nitefyre410 wrote...
The_KFD_Case wrote...
Xena_Shepard wrote...
Indie Thompson wrote...
GuyWithFace wrote...
Xena_Shepard wrote...
They're MACHINES! They might be self-aware but they feel nothing. >.<
Exactly. Which makes the 'peaceful resolution' that much easier to attain. The Quarians simply need to understand that the Geth have no feelings of remorse, hatred, or revenge. They just need to find a conclusion that benefits both sides.
They need to reach a peaceful and mutually useful agreement.
And i am sure that the geth are willing to work something out.
They are all about the logic, while quarians are still pretty emotional about everything that happened.
Let's put it this way, if your toaster, which is a damn machine, suddenly rose up and kicked you out of your own home, how would that make you feel?
The fact that the Geth are soulless machines doesn't seem to be getting across well to you people, them being self-aware doesn't make them people or give them souls or feelings, it simply means they KNOW they exist.
Hm. So what exactly is it about us organics that proves we have a soul? We are aware that we exist and we appear to conclude that this means we have souls despite having no empirical evidence to validate it. One could argue we are nothing more than an unlikely formula of chemical signals, flashes of nerve endings sheltered by flesh and supported by bones.![]()
And two back you up on this... Can anyone of the two qouted posters before even define what a soul is? Before you can say some one does not have something you have to be able to define what the something is.
No one will ever be able to define what a soul is, or at least agree on it for long. Just like when I ask people to define God and they say "energy", and I ask them if a lump of coal is God, then they just give me a deer-stuck-in-headlights look. I think what is more important is self-awareness and sentience, the definition of a soul can vary from one person to the next, sentience can be more easily quantified.




Ce sujet est fermé

Retour en haut






