20813 réponses à ce sujet

[Goat_Shepard]

As a Talimancer who knows about the cult-against-the-Tali-cult all too well, you guys might know how much what you said means to me.

I loled

Anyways, Jack. It goes without the saying that you let Aresh live, yes? He wouldn't actually be able to start a new facility or anything, right? Just want to get everything sorted out.

[kraidy1117]

Goat_Shepard wrote...

As a Talimancer who knows about the cult-against-the-Tali-cult all too well, you guys might know how much what you said means to me.

I loled

Anyways, Jack. It goes without the saying that you let Aresh live, yes? He wouldn't actually be able to start a new facility or anything, right? Just want to get everything sorted out.

Unlike Rana, I can't see him gettingo ut of the blast zone. I think he dies either way, it's what ever Jack does it or not that is the big things.

[Collider]

Pacifien wrote...

Goat_Shepard wrote...

NICKjnp wrote...
Eh... join the club.  I'm the second-in-command of the anti-Tali alliance. 

I didn't know Tali was so powerful she required a counter-alliance to combat her. You have a command structure and everything

As far as I can tell, the alliance consists of a treehouse, a secret handshake, and strategic strikes against anything with a mask, even if that's the Master Chief.

I got a private message from someone who insisted that they were very serious He was no mere troll, he explained indignantly, but rather a proud member of the Anti-Tali Alliance.
Hearing this, I apologized profusely for harming the fragile sensitivities of an ambassador of such an esteemed and serious business group.

Modifié par Collider, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:06 .

[Pacifien]

Regarding Aresh:
He had to have some transport just as Jack did, but seems like he'd have just hidden in the shadows while Shepard and crew departed so he could die in the blast like he wanted.

Modifié par Pacifien, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:04 .

[drunken pyromaniac]

I've always let Arresh live. No one would give the funds or resources to such an obvious nutjob to start up another facility. That is if he even got out of there in time, I don't think he did, personally.

Modifié par drunken pyromaniac, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:14 .

[StefanBW]

Plus Shepard gives his/her old little "you could have been like that, but you chose not to!" speech. So letting Arresh go is the proper thing to do for sure.

[Mondo47]

Just so you know, I'm not an anti-Tali kinda person (I actually have a not-so-secret fantasy about her being swept off her feet by a female Shepard... teaching her a thing or two, her being so innocent and all ). Nor do I have a problem with the vast majority of Tali, Miri, Kelly, Garrus, Thane, whoever fans - largely because they know when someone is being silly, or making a joke.

The people that can't tell the difference... I can get a bit anti-them. Like the Cerberus cheerleader, then need to back off... or we'll get to be friends real fast

[Pacifien]

What are there, four loyalty missions where you can stop the squadmate from killing someone in the end? The only one I tend not to stop is Mordin. Why he gets to kill Maelon while Garrus doesn't get to kill Sidonis is something I can't explain. Maybe I feel Mordin is more hardcore renegade than Garrus.

[Mondo47]

I can always talk Mordin out of killing Maelon...

And as for Aresh, the one time I tried to tell Jack to off him, she refused. I've never seen him get whacked. All my Sheps are imports though, so maybe their good-ness washes over more than I thought?

Modifié par Mondo47, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:21 .

[Collider]

I think Jack's defiance against Shepard's initial suggestion to kill or spare him is a display of one of her character traits.

[kraidy1117]

Pacifien wrote...

What are there, four loyalty missions where you can stop the squadmate from killing someone in the end? The only one I tend not to stop is Mordin. Why he gets to kill Maelon while Garrus doesn't get to kill Sidonis is something I can't explain. Maybe I feel Mordin is more hardcore renegade than Garrus.

1:Jack
2: Miri
3: Garrus
4: Mordin

Modifié par kraidy1117, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:27 .

