317 réponses à ce sujet

[Sleepy Buddha]

Tali's the most popular, at least judging by these boards.



I personally like Miranda way more. I just find her attitude and personality far more interesting. I hope Bioware gives her as big a role in ME3 as they did in ME2.



But I guess that's what's good about Bioware's games, choice. You get to choose whatever floats your boat. In my case, it's Miranda.

[Nadya2]

Lyrandori wrote...

Obviously Tali, it's not even comparable, Tali has a good character development, Miranda might be popular only due to her nice boobs and nice ass, other than that... not much to say about her, also I don't like her attitude overall.

if you choose to destroy the collectors ship at the end as a good character  you will find more about Miranda than just her looks.  she is a very strong will woman and knows exactly what she wants.

[flem1]

On the boards? Tali. But only Bio knows what all the non-board folks out there are doing...

(I believe info on the romance decisions is being collected.)

Modifié par flem1, 05 février 2010 - 10:18 .

[Robnhud]

 Here's the main reason Miranda is so popular....

i123.photobucket.com/albums/o319/robnhud/MirandaGreatButt1.jpg

[shinobi602]

Robnhud wrote...

 Here's the main reason Miranda is so popular....

i123.photobucket.com/albums/o319/robnhud/MirandaGreatButt1.jpg

Don't be so naive. That's pretty rude too, I know a TON of people that like her for who she is, not her "assets".

Modifié par shinobi602, 05 février 2010 - 10:22 .

[MerchantGOL]

TyDurden13 wrote...

Well Tali's fans are certainly the most vocal. I don't know that she is more popular. I bet if the devs looked at the game data for the most common romances pusued in ME2, it wouldn't be Tali.

Your all reallllly underestimating tali's popularity outside the boards

Modifié par MerchantGOL, 05 février 2010 - 10:23 .

[ShadyKat]

TyDurden13 wrote...

Well Tali's fans are certainly the most vocal. I don't know that she is more popular. I bet if the devs looked at the game data for the most common romances pusued in ME2, it wouldn't be Tali.

Keep telling yourself that.

[Wugger]

At the end of the day, it doesn't matter. I'd say Tali is more popular, but it may be more fan vocalage. Both are very popular characters so meh.

[BlueEyes_Austin]

Major-Shrinkage wrote...

EDarkness wrote...

I understand what you mean about Miranda, but Bioware has a habit of doing this.  An awesome looking babe that starts off as a total b***h, then somehow turns decent in the end.  For once I'd like them to make a woman like Kelly who is nice up front and stays that way until the end.  The reason I decided to go for Tali was because I didn't want to deal with Miranda's baggage in order to get to the good stuff.  At least with Tali she's nice from the beginning and doesn't get cold unless you do something bad to her (like tell the council about her father's experiments), or treat her like crap.  At the end of the day, I liked Miranda, but I didn't think she was worth trying to romance.

Exactly what im trying to convey. People dont like putting up with her baggage, hence why she takes a lot of critical reviews. However, Tali's history with Shepheard makes her love you all the way through. Though i will point out that she may not necessarily. She starts off pretty cold when you meet her on the first colony.

In other words, Miranda is written as a real woman, with a real history--including a real sexual history with Jacob--while Tali is basically written as a teenage virgin.  

[MerchantGOL]

BlueEyes_Austin wrote...

Major-Shrinkage wrote...

EDarkness wrote...

I understand what you mean about Miranda, but Bioware has a habit of doing this.  An awesome looking babe that starts off as a total b***h, then somehow turns decent in the end.  For once I'd like them to make a woman like Kelly who is nice up front and stays that way until the end.  The reason I decided to go for Tali was because I didn't want to deal with Miranda's baggage in order to get to the good stuff.  At least with Tali she's nice from the beginning and doesn't get cold unless you do something bad to her (like tell the council about her father's experiments), or treat her like crap.  At the end of the day, I liked Miranda, but I didn't think she was worth trying to romance.

Exactly what im trying to convey. People dont like putting up with her baggage, hence why she takes a lot of critical reviews. However, Tali's history with Shepheard makes her love you all the way through. Though i will point out that she may not necessarily. She starts off pretty cold when you meet her on the first colony.

In other words, Miranda is written as a real woman, with a real history--including a real sexual history with Jacob--while Tali is basically written as a teenage virgin.  

no miranda is wrten as your gneric sci fi heroine

[DarthRic]

axdorffe wrote...

I am not asking who is the better of the two, just basically who has gotten more attention so far? i was thinking it was probably tali but now ive seen alot of miranda love threads too. jw what you all think

Ashley

[Trystane75]

Actually, I like both characters.



