475 réponses à ce sujet

[LordMyaora]

Ashley - 6, The better of the two human romance options. For some reason Ashley always seemed very real.
Kaiden - 4 A cheap one, even tells you to go to the bridge when you finish the romance scene. Pathetic.
Wrex - 10 Wrex is king. He's a noble leader, a brutal warrior, and a diplomatic mind. Wrex is the ultimate krogan.
Garrus - 8 I liked Garrus, hes like Robin Hood.
Tali - 7 Tali's character is not one I really like.
Liara - 7 Liara was nice, her character was very selfless and sweet. Until ME 2 that is.
Miranda - 6 Too typical.
Jacob - 5 Boring...
Mordin - 9 A singing Salarian scientist, with an awesome Loyal quest.
Grunt - 7 Wrex, but with more brute and less dimplomat. Not quite as awesome, but still great.
Jack - 9 I for one loved Jack.
Thane - 8 Thane was undeniably a strong character. With the whole ''Im dying'' thing going on he made for a strong one.
Samara - 8 Personal Favorite.
Morinth -7 Not as awesome as Samara, still a little more vile.
Legion -9 Very Gethy, very awesome.
Zaeed - 3 Bland.

Modifié par LordMyaora, 09 février 2010 - 10:09 .

[RobRam10]

Ashley -7

Kaiden -7

Wrex - 10

Garrus -10

Tali - 9

Liara - 8

Miranda -7

Jacob - 8

Mordin -10

Grunt - 7

Jack - 6

Thane -7

Samara -8

Morinth -6

Legion - 10

Zaeed -10

[NuHPgn]

Ashley - 7

Kaiden - 5

Wrex - 6

Garrus - 8

Tali - 9

Liara - 6

Miranda - 7

Jacob - 5

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 6

Jack - 7

Thane - 7

Samara - 4

Morinth - 3

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 2

[DragonFire6464]

Ashley - 10



Kaiden - 1



Wrex - 9



Garrus - 9



Tali - 9



Liara - 8



Miranda - 7



Jacob - 9



Mordin - 10



Grunt - 7



Jack - 1



Thane - 8



Samara - 8



Morinth - 1



Legion - 8



Zaeed - 2

[Lord Atlia]

Sorry if I am stealing any of TC's thunder but here is a bit more detail on Tali for those interested just using data from the first 3 pages (discounting double posts and peeps who didn't follow the rules):

Tali
Obs. 66
Mean 8.227273
Std Dev. 1.903806
Variance 3.624476
Skewness -1.407309
Kurtosis: 5.212247

           Percentiles     Smallest

1%            1                       1
5%            5                       3
10%          6                       4
25%          7                       5
50%          9
                                      Largest
75%          10                    10
90%          10                    10
95%          10                    10
99%          10                    10

Modifié par Lord Atlia, 09 février 2010 - 10:15 .

[Mondo47]

Ashley - 5

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 10

Garrus - 7

Tali - 8

Liara - 7

Miranda - 5

Jacob - 4

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 7

Jack - 10

Thane - 4

Samara - 5

Morinth - 2

Legion - 9

Zaeed - 8

[Wrex.the.next.spectre]

Ashley -7
Kaiden -1
Wrex - 10
Garrus -8
Tali - 7
Liara - 7
Miranda -10
Jacob - 1
Mordin -10
Grunt - 5
Jack - 3
Thane -9
Samara -5
Morinth -4
Legion - 9
Zaeed -6

[Faerlyte]

Ashley - 1

Kaiden - 4

Wrex - 10

Garrus - 10

Tali - 9

Liara - 6

Miranda - 7

Jacob - 8

Mordin - 10

Grunt - 8

Jack - 7

Thane - 8

Samara - 9

Morinth - 5

Legion - 10

Zaeed - 2

[XX55XX]

Lord Atlia wrote...

Sorry if I am stealing any of TC's thunder but here is a bit more detail on Tali for those interested just using data from the first 3 pages (discounting double posts and peeps who didn't follow the rules):

Tali
Obs. 66
Mean 8.227273
Std Dev. 1.903806
Variance 3.624476
Skewness -1.407309
Kurtosis: 5.212247

           Percentiles     Smallest

1%            1                       1
5%            5                       3
10%          6                       4
25%          7                       5
50%          9
                                      Largest
75%          10                    10
90%          10                    10
95%          10                    10
99%          10                    10

I have 162 values inputted, and Tali's mean is 8.08, with a standard deviation of 2.082. It was higher when I was initially inputting values (I think it went up to 8.3 at one point?) but it has oscillated between 8.0-8.1 for the last one hundred inputs for so.

