Aller au contenu

Photo

Fanfiction Sucks


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
10369 réponses à ce sujet

#9176
thesnowtigress

thesnowtigress
  • Members
  • 116 messages
Umm, idiotic question here, but does AU = alternate universe???

Hehe.

And um, what is The Rescue?

#9177
Raonar

Raonar
  • Members
  • 1 180 messages

thesnowtigress wrote...

Umm, idiotic question here, but does AU = alternate universe???

Hehe.

And um, what is The Rescue?


Yes, Au means Alternate Universe.

As for The Rescue, it's Sialater's fanfiction ;)

#9178
inquartata02

inquartata02
  • Members
  • 355 messages

Raonar wrote...

inquartata02 wrote...

@Glor: I'm sorry! I just... next chapter, it will be resolved, I promise. I just wanted to do something a certain way and that meant a cliffhanger... and, er, you'll see later today. I'm sure it doesn't help any, but I felt bad doing it. And then I cowered and waited for pitchforks and torches from an angry "you wrote another cliffhanger" mob.


Why on EARTH would you feel bad for it? Cliffhangers are awesome, as long as you don't take half a year to get the next chapter out.

I don't feel nearly as bad about them when they're at the end of a chapter in a novel that's already written and published in its entirety. I mean, that way the reader can just go on merrily reading to find out what happens next. But... something in me just feels bad when it's at the end of a chapter in a serialized fic because it's making folks wait. It's just me, by the way, and a writing hangup I have. And an overly guilty conscience. I'm certainly not hammering on any other writer's way of writing. 

I also have some scary readers. Seriously, some of the reviews? Scary. Lots of anger. At the characters, mostly, but... yeah. Bit scary. :crying::?

Modifié par inquartata02, 07 mars 2011 - 05:12 .


#9179
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 817 messages
My fic was already AU, what with it being based on an in game decision that I never really made with my PC. Now it's mega AU with a little bit of "haw-haw!" thrown in.

And I write cliffhangers without even realizing they're cliffhangers until someone leaves a review that points it out. Not all the time, of course, and sometimes I do it knowingly. But usually it just happens because of how I structure chapters thematically and stylistically.

Modifié par SurelyForth, 07 mars 2011 - 05:27 .


#9180
inquartata02

inquartata02
  • Members
  • 355 messages
 I know when I tried to defend myself and be all, "But I don't always write cliffhangers!" after someone asked me if it were humanly possible for me not to write a cliffhanger, I had to go back to chapter *thinks* six or seven of a 50+ chapter fic. 
Okay, so that reviewer may have had a point. :whistle:

#9181
DreGregoire

DreGregoire
  • Members
  • 1 781 messages
No DA2 spoilers please. And like what you've already played the game? LOL

#9182
Raonar

Raonar
  • Members
  • 1 180 messages
Question: Branka left with about 300 people in the deep roads, right?

#9183
errant_knight

errant_knight
  • Members
  • 8 256 messages

inquartata02 wrote...

 I know when I tried to defend myself and be all, "But I don't always write cliffhangers!" after someone asked me if it were humanly possible for me not to write a cliffhanger, I had to go back to chapter *thinks* six or seven of a 50+ chapter fic. 
Okay, so that reviewer may have had a point. :whistle:


I feel a little bad about the end to part one of my story, knowing that people will have to wait for 8 or 9 months for part two. But I thought it was better to get the first half up than to take almost two years to write both parts, not knowing if there'd even be an audience for it after that time. Even if people drift away from DA fandom, I think they'll read a second installment if they want to know how it ends.

#9184
Glorfindel709

Glorfindel709
  • Members
  • 1 281 messages

inquartata02 wrote...

Raonar wrote...

inquartata02 wrote...

@Glor: I'm sorry! I just... next chapter, it will be resolved, I promise. I just wanted to do something a certain way and that meant a cliffhanger... and, er, you'll see later today. I'm sure it doesn't help any, but I felt bad doing it. And then I cowered and waited for pitchforks and torches from an angry "you wrote another cliffhanger" mob.


Why on EARTH would you feel bad for it? Cliffhangers are awesome, as long as you don't take half a year to get the next chapter out.

I don't feel nearly as bad about them when they're at the end of a chapter in a novel that's already written and published in its entirety. I mean, that way the reader can just go on merrily reading to find out what happens next. But... something in me just feels bad when it's at the end of a chapter in a serialized fic because it's making folks wait. It's just me, by the way, and a writing hangup I have. And an overly guilty conscience. I'm certainly not hammering on any other writer's way of writing. 

I also have some scary readers. Seriously, some of the reviews? Scary. Lots of anger. At the characters, mostly, but... yeah. Bit scary. :crying::?