[Goat_Shepard]

@Collider
l.o.l

@Kraidy
So it's unknown whether he lives or not. After 4 playthroughs, I noticed I always let my squaddies shoot Aresh, Maelon, Niket, Sidonis, because I see that my squaddie wants to kill them, and I do what they say cuz I'm weak like that. None of the dialogue suggests they regretted it or anything, so I figure letting them live = they regret it.

@Pyro
I suppose your right, it seemed pretty far fetched plan. I felt really bad for his state-of-mind, so killing him seemed appropriate, but if he dies anyway...

stefanbw wrote...

Plus Shepard gives his/her old little "you could have been like that, but you chose not to!" speech. So letting Arresh go is the proper thing to do for sure.

That's....pretty awesome. I can't even remember what the renegade line is...something like "Strike him down, and your destiny will be fulfilled!"

[Collider]

JohnnyDollar wrote...

She doesn't like being told what to do.

That's it exactly. She's rebellious.

[Arhka]

Goat_Shepard wrote...

@Collider
l.o.l

@Kraidy
So it's unknown whether he lives or not. After 4 playthroughs, I noticed I always let my squaddies shoot Aresh, Maelon, Niket, Sidonis, because I see that my squaddie wants to kill them, and I do what they say cuz I'm weak like that. None of the dialogue suggests they regretted it or anything, so I figure letting them live = they regret it.

@Pyro
I suppose your right, it seemed pretty far fetched plan. I felt really bad for his state-of-mind, so killing him seemed appropriate, but if he dies anyway...

stefanbw wrote...

Plus Shepard gives his/her old little "you could have been like that, but you chose not to!" speech. So letting Arresh go is the proper thing to do for sure.

That's....pretty awesome. I can't even remember what the renegade line is...something like "Strike him down, and your destiny will be fulfilled!"

The renegade line is that Shepard threatens to shoot him if she won't. Basically telling her to man up if she wants to shoot him.

[Goat_Shepard]

Mondo47 wrote...

I can always talk Mordin out of killing Maelon...

And as for Aresh, the one time I tried to tell Jack to off him, she refused. I've never seen him get whacked. All my Sheps are imports though, so maybe their good-ness washes over more than I thought?

She refused? You gotta go bottom left to convince her, right? So confused.

Btw Tali is not innocent! Get that look out of your eye! Wait, saying she's not innocent will only make it worse.

Pacifien wrote...
Why he gets to kill Maelon while Garrus doesn't get to kill Sidonis is something I can't explain. Maybe I feel Mordin is more hardcore renegade than Garrus.

Garrus kills Sidonis in all my playthroughs, what're you babbling about?

Modifié par Goat_Shepard, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:36 .

[StefanBW]

Mordin once killed with farming equipment, if that isn't hardcore, I don't know what is.

[Collider]

From what I understand, Maelon did some pretty crude experiments for his research on the genophage.

[Goat_Shepard]

Arhka wrote...
The renegade line is that Shepard threatens to shoot him if she won't. Basically telling her to man up if she wants to shoot him.

I remember now. This upcoming playthrough is gunna rock. I thought my previous PTs were paragon, turns out Idk what paragon is.

[Mondo47]

Goat_Shepard wrote...

ZOMG love that screenie!

How can anyone dislike a gal whose face can scream "Hug me" like that?

Modifié par Mondo47, 14 juillet 2010 - 11:50 .

[drunken pyromaniac]

Goat_Shepard wrote...

Arhka wrote...
The renegade line is that Shepard threatens to shoot him if she won't. Basically telling her to man up if she wants to shoot him.

I remember now. This upcoming playthrough is gunna rock. I thought my previous PTs were paragon, turns out Idk what paragon is.

Ho-ly Crap, that's beautiful!

[Collider]

I noticed a significant contrast between Jack and Miranda in terms of facial expressions. Miranda is much less. She sort of has a moderate or neutral expression on virtually all of the time. I've heard people (well, a person) describe Miranda as a sort of "robot," so I can understand the emotional detachment. Miranda & Jack are basically character foils of one another.