kazic284 wrote...
Pretty sure he/she was joking Errant
Yes, that was my way of saying lets keep this thread to real discussion, not one liners.
kazic284 wrote...
Pretty sure he/she was joking Errant
SusanStoHelit wrote...
Ibby1kanobi wrote...
Quick Question: I was told that even if you refuse the Dark ritual, she will still be seen with a baby at the end of the game if you romanced her at any point in the game....even if you broke it off and chose Leliana....true?
* If you are a male warden, and you romanced Morrigan, and did the Ritual - Old God baby.
* If you are a male warden, and you romanced Morrigan, and refused the Ritual - baby, but not an old god one (you did have sex with her, after all).
* If you are a female warden, and you have someone else do the Ritual - Old God baby.
* If you are a female warden, and you refuse the Ritual - no baby at all (because M. didn't have sex with anyone).
[Edited for clarity and formatting.]
If she's stealing them, I suspect she has a means of scoping out whether they have magic or not before she takes them.Doyle41 wrote...
Also, if Flemeth was having or stealing children, there is no guarantee that they would be mages. That would certainly encourage the sacrifice of these particular children if the had no magic.
This makes sense with one exception... Morrigan states that the child has to be conceived by a grey warden so the child will carry the taint, this is what pulls the old gods soul from the Archdemon into the child and not into other wardens. This indicates that, at least when using the ritual, the taint is passed on to the child. Whether or not the child outgrows the taint later on is never mentioned.draxynnus wrote...
From my memory of the discussion about the ritual, the whole point was that the soul of the Old God would be in an untainted body and thus cleansed.
It's also worth noting that while Grey Wardens have reduced fertility, they can still have children, and those children aren't automatically Grey Wardens - it seems that the taint isn't passed on.
TheLion36 wrote...
This makes sense with one exception... Morrigan states that the child has to be conceived by a grey warden so the child will carry the taint, this is what pulls the old gods soul from the Archdemon into the child and not into other wardens. This indicates that, at least when using the ritual, the taint is passed on to the child. Whether or not the child outgrows the taint later on is never mentioned.draxynnus wrote...
From my memory of the discussion about the ritual, the whole point was that the soul of the Old God would be in an untainted body and thus cleansed.
It's also worth noting that while Grey Wardens have reduced fertility, they can still have children, and those children aren't automatically Grey Wardens - it seems that the taint isn't passed on.
Modifié par errant_knight, 12 février 2010 - 08:46 .
I remember her saying that the child could handle the soul and that the tainted part of the soul would be cleansed. I can't really remember her speaking about the grey warden taint being destroyed (this could be destroyed at the same time the soul is cleansed tho), however I know the child won't be simply tainted otherwise the soul would become the next Archdemon... I've always wondered however if the child would become taint immune somehow, imagine an old god that couldn't be tainted again.errant_knight wrote...
Morrigan also explains how the taint is destroyed althoth I don't remember the details. Sorry, it's late.But the child is untainted.
Modifié par TheLion36, 12 février 2010 - 08:48 .
errant_knight wrote...
I always thought she had eyes like a wolf. I figured it was reflective of her shapechanger abilities.
I remember Morrigan saying that Flemeth had once been young and beautiful, but not that she'd seen it. That would be a huge game changer, because it would mean that Morrigan is thousands of years old, too. I've suspected that, but didn't think there was any proof. Do you remember the exact words and where this was?
PC: She was not always as old as she is now, was she?
Morrigan: As a matter of act, I remember her being younger once. She had black hair much like my own, long and lustrous.
Morrigan: But how could that be if she is centuries old? Has she become wizened only recently? Or are the tales of her legend only that and nothing more?

Modifié par TheLion36, 12 février 2010 - 10:54 .
TheLion36 wrote...
I remember her saying that the child could handle the soul and that the tainted part of the soul would be cleansed. I can't really remember her speaking about the grey warden taint being destroyed (this could be destroyed at the same time the soul is cleansed tho), however I know the child won't be simply tainted otherwise the soul would become the next Archdemon... I've always wondered however if the child would become taint immune somehow, imagine an old god that couldn't be tainted again.
(Its been a while since I've done the ritual bit besides just going through a few sentences so I might have forgotten something she said as well).
Grimauld wrote...
But in any ending other than the ritual- a warden dies with the old-gods soul. So Morrigan may have a baby from an earlier tryst but it won't have any connection to the archdemon, right?
master-fluff wrote...