I didnt mean to scare you!! =o

I love your story :D It's just Im very anxious to figure out what happens to Fiona... it would be heartbreaking for the Joining to go wrong right after Alistair finally really got to meet her... and my mind went :crying::crying::crying::crying::crying: WHHHHHHY to the cliffhanger :-p

The wait makes it all the sweeter... muhahahaha

#9185
Glorfindel709

Glorfindel709
  • Members
  • 1 281 messages
@Raonar It was around 200 to my knowledge, though I could be mistaken *shrugs*

@All responses to my question

My Mahariel Mage is not going to be chosen at the Tower in the traditional sense of the Magi Origin, He's going to be sent to fight with the mage contingent at Ostagar due to his aptitude with the more offensive casting plus his learning of the Sword and Staff mage combat style (CANON THANKS TO WITCH HUNT, BABY!). He'll be twenty eight years old, an Enchanter at the circle helping to teach Primal and spirit magic to higher level apprentices, and he's going to become infected with the taint during one of the battles before the final battle at Ostagar while fighting along side the Grey Warden contingent at the vanguard. The Wardens see his potential and put him through an emergency joining. And thus Mahariel Mage becomes a Warden! *banners and streamers*

I was also joking about him trying to help against Remille, that would be insanely mary stu-esque for an 11 year old to try and help some soldiers like Loghain and the King.... though I kind of do want him to meet Maric at some point (I personally have always admired Marics' growth [read:not his choice of places to have sex O.o] as a character and I want to have a reason for why my Warden would reaaally want to be able to keep Marics' Longsword rather than having Alistair keep it (until that bastard Eamon snatches it away as a legacy of the Theirin bloodline.... >.<))

Corker... I really want to lift that in some way to put a similar scene in my story.... It's just, I know that in the formative years being indoctrinated from a young age to believe that all humans are dangerous scum is going to take quite a bit of work to fix (Jowan, human teachers, fellow apprentices, people that come to the Tower) but I also think that since he's seen and lived in the outside world, he'd need examples from the wider world to see that not just those near the Tower are alright

#9186
inquartata02

inquartata02
  • Members
  • 355 messages

Glorfindel709 wrote...

I didnt mean to scare you!! =o

I love your story :D It's just Im very anxious to figure out what happens to Fiona... it would be heartbreaking for the Joining to go wrong right after Alistair finally really got to meet her... and my mind went :crying::crying::crying::crying::crying: WHHHHHHY to the cliffhanger :-p

The wait makes it all the sweeter... muhahahaha

It's cool. I'm mostly not scared. Well, of you, unless you were one of the folks who left ranty reviews. I mean, they were goodrants, but I was kind of :unsure: and :? when I read them. 

But thank you very much for reading! :happy:

Er, anyway. I updated.  *flees*

Modifié par inquartata02, 08 mars 2011 - 12:05 .


#9187
erynnar

erynnar
  • Members
  • 3 010 messages
SNORT! Inquartata you crack me up. You did have some very ranty sudo threatening reviews. But you are an awesome writer, so they have to go through me to get to you.

#9188
LupusYondergirl

LupusYondergirl
  • Members
  • 2 616 messages
@Inquartata: don't worry, you get used to those sort of reviews eventually. Sometimes that's three quarters of what I get. ;). (I assume the ones that say things like "damn it, woman, you'd better update soon!" mean it nicely. )
I did try and give my two most recently updated fics non-cliffhangers this time since I know I'll be too busy playing da2 to update for a bit.

#9189
DreGregoire

DreGregoire
  • Members
  • 1 781 messages
I'm going to try to remember to update my stories at least once a week while playing DA2. LOL. Try!

#9190
Corker

Corker
  • Members
  • 2 766 messages

Glorfindel709 wrote...

Corker... I really want to lift that in some way to put a similar scene in my story.... It's just, I know that in the formative years being indoctrinated from a young age to believe that all humans are dangerous scum is going to take quite a bit of work to fix (Jowan, human teachers, fellow apprentices, people that come to the Tower) but I also think that since he's seen and lived in the outside world, he'd need examples from the wider world to see that not just those near the Tower are alright


And it's all the more challenging since the nearby non-mage humans have been indoctrinated from a young age to think that all mages are dangerous scum. 

If you think the Tower has non-mage staff for the menial work, they're ideal.  They actually work near the mages and probably realize they're not fanged monsters.  Otherwise... I like Greagoir bunches, and I can imagine templars who - if not friendly with the mages - are at least... fair, and not unkind.  Otherwise, feel free to borrow the little fisher boy.  Glad you liked. :lol:

#9191
DreGregoire

DreGregoire
  • Members
  • 1 781 messages
So I noticed on the DAII Creations Forum we are only allowed to post links for our fanfiction, art, etc creations; so that nicely keeps the stories here :)

#9192
DreGregoire

DreGregoire
  • Members
  • 1 781 messages

Corker wrote...

Glorfindel709 wrote...

