475 réponses à ce sujet

[DigitalMaster37]

please vote on me and XX55XX's new 2.0 doc so your vote can count http://spreadsheets....JNHhTOVBCZmc6MA

Modifié par Deltaboy37-1, 11 février 2010 - 07:43 .

[Chromie]

Ashley -7

Kaiden -7

Wrex - 10

Garrus -9

Tali - 8

Liara - 10

Miranda -10

Jacob - 7

Mordin -10

Grunt - 8

Jack - 7

Thane -9

Samara -10

Morinth -5

Legion - 10

Zaeed - 8

[Funkcase]

Ashley - 10 (The best written caracter in ME)



Kaiden - 7 (cool guy and good friend, i just felt Bioware could have put more into him)



Wrex - 10 (When you think ME you think Wrex)



Garrus - 9 (Realy good caracter and feels like family in ME2, i just thought what route we guided him on in ME would result in how he turn out in ME2)



Tali - 8 (Not much to go on in ME, but ME2 you create a close bond with her and she is starting to feel fleshed out more now, good job Bioware)



Liara - 5 (I found her slightly boring in ME there wasnt much to go on and ME2 they made her even worse by making her so different she dosent feel like the same caracter anymore)



Miranda - 7 (I didnt find much flaws with Miranda a very well writen caracter but there wasnt enough to go on unless you had her as a LI the score might be higher if i did)



Jacob - 7 (Like Kaiden and Garrus he felt like a close friend, i liked the voice accting alot also)



Mordin - 10 (He sings, he gives sex advice, he can kill people with anything)



Grunt - 9 (He was a realy well written caracter but it felt like he was just a replacement for Wrex, a good insight at Krogan though and gotta love the blue eyes)



Jack - 8 (I loved listening to Jack and trying to help her, but my expectations for her where way to high)



Thane - 10 (Thane is the Wrex of ME2 to me, he stands out to me than the rest of the ME2 squad, i was more interested in hearing what he had to say over the rest of the squad.



Samara - 7 ( I felt for her but i didnt feel as close to her as i did the rest of the squad, but that was her caracter i guess she dosent open up to you. Regardless i love her caracter)



Morinth - 6 (I never had her on my squad so thats just judging on that one mission the voice accting was realy good though)



Legion - 10 ( The robot dose the robot!! It was great getting an insight into the life of the Geth and the Geth/Quarian problem)





Zaeed - 8 (Bioware dropped the ball not letting us have interactive conversations with him, regardless the voice acting is amazing and he says some of the best lines in the game, plus inferno grenades!)

[jerryl]

Ashley - 6
Kaiden - 2
Wrex - 7
Garrus - 6
Tali - 6
Liara - 7
Miranda - 9
Jacob - 6
Mordin - 7
Grunt - 8
Jack - 7
Thane - 7
Samara - 8
Morinth - 7
Legion - 7
Zaeed - 6

Modifié par jerryl, 11 février 2010 - 08:40 .

[DigitalMaster37]

Please DO NOT vote twice or we throw off the accuracy of the survey.

[Dark Glasses]

What the hell? Zaeed got the 2nd lowest score? I'm very disappointed at Mass Effect community now.

[Skilled Seeker]

Great graphs! Funny thing is the top 4 squadmates are all my favourite too and I used Garrus + Wrex in ME1 and Garrus + Legion in ME2!

Modifié par Skilled Seeker, 11 février 2010 - 09:09 .

[SL22]

Ashley -4
Kaiden -7
Wrex - 10
Garrus -10
Tali - 10
Liara - 3
Miranda -3
Jacob - 6
Mordin -10
Grunt - 7
Jack - 2
Thane -9
Samara -4
Morinth -1
Legion - 10
Zaeed -6

[SL22]

antilles333 wrote...

Why is everyone spelling Kaidan wrong?

Because we're copy/pasting.

Also no one cares.

Modifié par SL22, 11 février 2010 - 09:12 .

[Gill Kaiser]

I wasn't expecting Tali to be the MOST popular character. I merely expected her to be among the most popular, and more popular than the ME1 love interests, which she was.

[Skilled Seeker]

Ashley-6

Kaiden-8

Wrex-9

Garrus-10

Tali-4

Liara-3

Miranda-6

Jacob-8

Mordin-10

Grunt-2

Jack-5

Thane-6

Samara-3

Morinth-10

Legion-9

Zaeed-10

[Deejtage]

Ashley - 7

Kaiden - 6

Wrex - 7

Garrus - 8

Tali - 9

Liara - 9

Miranda -7

Jacob - 5

Mordin - 8

Grunt - 7

Jack - 5

Thane - 8

Samara - 7

Morinth - 6

Legion - 7

Zaeed - 6

[JLocke37]

Ashley - 5

Kaiden - 3

Wrex - 9

Garrus - 8

Tali - 7

Liara - 9

Miranda -9

Jacob - 7

Mordin -10

Grunt - 7

Jack - 7

Thane - 9

Samara -8

Morinth - 5

Legion - 10

Zaeed - 5

[Manou1]

Ashley - 7
Kaiden - 1
Wrex - 10
Garrus - 8
Tali - 10
Liara - 6
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 5
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 7
Jack - 9
Thane - 8
Samara - 6
Morinth - 3
Legion - 9
Zaeed - 7

[Tsumoro]

Ashley - 6

Kaiden - 1 (hated him)

Wrex - 7

Garrus - 9

Tali - 10+

Liara - 5

Miranda - 1

Jacob - 4

Mordin - 10

Grunt - 10

Jack - 10

Thane - 10

Samara - 7

Morinth - 1

Legion - 10

Zaeed - 8

[Fulgrim88]

Wow...i honestly didn't expect this to turn out this good.