I remember this from somewhere too. But I've just reloaded and played the conversation with Morrigan a few times and can't find it. Here's what Morrigan says about the child:
"The child will bear the taint, and when the AD is slain, it's essence will seek out the child like a beacon."
In response to the Q about what do she intends to do with this child when you insist knowing: "The child will represent freedom for an ancient power, a chance to be reborn apart from the taint. Is that not reason enough to do it?"
In reponse to the Q asking if the child will be evil: "Allow me to say that what I seek is the essence of the old God that once was and not the dark forces that corrupted it. Some things are worth preserving in this world. Make of that what you will."
When you refuse and she asks if you will not reconsider, PC can say "And bring some demon-spawn into the world ? Never !", Morrigan says "Then you are a fool. I will not stand by and watch you waste this opportunity." Morrigan exits stage left.
So that makes it perfectly clear !
draxynnus wrote...
Susan: We don't know if there's a blood link between Morrigan and Flemeth. In fact, even Morrigan seems to think it was more likely that she was adopted (possibly against the will of her biological parents) rather than being the child of Flemeth's womb.
Modifié par master-fluff, 12 février 2010 - 12:04 .
Here's the quote:SusanStoHelit wrote...
Confusing, no? I seem to recall David Gaider saying that the children of Grey Wardens are not born with the taint; of course, who knows what the ritual does?
Could the child be tainted when conceived - but not tainted when born? Possible, I suppose, if Morrigan has some other ritual to cleanse the taint from the child. Or possibly Urthemiel can cleanse the taint (being a god) if he is awake. This does not, however, explain my vague memory of DG saying that the children of wardens are not born tainted. After all, the mothers of those children wouldn't have an Old God or Flemeth/Morrigan around to cleanse the baby.
Perhaps it's just a 'bad' dialogue like the Alistair hardening one - and the first part should say "the child will seem to bear the taint"?
So, normally, a child of a Grey Warden isn't tainted - it seems the ritual may have done something to change that, however, or at least make it seem tainted as you say.David Gaider wrote...
A Grey Warden can have a child... just not with another Grey Warden. So in the case of Alistair being married to a female PC the only possible result is no heir (unless Alistair has a child with someone other than his wife, I suppose). Grey Wardens have a limited chance of conception with a non-Grey Warden, but it does happen... and the child is not tainted in any fashion.
Interesting parallel with Odin there...master-fluff wrote...
An ancient elven god, Dirthamen, Keeper of the Secrets, had 2 raven servants. One was Fear, the other Deceit. The elven gods are now said to be sealed away by the trickery of the elven dread wolf god, Fen'Harel, so the ravens lost their master and presumably are now free. So in addition to the Flemeth-raven thing, whose battle cry is "You shall learn to fear me !" and who wears black feathers on her robes ?
Curlain wrote...
Also though, I think Morrigan is more inspired by the Irish mythological figure of the same name (and variants of that name) that was possibly once a Celtic deity.
master-fluff wrote...
An ancient elven god, Dirthamen, Keeper of the Secrets, had 2 raven servants. One was Fear, the other Deceit.
They are, now that you mention it. There's another parallel in that Odin had wisdom, magic, and prophecy among his responsibilities, which serves as another parallel with Dirthamen's identity as the keeper of secrets.SusanStoHelit wrote...
master-fluff wrote...
An ancient elven god, Dirthamen, Keeper of the Secrets, had 2 raven servants. One was Fear, the other Deceit.
As draxynnus says, interesting parallel with Odin - though his were Thought and Memory, as I recall.
draxynnus wrote...
They are, now that you mention it. There's another parallel in that Odin had wisdom, magic, and prophecy among his responsibilities, which serves as another parallel with Dirthamen's identity as the keeper of secrets.
master-fluff wrote...
The other thing is that I understand Flemeth's grimoire has an image of a tree on it (although couldn't find reference to it in the wiki and can't remember it directly).
Modifié par TheLion36, 12 février 2010 - 12:37 .
Modifié par SusanStoHelit, 12 février 2010 - 09:22 .
Curlain wrote...
I don't think we are or should ever get absolute confirmation of the existence of the Maker, or the elven god (or even any absolute confirmation on the true nature of the Old Gods), which a war between these deities would provide. I like that belief in the deities in this game is a matter of faith, there are things that those who believe can look to as confirmation of their belief but that others can look at very differently and disagree.
So a another figure rising to appose the Andraste figure with their own movement would be interesting, but I think the writers should maintain the ambiguity of the divine in Thedas, so it remains a matter of faith, not fact, as it is in many other fantasy settings.
Modifié par Curlain, 12 février 2010 - 10:09 .