475 réponses à ce sujet

[XX55XX]

Malanek999 wrote...

Alraiis wrote...
Tali seemed to be getting more low-end scores than, say, Mordin. Backlash against Tali fans, or just a genuine love-her-or-hate-her mentality. Favorite-character polls often leave out the least-favorite part of the spectrum. This one doesn't.

I think this is applying to a lot of characters. People are putting in scores of 1 to skew away from their favourites more. I don't think any of the characters are badly written enough to deserve a 1.

Morinth and Zaeed especially.

Half of the characters have normally distributed histograms, a few (like Tali, Garrus, Wrex, Legion, and Mordin) have their histograms skewed to the left, and characters like Morinth and Zaeed have their's skewed way towards the right.

I'm still inputting values, so a report will out within a few days. But it seems that Mordin is the least polarizing of characters and almost everyone agrees that he is a great character, due to the high mean (8.81!) and a low standard deviation.

[ritchie89]

Ashley -   8

Kaiden -   1

Wrex -     9

Garrus -   7

Tali -        8

Liara -      7

Miranda - 7

Jacob -    1

Mordin -   8

Grunt -     7

Jack -       5

Thane -    4

Samara -  2

Morinth -  3

Legion -    8

Zaeed -    9

[Chuvvy]

Ashley - 0
Kaiden - 4
Wrex - 10
Garrus - 10
Tali - 7
Liara - 9
Miranda - 5
Jacob - 8 BRO HUG
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 7.5
Jack - 5.5
Thane - 7.5
Samara - 9
Morinth - never had her
Legion - 10
Zaeed - 7

5 = average.

Modifié par Slidell505, 10 février 2010 - 01:09 .

[Wrex.the.next.spectre]

Malanek999 wrote...

Alraiis wrote...
Tali seemed to be getting more low-end scores than, say, Mordin. Backlash against Tali fans, or just a genuine love-her-or-hate-her mentality. Favorite-character polls often leave out the least-favorite part of the spectrum. This one doesn't.

I think this is applying to a lot of characters. People are putting in scores of 1 to skew away from their favourites more. I don't think any of the characters are badly written enough to deserve a 1.

I disagree, as when I posted my scores, I had no idea the data was being recorded for statistics. I truly thought that Kaiden, along with Jacob, were the worst characters in a video game, I ever came across. That ranks as a 1 in my book. For me, there is nothing to like about those characters. I also, resisted putting Jack at 1, because as much as I didn't like the character, I thought that there were worse characters in other franchises.

It might be the case with a few people, but I think the majority aren't compelled to put their most hated characters at 1, and favorite characters at 10. Thane was one of my favorite characters, and I put him at 9.

[mabalogna]

Ashley - 4

Kaiden - 1

Wrex - 10

Garrus - 7

Tali - 6

Liara - 1

Miranda - 6

Jacob - 4

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 9

Jack - 8

Thane - 7

Samara - 6

Morinth - 5

Legion - 10

Zaeed - 10

[SuperZombieChow]

Ashley - 4

Kaiden - 4

Wrex - 7

Garrus - 9

Tali - 9

Liara - 6

Miranda - 4

Jacob - 3

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 5

Jack - 7

Thane - 7

Samara - 3

Morinth - 4

Legion - 5

Zaeed - 4

[BlackwindTheCommander]

Ashley - 7
Kaiden - 8
Wrex - 9.5
Garrus - 9
Tali - 10
Liara - 8
Miranda - 8
Jacob - 7
Mordin - 8.5
Grunt - 6.7
Jack - 7
Thane - 6.5
Samara - 5.4
Morinth - N/A
Legion - 9.8
Zaeed - 10

[Jollyroger711]

Ashley - 1

Kaiden - 7

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 8

Tali - 10

Liara - 6

Miranda - 8

Jacob - 5

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 3

Jack - 4

Thane - 10

Samara - 2

Morinth - N/A

Legion - 1

Zaeed -6

[Knightfly]

Ashley - 10

Kaiden - 3

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 8

Tali - 7

Liara - 4

Miranda - 8

Jacob - 6

Mordin - 7

Grunt - 7

Jack - 4

Thane - 7

Samara - 7

Morinth - 5

Legion - 8

Zaeed - 7

[Dewarren2010]

Ashley - 8
Kaiden - 7
Wrex -  10
Garrus - 9
Tali -  8
Liara - 8
Miranda - 8
Jacob -  7
Mordin - 10
Grunt - 8
Jack - 9
Thane - 10
Samara - 8
Morinth - 6
Legion - 9
Zaeed -6

[TeddyBearMan]

Ashley - 4
Kaiden - 3
Wrex - 10
Garrus - 10
Tali - 10
Liara - 7
Miranda - 5
Jacob - 4
Mordin - 9
Grunt - 8
Jack - 6
Thane - 4
Samara - 7
Morinth - 7
Legion - 9
Zaeed - 1

[penguin12345]