Corker... I really want to lift that in some way to put a similar scene in my story.... It's just, I know that in the formative years being indoctrinated from a young age to believe that all humans are dangerous scum is going to take quite a bit of work to fix (Jowan, human teachers, fellow apprentices, people that come to the Tower) but I also think that since he's seen and lived in the outside world, he'd need examples from the wider world to see that not just those near the Tower are alright


And it's all the more challenging since the nearby non-mage humans have been indoctrinated from a young age to think that all mages are dangerous scum. 

If you think the Tower has non-mage staff for the menial work, they're ideal.  They actually work near the mages and probably realize they're not fanged monsters.  Otherwise... I like Greagoir bunches, and I can imagine templars who - if not friendly with the mages - are at least... fair, and not unkind.  Otherwise, feel free to borrow the little fisher boy.  Glad you liked. :lol:


Remember that elderly mage who was getting Duncan's room ready? I don't think there are non-mage, chantry, or templar people in the circle tower. There was also that mage cleaning her own room, scrubbing floor. Now maybe it was just game mechanics but I don't think mages are in a position, or templars for that matter, to have servants or people not of their type that do menial labor.

#9193
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages

Raonar wrote...

thesnowtigress wrote...

Umm, idiotic question here, but does AU = alternate universe???

Hehe.

And um, what is The Rescue?


Yes, Au means Alternate Universe.

As for The Rescue, it's Sialater's fanfiction ;)


Yes, that's me.  OK, I'll wait to complain.  And I'd been trying very hard to make it NOT AU.

Modifié par Sialater, 08 mars 2011 - 02:01 .


#9194
Sialater

Sialater
  • Members
  • 12 600 messages
Ugh. I HATE chrome. This is what I said, but it got mixed up in the quotes.

Yes, that's me. OK, I'll wait to complain. And I'd been trying very hard to make it NOT AU.

ETA:  And now it's fixed????  *headdesk*

Modifié par Sialater, 08 mars 2011 - 02:03 .


#9195
LupusYondergirl

LupusYondergirl
  • Members
  • 2 616 messages
I've always stuck pretty close to the lore/cannon stuff, but I think my fic in and of itself was AU from the get-go since there was no Anders romance in-game.

#9196
errant_knight

errant_knight
  • Members
  • 8 256 messages

Sialater wrote...

Are we allowing DA2 spoilers at all? Cause I really wanna whine about them making The Rescue AU.

I feel very, very lucky that DA2 didn't affect Part One except for some slight rewriting at the last minute to allow for DA2 to affect part two. Of course, it completely gutted the plot I had in mind for part two, but I have time to figure out how I'm going to change it after I play and discover just how much impact it will have. It's already necessitated a major change, though, and the timeline will probably be somewhat off. 'Remnants' is a bit AU anyway, since Alistair survived execution, and the plot evolves from that. Also, I've given the NPCs the freedom to have opinions that differ with the warden. But I'm trying to keep it as close as possible to game lore.

#9197
erynnar

erynnar
  • Members
  • 3 010 messages
My Soulmates is completely AU, ROFL. So DA2 affects it not a jot. Which leaves me free to write for DA2 later. Right now Anders is in Orzammar with Kai, about to be dressed in Templar armor...tee hee.

#9198
Raonar

Raonar
  • Members
  • 1 180 messages
I also don't think there are non-mage servants. I got the feeling the Tranquil did most menial tasks (Owain: the storeroom had to be kept in order, or whatever he said). Mages probably have chores as well.

#9199
Maria13

Maria13
  • Members
  • 3 831 messages

DreGregoire wrote...

So I noticed on the DAII Creations Forum we are only allowed to post links for our fanfiction, art, etc creations; so that nicely keeps the stories here :)


'Tis true.  Just checked it myself plus there is nothing that says the Fics etc have to be specifically about DAII:

"This forum is for owners of Dragon Age II to discuss their fan creations
(links to artwork, music, fan fiction, etc) as well as fan created mods
and modding discussion. We do not allow fan fiction posted on these
forums, but links to fan fiction are allowed. Reading fan fiction,
viewing art and using fan mods is done at your own risk. These are fan
creations, not officially supported BioWare products."


So potentially we can all post links there.

#9200
Esbatty

Esbatty
  • Members
  • 3 760 messages

Maria13 wrote...

DreGregoire wrote...

So I noticed on the DAII Creations Forum we are only allowed to post links for our fanfiction, art, etc creations; so that nicely keeps the stories here :)


'Tis true.  Just checked it myself plus there is nothing that says the Fics etc have to be specifically about DAII:

"This forum is for owners of Dragon Age II to discuss their fan creations
(links to artwork, music, fan fiction, etc) as well as fan created mods
and modding discussion. We do not allow fan fiction posted on these
forums, but links to fan fiction are allowed. Reading fan fiction,
viewing art and using fan mods is done at your own risk. These are fan
creations, not officially supported BioWare products."


So potentially we can all post links there.


Aww but I just got used to reading longform fiction with the BSN formatting lol