234 réponses à ce sujet

[sergio71785]

Tali
.
.
.
Garrus
.
.
Mordin
Grunt
Legion
Thane
.
Jacob
.
Samara
.
Miranda
.
.
Jack
Zaeed

I added some space inbetween them to emphasis how much "'like' difference" there is between them for me.

Modifié par sergio71785, 08 février 2010 - 08:19 .

[hawat333]

1. Jack
2. Mordin
3. Garrus
4. Thane
5. Grunt (got a "raise" on my recent playthrough )
6. Miranda
7. Legion
8. Jacob
9. Samara
10. Zaeed
11. Tali


(Oh and lol on those who still whining about a lifelike argument with Ash/Kaidan after returning from the dead, under ex-enemy bannaers, without a single world to the women/men who was grieving you for two years)

Modifié par hawat333, 08 février 2010 - 08:17 .

[Mir Aven]

1. Garrus

2. Mordin

3. Thane

4. Legion

5. Grunt

6. Samara

7. Jack

8. Jacob

9. Tali

10. Miranda

11. Zaeed

[Daerog]

So hard to choose an exact order...

1. Mordin

2. Garrus

3. Tali

4. Zaeed

5. Jack

6. Thane

7. Miranda

8. Legion

9. Jacob

10. Samara

11. Grunt

I like them all, though. They will all always live in my playthroughs, I refuse to let any of them die. Hope to see at least a cameo of each one in ME3...

[shoemy89]

1. Garrus
2. Mordin
3. Legion
4. Grunt
5. Tali
6. Thane
7. Jack
8. Samara
9. Jacob
10. Miranda

And I didn't even download Zaeed yet so... yeah.

[Miniazza]

Best



1) Wrex (So upset he wasn't a squad member in this game, but my most favourite Krogan was doing something he believed and was doing it well. This has to be my biggest gripe with ME2)

2)Garrus (Garrus is cool. Nuf said really)

3) Tali (Not so much from ME1, but definately so much better in ME2)

4) Thane (This guy is very very cool. Definately the best "new" character)

5) Legion (If we do not see more of this guy in ME3, this is a crime worthy of jail time)

6) Mordin (This guy is awesome for simply giving me doctors advice over Tali)

7) Liara (Her badself from ME2 would be most welcome in ME3....as a team member)



Needs work but could be awesome



8) Samara (There is something very interesting about her but needs more fleshing out. I so would have had her as my LI over the rest, even Tali)

9) Jacob (Bit more to this guy and I could have warmed to him. Not really interested in his daddy issues

10) Miranda (Cerberus-to-the-core-until the-end-scene chick needed more. She had a lot already but something was missing, I don't know what)



Will be happy to never see again



11) Ashley (her anti alien stuff is just wrong. only saved her if I wasn't playing as a soldier)

12) Alenko (I hated this guy the minute I saw him. Was a total tool in ME2)





Wishes had never been created:



13) Zaeed (tool)

14) Grunt (this is a close call with bottom spot simply becuase this muppet was a replacement for the almighty Wrex. However I did actually use Grunt at times unlike....

15) Jack is by far the most horrible character ever created in the history of gaming ever. EVER. She died in my first play through and I'll admit I was upset....at the fact I didn't get to see it!!!

[Emperor Mars]

1/2 Tali/Legion
3. Garrus
4. Space Kermit
5. Mordin
6.Zaeed
7. Grunt
8. Jacob/samara
9.  Jack
10. Space Morrigan
Reasons! 
Tali---well rounded, well made character
Legion--I love robot characters, and they hit the nail on the head with Legion, and his little bits about the geth are cool
Garrus---basically a turian version of shepard
Space Kermit---like the race and his story
Mordin--like his comments and his morals (do what is nessecary but not the worst option)
Zaeed---like the fact we got an expierenced member of the squad
Grunt--simply liked him more than the other characters
Jacob--liked the story and character, but feeled like a fill in character, sorta bland.
samara----I dont think she
was a memerable character, so I didnt hate her or like the
character...it was like jacob sort of a fill in
Jack--dont buy the "tough ****" personality
Space Morrigan--hated the personality and her face fell well into the uncanny valley imo

Modifié par Emperor Mars, 08 février 2010 - 08:47 .

[ZetaSheperd]

1. Miranda

2. Jack

3. Tali

4. Liara

5. The girl who sais you've got new messages (don't remember her name)



Girls characters on this game are amazing!

[Lord Shadowsong]

gutty47 wrote...

I find it quite interesting that the maleshep LIs are usually located at the top (for thier preferred LI) and bottom (for the rest). I wonder if this is good character design? Its better for a character to be hated than for them to evoke no emotion at all.

Most the female LI's excluding Garus suck. I just wish Zaeed had a real dialogue option, hed be way higher probably. I know a ton of people loved canderos and hes basically canderos that you cant interact with.

[Collider]

1. Tali

2. Mordin

3. Jacob

4. Garrus

5. Zaeed

6. Grunt

7. Samara

8. Jack

9. Thane

10. Miranda



Probably throw in Legion somewhere in the top numbers if I ever decide to recruit him.

