475 réponses à ce sujet

[naspatria]

Ashley - 9
Kaiden -3
Wrex - 7
Garrus - 10
Tali - 9
Liara - 7
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 5
Mordin -9
Grunt - 7
Jack - 6
Thane - 7
Samara - 7
Morinth - 7
Legion - 9
Zaeed - 5

[ushae]

Ashley - 5

Kaiden - 8

Wrex - 8

Garrus - 9

Tali - 10

Liara - 9

Miranda - 5

Jacob - 7

Mordin - 10

Grunt - 7

Jack - 8

Thane - 8

Samara - 8

Morinth - 5

Legion - 9

Zaeed - 5

[VettoRyouzou]

Ashley - 1 ((I was a soldier she just got in my way))
Kaiden -7
Wrex - 9
Garrus -8
Tali - 10
Liara - 4
Miranda -4
Jacob - 2
Mordin -7
Grunt - 9
Jack - 2
Thane -8
Samara -5
Morinth -0
Legion - 9
Zaeed -1

[XX55XX]

adriano_c wrote...

XX55XX wrote...

I am just curious to how people rate the characters. Don't worry, within the next two weeks, I will publish a big report for all to see. Remember, this is a survey, not a census. But, according to certain statistical theorems, the more samples that are gathered, the more the sample mean will be closer to the actual population mean score for these characters.

How in-depth will these results be? Simply mean, median, SD, etc.?

Or can we expect something more interesting such as, "Those who voted Mordin on average over 8, voted for Samara on average less than 5", or something along those lines?

I doubt it. I really don't know how to use SPSS well enough to calculate those relationships for you. But, it certainly would be interesting to see...

This inputting data is really a pain. I have only 86 data sets now inputted, and even more are coming in! On top of that, I have a five page paper to write... lol... I should concentrate on that instead...

I plan to close this poll tomorrow and input whatever remaining data within the next 10 days or so and release a report by March for you guys.

Thank you to everyone who has voted so far!

[Bratinov]

Ashley -1

Kaiden - 1

Wrex - 4

Garrus - 6

Tali - 10

Liara - 8 (ME2 ruined Liara for me)

Miranda - 4

Jacob - 6

Mordin - 7

Grunt - 2

Jack - 8

Thane - 2 (i hate his voice)

Samara - 4

Morinth - 7

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 1

[AvalonTLW]

Ashley - 4
Kaiden - 6
Wrex -  10
Garrus - 10
Tali -  6
Liara - 6
Miranda - 8
Jacob - 6
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 10
Jack - 5
Thane - 7
Samara - 8
Morinth - never used her.
Legion -  7
Zaeed - 5

This is out of their personality.

[Ebolha]

Ashley 7

Kaiden 4

Wrex 9

Garrus 8

Tali 8

Liara 7

Miranda 9

Jacob 7

Mordin 10

Grunt 8

Jack 3

Thane 9

Samara 9

Morint NA

Legion 6

Zaeed 5

[Xarxemas]

Ashley - 8
Kaiden - 0
Wrex - 10
Garrus - 10
Tali - 7 (Way better in ME2, I never used her in ME1)
Liara - 2 (Disliked her immensely, liking her more in the comics and on Ilium)
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 6
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 6
Jack - 5
Thane - 7
Samara - 6
Morinth - 4
Legion - 8
Zaeed - 1 (Ugly ******, seemed really under developed and awful imo)

HATED Kaiden with a vengeance. I've pledged to let him die on virmire EVERY play through, lol.

Modifié par Xarxemas, 09 février 2010 - 04:46 .

[Lao Dan]

Ashley -  7
Kaiden - 5
Wrex -  10
Garrus - 7
Tali - 2
Liara - 7
Miranda -7
Jacob - 5
Mordin -5
Grunt - 9
Jack - 5
Thane -9
Samara -3
Morinth -na
Legion - 6
Zaeed -1

If you are allowing zeros make Zaeed a 0.  You couldn't talk to him at all. 

Modifié par Lao Dan, 09 février 2010 - 04:45 .

[Berto1]

Ashley - 6

Kaiden - 5

Wrex - 6

Garrus - 9

Tali - 10

Liara - 7

Miranda - 6

Jacob - 4

Mordin - 8

Grunt - 3

Jack - 6

Thane - 7

Samara - 5

Morinth - Never used her

Legion - 9

Zaeed - 3

[xMister Vx]

So, let's say this scale is only for ME characters. Not relative to other BioWare games, or my own ideals of party NPCs. Also, I'll say right away that these ratings are half-objective, half-subjective. For instance, even though Ashley and Kaidan (it's an A! not an E!!) get around the same amount of character development, they get different results. This is also based on their appearances and behaviour in both games (so Wrex for example gets points for that).

Ashley - 4
Kaiden - 6
Wrex - 7 
Garrus - 10
Tali - 10 
Liara - 7 
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 6 
Mordin - 9
Grunt - 6 
Jack - 6 
Thane - 8
Samara - 8
Morinth - 2*
Legion - 8 
Zaeed - 3*


*Note that these two aren't even real party members, to my mind... they get points "for participation".


P.S. I believe it would be wiser to share a "preliminary" report, because if the thread dies, then it's obvious that the users' interest has gone away.

[XX55XX]

xMister Vx wrote...

So, let's say this scale is only for ME characters. Not relative to other BioWare games, or my own ideals of party NPCs. Also, I'll say right away that these ratings are half-objective, half-subjective. For instance, even though Ashley and Kaidan (it's an A! not an E!!) get around the same amount of character development, they get different results. This is also based on their appearances and behaviour in both games (so Wrex for example gets points for that).

