26 réponses à ce sujet

[Rubbish Hero]

When Startrek Voyager was aired I never really found Captian Janeway attractive.
It always struck me as a woman cast in the role of the man. Kate Mulgrew is an attractive woman however in that rule any attractivebess melted away. Erin Gray AKA Wilma from Buckrogers from (who audicenced for Janeway) was sexually atrractive but much like Seven Of Nine she was designed for titillation. I don't think it has anything to do with needing sexed up or being empowered, many woman on Battlestar Galatican also have an empowered role like Caption Janeway yet Starbuck, Boomer and that really old President woman are still attractive without any skin tight uniforms.

Did anyone who watched Star Voyager think "oh, she's pretty hot"?  Or just think of her as a man rather than a woman?

[Tyrax Lightning]

I like her. & yes I think she's attractive in a formal by-the-book kinda way. She doesn't have to be a party girl to look good. & lastly, no, I don't think of Starship Captain as a 'man' role, such a notion is ridiculous.



My 1 1/2 cents.

[SargeantRenegade]

I didn't find Captain Janeway to be attractive, but then again I'm not into women so that isn't a fair statement coming from me. Though to be honest, I don't think that Janeway was meant to be the "ship's babe" - I thought her role was more like a mother than anything else as the show went on. She took it on herself to help the people under her command grow (often taking a more "hands-on" approach with a few of them) and come together as a family as well as a crew.

Janeway didn't need to be sexy. She brought her own brand of femininity to the captain's chair, and she did it well.

[Pious_Augustus]

No Seven of Nine (Jeri Ryan) really out did her and the rest of the cast. It's too bad she was a casualty of Barrack Obama's rise to power. To think this young pretty star would go down after her EX Husband got in Obama's way and was winning the bid of Senate Seat against Obama in which the Liberal Media in full force for the first time ever had their sealed divorce records opened and with Jeri Ryan’s family smeared and their children embarrassed Jack Ryan stopped running against the Liberal God of Change Barrack Obama and Jeri Ryan went on to not getting much jobs and their kids went to therapy.

God, I remember those days in Chicago but hey at least when he ran for State Senate him winning by kicking everyone else off the ballot didn’t get much news since he was not as popular back then.

In Memory of Seven of Nine whose family dared to challenge he who is change!

Modifié par Pious_Augustus, 05 février 2010 - 08:46 .

[AntiChri5]

Janeway was a captain. And a woman. They are not mutually exclusive. I did not find her attractive. Leave politics out of this.

[Lotion Soronarr]

Attractive? No.



Repulsive, yes. I blame the writers.

[Dark Lilith]

no,but many others I did..yummy

[darkshadow136]

no but 7of9 made me want to be assimilated.

[Dark Lilith]

darkshadow136 wrote...

no but 7of9 made me want to be assimilated.

oh god yes!!!!!!!!

[Ponce de Leon]

Attractive? Well, strictly speaking, she does (or seem) have a nice body, but heck, I am too young for her anyway. I find her OK as a captain as well, and don't see why female couldn't be in these ranks.

Rather look at Picard, a Frenchman with English accent? That's a ridiculous idea to start with!

[bzombo]

Rubbish Hero wrote...

When Startrek Voyager was aired I never really found Captian Janeway attractive.
It always struck me as a woman cast in the role of the man. Kate Mulgrew is an attractive woman however in that rule any attractivebess melted away. Erin Gray AKA Wilma from Buckrogers from (who audicenced for Janeway) was sexually atrractive but much like Seven Of Nine she was designed for titillation. I don't think it has anything to do with needing sexed up or being empowered, many woman on Battlestar Galatican also have an empowered role like Caption Janeway yet Starbuck, Boomer and that really old President woman are still attractive without any skin tight uniforms.

Did anyone who watched Star Voyager think "oh, she's pretty hot"?  Or just think of her as a man rather than a woman?

attractive, yes. hot, no. seven of nine was hot. janeway was good looking and tough. if you like that kind of personality it probably would make her more attractive. she was pleasant looking, though, just very tough and proper.

[Lotion Soronarr]

dark-lauron wrote...

Attractive? Well, strictly speaking, she does (or seem) have a nice body, but heck, I am too young for her anyway. I find her OK as a captain as well, and don't see why female couldn't be in these ranks.
Rather look at Picard, a Frenchman with English accent? That's a ridiculous idea to start with!

You DARE to compare the greatness that is Ser Patrick Stewart character (Picard) with...that....thing cakked Janeway?!?!?!?!?!

Assasins have been notified. Enjoy your last hours of life.

[Jae Onasi]

Rubbish Hero wrote...
Did anyone who watched Star Voyager think "oh, she's pretty hot"?

No.