[4lice4nn]

1. Mordin

2. Thane

3. Tali

4. Miranda

5. Garrus

6. Legion

7. Samara

8. Grunt

9. Jack

10. Zaeed

11. Jacob

[pfhughes]

1. Tali (Favorite from ME1 and romance option)
2. Garrus (My unofficial 2nd in command)
3. Jack (grew on me, interesting story)
4. Miranda (Redeemed herself at the end, plus a couple of points for the butt)
5. Mordin (Best dialog but didn't use much in missions)
6. Legion (Wished I could have recruited earlier, gets points for his dancing)

Character I didn't use much:
7. Jacob
8.Grunt
9. Samara
10. Thane (Can see using more in next play through, but got him next to last) 

Never used:
11. Zaeed (Enjoyed some of the stories but didn't feel like a full squad member)

Next play through going to try and exhaust all the dialog options, which would probably change my rankings.

[redloz]

Top 3:

Jack
Grunt (It's a bit weird but I found him quite sweet. I liked helping him find his purpose, and when he calls Shep 'Battlemaster' it made me feel rather proud.)
Legion

Middle 4:

Mordin (used him alot, he was great.)
Tali and Garrus (so much improvment from ME1, liked them both.)
Samara

Last Place:

Jacob (I tried to romance him, but I suppose my Femshep was too renegade. Even so, the guy was pretty dull.)
Thane (I liked him but I never used him - until I sent him down the vent during the suicide mission and he got a slug to the face. Poor guy.)
Miranda (Again, just not all that interesting. Might be different for a DudeShep.)

Modifié par redloz, 08 février 2010 - 10:41 .

[Deco Bryl]

01. Tali
02. Samara
03. Legion
04. Mordin
05. Garrus
06. Grunt
07. Miranda
08. Thane
09. Jacob
10. Zaeed
11. Subject Zero

Modifié par Deco Bryl, 08 février 2010 - 10:30 .

[HAGA NAGA]

1. Tali
2. Garrus
3. Jack
4. Thane
5. Samara
6. Legion
7. Zaeed
8. Miranda
9. Mordin
10. Jacob
11. Grunt

4-7 are honestly about dead even for me
and i pretty much love them all except Jacob & Grunt (they're ok i guess)

[Makariel]

1. Mordin

2. Miranda

3. Grunt

4. Samara

5. Tali

6. Garrus

7. Thane

8. Jacob

9. Legion

10. Jack

11. Zaeed



Places 1-6 are pretty even for me, with Mordin being full of win for his song

Zaeed is far off, because even Jack has at least some human emotions while Zaeed is what I would call sick. And I played Renegade.

[HwyCrossingFrog]

1. Tali
2. Mordin
3. Garrus
4. Legion
5. Thane
6. Miranda
7. Grunt
8. Jack
9. Samara
10. Jacob
11. Zaeed

[LOST GAM3R]

1. Tali

2. Garrus

3. Mordin

4. Legion

5. Grunt

6. Thane

7. Jack

8. Jacob

9. Samara

10. Miranda

[IccaRa]

I actually like all the team mates, so my list is pretty condensed.



1. Thane

2. Garrus / Mordin / Grunt / Samara

3. Tali / Miranda / Legion

4. Jack

5. Zaeed / Jacob



1 - 3 = love. They engaged me, surprised me. forced my involvement.

4 - 5 = still like them, but they haven't wowed me yet. Always willing to give a character another chance, though.

[StreetlightEagle]

Oooh this is a tough one.



1) Liara

2) Thane

3) Garrus

4) Mordin

5) Legion

6) Wrex

7) Samara

8) Jack

9) Grunt

10) Miranda

11) Zaeed

12) Ashley

13) Jacob

14) Carth

15) Tali



Bioware are incredibly good at making quirky characters yet can never get the starting off 'human buddies' right. Why do characters need a gimmick (assassin lizard man and robot, for example) to be interesting?

[boardnfool86]

• Jacob
• Garrus
• Wrex
• Thane
• Kaidan
• Grunt
• Mordin
• Legion
• Miranda
• Jack
• Tali
• Ashley (I romanced her too... haha)
• Samara
• Liara
• Zaeed
• Upcoming DLC human assasain (she has files in the game already anyways)

[*]Edit - put in 4 missing ME1 team members

Modifié par boardnfool86, 08 février 2010 - 11:32 .

[Malanek]

In general I liked the ME2 characters more, I just think they were more interesting



Ashley (Didn't like her as a person, loved her as a character, very believable and got a strong reaction)

Mordin

Jack

Tali (ME1 she was boring would be down the bottom, much, much better in ME2)

Legion

Miranda

Grunt

Samara

Garrus (again better in ME2)

Thane

Liara

Kaidan

Wrex

Jacob

[Chuck_Vu]

Wrex
Mordin
Jack
Garrus
Thane
Miranda
Grunt
Kaiden
Legion
Ashley
Liara
Tali

Modifié par Chuck_Vu, 09 février 2010 - 01:13 .

[Jackal904]

1) Jack (She's the most unique and deepest character in the game)
2) Garrus
3) Tali
4) Mordin
5) Grunt
6) Miranda
7) Thane
8) Legion
9) Samara
10) Jacob
11) Zaeed

Modifié par Jackal904, 09 février 2010 - 01:19 .