it backfired big time.

Especially considering if someone romanced Jacob in ME2, they wouldn't have the option to romance Garrus in ME3; it was only available if continued.  And, if the playthrough was an ME1 import as well, Kaidan has a 50% chance of being dead.

Mandatory lesbian for FemShep.

Not too nice in a game about interactive storytelling and player choice.

Modifié par giftfish, 25 octobre 2012 - 09:48 .

[mnomaha]

mnomaha wrote...

You know what I wish...what I really with all my heart wish? I wish someone would document this completely in a video form and send it to me. I really wish that.

No really guys. I need this. I might be inclined to post this request every page if I have to.

..."From here to the eyes and the ears of the 'Verse"

Yes, I have a plan.

[Roxy]

You trying to turn my femshep into a lesbian Bioware? Not cool *puts sunglasses on* not cool!

I love Garrus just as much as the next person but when I see how much attention he gets and compare it to Thane...my blood starts to boil! It's a total wtf moment with the little time you have with thane and how he's not himself and then he dies...poof...he's gone! It's liike really? Did somebody write this while sitting on the ****ter?....*sighs*


Sorry if I sound crazy guys..it's been a long day for me lol!

Modifié par Roxy, 26 octobre 2012 - 02:45 .

[Seifer006]

Roxy wrote...
Sorry if I sound crazy guys..it's been a long day for me lol!

[Roxy]

Seifer006 wrote...

Roxy wrote...
Sorry if I sound crazy guys..it's been a long day for me lol!

Dagnabbit...that looks good Seifer lol!

I just might have to talk my hubby into taking me to the liquor store real soon,Thanks!

[Seifer006]

Roxy wrote...
Dagnabbit...that looks good Seifer lol!

I just might have to talk my hubby into taking me to the liquor store real soon,Thanks!

[DineBoo]

Siefer, even though I don't post in your threads, I just love the way you rile up certain people regarding a certain blueberry.

Keep up the good work.

[mnomaha]

Hey my peeps, can someone pop into that other thread and provide the forum-challenged David with some dlc ideas. I don't have them saved and have the broadband from hell lately.

[Emeraldfern]

I'm writing one up as we speak. I have one old idea already but it's way too rough to share as-is.

However, if anyone else want to have go too, keep in mind that this particular poster usually responds to empirical logic (atleast from what I've seen in other threads).

Modifié par Emeraldfern, 26 octobre 2012 - 03:44 .

[Roxy]

@ Mnomaha I would if I could but I don't know much about the DLC ideas...didn't Coldi or Squeegee know more about them?

Tbh I really don't see why we should explain to these one sided people about anything...they are so stuck with in their own minds!....sorry that might be the whiskey talking! ^^

[mnomaha]

I know Roxy, but I refuse to let CP think he has shut us up.

Thanks Em! I'm not even sure where to look anymore and I haven't seen Coldi all day.

[Roxy]

Emeraldfern wrote...

I'm writing one up as we speak. I have one old idea already but it's way too rough to share as-is.

However, if anyone else want to have go too, keep in mind that this particular poster usually responds to empirical logic (atleast from what I've seen in other threads).

Yaay your writing one up? You'd pretty much be better at explaining it than I would! ^^
Even when I don't know much about it....how sad!

I've read on other people's ideas for a DLC to Save thane which are really good ideas...some of it just never sunk in me brain...horrible!


Still I don't think we should explain a darn thing!

Modifié par Roxy, 26 octobre 2012 - 03:58 .

[mnomaha]

If I knew where Coldi was, I would get her to put it up. But I don't want to do that in the off chance someone thinks it is mine. I don't take credit on things I didn't do. My brain gears towards numbers and general tech, definitely not the creative type.

[Roxy]

mnomaha wrote...

I know Roxy, but I refuse to let CP think he has shut us up.

Fight the Good Fight..I like that!

Modifié par Roxy, 26 octobre 2012 - 04:00 .

[DineBoo]

Why is that people who find Thane's death to be "perfect" don't consider other people who might not like it?

Would people find Miri or Jack's death (if there was no recourse) not perfect be able to protest it? I think so.

[Twilight_Princess]

mnomaha wrote...

Hey my peeps, can someone pop into that other thread and provide the forum-challenged David with some dlc ideas. I don't have them saved and have the broadband from hell lately.

I was just about to ask the same thing  I can debate Thane's fight , death and romance execution in my sleep  but a detailed example of an option DLC . Well that I'm not the most articulate about that and I'm not going to try. People who want an example brought to them are looking for anything to discount it and I know there are better people to provide examples that are idiot proof LOL *reads posts above* awesome eme writing one up , fantastic. Make it good girl!

Modifié par Hyrule_Gal, 26 octobre 2012 - 04:07 .

[Roxy]

Didn't somebody say that Jack wasn't gonna get an option to be saved and people protested aginast it so they changed it?....I saw that somewhere.....

[mnomaha]

Roxy wrote...

Emeraldfern wrote...

I'm writing one up as we speak. I have one old idea already but it's way too rough to share as-is.

However, if anyone else want to have go too, keep in mind that this particular poster usually responds to empirical logic (atleast from what I've seen in other threads).

Yaay your writing one up? You'd pretty much be better at explaining it than I would! ^^
Even when I don't know much about it....how sad!

I've read on other people's ideas for a DLC to Save thane which are really good ideas...some of it just never sunk in me brain...horrible!
Still I don't think we should explain a darn thing!

We shouldn't have to but think of it this way:

One person, converted, can convert another, beginning a lot chain of events. Before you know it, there's an army out there of pissed off Thane fans. Or there is in my strategy.

Which would be freaking easier with video. <_<

[AresKeith]

DineBoo wrote...

Why is that people who find Thane's death to be "perfect" don't consider other people who might not like it?

Would people find Miri or Jack's death (if there was no recourse) not perfect be able to protest it? I think so.

Miranda and Grunt has a "perfect" death, but they have the chance to live

[Seifer006]

DineBoo wrote...

Siefer, even though I don't post in your threads, I just love the way you rile up certain people regarding a certain blueberry.

Keep up the good work.

HA!

- yeah it all started with this One Thread.  That thread made me a celebrity lol!!!

- then I expanded it with a DLC Suggestion Thread

For some frickin reason, the fanbase says I wrote 5+ threads on her..............???

watever.