Rubbish Hero wrote...
Or just think of her as a man rather than a woman?

No.  Why would I think of her gender being any different than female just because she's a captain?

[Godak]

Voyager and Deep Space Nine are sh!t stains on an otherwise flawless pair of boxers known as Star Trek.



So, no. Janeway never got me excited.

[Rubbish Hero]

Deep Space 9 was the best startrek season 3 onward I feel.

Jae Onasi wrote...No.  Why would I think of her gender being any
different than female just because she's a captain?

She probably smokes a pipe.

Modifié par Rubbish Hero, 06 février 2010 - 05:41 .

[Rheannan]

Rubbish Hero wrote...

When Startrek Voyager was aired I never really found Captian Janeway attractive.

She's attractive, but that's not the same thing as sexually attractive. My answer to the topic's question is 'no', since I'm not male.

It always struck me as a woman cast in the role of the man.

That's just a bias. There isn't anything wrong with a female captain in a Star Trek series.

[Dark Lilith]

Rheannan wrote...

Rubbish Hero wrote...

When Startrek Voyager was aired I never really found Captian Janeway attractive.

She's attractive, but that's not the same thing as sexually attractive. My answer to the topic's question is 'no', since I'm not male.

It always struck me as a woman cast in the role of the man.

That's just a bias. There isn't anything wrong with a female captain in a Star Trek series.

indeed and nothing wrong with one woman loving another either...doubles my chances anyway! lol

[XianduSER]

I found her attractive, but i also have a thing for redheads so it's hard for me to judge her on a normal scale, and yes seven of nine was hot too, miss seeing jerry ryan on tv.

[Barrendall]

Godak wrote...

Voyager and Deep Space Nine are sh!t stains on an otherwise flawless pair of boxers known as Star Trek.

So, no. Janeway never got me excited.

That's your opinion...just because you yourself didn't enjoy or even like the shows doesn't mean they were crap.  Voyager was my favorite out of all the series but I didn't consider any of them bad.  Just as my tastes went towards "Wings"(my all time favorite sitcom) over "Friends" doesn't mean that "Friends" was crap just means I didn't like it personally.

[Godak]

Barrendall111 wrote...

Godak wrote...

Voyager and Deep Space Nine are sh!t stains on an otherwise flawless pair of boxers known as Star Trek.

So, no. Janeway never got me excited.

That's your opinion...

Yes, it is my opinion. This entire topic is about people giving there opinions as to why we do not find Janeway attractive (or vice a versa). There is no right or wrong answer. If you like Voyager, that's perfectly within your rights.

[Jae Onasi]

Dark Lilith wrote...
indeed and nothing wrong with one woman loving another either...doubles my chances anyway! lol

Aw, Dark Lilith, how can you worry about your chances?   I'd ask you out in a heartbeat if I weren't already straight happily married and living an ocean away.

Modifié par Jae Onasi, 07 février 2010 - 07:41 .

[rock_brm]

janeway? i'd hit it.

Modifié par rock_brm, 08 février 2010 - 01:50 .

[Lotion Soronarr]

Barrendall111 wrote...
That's your opinion...just because you yourself didn't enjoy or even like the shows doesn't mean they were crap.  Voyager was my favorite out of all the series but I didn't consider any of them bad.  Just as my tastes went towards "Wings"(my all time favorite sitcom) over "Friends" doesn't mean that "Friends" was crap just means I didn't like it personally.

Actually, if you were to just carefuly watch each episode of all shows and make a note of all plot holes, inconcistencies and bad acting,  DS9 and VOY come out with a way, WAAAY worse total.
Those things can be reasonably counted.
In this case, I consider my "oppinion" to be as objective as it can possibly be.

[Rubbish Hero]

Lotion Soronnar wrote...

Actually, if you were to just carefuly watch each episode of all shows and make a note of all plot holes, inconcistencies and bad acting,  DS9 and VOY come out with a way, WAAAY worse total.
Those things can be reasonably counted.
In this case, I consider my "oppinion" to be as objective as it can possibly be

.

Season 1-3 of Deep Space 9 is basically a poor mans Enterprise, onward the writing and acting and scope of the show is far greater than any of the other shows. The introduction of the Dominion and the use of long standing story-arcs elevated it above the other shows.

[Ponce de Leon]

Lotion Soronnar wrote...
You DARE to compare the greatness
that is Ser Patrick Stewart character (Picard) with...that....thing
cakked Janeway?!?!?!?!?!

Assasins have been notified. Enjoy your
last hours of life.

(I killed
the assassins and gave the bodies to the dogs! [smilie]../../../images/forum/emoticons/devil.png[/smilie])

Still, I don't think ST Voyager was badly acted, or what-else. In fact, I find it a pretty much enjoyable show.