Ashley - -2

Kaiden - 4

Wrex - 8

Garrus - 9

Tali - 10

Liara - 8

Miranda - 5

Jacob - 7

Mordin - 8

Grunt - 7

Jack - 2

Thane - 8

Samara - 7

Morinth - 5

Legion - 9.5

Zaeed - 1

[VillainZ]

Ashley - 3

Kaiden - 1

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 7

Tali - 4

Liara - 3

Miranda - 9

Jacob - 1

Mordin - 7

Grunt - 8

Jack - 8

Thane - 7

Samara - 7

Morinth - 10! (personal fav)

Legion - 10

Zaeed -1

[NeoNight1986]

Ashley - 7

Kaiden - 3

Wrex - 9

Garrus -10

Tali - 10

Liara - 3

Miranda - 7

Jacob - 7

Mordin - 9

Grunt - 8

Jack - 3

Thane - 6

Samara - 5

Morinth - 3

Legion - 9

Zaeed - 2

[DeeLite808]

Ashley - 5

Kaiden - 8

Wrex -  8

Garrus - 10

Tali -  10

Liara -  10

Miranda - 7

Jacob -  5

Mordin - 7

Grunt -  7

Jack -  6

Thane - 8

Samara - 4

Morinth - 1

Legion -  5

Zaeed - 1

Modifié par DeeLite808, 10 février 2010 - 02:49 .

[HAGA NAGA]

Ashley - 0
Kaiden - 4
Wrex - 7
Grunt - 4
Garrus - 10
Tali - 10
Liara - 6
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 3
Mordin - 8
Jack - 9
Thane - 8
Samara - 9
Morinth - never had her (seemed interesting though)
Legion - 8
Zaeed - 7

[ThatDancingTurian]

OP, if you're not inputting anymore you might want to change the title.

[XX55XX]

Aris Ravenstar wrote...

OP, if you're not inputting anymore you might want to change the title.

Yep, thanks for the suggestion. Did just that.

[StaR_JeS]

Ashley - 7
Kaiden - 6
Wrex -  10
Garrus - 10
Tali - 8/9
Liara - 7/8
Miranda - 9
Jacob - 6
Mordin - 10
Grunt - 8
Jack - 5
Thane - 8
Samara - 9
Morinth - 1
Legion - 9
Zaeed - 7

[MA5Bergey]

Ashley - 9.5
Kaiden - 2
Wrex -  8.5
Garrus - 8.5
Tali - 9
Liara - 9
Miranda - 8 (a 6 without her skimpy outfit)
Jacob - 8
Mordin - 9
Grunt -5
Jack - 9.5
Thane - 7
Samara - 7
Morinth - 5
Legion - 8
Zaeed - 3

[Heyalrey]

I have a hard time ranking shared characters across both games combined... people like Garrus were pretty boring (to me) in ME1, then came alive in ME2. The ME1 characters in general just didn't do much for me.
ME2 was a complete 180... the characters made the game.

ME1:
Ashley - 2
Kaiden - 1
Wrex -  6
Garrus - 5
Tali - 8
Liara - 7

ME2:
Ashley - 6

Kaiden - 0

Wrex -  7

Garrus - 8

Tali - 9

Liara - 5
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 8
Mordin - 9
Grunt -6
Jack - 10
Thane - 8
Samara - 6
Morinth - 5
Legion - 8
Zaeed - 7

[Lao Dan]

Wrex.the.next.spectre wrote...

Malanek999 wrote...

Alraiis wrote...
Tali seemed to be getting more low-end scores than, say, Mordin. Backlash against Tali fans, or just a genuine love-her-or-hate-her mentality. Favorite-character polls often leave out the least-favorite part of the spectrum. This one doesn't.

I think this is applying to a lot of characters. People are putting in scores of 1 to skew away from their favourites more. I don't think any of the characters are badly written enough to deserve a 1.

I disagree, as when I posted my scores, I had no idea the data was being recorded for statistics. I truly thought that Kaiden, along with Jacob, were the worst characters in a video game, I ever came across. That ranks as a 1 in my book. For me, there is nothing to like about those characters. I also, resisted putting Jack at 1, because as much as I didn't like the character, I thought that there were worse characters in other franchises.

It might be the case with a few people, but I think the majority aren't compelled to put their most hated characters at 1, and favorite characters at 10. Thane was one of my favorite characters, and I put him at 9.

I rated them based on
a) how likely I was to put them in my party
How interesting they were to talk to

Zaeed got a 1 because I never use him outside his loyalty and you can't talk to him. His character seemed like an afterthought.  I know he was a freebie, but so was Shale in DAO, and she was much more interesting.

[nilamu]

Ashley - -10(personnal favorite)



Kaiden - 4



Wrex - 8



Garrus - 9



Tali - 3



Liara - 6



Miranda - 3



Jacob - 7



Mordin - 8



Grunt - 6



Jack - 5



Thane - 8



Samara - 2



Morinth - 5



Legion -6



Zaeed - 1