Ashley - 4
Kaiden - 6
Wrex - 7 
Garrus - 10
Tali - 10 
Liara - 7 
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 6 
Mordin - 9
Grunt - 6 
Jack - 6 
Thane - 8
Samara - 8
Morinth - 2*
Legion - 8 
Zaeed - 3*


*Note that these two aren't even real party members, to my mind... they get points "for participation".


P.S. I believe it would be wiser to share a "preliminary" report, because if the thread dies, then it's obvious that the users' interest has gone away.

Look a few pages back. I did share some initial data.

[Kabraxal]

Ashley - 10

Miranda - 10

Tali - 10

Mordin - 9

Garrus - 9

Thane - 9

Kaidan - 8

Jack - 8 (paragon romance only, otherwise a 6)

Jacob - 8

Wrex - 8

Grunt - 7

Legion - 7 (too little there)

Samara - 7

Morinth - 6

Liara - 5 (without proper explanation of personality change, 8 with ME1 only)

Zaaede - 0 space the worthless excriment.

[We Tigers]

The characters in ME2 were, to my surprise, much better developed than the ME1 crew, and the scores of the ME1-only crew suffered by comparison (with the exception of Wrex, who is the gold standard for everyone).  I think Legion could have been higher if we didn't pick him up so late, but what was there was fascinating.   In ME2, Thane was really the only character I liked less than expected.  His spazzy memories with the fisheye lens effect were the blurst. 

Ashley - 4
Kaiden - 4
Wrex - 10
Garrus - 9
Tali - 8
Liara - 6
Miranda - 9
Jacob - 7
Mordin - 9
Grunt - 8
Jack - 6
Thane - 5
Samara - 7
Morinth - 2
Legion - 7
Zaeed - 3

[bobtheorc]

Ashley - 8

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 10

Garrus - 7

Tali - 8

Liara - 8

Miranda - 7

Jacob - 6

Mordin - 8

Grunt - 4

Jack - 9

Thane - 7

Samara - 6

Morinth - 7

Legion - 9

Zaeed - 5

[GarethLorn]

Ashley - 6

Kaiden - 5

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 10

Tali - 10

Liara - 1

Miranda - 5

Jacob - 5

Mordin - 10

Grunt - 7

Jack - 7

Thane - 9

Samara - 4

Morinth - 5

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 7

[Benji1306]

Ashley - 8
Kaiden - 3
Wrex -  9
Garrus - 10
Tali -  8
Liara -  5
Miranda - 8
Jacob -  7
Mordin - 10
Grunt -  9
Jack -  2
Thane - 8
Samara - 7
Morinth - (NA)
Legion -  10
Zaeed - 6

Modifié par Benji1306, 09 février 2010 - 07:31 .

[TheEdders]

Ashley - 2
Kaiden - 5
Wrex - 6
Garrus - 9
Tali - 8
Liara - 6
Miranda - 5
Jacob - 7.5
Mordin - 9.5
Grunt - 3
Jack - 7
Thane - 8
Samara - 6
Morinth - 6
Legion - 8.5
Zaeed - 3

[beserker7]

Ashley - 6
Kaiden - 5
Wrex -  10
Garrus - 9
Tali - 7
Liara - 9
Miranda - 10
Jacob - 5
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 9
Jack - 1
Thane - 9
Samara - 10
Morinth - 9
Legion - 8
Zaeed - don't have DLC access yet. Damn 100 dollar wireless 360 adaptor.

[IccaRa]

Ashley - 9
Kaiden - 7
Wrex - 8
Garrus - 9
Tali - 8
Liara - 6
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 5
Mordin - 10
Grunt - 8
Jack - 6
Thane - 10
Samara - 10
Morinth - 6
Legion - 9
Zaeed - 5

Modifié par IccaRa, 09 février 2010 - 07:44 .

[Justin2k]

Ashley - 9
Kaiden - 4
Wrex - 8
Garrus - 9
Tali - 10
Liara - 1
Miranda - 9
Jacob - 4
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 6
Jack - 7
Thane - 5
Samara - 7
Morinth - 7
Legion - 8
Zaeed - 6

Modifié par Justin2k, 09 février 2010 - 08:01 .

[SparksX]

Ashley - 5

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 9

Tali - 10

Liara - 9

Miranda - 2

Jacob - 6

Mordin - 10

Grunt - 5

Jack - 3

Thane - 7

Samara - 7

Morinth - 6

Legion - 10

Zaeed - 6

[JRCHOharry]

Ashley - 8

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 8

Garrus - 6

Tali - 5

Liara - 4

Miranda - 8

Jacob - 8

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 5

Jack - 3

Thane - 6

Samara - 9

Morinth - 1

Legion - 7

Zaeed -7

[SelphieSK]

Ashley - 4
Kaiden - 7
Wrex - 9
Garrus - 8
Tali - 6
Liara - 4
Miranda - 5
Jacob - 1
Mordin - 10
Grunt - 7
Jack - 7
Thane - 8
Samara - 9
Morinth - 4
Legion - 10
Zaeed -3

[The Governator]

Ashley -6
Kaiden -8
Wrex - 7
Garrus -8
Tali -10 <3
Liara -4
Miranda -5
Jacob -5
Mordin -4
Grunt -4
Jack -2
Thane -5
Samara -4
Morinth -1
Legion -2
Zaeed -(n/a...I cannot recruit him)



1 is the lowest rating, and 10 is the highest.