[Cerrydd]

lol, I hate SPSS.



Ashley - 4

Kaiden - 4

Wrex - 10

Garrus - 10

Tali - 8

Liara - 8

Miranda - 6

Jacob - 5

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 9

Jack - 4

Thane - 8

Samara - 8

Morinth - n/a

Legion - 7

Zaeed - 6

[rakzztar]

Ashley -8

Kaiden -7

Wrex - 9

Garrus -10

Tali - 8

Liara - 8

Miranda -10

Jacob - 7

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 10

Jack - 9

Thane - 10

Samara - 8

Morinth - 5

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 6

[Coopjns]

Ashley - 8

Kaiden - 4

Wrex - 7

Garrus - 8

Tali - 10

Liara - 8

Miranda - 10

Jacob - 6

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 8

Jack - 6

Thane - 7

Samara - 7

Morinth - n/a

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 5

[BROMLEYUK]

Ashley - 7

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 8

Garrus - 9

Tali - 5

Liara - 10

Miranda - 8

Jacob - 6

Mordin -7

Grunt - 8

Jack - 4

Thane -10

Samara -10

Morinth -9

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 7

[apotheosic]

Ashley - 3/10
Kaiden -7/10
Wrex - 9/10
Garrus -9/10
Tali - 10/10
Liara - 6/10
Miranda -4/10
Jacob - 7/10
Mordin -10/10
Grunt - 8/10
Jack - 5/10
Thane -9/10
Samara -7/10
Morinth - N/A
Legion - 9/10
Zaeed - 4/10

where five is average.

[Finnegone]

Ashley - 1



Kaiden - 1



Wrex - 7



Garrus - 9



Tali - 4



Liara - 8



Miranda - 10



Jacob - 5



Mordin - 7



Grunt - 4



Jack - 8



Thane - 4



Samara - 8



Morinth - n/a



Legion - 6



Zaeed - 3

[Lord Atlia]

XX55XX wrote...

Lord Atlia wrote...

Sorry if I am stealing any of TC's thunder but here is a bit more detail on Tali for those interested just using data from the first 3 pages (discounting double posts and peeps who didn't follow the rules):

Tali
Obs. 66
Mean 8.227273
Std Dev. 1.903806
Variance 3.624476
Skewness -1.407309
Kurtosis: 5.212247

           Percentiles     Smallest

1%            1                       1
5%            5                       3
10%          6                       4
25%          7                       5
50%          9
                                      Largest
75%          10                    10
90%          10                    10
95%          10                    10
99%          10                    10

I have 162 values inputted, and Tali's mean is 8.08, with a standard deviation of 2.082. It was higher when I was initially inputting values (I think it went up to 8.3 at one point?) but it has oscillated between 8.0-8.1 for the last one hundred inputs for so.

Makes sense as more data is collected the value becomes more accurate, so unless there are a lot of early low or high outliers  you can hypothesize that Tali's character score is roughly 8.   

[omnitremere]

Ashley - 9

Kaiden -1

Wrex -10

Garrus -10

Tali - 8

Liara - 1

Miranda - 10

Jacob -6

Mordin -10

Grunt -10

Jack -8

Thane -7

Samara -10

Morinth -8(Really wish there was more content for her)

Legion -10

Zaeed - 1(maybe this is because I've never had him in my party besides loyalty mission)

[mass_zotz]

Ashley - 8

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 10

Tali - 8

Liara - 8

Miranda - 9

Jacob - 7

Mordin - 10

Grunt - 8

Jack - 7

Thane - 8

Samara - 10

Morinth - 3

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 5

[XX55XX]

Lord Atlia wrote...

XX55XX wrote...

Lord Atlia wrote...

Sorry if I am stealing any of TC's thunder but here is a bit more detail on Tali for those interested just using data from the first 3 pages (discounting double posts and peeps who didn't follow the rules):

Tali
Obs. 66
Mean 8.227273
Std Dev. 1.903806
Variance 3.624476
Skewness -1.407309
Kurtosis: 5.212247

           Percentiles     Smallest

1%            1                       1
5%            5                       3
10%          6                       4
25%          7                       5
50%          9
                                      Largest
75%          10                    10
90%          10                    10
95%          10                    10
99%          10                    10

I have 162 values inputted, and Tali's mean is 8.08, with a standard deviation of 2.082. It was higher when I was initially inputting values (I think it went up to 8.3 at one point?) but it has oscillated between 8.0-8.1 for the last one hundred inputs for so.