It's semi-professional, might actually be one of the first forum ratings being of some use for analysis



Great job

[Asheer_Khan]

Ashley - 8 (Despite her cold appearance on horizon)
Kaidan - 4 (Sorry but he is waaay to Carthish and he never pass Virmire in my case.)
Wrex - 10 (No complains here, coolest Krogan in ME universe)
Garrus - 8 (Still same great and too trigger happy Turian)
Tali - 10 (What can i say... 10/10 in both games)
Liara - 7 (Hmmm... here i have problem..., in ME 1 my Li and she get 10/10 but then metting on Illum was like ice cold shower and that's why i can't give her more as 7 but nevertheless i remain loyal to her )
Miranda - 8 (Good character but i miss some option to casual talk which could help me to learn her better).
Jacob - 5 (I will go neutral here because i have mixed fellings when comes to Jacob)
Mordin - 9 (Facynating Salarian)
Grunt - 8 (But he never beat Wrexy despite his genetic perfectines)
Jack - 9 (Great character but whit same issue as in Miranda's case, there are too less otion for neutral dialouges (without romancing) to help me learn her better).
Thane - 8 (Strange character)
Samara - 7 (Somehow she remembering me light sided Benezia)
Morinth - 7 (may she Rest in Peace)
Legion - 9 (HK get great replacement for ME Universe)
Zaeed - 7 (Well... again i wish i can learn him better )

Modifié par Asheer_Khan, 12 février 2010 - 11:33 .

[Sharn01]

SurfaceBeneath wrote...

Interesting post OP, I regret that I wasn't able to post my opinions before polling was closed.

Some questions:

1.) Have you considered trying this kind of poll outside the ME forums? I'm actually super interested to see what the opinions are of people who do not post here are... I'm actually pretty certain you'd get some very different results.

2.) I was curious about how you said Liara's lower score was indicative of her presentation in ME2. It seems to me that most of her fans pretty much disregard it and most everyone else doesn't give it much thought. Have you considered what the Mass Effect comic did for her popularity? Do you think such considerations enter in to the general equation?

3.) Actually, the love interests in general just seem to have very high deviations (Except Tali). Do you think that this is related to the fact that while most characters one can experience all their dialogue and character without exclusively having to choose them, people who romance one character actually do lose out on quite a bit of dialogue from every other potential romantic partners. In essence, if I choose to romance Thane in ME2, I will get several extra dialogues from him, meanwhile I will miss out on dialogues from Garrus, Jacob, Jack, Miranda, and Tali that might influence my opinion.

Just some things to think about : )

You should go through this topic and read over it, there is actually quite a few people who felt Liara's appearance in ME2 not only warrented a lower score, but also warrented posting that it was the reason they gave her a low score.

[Palmstroem]

Ashley - 10 (favourite character)
Kaiden - 7
Wrex - 8
Garrus - 8
Tali - 7
Liara - 5
Miranda - 5
Jacob -7
Mordin - 9
Grunt - 5
Jack - 7
Thane - 9
Samara - 7
Morinth - 4
Legion - 4
Zaeed - 4


Im really surprised about legion. Its a funny and interesting character, but imo he is just very poorly implanted in ME2. If suddendly the archenemy become an ally,  you will have to explain that very well (and they didnt).


An interesting additional question would be the favourite character. That would be imo a better indicator for who should really return in ME3. The LIs would have probably the most votes.

[grayfox4000]

No I'll just rate 2 people.



Ashley: Negitive -10 (Because shes speciesist and I sent her to die with the nuke because of her anti alien BS.)



Tali: OVER NINE THOUSAND!!! (Because shes the smart shy tomboy type and not human.)

The rest of the characters are good I can't like them more or less then one another.



Maybe a 3rd just cus Garrus was with my evil ways backing me up. So was Grunt and Wrex they need a +10. I could care less about anybody else.

[Lao Dan]

I wouldn't be surprised to see Tali or Garrus take a huge jump in the anonymous poll, unless there is a way to ensure one vote per person. As convenient as it might be, I I have a hard time believing everyone will vote only once.

[DigitalMaster37]

be sure to vote in the 3.0 version made by XX55XX. here --> http://spreadsheets....1WHNOUXJDYUE6MA

[Gunnman185]

Ashley - 7
Kaiden - 8
Wrex - 6
Garrus - 4 (ME1)  7 (ME2)
Tali - 9
Liara - 8 (ME1)  6 (ME2)
Miranda - 7
Jacob - 5
Mordin - 9
Grunt - 6
Jack - 8
Thane - 8
Samara - 7
Morinth - 5
Legion -  8
Zaeed -  6

[AeonLibertas]

Ashley - 1 (actually also -10 .. hmpf)
Kaiden - 2
Wrex - 9 (both)
Garrus - 10 (ME1), 8 (ME2)
Tali - 10 (both)
Liara - 5 (ME1), 3 (ME2)
Miranda - 6
Jacob - 4
Mordin - 8
Grunt - 8
Jack - 9
Thane - 6
Samara - 4
Morinth - 2
Legion - 8
Zaeed - 1

Modifié par AeonLibertas, 12 février 2010 - 08:10 .