Tali is a wonderful character, passionate about her believes, knows where her loyalties are - and she does have a great voice. However, she does not get along that well with a renegade Shepard.

But for my paragon Shepard she is a bit of a soulmate.



Miranda is complicated and troubled and that does make her believable and from my POV a great character. And she gets along well with both my renegade and paragon Shepards.



But if I had to choose only 1... Tali if I play paragon and Miranda if I play renegade. (you wont get a definite choice from me)

[ComTrav]

MerchantGOL wrote...

TyDurden13 wrote...

Well Tali's fans are certainly the most vocal. I don't know that she is more popular. I bet if the devs looked at the game data for the most common romances pusued in ME2, it wouldn't be Tali.

Your all reallllly underestimating tali's popularity outside the boards

Um....how else are you going to gauge a character's popularity?

I don't know hundreds/thousands of people IRL who have played this game.

It's not like the most popular ME2 character is up there with Barack Obama and Healthcare Reform on Pollingreports.com or Gallup.com.

[Elastica]

Here? Clearly Tali, although Miranda was more or less designed to be the "default" choice, so who knows what the real numbers are.

[Stonetwister]

No one can touch Tali. She is number one! WOOOOOO!!!!!!

[Sir Ulrich Von Lichenstien]

Neither of them, EDI is far superior to them in every way!




That was a joke

[challenger18]

BlueEyes_Austin wrote...

Major-Shrinkage wrote...

EDarkness wrote...

I understand what you mean about Miranda, but Bioware has a habit of doing this.  An awesome looking babe that starts off as a total b***h, then somehow turns decent in the end.  For once I'd like them to make a woman like Kelly who is nice up front and stays that way until the end.  The reason I decided to go for Tali was because I didn't want to deal with Miranda's baggage in order to get to the good stuff.  At least with Tali she's nice from the beginning and doesn't get cold unless you do something bad to her (like tell the council about her father's experiments), or treat her like crap.  At the end of the day, I liked Miranda, but I didn't think she was worth trying to romance.

Exactly what im trying to convey. People dont like putting up with her baggage, hence why she takes a lot of critical reviews. However, Tali's history with Shepheard makes her love you all the way through. Though i will point out that she may not necessarily. She starts off pretty cold when you meet her on the first colony.

In other words, Miranda is written as a real woman, with a real history--including a real sexual history with Jacob--while Tali is basically written as a teenage virgin.  

What sexual history with Jacob? The only content I can get out of either of them in like of MEG is Jacob just says "she requires a better man [or something like that] then I".

[Barquiel]

I prefer Miranda:wub:

[Jared_704]

Tali's been the fan favorite since ME1. This is a no brainer bro.

[ussbones]

This thread just proves its Tali... We have two threads now, yay.

[SkywardDescent]

ODST 3 wrote...

Everyone loves Tali because they can relate to her youth, insecurity, and inexperience. I like all the women equally, except Ashley. She's my number one girl.

Are you saying Tali fans are a bunch of lonely little kids?

If you are, I think lonely little kids would most likely flock to Miranda >_>


EDIT:
Damn, I forgot there were more pages- very, very late >_>

Modifié par SkywardDescent, 05 février 2010 - 11:31 .

[ShadyKat]

SkywardDescent wrote...

ODST 3 wrote...

Everyone loves Tali because they can relate to her youth, insecurity, and inexperience. I like all the women equally, except Ashley. She's my number one girl.

Are you saying Tali fans are a bunch of lonely little kids?

If you are, I think lonely little kids would most likely flock to Miranda >_>


EDIT:
Damn, I forgot there were more pages- very, very late >_>

Is it me, or is Tali not any of those things? She is young (24) but hardley a child. Inexperience?...In what?...Sex? Then yes, but in life she is the most travled person besides Samara on the team.

[DeathCultArm]

It doesn't matter who's more popualr, Miranda was the better character.

[ShadyKat]

DeathCultArm wrote...

It doesn't matter who's more popualr, Miranda was the better character.

If you mean as in more boring, then yes I agree.

[mac35]

ShadyKat wrote...

TyDurden13 wrote...

Well Tali's fans are certainly the most vocal. I don't know that she is more popular. I bet if the devs looked at the game data for the most common romances pusued in ME2, it wouldn't be Tali.

Keep telling yourself that.

Aaaand you can keep telling yourself otherwise...but the fact is that we really don't know since the boards themselves aren't a representative sample of the game's average player.

I wouldn't be surprised if Miranda was the most frequently romanced.