Makes sense as more data is collected the value becomes more accurate, so unless there are a lot of early low or high outliers  you can hypothesize that Tali's character score is roughly 8.   

Well, that's why I just instituted a cutoff point. The means seem fairly stable (but it seems that Ashley's mean just went for a nosedive) so including more numbers isn't going to change anything drastically.

176 inputs, Tali's mean is now an 8.07. Her rating is lower than Wrex's, Legion's, Garrus', and Mordin's. Oddly enough, in most character polls, she ranks as the most favorite character most of the time. Seems strange that her score isn't any higher.

[Alraiis]

XX55XX wrote...

176 inputs, Tali's mean is now an 8.07. Her rating is lower than Wrex's, Legion's, Garrus', and Mordin's. Oddly enough, in most character polls, she ranks as the most favorite character most of the time. Seems strange that her score isn't any higher.

Tali seemed to be getting more low-end scores than, say, Mordin. Backlash against Tali fans, or just a genuine love-her-or-hate-her mentality. Favorite-character polls often leave out the least-favorite part of the spectrum. This one doesn't.

Modifié par Alraiis, 09 février 2010 - 11:00 .

[DalishRanger]

Ashley - 9
Kaiden - 6
Wrex - 5
Garrus - 7
Tali - 8
Liara - 6
Miranda - 8
Jacob - 7
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 6
Jack - 7
Thane - 7
Samara - 6
Morinth - N/A
Legion - 5
Zaeed - 3

Hm, guess it's easy to see who wows me and who bores me, heh.

[Lord Atlia]

XX55XX wrote...

Lord Atlia wrote...

XX55XX wrote...

Lord Atlia wrote...

Sorry if I am stealing any of TC's thunder but here is a bit more detail on Tali for those interested just using data from the first 3 pages (discounting double posts and peeps who didn't follow the rules):

Tali
Obs. 66
Mean 8.227273
Std Dev. 1.903806
Variance 3.624476
Skewness -1.407309
Kurtosis: 5.212247

           Percentiles     Smallest

1%            1                       1
5%            5                       3
10%          6                       4
25%          7                       5
50%          9
                                      Largest
75%          10                    10
90%          10                    10
95%          10                    10
99%          10                    10

I have 162 values inputted, and Tali's mean is 8.08, with a standard deviation of 2.082. It was higher when I was initially inputting values (I think it went up to 8.3 at one point?) but it has oscillated between 8.0-8.1 for the last one hundred inputs for so.

Makes sense as more data is collected the value becomes more accurate, so unless there are a lot of early low or high outliers  you can hypothesize that Tali's character score is roughly 8.   

Well, that's why I just instituted a cutoff point. The means seem fairly stable (but it seems that Ashley's mean just went for a nosedive) so including more numbers isn't going to change anything drastically.

176 inputs, Tali's mean is now an 8.07. Her rating is lower than Wrex's, Legion's, Garrus', and Mordin's. Oddly enough, in most character polls, she ranks as the most favorite character most of the time. Seems strange that her score isn't any higher.

Tali is a character which polarizes people, most either lover her or hate her. She wins "some" polls because more people within that sample agree on a singly character (Tali) than any given character the people who don't like her pick (example you might have 5 ME fans, 2 love Tali as their favorite character, 3 hate her, but of those 3 one is a Liara fan, one is a Wrex fan, and one is a Ashley fan, so in a poll Tali will still win).  A character like Mordin is well recieved with only a few outlying negative results, same goes for Wrex, Garrus, and Legion, they might not have as many fans placing them as #1 on their top 15, but they also don't have people dragging them down.

[Malanek]

Alraiis wrote...
Tali seemed to be getting more low-end scores than, say, Mordin. Backlash against Tali fans, or just a genuine love-her-or-hate-her mentality. Favorite-character polls often leave out the least-favorite part of the spectrum. This one doesn't.

I think this is applying to a lot of characters. People are putting in scores of 1 to skew away from their favourites more. I don't think any of the characters are badly written enough to deserve a 1.

[AirWonderCross]

Ashley - 6 (She ****ed at you in ME2 xP)

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 8

Garrus - 6 (Would be higher but lost most of my respect for him once he turned into a renegade)

Tali - 7

Liara - 7

Miranda - 10

Jacob - 7

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 8

Jack - 3

Thane - 10

Samara - 8

Morinth - N/A

Legion - 7

Zaeed - N/A



To be honest, I liked the ME2 characters more then the ME1 characters. (Not including Jack and the N/A ones.)