92 réponses à ce sujet

[Rainydays]

But only one leaves.....
Who wins?

Grunt being able to shrug off all damage?
Jack having no remorse about killing?
Zaeed able to survive years of suicidal encounters?

/discuss
/no this ring isn't full of mud and/or jello

Edit:
Go ahead and throw in temporary alliances and grudges into the fights also
(ie. would Jack go all out gunning for Miranda, would Jacob help Miranda take Jack out?)

Edit again:
Well we have some real interesting ideas, let me clarify a few details to get keep the train of though moving

Medium circle sized arena, big enough to keep some fights form spilling into another battle, but small enough that no one can hide too effectively, unless that's what they are good at

Clusters of cover with open ground between them

Single level, not to be overly sniper biased, they already have people forced in open ground to get them after all

All Members enter at same time, so they all have equal time to prepare

All Members are unaware of where other members will be entering until battle starts, so some people can very well be taken out before they have a chance to make alliances, or act on grudges

Sheppard is busy deleting spam emails and feeding fish, so he's not around

Modifié par Rainydays, 09 février 2010 - 08:00 .

[Kurupt87]

"/no this ring isn't full of mud and/or jello"
damn
but anyway, storywise i'd go with zaeed because he "always" survives.
ability wise, on insanity, probably legion, he'd sit behind a rock spamming drone and introducing ppl to the business end of the widow. gogo geth powa!

edit: this shouldnt be in this forum btw, put it in general discussion.

Modifié par Kurupt87, 09 février 2010 - 02:36 .

[Zandercode]

Well if Jack suddenly summons up the amount of power she had when she was escaping Purgatory, then I'd say it would be her. Remember she took out like 4 giant mechs at once then fought her way alone through the station knocking down walls to make short cuts.



She would probably take Legion, Jacob, Miranda, and Tali out with one blow, but be weak for the rest of the fight. But maybe Grunt would end up winning because he'd get shot down and whoever was left would forget that he's a krogan and practically has a second life. He'd suddenly wake back up a few seconds after it's over and shotgun the last person, but he'd probably be in a permanent blood rage and never recover, so he'd be "put down" sometime later.



So ultimately no one would win.

[Kronner]

The guy with a redundant nervous system, of course.

[Nemostor]

remember Grunt can 1 shot a Thresher Maw

[Homebound]

Grunt.

[Rainydays]

Don't think any of the others would make temporary alliances?

(ie. miranda and jacob, tali and garrus, good vs evil, human vs alien)

[CTKatech]

Morinth can just Dominate one, and then start frying the rest of their brains with her black eyes.

[Eragondragonrider]

If Shepard is in the ring he/she wins hands down, If not then I would think Thane would win because he will just cloak and sniper the rest from an unknown location.

[Stratomunchkin]

Garrus because he's ****in' ace!

[andrewv42]

Legion.



Combat Drone -> Geth Shield Boost -> Widow Anti-material rifle death!

[Shizly]

Thane. He waits till there is only one left and kills him from the back.

[SmilingMirror]

Garrus because he has reach.

[Dark83]

Mordin. Everyone else will die of a plague before they can even enter the ring. He's the very model of a salarian scientists, you know.

[blank1]

Thane wins. Biotics + guns + fisticuffs.

[Skiffy707]

Morinth!

[Lord Exar]

I'm going to have to give this to Samara. She's got the experience and strength to really crush just about everyone else. Jack may give her a problem, but that's where her experience wins.



Biotics are/should be the strongest out there...it just isn't the case in-game, sadly.

[Relinquished2]

Tali wins, duh!

Simple, Tali get's hurt, Shepard goes into insanity mode and kills everyone. Thus Tali wins

[Rhokarin]

i vote thane, in one scene he basically disappears in a crowded room... wait till only one is left, snipe him

[Joie de Combat]

If it's strictly a steel cage deathmatch, I'm inclined to put my money on Grunt. Jack or Samara have enough raw biotic power to stand up to him, but if you get through their biotics, they're much squishier. Grunt is, well, krogan.



I'm not really sure how cooperation could tip the scales, though; Miranda, Jacob, Garrus, Mordin, and potentially Tali and Samara could get a lot out of strategic alliances. In that case I'm really not sure who'd come out on top, but I lean towards either Miranda or Samara as the ones least likely to have qualms about turning on their allies once the other opponents are dealt with. (Mordin too, but he's just too squishy to hold up well in this kind of fight.)



Introducing terrain mixes things up further. If Garrus can set himself up in a nice bottleneck like he did on Omega, I'm pretty confident he could hold off all comers, at least until Thane slipped out of the shadows from freaking nowhere and caught him unprepared.

[Rainydays]

Updated to show front runners

[WrexKroganKing]

One on one, hand to hand it has to be Jack or Grunt. Jack is listed as the most powerful human biotic in existence, and as much as Samara has power an experience it simply doesn't mach Jack's ridiculous. Without Biotics, Grunt is well...Grunt.

[pacer90]

Tali via rabid fan base jumping in to assist her.

[Occams Razor 17]

Definitely a different result depending on if it's tourny style 1 vs 1s or if it's a grand melee.

I'm going to assume a large arena with lots of irregularities and cover, just because that would be far more interesting to watch.



1 vs 1s: Jack. Smash, wait for dust to settle, repeat.



Grand melee: Thane. Stealth, wait, snipe, gg.

[TeaWhiteNonePlease]

Miranda every time!