Hails A Tan wrote...
...Gentlemen. (Mentlegen, if you prefer.) This is my first real foray into the Bioware forums proper, and it's kind of a scary place, so be gentle or the husk in my avatar will cry bitter, synthetic tears.
In response to a challenge to carry out the most bizarre pairing that I could think of, I started work on a fanfiction called Rock Steady a few months ago; it pairs Jack with (brace yourselves) Thane. I'm right up to the chapter that involves the Omega 4 relay at the moment, and I find myself at a bit of a conundrum that I was wondering if you guys could help me with: my tiny fanbase is mostly comprised of Thane admirers (ie: girls), and in response to 'so, uh, should there be a sex scene like in the normal game' they've mostly said yes. However, this thing is really supposed to be Jack-centric (she's my favorite squadmate by leaps and bounds), and I thought it'd be better to get the opinions of the people who know the character best.
I ask because, and I'm aware this is fanfiction heresy, I really don't feel that screwing down in the cargo hold is really a stage that they've reached, at the rate of development they've gone through, nor that it would be what either of the characters would really feel they needed. Despite what feedback I've gotten so far has suggested, it seems to me like it'd be...cheap, I don't know. Too physical. I was mostly entertaining the idea of substituting a discussion about the inevitable problems in the future (I mean, he's dying and we know from canon she doesn't take loss well), but...oy. I am at an impasse.
also I think I'd be too embarrassed to write smut, oh god don't hurt me
So, if anybody wouldn't mind offering an opinion on that, I would be hugely appreciative. I'd really prefer some input from the Jack side of the equation, for once (really, I need all the help I can get :| but one step at a time).
Nice of you to drop by - I read your fic up to part 10 a couple of days ago, and your use of language and tone is pretty damn sweet, as is some of the little bits of character colour. I'm no expert on writing, but I did like your crafting (even though I couldn't really see Jack and Thane - that's just me, you make it work on the page, and the page is God, not some shmuck reading it

). It's all in all a damn good bit of fic.
As for this moment... I think if you hang about here a while, read back a couple of hundred pages, a lot of us don't take Jack's Omega 4 scene as sex. It comes close, but a lot of us here think that it's just two people sharing some physical closeness, but it's the emotional closeness that's the vital part to a lot of us. We all, despite our different takes on the character, tend to agree that the scene is less about a struggle for mental and physical superiority (like Shep and Miri) or final romantic physicality moving beyond the boundaries of a suit (like Shep and Tali), it's about Jack allowing herself to be emotional, to be vulnerable, with someone else; about risking her heart, and risking theirs. This is a lot more romantic than an engineroom floor fumble... it's about love. That real thing we talk about. That evil bastard spawn of emotion that makes us laugh and cry and want to strangle our other-halves sometimes. Jack's letting herself feel again, and to be uncouth about it, dicks generally feel nowhere near as good as what she's getting.
I'd say go that way. Or go with the wild frogboy mambo - page is God

All the best with it, looking forward to reading it. Stick around here, too. I know you'll be more than welcome